Damn good pizza! Thin crust with the perfect amount of toppings. Plus it's easy to fold. I'm from NY so I know good pizza and this place hits the mark. The slices are huge so I recommend only getting one unless you haven't eaten for days. read more

Delicious pizza. Friendly owner. Will be back. First time trying lasagna pizza. I loved it. read more

I stopped by there last week. I had a regular slice and a Sicilian slice. Both were good with a fine balance of cheese and sauce. I'll definitely eat there again when I'm in the neighborhood read more

Crestwood Pizzeria - Regular slice and Sicilian slice - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Mostly for to go orders on your way from the Crestwood metro north train station. They do have a few tables for dine in customers. I'm a bit confused by their pricing; they list a regular slice for $4, Sicilian for $4.50, but the grandma slice (which I didn't see listed separately) is $5.25. There's a 50c surcharge for card purchases under $10. That's feels overpriced for a single square, cash. I would have just gotten a regular plain slice but they only had meat pizzas. No restroom. Nice people. All in all, I probably wouldn't come back here, but the pizza itself was fine. read more

If you like crispy crust dough, CrestWood pizzeria is the way to go, as you fold your slice and take your 1st bite , you can hear the crunch . The size of the slice is not too big or small, just the right sz. This is the place I go to when my child attended Waverly during the school yr, and galaxy camp. Theres meter parking in front and the metro is across the street. The service is quick. You can dine in but it's a tiny space. They deliver. The price is good. read more

Back again after a few days. Ordered the pasta fagiole soup or better known as pasta fazool. I love the flavor which includes crushed tomato, making the soup different. Of course, I also ordered the chicken marsala roll, which is addictive because of its Marsala flavor. if you like chicken marsala order this roll and you will be very pleased. Other mains were chicken Parm dinner, Chicken Parm hero and of course Pepperoni, pizza, and plain pizza.Sal E New Rochelle read more

Our annual tradition for Halloween is to go to Eastchester for trick-or-treating. We always get Crestwood pizza for everyone there. Located across from the Tuckahoe train station. Conveniently located for Eastchester and Tuckahoe residents. Always hot and fresh. I love the mozzarella they use. Looking forward to next Halloween to get sone good New York pizza. read more

Crestwood Pizzeria - a cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

See all

Crestwood is our reliable old New York style pizza joint up here in the sticks. They're always busy popping out piping hot cheesy pies. Even throughout Covid times. They are always friendly in that NY kinda way. Crestwood pizza slices, make it "to go" ! read more

Crestwood Pizzeria - The Box - (1/22/2021) - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

See all

My go to neighborhood pizzeria, food is always consistent, I love their meatballs, my favorite is their chicken francese and pizza of course. They can get really busy, but always friendly and service with a smile. read more

I stopped in for a slice, pleased to see they had Grandma slices. Sadly it was very mediocre and cost $6 on my debit card. Suggest you try Famiglia's Grandma slice in downtown WP. 10 times better, fresher and tastier (and $2 less expensive). read more

This was by far the best Margarita Pizza ever enjoyed. The tomatoes were fresh and the fresh Basil made it all worth while. You can taste the virgin olive oil lightly drizzled on top and the crust was light and thin and so crispy. Trust me and get this pizza! The owner is an Authentic Italian American and you can see he takes pride and care to make his customers happy! read more

Crestwood Pizzeria - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Very solid food and pizza. Clean nice local establishment. Service is very good and ambiance is solid. read more

My review 8 years ago was unfair. The pizzeria is a small gem. The food is always top notch. I would eat the Chicken Franchese 7 days a week if it was a little More healthy. I have yet to have a bad Alice or pie always hot tasty & typically other than Friday nights ready in ample time to be super happy with the plateful of gloriousness one receives each time one enters and orders read more

No-frills pizzeria convenient to the train station serving NY Style pies, wings, meatballs, calzones, and other traditional pizza joint fare. Seating is extremely limited, as most orders are pick-up and delivery. Busy place around 5 p.m., but staff were still friendly and courteous. Ordered a 12" pepperoni and three large meatballs; pie was tasteful and generous on the toppings, though the meatballs were rather lacking in taste. read more

Excellent Pizza, Excellent Service Excellent communication. Thank you John for making our experience seamless. Our HS team travelled from LI for a Lacrosse game the driver delivered to the field promptly our girls LOVED the pies and garlic knots. Thank you so so much!! read more

Been thinking about Crestwood Pizzeria and the review I should write. Was the pizza decent, YES. Was it great, NO. Was the salad good, YES. I guess if this was my go to pizzeria I would give it an extra star, but the one hour delivery time is hard to swallow. We ordered some thin crust New York style pizza with sausage, parmesan and mozzarella cheese, marinara . While it was a decent pie it took an hour to deliver and cold. Not ice cold, but cold when you leave leftover pizza in a box for an hour cold. Not use to long delivery times, but this is the burbs. I had the feeling delivery guy did not have thermal delivery bags like they do in the city. Hard to rate the pizza since it was cold. Thin crust. Ratio of ingredients was light. Could have a little more of everything. It was tasty, but then again was starving from drinking beers. Salad was decent, but very standard ingredients. I guess it was good and came with bread, but nothing out of this world good. They take Credit Cards. Overall, we ordered from Crestwood Pizzeria because we where at Broken Bow Brewery. GPS told me it was less than a mile. I know Saturdays are busy delivery days, but with all the tools available to provide hot food. You know the rest; get it, utilize it. If take out is a good portion of your business, then try to make it better. Next time I will just pick it up myself and save a five buck tip. Comm'on guys......... read more

See all

Great location right across from the crestwood train station. If that were my stop, I'm sure I would be getting takeout from here quite often. Very nice people. Quick service from Call to pick up. Pizza is good, but I wish it were better. Closer to the usual of the area. Tried the pepperoni, regular, white and chicken parm pizza. Nothing really stood out for me. I would give the entrees and pastas a try on a second visit, but wouldn't go out of my way for the pizza. read more

Crestwood Pizzeria - Half pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Solid pizza, pasta and quality food. I'm a fan and have been going here since we moved up from the city last year. Must try....especially if you like thin, crispy and tasty pizza! read more

Been going here since I moved to eastchester. Still the best pizza you can get around here. And it's cheap. I always recommend this place.

Once again another Disgrazie slice!!!! Why is it that in this great town of Italians known as Eastchester there is only one place which stands above the rest and take great pride in their ingredients which is Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria ( I am not a sponsor or work for Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria I am just comparing taste and quality). Please fix your receipt. Better than pizza shop but still lacking flavor and quality. Sometimes the slice doesn't have enough sauce and to much cheese or sometimes the bread part taste bland and doesn't have enough cheese and enough sauce. Very inconsistent. Please equal out your recipe!!!!! read more

What a great place, I'm new to the area and some friends told me to order here. They are terrific, fast delivery, good food and good service. Thanks a lot you guys are great read more

My favorite pizza in Westchester... I can't really go into too many specifics because in reality, Crestwood Pizza tastes exactly like New York Pizza should. I've only tried regular cheese pizza, the white pizza, the baked ziti pizza and the calzones - all were fantastic. There is only one or two tables in there so I'd recommend taking it to go. The pizzas are very reasonably priced and are enormous in size. Highly recommended. read more

Crestwood Pizzeria - a man and a woman in the kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

GREAT pizza, salads and sandwiches. John is a great owner and runs a very organized restaurant. Pizza... love it... great sauce and PLENTY of PRODUCTS... always loaded. Salads and sandwiches as good as pizza.... read more

Food and service are always excellent. My go to place since Johnny open. Pizza and food are always delicious

Crestwood Pizza is awesome, they put out a great pie. We order from them once and a while for dinner. They are fast and the food is amazing.

I ordered a pizza at 5:30. Was told it would be 30-45 minutes. At 7:00 I called to ask where the pie was. The delivery person was lost. I asked if I would get a new pie or will it arrive cold. They told me they'd call the delivery guy and see where he was. He still had 3 other deliveries. I canceled my order. Ten minutes later the pizza arrived. In a world with GPS and needing delivery with the current circumstances, you would think getting a delivery five minutes away wouldn't take an hour and a half. You would think management would offer some sort of recompense. No they were rude and unapologetic. I'll never order from them again. Too bad. Maybe it's new management. read more

I ordered a pizza and I was told it would be 45 minutes. I'm used to waiting for this pizza but they usually are prompt and tell us when the delivery will be there. I called at 6 o'clock which was already an hour, and I was told that the delivery man had left. I live maybe a mile away and the pizza did not get to my house until 630, ice cold. I think it might be time to seek out other neighborhood pizzerias. read more

Food taste good had a plane slice of pizza and a grandma's they both had great flavors the service was good as well price is far no complaints read more

Crestwood Pizzeria - Yum yum time - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Not very good pizza and they charge $3 more than most places for a large plain pie. Both Cosimo & Johnny's and Villagios are way better and charge less. read more

One of the best local pizza places around. the pizza is always done to a crisp and full of flavor. portions are good size but the chicken parm wedges are amazing. chicken nicly deep fried with sauce and mozzerella melted and bubbly brown on top...yummmy!!! read more

I'm giving it an extra star for the really nice service! Will start with the bad..the $15 chicken parm to go. Chicken completely overcooked, pretty tasteless and not at all tender. Sauce had good flavor but was watery- perhaps from the overdone spaghetti on the side. Portion was incredibly small for the price. Real let down. Now on to the regular slice-- loved the crust - had flavor, perfect texture of old NY style crust- folded perfectly and not too crisp--more on the soft side.. This looked like the real old NY style slice I was hoping for. Oil was dripping off the slice like crazy-- much too much oil used. Cheese was good. Sauce was pretty good but there was so little of it. Much more sauce, a bit more flavor and 1/4 of the amount of oil and this could be close to a 5 star slice. I liked the place and the people..and the crust. So I'll give it another try-- for the Sicilian! read more

Updated review. The delivery people are much better and the wedges/dishes are NOT arriving cold anymore.

No matter where we are or are traveling to, Crestwood is a frequent topic of conversation. We have even requested,w/out a problem, to purchase 1/2 baked pies to later cook at a further awAy destination. There is NO substitution for Crestwood. We have yet to find a close second anywhere else in Westchester County. read more

This was so good. We ate leftovers for three days straight. My in-laws get pizza from here, so when I'm Eastchester, we follow their suggestions. Right on! read more

Pizza was excellent! Perfect crust, ruby red sauce and nice amount of oozing mozzarella cheese, John, the owner is very respectful to his customers and staff. Knows his customers by name and you can tell he cares. Ordered Eggplant parm, chicken parm a nd grilled chicken salad and all were excellent. You can tell excellent ingredients are used. I wish them continued success. Will report back on future visits. read more

See all

Wow -- I can't believe we lived nearby a whole year without trying this excellent pizzeria. We were going to make an order for delivery last night, but after being told it would take over an hour, my husband decided to just go pick it up. He said the place was super-busy, which I always take as a good sign (it's not going to be crowded if it's not good, especially in a town with as many Italian options as Tuckahoe). We each had a slice of regular pizza, so we could get a baseline read on their pizza skills. I am happy to report that we were very pleased; I thought the crust could stand to be a bit crispier but the cheese to sauce ratio was on point and the sauce itself was great. We also shared the baked ziti and a mesclun salad (with roasted peppers, artichokes, and provolone) and both were yummy. I think Angelina's may have just been replaced by Crestwood Pizzeria as our go-to Italian takeout spot. Thanks Yelpers for steering us, as always, in the right direction. read more

UPDATE: I ordered a large pie for pick-up, and it was NOT representative of what I was accustomed to w/ their in-house slice. Small, burned and all-around blah. I had good luck in the store, but I can no longer recommend it as a 5-Star winner. ______________________ Crestwood Pizzeria is amazingly good. I've lived w/in 10 miles of this place for half of my life, and I was never there until yesterday (05/25/2011). It honestly gave my favorite place (Four Corners in Pelham Manor) some SERIOUS competition. One more visit and there may be a new sherriff in town. I had 2 plain slices. Wow. Pretty fat menu, too. read more

We've lived in the area for 54 years and I think this place has been a pizzeria for at least 30 of those years. It's always been a great place for pizza and whenever family comes to New York to visit us, a call is made to Crestwood Pizza for dinner. Now that nieces and nephews are grown and married, they still come to NY to visit with their kids and the call goes in to Crestwood Pizza. Ya' can't say much more than that! read more

I recommend eating pizza here if you're in Crestwood. I had a Sicilian slice and it came quick. The slice was delicious and would recommend anyone who is near by to eat here! read more

Good old neighborhood pizza joint, with possibly the best sicilian slices in the area. And the guys behind the counter, especially John the (I presume) owner, are always friendly and quick, even if the place is super busy (usually Friday and Saturday nights). Pizza slices are good sized, the sicilian is nice and doughy, the sauce good and in just the right amounts. The cheese could be a little more salty for my tastes, but that's really a minor quibble. I wasn't as impressed with their chicken parm, but their salads are very good -- generous portions, nice fresh greens. I particularly recommend the mesclun salad with grilled chicken, parmesan, roasted peppers and artichokes. Their Caesar's salad is pretty good, too. A nice addition to a pie or a couple of slices. Delivery can be a little slow, especially on busy nights. I suggest calling in the order for pick up instead. read more