Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Conestoga Restaurant

    3.2 (124 reviews)
    ModerateBars, New American, Greek
    Open 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Conestoga Restaurant Photos

    Business Info

    CONESTOGA RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Quiet
    Casual
    Good for groups
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Conestoga Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Chicken & Shrimp Amatriciana

    ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING! From the moment I walked in to the second | left. Not 1 person greeted me as 4 servers passed me. It wasn't until | asked, "do we seat ourselves?" Then I was acknowledged. The food was so bad we left it barely touched & told the waitress how disgusting it was. Nobody came to ask what was wrong or how they could fix it. $90 for unseasoned steak, sour mash potatoes & unseasoned shrimp and chicken in watered "Amatriciana" with excessive tomatoes, if you can consider it that. I have never been so disgusted with a food establishment as this or how they had full tables! I'll never return nor suggest this place to anyone. We were looking for outdoor dining by the river. This isn't it! It's by a very congested street. Very minimal view of water.

    Garlic parm and hot wings
    Kenneth N.

    I got the weekend prime rib special for 32 dollars or 0.0000085 bitcoin in today's price. Steak was 16oz but it was probably bigger. It came with a salad, bread, a side of your choice, and the PRIME RIB!!!! The staff was very kind and seems like there were lots of locals enjoying some liberations and food. My only issue is that the service was a tad slow so the fries came out a little cold. For the appetizer, we got the wings and that was a little on cold and the chicken was somewhat soggy. However, this place will get 5 stars because the prime rib was some of the best in the county!

    Menu
    Brandon H.

    So we visited Dutch Wonderland in Lancaster, PA earlier in the day on Sunday. The food inside the theme park was terrible, so we needed some great food to make up for that part of Dutch Wonderland When we got there it was already dark out and was actually colder inside the restaurant than outside so we decided to sit outside which was fine because they have a beautiful outdoor seating area that overlooks the Conestoga River. Our waitress was so nice and took her time explaining some items on the menu and how they could accommodate one of our daughter's allergies. The food began coming out and the cheese sticks came first with the perfect crunchy outside and gooey cheesy inside that made for the perfect cheese pull. I haven't begun filming myself yet so those small details being captures on film for the public to see will have to be saved for a later date. Our 4 year old said her personal pizza was excellent and she ended up eating it all so that speaks volumes. Our 9 year old got a burger patty, steamed broccoli, and orange slices and proclaimed, "This is the best burger I've ever had!" Success! My wife ordered a pizza and didn't realize she had ordered a whole pie, but it was a mix of veggies and pepperoni and she loved it! Said it was very tasty. I got a personal flatbread pizza that was originally supposed to have pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon. I personally am not a big fan of ham or bacon on pizza so I asked for extra sausage and pepperoni and they absolutely delivered! One of the best pizzas I've had! Would definitely recommend to anyone visiting Lancaster, PA. * From what I understand they are under new ownership and things have turned around in a big way! IG & TikTok: @bmh_reviewer

    Sour Monkey..
    Bobbye S.

    Out galavanting and decided to grab some dinner early. We got onion rings for an appetizer. We both got different flavors of wings. Everything was delicious. Our server Amanda was great!

    Good food. Decent sized portions. Friendly staff. Clean. A little pricey. Might eat outside next time.

    Salmon was good
    Lillian W.

    Great atmosphere! The restaurant was spacious clean and warm. Waitess greeting and seated us. The serice and food was great!

    Jill S.

    I'm from north jersey and we come to Lancaster once a year. We came here on a limb because we couldn't find something that wasn't a chain that was open for lunch besides pubs. When we walked inside and it was completely empty so we were a little skeptical but decided to try it anyways and we are extremely glad we did. This was such a delicious meal. The food was cooked with so much flavor and was super tasty. They also were out of the large pitas and instead gave me two which were much bigger than expected with no added charge. The waitress was very nice and we sat outside on the patio which is lovely. We will definitely be back!

    Tuna Melt

    See all

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of C H.
    0
    140
    1

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Conestoga Restaurant

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bars 2,299 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Passerine

    Passerine

    4.4
    (84 reviews)
    1.8 mi

    Fabulous brunch at Passerine. From the moment you enter this charming restaurant, you'll feel…read morewelcome. Be sure to begin your brunch with a cup of their robust coffee or your favorite brunch cocktail. We stuck with coffee but the cocktails looked divine. Small but interesting brunch menu. Really appreciate Passerine's commitment to local producers.

    My wife and I dined at Passerine in Lancaster for Valentine's Day and chose the $75 per person…read morefixed-price five-course menu. Unfortunately, the evening was very disappointing. When we were seated, we were given the prix fixe food menu but never provided with a drink menu. We were served water, but our waitress didn't ask if we'd like cocktails, wine, or any featured Valentine's drinks. For a special occasion dinner, that felt like a major oversight. The bigger issue, though, was the food. Several courses were noticeably undercooked and difficult to enjoy. The carrot salad had hard, undercooked carrots and a very bitter sauce that overwhelmed the dish. The grilled Badger Flame beets were also undercooked and had an unpleasant flavor. The beet risotto was firm and lacked the creamy consistency you expect from a properly prepared risotto. The halibut tasted overly fishy and seemed undercooked in the center. For $75 per person on Valentine's Day, we expected a polished, thoughtfully executed experience. Instead, the meal felt poorly prepared and not worth the price. It was an unsatisfying way to spend what should have been a special evening. The ambiance was very nice but the rest of the experience left a lot to be desired.

    Photos
    Passerine Lancaster
    Passerine Lancaster
    Japanese milk bread French toast
    Japanese milk bread French toast
    Citrus & Parsnip is perfect for root vegetable lovers

    See all

    Citrus & Parsnip is perfect for root vegetable lovers
    Horse Inn

    Horse Inn

    4.4
    (408 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $$

    You know those meals that are so darn delicious that days later your still thinking about it?…read more Well this was that meal!! OMG. In a recent visit to Lancaster I did some searching online for places to eat and followed the recommendations to the Horse Inn. Sooo happy we did!! The food was amazing. My husband says it was the best shrimp and grits he's ever had! My steak tips were equally as yummy. The sauce was out of this world good!! The fries!! Jesus what was that sorcery ?? YUMMMM. Hats off to the owners and chefs! Only bad thing is we don't live close by and we can't go back soon. But we will be back!! Special mention to our wonderful fun server, Luis, who made the experience even better for us! Give that guy a raise. THANK YOU!!

    This place was BUSY on a Saturday night (a good thing for a restaurant and a good sign for those…read morecoming in for the first time)... we didn't have a reservation, having planned to late, but they do keep tables open for walk-ins and despite being told it was an hour wait (whatever, we knew we ran that risk), we were seated in 15 minutes - Luck, maybe? But awesome all the same! For how busy they were, the server was very attentive and very accommodating as we were yapping away and constantly not ready with our orders so kuddos for the team and putting up with us! I love the mystery beer concept, its not great beer, but being from DC at like $2 a can, I am not passing that up, ever. And a cheap beer with a burger is the perfect combo! On to the burger... I have heard that this is a great burger... and I have to conclude that I agree though it is reminiscent of a Big Mac - just way better ingredients - it has to be the sauce they put on it... Anyway, nice size patty, good amount of toppings and a quality bun (not too soft, not too thick, bread soaks up some of the juices but doesn't fall apart). The mussels were quite excellent as well. It was a Thai curry broth the night we were there and it was drinkable, like soup... we did ask for extra bread... enough said. I am going to take a minute too and praise their spirit free cocktails. THIS IS HOW THEY SHOULD BE MADE. They used bitters, tonics, etc to craft something that tasted like a cocktail but without alcohol which means they were not sickly sugary concoctions, but expertly crafted beverages. Just really great options. All that said though, their espresso martini was one of the worst I have had. Just skip that.

    Photos
    Bar
    Bar
    Horse Inn
    SUMMER MELON MARG

    See all

    SUMMER MELON MARG
    Route 66

    Route 66

    4.4
    (203 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    $

    Such a great food find in Lancaster!…read more Friendly crew here! Lots of hellos and the fun Route 66 decor is very welcoming. They have several tables and lots of different options on their menu! Casual shop with brisk business. Walk in, order, and pay. When your food is ready, they call out your order. Everything is made fresh and the prices are actually very reasonable for the quality of food. My cole slaw in the Nashville fried chicken was very fresh and delicious. Fries were fresh, and perfectly seasoned with salt. All their burgers and sandwiches have the Route 66 sauce. Don't skip it, if it's served with it, just go with the flow! Nashville hot fried chicken sandwich $8.49 Double cheeseburger $8.99 Fried chicken tikka masala sandwich $8.99 Large home cut fries $5.99 They take credit cards. Can't wait to come back!

    If friends and family ask me where to go in Lancaster, there is 1 answer everytime. Route 66…read more Small little place on the corner of Liberty and Prince. Not much seating, but the food is WORTH IT! Don't know what to get? Chicken Tandoori Cheesesteak. Trust us and enjoy. 5 star sandwich. Any of their Chicken sandwiches are INCREDIBLE and they are MASSIVE! Plus for 7.50, nobody is beating that quality of food for that price in the entire city. Fresh cut fries, awesome. Smash burgers, tasty and fulfilling. This is your sign, go to Route 66.

    Photos
    Fountain Soda
    Fountain Soda
    Yummm
    Yummm
    Double Cheeseburger (7.4 oz.)

    See all

    Double Cheeseburger (7.4 oz.)
    The Watershed Pub

    The Watershed Pub

    4.4
    (335 reviews)
    36.9 mi
    $$
    Outdoor seating
    Full bar

    Loved loved loved Jessie the waiter! He was extremely attentive and knowledgeable about the menu.read more

    I've passed Watershed Pub a million times and never stopped, so when I met a friend for lunch, it…read morefinally felt like the right time to check it out. Naturally, I had already done my due diligence (read: stalked the menu for a full week) and had a game plan. At the top of my list? The deviled eggs and the Kale Caesar salad with salmon. The only problem...I absolutely did not need $40 worth of food for lunch. So I quietly spent the week putting "deviled egg energy" out into the Universe, hoping my lunch partner would suggest splitting them. Manifestation is real, people. I arrived around 12pm and found plenty of parking out back in Watershed's designated lot, which is clearly labeled--a good thing, because parking in that area looks like it could get competitive if you're not paying attention. We had made a 12:15pm reservation (Monday lunch felt safe, but why risk it?), and our table on the enclosed patio was ready when we arrived. It was the perfect setup--sunny and bright, but still warm enough to be comfortable on a chilly day. The vibe was great, and our server was even better--friendly, attentive, and consistently checking in without being overbearing. Then it was time to order. I let my lunch partner go first and waited... "Do you want to try the deviled eggs as an appetizer?" Are you kidding me?!. YES. Yes, I did! We ordered the deviled eggs ($11) to share, and I followed through with my Kale Caesar salad ($15) topped with seared salmon (+$13), officially completing my week-long menu-stalking mission. The deviled eggs came out FAST, and in my excitement, I completely forgot to take a picture--which tells you everything you need to know. Each egg was topped with a cube of candied bacon that absolutely stole the show. Sweet, savory, and just the right texture to complement the creamy filling. We made quick work of all four--excellent start to the meal! Not long after, our lunches arrived, and my salad? Gorgeous. Like, actually exciting to look at. I dug in immediately and it delivered. The mix of shaved brussels sprouts, kale, and romaine gave it great texture, the dressing was well-balanced, and the red onion didn't overpower the rest of the flavors. But my favorite part? The garlic parmesan crouton crumble. No chasing rogue croutons around the plate--just perfectly distributed crunch in every bite. Genius! The portion size was generous, too--I made it through about half before calling it and boxing the rest for dinner later. By the time we were wrapping up, the enclosed patio had filled up significantly, which tells me this is a popular lunch spot--and for good reason. The food is solid, the atmosphere is great, and the service was spot on. That said...$40 for deviled eggs, a salad and water is a bit steep for an everyday lunch. For me, this feels more like a "treat yourself," client meeting, or special occasion kind of place rather than a regular rotation spot. Would I come back? Absolutely. Would I be casually popping in every week? Probably not. But those deviled eggs? Totally worth manifesting!

    Photos
    The Watershed Pub
    The Watershed Pub
    The Watershed Pub

    See all

    On Orange

    On Orange

    4.5
    (364 reviews)
    1.8 mi
    $$

    Introduction:…read more Representing 2018 in alphabet series, O is for On Orange. The letter O only has 5 of the 8 possible years represented in the alphabet series. Interestingly, 2 of them are in Lancaster County, PA. This was prior to my parents moving to Lancaster in 2021. In March 2018, my girlfriend of that time & I took a day trip to Lancaster. I lived in Montgomery County, Maryland (near DC) at the time, and we were meeting up with a friend who was living in New Jersey kind of in the middle. We agreed to meet at On Orange at 12 PM on that Sunday, March 25 since we were driving from far away, and I think they were doing a day trip too, but possible they stayed a night in town, not sure. Also, On Orange closes at 1 PM too, so even more reason to be punctual. My g/f of then was notoriously late & took a long time to get ready. She was taking too long to get ready, and I knew we needed to leave if we even had a chance of making it on time. After a while I said I don't want to do this, but I will leave without you & meet my friend (& his girlfriend). I started the car and texted you have 1 minute to come out, and if you aren't out, I'm leaving without you. My timer reached 0, and I slowly was driving off, but I saw her shuffling with her coat and what have you leaving, so I waited. We got in the car, and I rushed off. If that weren't bad enough, my g/f said we needed to stop at her bank to get cash. Of course, there was none right within route, but saw a location right off I-83 in northern MD, Hunt Valley, but we wasted more time to get off the freeway, for her to go to her ATM, & get back on the freeway when we were running significantly late. I said we are running significantly late as it is, so why are we wasting more time. She claimed in case there was something she wanted to buy in Lancaster, but that was not the primary purpose, but I'll get to that at the end. I was panicking on the significant late, and that the restaurant closes at 1, and I drove above 100 mph at times on I-70, which I think was the only time I've ever gone that fast on 70, and maybe only 4 times ever in my life reaching that speed. Experience with the Restaurant: This is street parking around here, which was free meters on Sunday. We got a decent parking spot a block away. We walked in at 12:50 PM, which was 50 minutes LATE and 10 minutes before On Orange's closing time of 1 PM. My friend & his girlfriend were already done eating. He said that they had their stomach set for eating at 12, and there was pressure to order since it's not a huge place and pretty busy. I was annoyed with my friend for not waiting for us, but I get it because let's be honest, my g/f fault on that one. Server was cordial, and my g/f & I quickly ordered. Food came out quickly. We ate quickly, and my friend & his g/f watching us eat. Food was delicious, and they were quick, but to be fair, they were closing in 10 minutes, so they were motivated to get out of there. I got a pancake & egg dish as I recall. This was a top notch brunch. In spite of the negative experience of being so late because of my g/f, the experience at the restaurant was excellent. Conclusion: After brunch, we looked around downtown, Amish Farm (see my 5-star review of them written in April 2018), etc. and was overall a nice day with the 3 of them albeit very cold. After we left, I took the back road from I-83 all the way back to Germantown, MD where she lived to see something different and to save a little gas too since it's pretty direct going that way. My g/f was complaining about it taking so long getting back. I knew she was meeting up with a friend that night. But what I later realized, she wanted to stop at an ATM that morning really because she needed cash to pay that friend for cannabis that night. So, she disrespected everyone's time for this. I guess on a positive at least she wasn't cheating on me with that guy and really was just for pot. In conclusion, I thought On Orange was top notch, and they were accommodating to our time schedules.

    Stopped by on a Tuesday morning and had just the best experience. The owner created us and took us…read moreto the patio. It had a little bit of a magical feel for a Tuesday morning. It was a very intimate space. We ordered an Indian omelet and a peasant omelet. Both were delicious, had there not been more people on the patio we may have licked our plates. The side of sautéed tomatoes with garlic were out of this world.

    Photos
    On Orange
    Stewed Pancakes
    Stewed Pancakes
    On Orange

    See all

    Conestoga Restaurant - bars - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...