Awesome pizza! It was our last night on the island and we had heard this was the place to go for both pizza & local Italian favorites! Great food, our waiter was fun, and took care of us on a busy Thursday evening. It's definitely a locals spot & we always enjoy those while on vacation. Definitely check it out! read more

We had enjoyed seafood every day of our Florida trip but were longing for something a little different. Coastal pizza was just the ticket! The toppings were great (particularly the Kalamata olives) and the crust was just right...even the next day! Very reasonable, great food. Don't be put off by the sports bar vibe, it's worth it! read more

Take out order is completed quick fast and friendly. Very good quality pasta, as well as the meatball appetizer. Very crowded on a football Saturday early evening. Nice family friendly atmosphere. Both priced we got the coastal pasta special, which was amazing. The meatballs were twice the size of golf balls and almost as big as a baseball . read more

Ordered pizza for takeout. Very pleasant young lady took my order. Pizza was ready on time. It was a large Margarita. The Roma tomatoes were tasteless. The underlying sauce was too concentrated. There was lots of mozzarella but not much basil. The size of the pizza was generous and the price was fair. read more

We had an excellent pizza the other night with some boddingtons ale. Our friends had chicken parm and another deep dish and loved their food too. Staff is great. We eat here more than anywhere on the island, it's always consistent, delicious, and a good value. read more

Visiting here on spring break with my family and we were looking for a very chill night at our villa after a long day out and about. Coastal pizza hit the spot!!!! Very good pizza and very friendly staff. Woman behind the bar was delightful and easy to chat with. I got a cheese pizza with extra cheese for the kids and Margherita pizza for me and wifey. So good! See below. read more

See all

Ordered take out and pizza and Cheesesteak Stromboli was so good. Definitely will be back and order again. The attendant was friendly and the food was ready before they told me. Great service and my daughter loved the cheese pizza. It almost seemed like a community pizzeria with a sports bar feel. Sorry no pics to show. read more

We ordered pizza to go to relax in our hotel room after a long day. We were able to order a split pizza. Half for each of us. The crust and pizza sauce were delicious. I would recommend this favorite local restaurant. read more

Was searching for a good carryout option for a pizza picnic on the beach, and we luckily found Coastal Pizza! We loved the flavoring of the crust, and the toppings were fresh and plentiful. We would highly recommend you give it a try! Our two tips to make it even better: 1. Call it in an hour or more before you need it. (They were very busy on Sunday evening, so we had to wait 50 minutes for our pizza) 2. The "Hungry" size pizza is VERY large. Proceed with caution, lol. read more

Coastal Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

We ordered take out but decided to head to the restaurant and have a beer while waiting for the pizza to get done. The place was pretty packed on a Friday night. We ordered two "hungry" sized pizzas - huge and really tasty. The bartender was a blast and everyone we met was really friendly. Overall a great vibe and great pizza. Not overly loud even with the place being full. Will definitely be back. read more

Great Pizza!! Crispy crust and great sauce. Service on phone and servers always super nice. Great Job!!

The pizza was very good. Crust was excellent. Caesar salad was unexpectedly very good. Went back. Would go again. read more

One of 3 really good pizza joints on the island I won't mention the other two that's up to you to discover. Clean , courteous , and a lot of flatscreens to watch your favorite team on. read more

Fantastic food and service, best pizza that we've found so far on the island Highly recommend read more

Slice & salad....great price performer & pizza is the best thin crust around!!! Salad with house dressing is great, too!

The House Salad with Chianti dressing equals perfection! The Pizza was delicious! We had the Manatee Pizza, thin crisp crust loaded with fresh veggies. So yummy and generous portion size. read more

Hands down, the Best pizza in Fernandina Beach/Amelia Island. The balance of weight, cheese, sauce, and toppings are precisely what you want...unless you're eyeing a Detroit Pizza or Chicago Pizza (both pizza styles regrettably unavailable in the area. I have tried many pizzas in the area and there is no question this is a terrific pizza! read more

This is a great place for pizza; whether you dine in or carry out. The quality of the pizza is good, with great ingredients and a nice crust. They do a good job of quality control in pick up to ensure that you are getting the pizza you order. They can be hard to reach via phone; but I think that speaks to the quality of their product. In the future I'd love to see a deliver service; but they may not want to as it might reduce the quality. Overall great place; highly recommend. read more

The food is great and the staff is t notch Cannot say enough for friendliness. Always fresh made when you order. Veggies fresh cut for pizza read more

In Amelia for car weekend. Reviews were good so I thought I would try it out. Friday night, dinner time but only about 7-8 minute wait. Great food, friendly service. I would definitely go back read more

First time there will never ever go there again. Service was terrible. Got my food after everybody else was served. Waitress was terrible. Service sucks. Spoke to the manager. He was very professional and informed me that everything was addressed. I appreciate him taking the time to talk to me. We will come back and try again. read more

Coastal Pizza is always good. The pies are served hot and fresh. The slices are a little heavy so ask for the pie to be cooked a little extra to crisp it up. The service is usually good especially if you sit at the bar. read more

Nice find. Much better than V's pizza. I like the thicker crunchier crust here and the Garlic Knots are the bomb. Order a appetizer of Garlic Knots. You won't get any unless you order a side salad and only then you only get one. It's not enough!!! The Garlic Cesar dressing is yum and the chianti basil dressing is more of a sweet vinaigrette. Both were yum read more

See all

The phone is almost never answered I have called 20 times in a row If you want to eat in it is cold and takes forever to get your meal read more

Coastal Pizza has the best Cesar Salad dressing and bread knots on the island! Love the laid back atmosphere.

I am from NJ and it would not be fair to rate pizza here on that scale, however with that being said, Coastal makes a nice solid pizza... one of the best in the area. It's not overpriced boutique pizza. The restaurant is also a bar. The customer service is one best in its class as well. Price are what they should be. Don't be afraid to give them a shot! read more

Best pizza ever! The food was so good! It wasn't too greasy and it was the perfect combination of crispy and fluffy! I highly recommend eating here! The service was wonderful as well! read more

Coastal Pizza - Mainlanders with mushrooms, olives ricotta, spinach and garlic - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Solid choice. Pizza was really good - we had the ranch dressing base "CBR" plus the First Coaster. Both were excellent. Beer ranking was about 2.5 stars. Ok selection, but one classic - Sierra Nevada Pale Ale was flat - it was quickly replaced. Their IPA (it was new to me) was just ok - probably about 8 on drafts. Fairly busy early on a wednesday night - looked like mostly older locals. I would return1 read more

Good pizza , not far from the beach . Cold beer and great outdoor seating. Always busy and great way to relax off the beaten path.

Currently the best pizza place in Fernandina beach. Service is polite and friendly and fast and the pizza is just the best on the island right no. Highly recommend. read more

Just flew in from Los Angeles to visit my family on the island, and their chicken parmigiana was incredible--definitely the best meal I've had here! Plus, they've got all the games on, so it's the perfect spot for sports fans. If you haven't been yet, I highly recommend checking them out! Wish I took pics of my meal to post but I was so hungry after getting a massage just now and had ate it in seconds. read more

Good place. We wanted pizza bad and usually go to Townies but they were closed, so we tried this based on Yelp recommendations. The cheese pizza was excellent and the veggie was ok. Large is pretty large! They were super busy when we came to pick up so it took a few minutes but they delivered. The cheese pizza had a portion of in the middle that was missing. It wasn't much and I would've been fine with it but the owner very conscientiously told us about it and offered us a $15 gift card for a return visit! I appreciated this! And of course it's smart because it ensures we will come back ;-) read more

Food is delicious. Better than average pizza joint. We ended up going back during our trip because everyone was happy with their meal.

Coastal Pizza is tiny but yummy!! Tucked away in a corner plaza off SR 200, it has a locals vibe; a laid back atmosphere coupled with fresh and tasty food! Try their slice, salad and drink special! If you go on Friday night, order 30 to 45 minutes ahead or you may be waiting a bit. read more

Coastal Pizza - Greek salad and a Stromboli underneath! - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

The pizza was okay. I prefer a little more seasoning.. Service was astronomical! Lemon drop martini was on point.

Very Tasty Great Service Had Calzone and Pizza they were both delicious It would be great to have longer hours for pickup or delivery read more

Good pizza. Friendly staff. Their system went down and they were making the best of a tough situation. Make sure you order early on a Friday evening. read more

Great wings and nice people. Only have ordered takeout but always looks busy. Must be something right

Great pizza good food. New to the area. This place was recommended so I went in. Everybody's very friendly. The waitresses are great and the food was excellent gonna be one of my regular spots. read more

We came across this spot by chance. We were in town for pizza but our "go to" was only open for drive thru and we wanted a place to sit and chill. They have pizza, wings, sandwiches and pasta dishes. We kept it simple with pizza and a calzone. The calzone was perfectly cooked but I found the addition of gorgonzola cheese an oddity for me (I opted out of that) . EVOO is also an interesting addition. If you're wondering, extra virgin olive oil. I probably will ask for lighter on the oil too next time. With cheese and pepperoni it really makes it a little bit greasy for my palate. The service is EXCELLENT. Very attentive and professional. I love that they offer a variety of beers that probably pair well with the wings. This place probably rocks game days based upon all the TVs. We'll be back. read more

See all