My sister was visiting and wanted Italian and I heard so many good things about Ciro's so we decided to try it. Full disclosure we are from Boston (the other place Italians made their home lol). At first, my sister questioned it because it's just a spot in a plaza, but I explained to her in Florida that's quite normal. But I really enjoy is that they have darken the windows so you can't see in but you are able to see out so you're not sitting in the normal fishbowl of a plaza restaurant. Small place obviously but they have both booths and tables. My sister ordered a chicken masala and a side Caesar salad. I ordered the Bronx chicken cutlet with a side Caesar and they were able to add anchovies, which just made it all that much better. The masala was thick, tons of mushrooms. The chicken was tender. You only needed a fork to break it apart, she got it over linguine and it was perfectly cooked. My dinner were too fresh chicken cutlets paper, thin freshly made topped with cherry peppers and burrata. Served with cheese ravioli's in a vodka sauce. Again, Caesar salad refreshing made freshly tossed, the food was timed nicely between the salads being delivered in our meals. My sister was so happy. She ordered a personal pan pizza to take home with her. We had the pleasure of Caitlin being our server and she was attentive and friendly and helped make it a great night. read more

See all

We've moved from CT to FL. Since we've been down here it's been so hard to find good pizza. My husband is much more passionate about pizza than me; and we finally found a place he enjoys! A little pricey but for quality pizza-- we'll pay! Haha We only ordered take out, but ambiance seemed busy yet attentive and helpful. We will definitely be going back! read more

Just an average Wednesday and saw the restaurant when I was shopping in the plaza. Why not see what's up? I mean we love pizza and esp. NY pizza. LISTEN.. this pizza is the real deal NY pizza. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio, perfect crunch and pull of dough. The sauce has a sweet zesty flavor to pop with cheese. I am telling you, best Freaking NY pizza in Orlando area. We love pizza and been looking for the perfect spot. Too bad we live in Altamonte, but I will be over to Sanford for my pizza cravings. You will not be disappointed, get the pizza. read more

For an inexpensive slice in the area, Ciro's is still the best place. Traditional slices are decent, Sicilian slices are great, stromboli is a little more oily/greasy than I like. Place is clean and servers are there at your table before you even need anything. Food quality and taste may be a 3.5. read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - Stromboli - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Best NY/NJ style pizza and dinners! Always fresh and delicious ! Friendly staff too. Jersey girl approved! The only place I go w Im craving a pie. Great garlic knots too read more

Ok. Since moving here 5 years ago, this has been our go to pizza place. I never once looked at the menu because we typically got carry out and the pizza is goated anyways, well, I've been missing out big time. Best blacked chicken Fettuccine Alfredo I've ever had, and it was a take out order that I was about 10 min late picking up. Was still BANGING!!! This place never disappoints and is always delicious!!! read more

This is the BEST pizza in Sanford and the surrounding area. The owner takes pride in making good pizza pies and is pretty consistent on the crust. This is NY style pizza and the real deal folks. If you want good quality pizza, this is the place. read more

Heyyyyyyyy you guyyyyyyssss! Tried this place and it was delicious. Crust was on point, we opted for half pepperoni and mushrooms and half basil and garlic. 10 outta 10! Our server was sweet, looks to be a family owned restaurant. The beers were cold and a perfect pairing with the pizza. Definitely found a new local pizza spot. They had a great menu, lots of options, let's eat!! read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

This place is absolutely delicious! Their pizzas and pastas truly embodies the spirit of New York Italian cuisine. All their food and ingredients are fresh including their in house handmade mozzarella cheese. This pasta has one of the best vodka sauces I've ever tried. Can't wait to go back read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - Rigatoni Alla Vodka With Shrimp - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Tried this place for the first time and the food and service was excellent for a store front pizza place. Will definitely be back when in the Sanford area read more

Delicious! Perfect NY style pizza. It hit the spot! Loved the music in the building. The service was excellent! Thank you!! read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - Stuffed meat lovers pizza Legit delicious NY style pizza. The plain cheese is outrageous!! TYTYTY - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

I've relocated here from New York and decided to try this place. I went in at about 5pm on a Friday and asked do you have slices. I was told nope, sorry we have no slices. Really? This time of the evening and you ran out of slices. This is no NY pizza in any way shape or form. I will never go back here again. read more

Great slice of pie! I had the Sicilian and Caesar salad for $9 ( note you toppings are extra. I added pepperoni and sausage for a couple of bucks. Bottled water was $3.12. Pizza was excellent. My slice was right out of the oven as it was about 11:30 am. Staff seamed pleasant and attentive. A bit of a walk from the Tesla charger but worth the walk from the other end of the plaza. Keep it up! Yum read more

See all

I tried the beef pizza and found it quite tasty. However, the crust is a bit soft and not as crispy as expected. The price is reasonable and the restaurant space is comfortable. read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Stopped in for a quick dinner. The interior was bright, clean and basic clean decor. They had the seat yourself sign up so we chose a booth near the door and were greeted quickly with menus, silverware, and a smile. I chose the mushroom and pepperoni personal pizza. It did not take too long for the pizza and it came out piping hot. There was a reasonable amount of toppings on the pizza and it had a good flavor. The crust was thinner and a little crunchy. It was good, but I would have preferred either thinner if crispy or a little thicker and not as crispy. It was good and I ate the pizza happily, but just my preference. If I am up in this area again would stop in to try some of their other items that looked delicious (like chicken parmesan, sandwiches, etc). read more

We ordered a pie margarita to be exact and the server came over to us to tell us you know that's the one with the fresh mozzarella and tomatoes on it and we said yes. Once our pizza arrived, it had regular mozzarella on it, and it had tons of tomatoes, chopped up it almost look like canned tomatoes, chopped up and thrown on the pizza. We asked the server if this was the margarita pizza with the buffalo mozzarella on it and she said yes of course well needless to say it wasn't. We also ordered a salad and it came out with warm, lettuce, tomato, and olives and cucumber no onion, which was stated on the menu that it had onion. as you can see from the picture below that is not fresh mozzarella read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - " margarita pizza " - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Came in for early lunch as my mom highly recommended the place. We ordered the meat lasagna, chicken Alfredo, and chicken alla siros. All the meals came with a salad, either ceaser or house. Both of the salads were great, lots of dressing, fresh veggies, good sized. The food came out fairly quick also, and everything is house made. Everything tasted amazing, hard to pick out what was best. Portions are also fairly big and will fill you up. Service was good and quick. A good suprise is that they have cream soda on tap! Thats a huge win as its my favorite and noone ever has it as a fountain drink option. Definitely worth it for the good food! read more

See all

Clean, inviting place with fun music playing in background. The service is good. Ordered cheese pizza- it was good, but had some issues. First it was very saucy. The sauce was good, but there was so much of it. They even poked holes in the cheese sometime in the baking process and it pooled on the top of the pizza. Second, I guess because of all the sauce the cheese did not stick to the crust and just slid right off. Third, it took awhile for it to arrive and it was a little expensive considering the issues. read more

IF YOU CAN GET PAST PAYING $16.00 FOR AN EGGPLANT PARM SUB, you wont get past the fact that there is very little eggplant on the sub. It was basically sauce, bread ,cheese and small, like 1x2 inch pieces of eggplant, it was ridiculous. Ciro's used to be so good. Have recommended them for years! The chicken parm sub was great. The pizza, eh, nothing to write home about. Lesson learned. read more

Amazing food, great staff and nice atmosphere! We will be back to try the other selections on their menu which offers more choices than your typical casual pizza place. read more

Good pizza with great specials for cost-efficient convenience. Excellent service with a super casual ambiance. Indoor seating. Eat-in or takeout options. Set in a large shopping plaza with plentiful shared parking. read more

See all

I ordered through their app. It said the pizzas would be ready at 6:07. My husband went early because usually they are quicker and we wanted hot pizza. When he got there, they hadn't even started to make them, but they told him it would be a bit.The 20 something girls arrived after the guy started making the pizza. They asked if they could help him and he said he was waiting for his pizzas. They ignored him from then on and were laughing and giggling. He waited and waited and finally got up and asked. Our pizzas were on top of the ovens and barely warm, so they had been there a while. By the time we got them home, they were cold. Plus the 14in cheese pizza had very little cheese and was too big for the box so it folded over. Their crust is really good but not enough to make up for the experience. Never going back and we will share our experience. read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - Pizza in the box, folded over. It was also cold even though we were waiting at Ciro's when it went into the oven - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

I have been wanting to check out this pizza place after hearing so many positive reviews about it on many different platforms. My husband and I love NY style pizza and keep wanting to discover new places that have that. Last Saturday we ordered a cheese pizza for takeout along with a half order of garlic knots. Once home, the pizza looked so appetizing and smelled like a true NY style pizza would. And what a surprise to see that they even gave us 2 additional garlic knots! After we tried both, we agreed that this place makes delicious pizza and knots. The cheese and sauce were on point as they were salty enough but also had a touch of sweetness. The knots were crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. We are looking forward to getting food from there again! read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Just conquered the climb of Mt. Calamari! lol The Calamari was a little on the salty side, but still delicious enough for me to devour it. Also got a Personal Pizza comprised of Sausage, Mushroom, Green Peppers. Along with an order of Garlic Knots as well. The buttery garlic aroma was amazing. I got delivery through Doordash so I didn't get to visit, but apparently this establishment changed their name from Caffe Positano to Ciro's NY Pizza Liking the food here thus far! read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - Calamari / Garlic Knots / Personal Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Had a short window to grab dinner with my family before work. Wife and son arrived and ordered a large supreme pizza and garlic knots. I arrived shortly after and dug in. All the onions, peppers, and sausage just slid off the pizza. After looking closer, it appears this was just an already made pepperoni pizza that had been premade and had additional toppings thrown in before being reheated. Why do I think that? The pepperonis and cheese actually stuck together on the pizza. No other toppings seemed to have melded with the cheese. Crust was soggy and bent immediately (another sign the veggies were added after the fact and not during initial cooking). Sub par experience, and after all that it was nearly $50 after tip. Sorry, not worth it, especially if my pie isn't gonna be made fresh when ordered. read more

Ciro's NY Pizza is located near my job. They have a great lunch special with two slices of pizza and a drink for like $7 bucks. Nothing is that cheap these days so definitely worth a try. This place was recommend and it didn't disappoint. I came here with two of my coworkers for a quick lunch and we all enjoyed the pizza. I have ordered it to-go as well for my team and it wasn't as good because the pizza was soggy. Definitely recommend eating inside or immediately. read more

See all

I don't understand wht this restaurant is on Uber Eats. They always say not taking orders at this time. It's been that way for months. I like their food, but what is the use being on an app, then not take orders. read more

Pretty good place that recently changed the name from Cafe Positano to Ciro's NY Pizza. Picked up wings, pizza slices, and spaghetti bolognese here the other night. Looks like there is online ordering now, but didn't see spaghetti bolognese on the online menu so I called in instead. The spaghetti with meat sauce is fantastic as always. I love the flavor and the sauce texture! The wings were good and I get them extra crispy. The garlic wing flavor is very subtle but still delicious. The pizza here is good, but the meat lover slices I ordered had the meat placed on top of a standard cheese slice and it looked like they were not really baked. I would suggest to Ciro's to put more cheese on top of the meat and bake the slices. The pizza seemed unfinished? I didn't complain because I was hungry and I put cheese on my pizza slices and threw them in my oven at home. No big deal, I was starving. But definitely order the spaghetti and wings, you can't go wrong! read more

The food is amazing. The atmosphere is great. The chef to make the best linguine with a red clam sauce is amazing, but specially is amazing and this person stands out as a great waitress is Allison read more

Yummy goodness! Called Donny for a catering order for 1k people. He took care of everything. Recommended the right mix of food and it was spot on! Feeding hungry and foodie cybersecurity professionals can be a challenge and Ciro's knocked it out of the park. Will use them again for my next Event. read more

We had a hunger for good pizza We stopped in Ciro's and had a great pizza! We were greeted promptly, ordered, and our pizza was served in no time. Wished we lived here to go there more often. read more

Most delicious food!!!!! Yummy yummy yummy! Hands down the best pizza/italian place in the area. read more

Ciro's NY Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sanford, Florida

This is the place, the Real Deal! We've gone often and tried most menu items and have not been dissatisfied once. The pizza is loaded with cheese, topping are generous, they make their own mozzarella, but let's face it - a pizza lives or dies by the sauce. The sauce here is made onsite and it's an understatement to say it's delicious. I also recommend the American Stromboli. Deliziosa! Mangia Tutto! read more

This pizza was ok but we had the tiramisu and it was terrible, we decided to say we didn't like it and the manager did not want to take it off our bill even though we had one bite each. Worst customer service and could even hear the cooks saying things as well as if we couldn't hear. Worst customer service, over priced for some mediocre pizza and terrible tiramisu. It was dry and they lost us as customers and also told my friends who go to never go back there and they said they wouldn't because it wasn't even that great anyways. read more

The first time I ordered from Ciros was this past week. On Saturday night, my family and I wanted some pies quickly. All of my regular pizza joints told me that our food would not be ready for at least an hour - Ciros had it ready in 20 minutes! It was really convenient. Arriving at the store to pick up my order, they were very welcoming. I was a bit early, so I waited to the side. They had a large seating area and many families were enjoying themselves. People came in to place orders to go and I was surprised at how many people did so. The pies came fresh out of the oven and were handed to me. It was impressive that they offered 18-inch pizzas at a reasonable price! And they were really tasty, too! Everyone commented how great the pizza was. We'll definitely be stopping by again soon. read more

They have slices up till around 3pm. One off the few places to offer Grandma (Nona) pizza read more

Best veal parm in central Florida! Donnie is the best! The pizza makes me feel like I am still in Brooklyn!

Since day one when we walked in the food and service has been great! Since the new upgrade of the restaurant which are beautiful the food and service is even better! Great additions to the wine menu, delicious especially the Sangue di Giuda a must try if you like bubbly and sweet! Over all we love this place from the pizza to pasta dishes and there special new appetizers they have for certain times have been delicious! Can't wait to go back again! read more

We were on our way to Target when hubby spotted this place and wanted to try it. I am so happy we did! We only had slices this time, but they were delicious and we can't wait to try more! read more

Omg omg omg! Yay!!! NY PIZZA! So im a Jersey girl, and I swear we had the best pizza better than New York, and Sarah's reminds me of it. I will say once in a while someone else does the cooking and it comes out a little less-than but 99.9% of the time it is flipping amazing. It's important to know that it's not just the pizza that's done right - all of the Italian dishes, and the specials! Oh! The specials...YUM OK To try: PIZZA buffalo chicken pizza - holy cow! Chicken white pizza Pepperoni roll Sicilian pizza Shrimp scampi Every special Newly remodeled Love it! read more