Well what a shame. I am compelled to drop my initial 4 star review to 2 and here's the story.
First, people reading these reviews should be sure to only pay attention to reviews past about April 2015, although it seems this place is slipping back in to what it used to be minus the cloud of cigarette smoke, and that's only because it's the law now...I think.
I don't see how anyone can give the Crescent Inn 5 stars. They must be friends or are having a radically different experience than me.
I have ordered out from here a few times since my first review. The fried chicken was OK and you can get, at least at the time, a baked potato as one of your sides. I don't see that very often.
I also ordered the sausage gravy and biscuits once and the portion was very large, but the gravy was bland. It needed way more sausage fat, salt and black pepper in it...and sausage. But for some people I'm sure they would rave about it. Some folks apparently like bland food.
Today I had an opportunity to nestle in, read some magazines, get on their WiFi and listen to some talk radio and take my time. I needed to kill some time actually.
Everything started out fine and normal, I was told to sit where I wanted. I got a whole booth to myself which was great because I wanted to spread out.
I was asked which menu I wanted and I chose both, in case I wanted something off the breakfast menu. I was in the mood for soup because it was so cold outside and thought I would get a bowl of the Italian wedding soup which is permanent on the menu. Guess what? They had none! Vegetable soup was the only soup they had, so I ordered a cup...thankfully not a bowl.
My server was an older lady. I'm OK with that, I like me some seasoned citizens, I'm getting there myself, but she came off...I don't know, maybe unhappy? Hard to explain exactly but a bit of a sourpuss.
After ordering the soup, I got her attention and asked if they had WiFi. First she said no, then I said the other girl had told me before they did. She just stood there and said she hadn't heard of it and had never been asked before. She continued to stand there with the order pad waiting for me to order and it was clear I was not ready to order. I had told her I was not in a hurry when I sat down.
I said, "I think I'll stop with the soup" and closed up my menus. She then said let me check on that for you and came back a little later with the WiFi password. But, by then I was already done with this experience and re-stated I would just have the soup and that's it. Plus, the password was the restaurant name and some numbers and the name wasn't even spelled correctly!
The soup was terrible. On a cold day, in a diner, how can you not have at least one if not a few soups on hand? This soup looked like they had diced fresh vegetables (I'll concede they were fresh or at least frozen and not canned) and thrown them in a pan of water when I ordered...and it tasted like it. Zero seasoning that I could detect and the vegetables were still sort of crunchy. A can of store brand canned soup would have been better.
I tried hot, sauce, salt and pepper and still could not pull the soup up to anything worth my time. I left 80% in the cup, and paid my tab and left. Of course at this point "sourpuss" was suddenly calling me honey and sweetie as I paid. It was obvious I was unhappy with her and the soup.
I left and went to the local pancake house, and left immediately as I saw they were completely un-managed as well. I ended up getting fast food. Sadly, with all the quirks and issues with the sit down restaurants around the Zion Crossroads area...and my wife and I have eaten at all of them...the fast food places are actually the best places to eat.
The crescent Inn probably does some good food. It's hard to mess up regular diner food like eggs, pancakes, breakfast meats, spaghetti and such, but step outside that and you get out of the range of this place. They have even taken things off the menu that were really attractive, probably because they cant do them well.
At this point I will be hard pressed to try again. Maybe someday this area will have a great sit-down restaurant but all of them here now have one issue or another. There are some good places to eat over in the Lake Monticello area 15 and 20 minutes south/southwest if you are not just off the highway for a pit stop. read more