Crusty&#x27;s Pizza

The service was fast and prompt but the bartender had the mouth of a sailor…read more The beer - the Overhung IPA was nothing special that made me think about having two. The pretzel was good, and the hot, spicy mustard was good. Good for a mid-day snack after skiing. The place was kind of broken/trashy. We were sitting at the bar and noticed that the brewing supplies were a little gross. I thought brewers were clean? The signs were not updated and had a make-shift feeling. Sad to see what was once a great brewery is now trying to pick up its pieces.

Brewery and tasting room with a full bar and five TVs. Plenty of tables and booths to sit at, plus…read morean outdoor rooftop patio. We opted to be inside since winter is still happening. All the wait staff were excellent. They came by several times to make sure everything was okay. The food came out quick, although the pub wasn't busy. Oh yes, to the food. The squeeze and I shared an order of finger steaks and fries. It is our norm to split an order for lunch. The meat tasted good, nice and tender. Spices in the coating decent. The fries were crispy on the outside and fluffy inside. The dip for the finger steaks had a good amount of horseradish in it, wasn't overpowering but put heat into the bite. They did bring an extra plate, which was nice, and not to be charged for it is even better. They may have added some extra fries and fingers, don't know, but we were more than satisfied with the quality and quantity. Hippy Hopped Pale Ale had a nice taste of hops, kind of like a session IPA. The Mackinaw Red brew was oh so malty! It was a little cool in there.

Merchandise

This is a picture of r old greasy fries that was served in 2 of r to go orders

See all

Pale ale & kolsch

Foresters Club

3.3(25 reviews)

•$

This place is a great little big bar in downtown McCall. Surprisingly good pizza and cheap well…read moremade cocktails. Very casual atmosphere and attentive bartenders and staff. It's a lot bigger inside than it appears from the street. Plus, they have bingo and trivia!!

We went to see the Turtle Poppers and had a great time! We met some friendly locals, played some…read morecorn hole and danced the night away!

The Turtle Poppers

See all

Got to love a place that serves Tito's.

Salmon River Brewery

3.5(442 reviews)

0.2 mi

the service was great and the food was outstanding. I got the crispy chicken sandwich and the…read morefries and have nothing but good things to say. Overall the restaurant wasn't too busy either. The outside seating was very cool and we got a nice spot in the shade.

Awesome! I had the Thai beef bowl, so fresh, healthy & satisfying. Paired it with a blonde beer…read more My husband had the Cod fish & chips which he enjoyed greatly. Our friend said the elk burger with gorgonzola was "Great", she liked the sweet potato criss cut fries too! We came on a recommendation & it did not disappoint! Cute interior & fabulous friendly service!

Southwest Chicken Salad with Crispy Chicken

See all

Black-N-Blue Elk Burger

Broken Horn Brewing Company

4.5(38 reviews)

1.0 mi

We had a great time here! There was a great selection of beers along with ciders, wine, seltzers…read moreand non-alcoholic beverages. Hubby had the pale ale and I had the lager. Both were refreshing and delicious. The Rivergrill food truck offered up tasty burgers and sandwiches. We had the double cheeseburger and the Philly cheesesteak sandwich. The burger was bit too overdone for our taste, but we didn't specify how we wanted it cooked. Still tasty though. The Philly was a bit too salty. It had plenty of meat and the bun was good and didn't fall apart. There was plenty of seating but it filled up fast. The live music was entertaining. Overall a great experience that we'll definitely repeat.

This place is outside of downtown which is great in my opinion. The bar guy was amazing, he made…read moreone of my friends an amber from two different beers he had on tap since he didn't have one. The food truck serves a great smash burger for a reasonable price.

Rivergrill food truck

See all

Live music

Lago Chapala Mexican Restaurant

3.0(164 reviews)

The food and drinks here are absolutely fantastic! I especially loved the chicken fajita--it was…read morefantastic! My better half ordered the bean and cheese enchiladas, though there was a little mix-up with the order (they accidentally got meat and cheese instead), but the staff handled it perfectly and made it right. The outdoor setting with views of Payerte Lake was truly beautiful. Our dessert, fried ice cream, was a big hit with the kids--they were so curious and enjoyed every bite, even if they did demolish it!

We've been coming to Lago Chapala for four years now! The food is consistent and delicious! Every…read moretime we come in they make us feel like family. They are doing a great job with the restaurant too: patio seating, new tables and benches and fresh paint. It's a wonderful place to dine!

The decor

Alex Platter

See all

Peach margarita

Yacht Club Lounge

2.7(39 reviews)

They comply with state ID laws. Great tequila soda and fun big buck hunter game! Loved itread more

Staff/ Chelsea was so awesome! Drinks were great. Food downstairs was great. Recommend to anyone…read morevisiting mccalll

Blue Viking

View from the smokers deck.

See all

Steamers Steak & Seafood Restaurant

4.0(224 reviews)

•$$$

Overall it is very good local spot! Recommend their…read moreseafood, especially the clams!!

Most awful dinner yet. Not enough staff . The waitress's were bussing tables. It was sad and the…read morepotatoes were instant. The veggies over cooked. Food slow to come out. Used to be my favorite restaurant. Sad

Oyster

See all

New York steak & Scampi

Beside the Mill

3.1(20 reviews)

0.4 mi

•$$$

B-side the Mill is my kind of bar. I ain't fancy and I don't know a whole lot, but I know when a…read moreplace is good. They got good food, hot and plenty of it, so you don't leave hungry. They got TVs everywhere you look. I sat there and watched the USA soccer game -- didn't even know we had a soccer team, but there it was, right in front of me on a big screen. Made it real fun to watch. The bartenders are real friendly and take care of you quick. They smile, they talk to you, they keep your drink full and don't act stuck‑up about nothing. If you like cold drinks, good food, and a bunch of TVs to watch the game, B-side the Mill is the place to be. I'll be back for sure.

We visited this spot to enjoy a World Cup game and the dude working the afternoon-evening shift on…read moreFriday was a pill; rude service. No wonder this place boasts a 3.3 - keep it up!

BESIDE THE MILL

See all

Liquor Store

3.7(3 reviews)

Great selection of wine, beer, and liquor. It is clean, and has easy parking!…read more Would definitely go back.

Terrible service. I was looking for one type of bourbon and I was told that they did not have it to…read morecome back the next day. I was told by another employee that they had plenty of it in the backroom. I return the following day at opening of the store and they claimed that they did not have any. I question what the other employee had told me and I was informed that he didn't know what he was talking about. Very shady in their dealings.

See all

Hometown Pizza

4.3(178 reviews)

0.8 mi

We are visiting McCall and looking for a pizza option... there are a few to choose from. I am happy…read morewe picked Hometown Pizza. I've read posts about other items on the menu, this rating is just based on what we ordered - pizza! Pros - great pizza! We order a large cheese and pineapple pizza for 3 kids. A medium 1/2 garden & 1/2 combo for two adults. The garden was delicious (great flavor, fresh, good veggies/ crust proportions of ingredients) -- and no complaints and full bellies for everyone else. - super quick, ordered and it was ready for pick up in under 30. - very reasonably priced $50 for two pizza that fed us and left a few slices for lunch tomorrow. Cons - the website for ordering online was a little clunky, but worked... (not bad enough to knock off a star). - while everyone else liked the crust one kid did not, it was thinner and had a different texture (less "bready") than other pizza places, e.g. Papa John's. (IMO it was good!) The place was packed at 5pm on a Wednesday so that might mean something!

Gluten free pepperoni pizza was delicious! I didn't see gluten free on their menu, but it is an…read moreoption!

Great restaurant.

Small six shooter

See all

Cheesy garlic bread

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Ahmet H.

4

0

7 months ago

Only 2 for the little girl working. That place needs so much help. Need to send Gordon Ramsey there to revitalize that place.

Crusty's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Crusty's Pizza also viewed

Lardo Grill & Saloon

3.0

(195 reviews)

First time in McCall and I love this place!! Super kind staff, clean dive bar feel, everything I…read morewant in a bar while traveling. I will DEFINITELY be coming back every time I'm here

I think there are a lot in f haters out there. This place is across from lake payette rustic…read moremountain restaurant. Super cool inside, hosts 6 taps from local breweries. It's worth being a place to have a drink plus bar is open later than most in McCall. Haven't eaten here but cool, full bar and prioritized local beer. I am looking forward to trying the food

Hometown Pizza

4.3

(178 reviews)

We are visiting McCall and looking for a pizza option... there are a few to choose from. I am happy…read morewe picked Hometown Pizza. I've read posts about other items on the menu, this rating is just based on what we ordered - pizza! Pros - great pizza! We order a large cheese and pineapple pizza for 3 kids. A medium 1/2 garden & 1/2 combo for two adults. The garden was delicious (great flavor, fresh, good veggies/ crust proportions of ingredients) -- and no complaints and full bellies for everyone else. - super quick, ordered and it was ready for pick up in under 30. - very reasonably priced $50 for two pizza that fed us and left a few slices for lunch tomorrow. Cons - the website for ordering online was a little clunky, but worked... (not bad enough to knock off a star). - while everyone else liked the crust one kid did not, it was thinner and had a different texture (less "bready") than other pizza places, e.g. Papa John's. (IMO it was good!) The place was packed at 5pm on a Wednesday so that might mean something!

Gluten free pepperoni pizza was delicious! I didn't see gluten free on their menu, but it is an…read moreoption!

Showtime Pizza

4.6

(5 reviews)

I cannot comment on the taste of the pizza, as I did not have any, but my family said it was just…read more"meh". They give you a buzzer when you order, after about 10 minutes of noticing a pizza on the counter, we went and asked. Sure enough, it was ours, and they never rang our buzzer . Definitely a little disappointing after paying over $30 dollars for a pizza.

We're staying at tamarack this weekend and decided to order pizza and take it back to our room. We…read moreordered the New Yorker with no cheese and added pepperoni. This pizza was top notch!!! even without cheese! My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed it and said this is the best pizza we've had in Idaho! Definitely worth it. Would 10000% order again!

Toll Station Pizza

3.3

(193 reviews)

Had sandwiches, soup and salad. Good food, quality ingredients and the waiter was attentive and…read morequick. Hostess seems to hate her job, unfortunately.

Bottom Line: THE Best Place to Eat in McCall!!!…read more Went there on Father's Day without a reservation and ended up getting take out. We had our retriever with us and it 80 degrees so we couldn't wait for a patio table. All that said, especially if you have kids or a dog this is the best place to eat in Mccall. The Food: we got the spaghetti and meatballs $18.99 and a small Caesar salad with grilled chicken $14.75 and they were both good. 4.5/5 The value was reasonable for McCall which can be pricey being a ski town and inflation. The Venue: this is nicest venue in McCall which is kid and dog friendly. Large lawn area with corn hole games and lawn chairs. Nice dog friendly patio with table umbrellas. Large parking lot. 5/5 The Service: it was Fathers Day and it was really crazy. They were doing the best they could. They are very young adults so be nice and patient, it's probably their first job. 4/5

Crusty's Pizza

4.5

(4 reviews)

Amazing pizza! I loved how crusty was their pizza! The menu is very simple. The place is very…read moreclean. I Highly recommend trying it!

we've had pizza here twice now. it's a tiny place within tamarack resort, but it's super convenient…read morewhen you don't want to drive back into town for something. they have a pretty good sized menu of different pizzas to try. the other night we got the 4 pigs and the hawaiian. the 4 pigs was the best! it's bacon, canadian ham, sausage, and pepperoni. the toppings are decently generous as well. the hawaiian was canadian bacon and pineapple. if you like that kind of pizza like we do, you will enjoy it! the one thing about this place is the crust is kind of thin. it's like a cracker type thin crust. it's very crusty on the ends, which is probably why they have the name they do. It isn't my favorite kind of pizza crust, but it's still tasty. we got 2 pizzas for $48. it wasn't a deal breaker, especially when we didn't feel like going anywhere or cooking. you can also eat there and they have some beers too. my one gripe? they charge $1 a packet for ranch. and it's salad dressing ranch so it's really vinegary. kind of a bummer. I love ranch on pizza though!

McCall Brewing Company

3.2

(242 reviews)

The service was fast and prompt but the bartender had the mouth of a sailor…read more The beer - the Overhung IPA was nothing special that made me think about having two. The pretzel was good, and the hot, spicy mustard was good. Good for a mid-day snack after skiing. The place was kind of broken/trashy. We were sitting at the bar and noticed that the brewing supplies were a little gross. I thought brewers were clean? The signs were not updated and had a make-shift feeling. Sad to see what was once a great brewery is now trying to pick up its pieces.

Brewery and tasting room with a full bar and five TVs. Plenty of tables and booths to sit at, plus…read morean outdoor rooftop patio. We opted to be inside since winter is still happening. All the wait staff were excellent. They came by several times to make sure everything was okay. The food came out quick, although the pub wasn't busy. Oh yes, to the food. The squeeze and I shared an order of finger steaks and fries. It is our norm to split an order for lunch. The meat tasted good, nice and tender. Spices in the coating decent. The fries were crispy on the outside and fluffy inside. The dip for the finger steaks had a good amount of horseradish in it, wasn't overpowering but put heat into the bite. They did bring an extra plate, which was nice, and not to be charged for it is even better. They may have added some extra fries and fingers, don't know, but we were more than satisfied with the quality and quantity. Hippy Hopped Pale Ale had a nice taste of hops, kind of like a session IPA. The Mackinaw Red brew was oh so malty! It was a little cool in there.

Bistro 45

4.3

(20 reviews)

Great artichoke fondue! Don't miss it. Makes great breakfast leftovers. Just saying. The clams were…read morewonderful & roast beef panini was fabulous. Plenty to share. Enjoyed the live music, good wine selection & outstanding service. Huck is the BEST! Great job Chef Topple! This a must when in McCall!

Great food in the neatest old gas station! Really like the entrees, not in love with the salads,…read morelove the appetizers - especially the artichoke fondue! Friendly service!!

Salmon River Brewery

3.5

(442 reviews)

the service was great and the food was outstanding. I got the crispy chicken sandwich and the…read morefries and have nothing but good things to say. Overall the restaurant wasn't too busy either. The outside seating was very cool and we got a nice spot in the shade.

Awesome! I had the Thai beef bowl, so fresh, healthy & satisfying. Paired it with a blonde beer…read more My husband had the Cod fish & chips which he enjoyed greatly. Our friend said the elk burger with gorgonzola was "Great", she liked the sweet potato criss cut fries too! We came on a recommendation & it did not disappoint! Cute interior & fabulous friendly service!

Seven Devils Pub

3.4

(23 reviews)

This little pub is in the middle of Tamarack development, that's still is not completed. The…read moreambience is non existent. Service is lousy and food is even worse.

We stayed by the lake in Donnelly and road snowmobiles across the lake right up to the pub. Super…read morecool to be able to ride right up to the pub and chairlift. Bacon bleu burger was pretty good and the poutine with chopped steak, cheese curds and Demi glacé. Although it tasted more like pot roast than chopped steak. Service was good. Mango mama mimosa is delish.

Growler's Pizza & Grill

3.3

(236 reviews)