Stopped in on a Saturday for a quick fish and chips. Dinner wasn't disappointed at all. Quick…read moreservice. Excellent meal. Look forward to our next visit.

Absolutely pathetic & ridiculous the size of this! Used to hang off the plate now its literally a…read morefish patty. Last time order this here !

It was our servers first shift and she did a phenomenal job!…read more Appetizers and entrees were fantastic. Shout out to the chef who brought us some Brussels sprouts to try on the house! We will definitely be back often.

This was our first time here. The food was delicious. We ordered a I believe it was called an…read moreeggplant tower. It may have been a special I don't recall hand. I ordered the Al Kapone, which is a meatball sub.

I was fully prepared to judge this book by it's cover, but when my friend told me we were going to…read moredinner here and the seafood was fantastic, I took her word.... and she was right! This is a locals bar, an older crowd. Don't come for the atmosphere; come for the food and drinks! Bar staff was attentive and recommended the fish. They stress that they only serve FRESH haddock and only certain days of the week. I enjoy fish and chips so went for that.... and it was great! Awesome portion, not greasy at all, fries tasty and coleslaw with a nice tang! Can't go wrong for $16. Pretty big menu with lots of reasonably priced options. Pleasantly surprised! Would return!

Amazing food and service. Nice place to have Dinner and a good cocktail. Everyone is very friendly.read more

Solid restaurant with creative and tasty menu items. Reasonably priced and one of the best spots…read morein East Longmeadow! Be sure to try the general Tso cauliflower!

Service was fantastic. Food was delicious. Only complaint is the price point of the food was little…read morehigh, would have preferred less food smaller price point. We opted for a more tapas style light dinner. With sesame crusted tuna, Cobb salad, fondue tower, and calamari 1/2&1/2. We appreciated the 1/2 and 1/2 option for the calamari (1/2 Rhode island, 1/2 regular) but when the plate came you couldn't tell the divide. Which was an issue for those that don't want spicy. The bar was very busy and the cocktail menu seems very good. So I can definitely see this place as your after work dinner with friends place to be. But for a calm casual dinner - maybe not. Overall it is a good place. But probably not for everyone - but doesn't need to be.

Sat 2/28/2026 PROS:…read moreBaked Stuffed Haddock- Excellent Shrimp Scampi- Excellent Prime Rib - Excellent Got plenty of Au Jus unlike Outback & Texas were I have to ask for extra Au Jus Website ordering is easy and efficient CONS: Ordered for 5pm pickup, received two messages that my order was ready. Arrived at 5:05 pm. Order not ready! Had to wait over 20 minutes

I hate leaving negative reviews for local businesses, but I also believe customers deserve honesty…read moreand transparency. For months, I've been using Captain Jimmy's online ordering system, regularly placing large Friday night orders for my friends and me during our weekly gaming nights. Over that time, I accumulated 790 reward points through their online rewards program. Although I noticed there was never an option to redeem points during online checkout, I assumed I would be able to use them in the restaurant. Today, I visited with my wife and youngest daughter. After our entire meal was ordered, served, eaten, and we received the bill, I asked to redeem my reward points. Only then was I told that the rewards program was no longer active. I asked to speak with a manager, but instead of speaking with one, another server came over to explain the situation. I was told the rewards program had been inactive for four months. The problem is that while I was sitting at the table, I logged into my rewards account and verified that I still had 790 points. The website was still actively displaying my balance and showing that every 100 points could be redeemed for $5 off, meaning my account reflected approximately $35 in available rewards. Despite this, I was told those rewards would not be honored. If the rewards program has truly been discontinued, why is it still being advertised on the website? Why are customers still able to accumulate and view points with stated redemption values if those rewards won't actually be accepted? This wasn't about the $35. It was about trust. Businesses should stand behind the programs they advertise or clearly remove them if they're no longer valid. Continuing to display reward balances and redemption values while refusing to honor them is misleading and left me feeling deceived. I sincerely hope Captain Jimmy's either removes the inactive rewards program from its website or honors the rewards that loyal customers earned in good faith. Unfortunately, based on this experience, I left feeling disappointed and misled rather than appreciated as a repeat customer.

Great food and good service would avoid on Friday and Saturday nights, it's very busy which service…read morecan be little bit slower. Would definitely be back here during weekday.

Very attentive staff, food plentiful and very good. Fun, family style Italian restaurant.read more

Best prices in the area for quality food and drink. Excellent service in a pub atmosphere. We dine…read moreout often and this is a new favorite place for us.

The food was absolutely awful. I was very surprised on a Saturday night the place was dead at…read more8:30pm. The specialty drinks were terrible. The pumpkin martini looked and tasted like pure milk it was white. The caramel apple came in a pint class. It should be a martini drink not a pint glass drink. We got the sampler for an appetizer. The only good thing on there was the onion rings. Everything else was not good. Wings weren't saucy, Irish egg rolls tasted funny, Irish balls we're bland not flavor. Dinner my wife got the patty melt. The only thing good she said was the French fries. Our friends got a burger and Ruben sandwich both said they were terrible. I got the shepherds pie. I am Irish and have a huge problem with this dish. It was all potato and hardly any filling in it. Very bland and very disappointing. Non of us finished our dinners because the food was awful. We were so looking forward to a nice Irish pub. Very disappointed in this place. Will never ever go back. SHAME ON YOU NATHAN BILLS. Our sever was good. That's the only positive about this establishment.

Decided on Italian last night, found this restaurant on Grok. Came in and was seated right away…read more The place had an old rustic feel to it. Our server was very nice and attentive. Started with arancini and friend calamari. The calamari sauce was extremly heavy on garlic, quite over powering. Then we ordered our entrées. Eggplant parm for my sister in law, my nephew got Margherita pie, my husband a hamburger and I got salmon risotto. My risotto was not bad, but the salmon had no taste. There was no fresh mozzarella for the Margherita pie which was disappointing. disappointing. Overall the food was just okay, nothing stood out.

This place never disappoints! We always order an eggplant and chicken parm meal. With a big salad…read morethere is enough food for a big lunch and leftovers for another meal. Makaila was a sweet and friendly waitress, and we appreciated being greeted with a big smile. Instead of pasta I asked for garlic spinach. Good choice!