Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cutler Cookie Co.

    3.6 (7 reviews)
    Open 9:30 am - 8:00 pm

    Order Cutler Cookie Co. Takeout or Delivery

    Cutler Cookie Co. Photos

    Business Info

    CUTLER COOKIE CO. ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Cutler Cookie Co.

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 months ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Kevin K.
    274
    1017
    1332

    5 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Sandwich was great. Fresh ingredients and bread. Cookies homemade and better value than large chains. Kitchen looks pristine and organized!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Cutler Cookie Co.

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 2,277 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Peppered Vine

    The Peppered Vine

    4.9(60 reviews)
    8.4 mi

    This a super cute sandwich shop in Union Square with tons of parking! Limited seating, there's two…read moretables inside and two tables outside. The menu is simple and small. I was told, the Entrees are made to take and heat at home. Everything is made to order so it's fresh! Just be prepared to wait....for a while.....she did give us a heads up it was gonna be about 15-20, but it pushed closer to 25-30. Coming off a flight hungry, we are doubting our decision to come here. After 30 mins, our food finally arrives! We got the house sandwich (ham and turkey w/lettuce tomato and homemade herb Dijon sauce). It was served with a sugar cookie and a cup of pasta salad. Not bad for $16.99! The sandwich was delicious and tasty! Maybe cause we were beyond starving. The pasta salad was just ok. The sugar cookie was nice and soft. It wasn't crumbly or dry. The frosting on top had just enough sweetness to give the cookie some flavor. My daughter got the roast beef sandwich which came with cheese, a bunch of arugula, and a homemade garlic horseradish sauce. She opted out of the pickled onions. Her sandwich also came with a cup of pasta salad and a sugar cookie. The sandwich was flavorful and the peppery arugula completed the sandwich. We both agreed that the roast beef sandwich was the better of the two. All-in-all this is a good sandwich place. One thing I didn't care for was the long wait. I understand that they might have been a bit busy and everything is made to order, but the time that I was quoted to what we actually waited, we probably would have gone somewhere else.

    This is a gem in Sandy. The food is prepared with fresh ingredients and the flavors are wonderful…read more First, don't be put off that the whole menu is take out. As a matter of fact, there is only one small table there if you choose to dine in, and there is a couch there, mostly for patrons waiting for their order. Renee's (owner, chef) philosophy is that we do not spend enough time at home. She says to take her food home, eat with family, friends. Eat in your pajamas. Relax, enjoy. We work to hard, we are too busy. Food and mealtime should be a remedy for that, at the very least, a respite. Renee took time to visit with me. She is outgoing and a very cheerful person, a delight to converse with. She has extensive experience in the hospitality field and a great education with a Culinary Degree from Le Cordon Bleu. And it shows. Now the food--wow. The House Sandwich Box was outstanding. Just the right amount of ingredients to balance all the flavors. I must say that this is one of the very few, if not the only times, that we have actually tasted *smoked* turkey in a sandwich. Other sandwiches may say they use smoked turkey, but this one tasted smokey and boy was it good! You must try the piri piri chicken. And like Renee points out and as other reviews here have instructed, you use the slaw that comes with it with every bite because it compliments the flavors of the chicken. So, so good! The kitchen area is cordoned off with glass so that you can watch them prepare the meals. It is a cozy little place, but works well with what Renee is trying to do. Let's get the word out about this place! She is in her second year and I want this restaurant to succeed! 5* = A top favorite. Mind-blowing good. I will definitely return and I will go out of my way to go here. Worth every dime of my money. 4* = Outstanding. Top-tier. Some elements not quite as good as it gets, but it still is worthy of my regular business. 3* = Good experience. I might do repeat business if it is convenient, the only option, the only one in its category, or on a whim, but would not be among the first thing to come to mind. Would definitely recommend you trying it to get your own take on it. 2* = Not so good. Would not recommend at all. Waste of money. 1* = How are they still in business? Stay away at all costs!

    Photos
    The Peppered Vine
    The Peppered Vine
    The Peppered Vine

    See all

    Potbelly

    Potbelly

    3.4(127 reviews)
    7.0 mi
    $$

    My wife and I love the sandwiches here. One of our favorites. We hate that the one closer to our…read morehouse closed. Despite some criticism coming, we still love the place and will likely always be customers. But my gripes today was that nearly all tables hadn't been cleaned. We had to do it. And my biggest gripe tonight was the obvious need for some refresher policy training. As my picture shows, they have an 8 minute thru the line promos or you get a cookie. They were not very busy but in fact very slow. We were in line for at least 8 minutes before starting our order. I asked the guy about the 8min guarantee and he genuinely had NEVER heard of it. I pointed to the sign..... he said he had never noticed it. I wanted to know if the time started once we order or once we walked up. Couldn't answer. So we moved to the cashier to ask. Same result. No clue.... Hadn't heard of it.... Hadn't ever noticed the sign. A little disappointing. Will we still go? Absolutely. We won't ask the hard questions next time.

    Disgusting customer service. Never in my life have i spoken to such an unprofessional manager. I…read morecan only conclude pure laziness or pure stupidity is the bread and butter of her management style. Please have higher standards. Please do better. I ordered a sandwhich and soup from uber eats. I watched as 3 delivery drivers pull up and leave. So i messaged the 4th and asked her to tell me if there's an issue with the order or something. She tells me the manager told her, "the order was stolen and we will NOT remake it." Mind you this is 4th delivery driver and it's been over a hour as this point. Instead of contacting uber on their end...They chose to waste 4 driver's time and my time. I call the store and the manager laughs when i ask her about the situation. She said, "ya haha i told a few of the drivers that." She told me, "uber usually sends us a new ticket eventually." Well it's 7:54 pm at this point, when i call and they close at 8 pm. So i realize at this point that im not getting anything from them. I waited over a hour for the sandwich... i paid for it.... how is it my problem that someone else stole it? It sounds like the store's problem, not mine. Oh but no it turned out it was my problem. Though i was the one that paid for a sandwich i never got..... Truly repulsed by this manager and the way she conducts business. Will never return to any of the potbelly's. Will have a horrible taste in my mouth about this place for the rest of my life and will tell everyone I know what a shit fucking company it is. Never in my life have i seen such shit customer service. It's truly embarrassing that you would hire someone like that to represent your store. God i'd be ashamed to have any connection to this store with the way it's run.

    Photos
    Potbelly
    Potbelly
    Potbelly

    See all

    Café Zupas

    Café Zupas

    2.6(119 reviews)
    2.3 mi
    $

    Liam is the absolute best, my friend was two dollars short and he paid for it. never had better…read moreservice in my entire life, genuinely so amazing!! promote him ASAP.

    *I'd have to agree this place is jam packed w/phone orders and it may take FOREVER to get your…read moreorder but I'd rather get food from a place that is BUSY than a place that doesn't have too much customers. For those who are complaining about bad customer service because workers aren't paying enough attention to you, that's a YOU problem. I came here tonight w/girlfriends and the 1st worker that helped take our orders greeted us kindly even w/the chaos of phone orders and in person orders. She still tried to be kind, it goes both ways. They had trainees as well and they still did their best. I can appreciate that wish all y'all complaining would get off your high horses. For crying out loud they're there to make you yummy food, not treat you like your the most important person in the room today. Have some Grace my gosh. Came here again but this time I got to try a soup and sandwich and WOW!!! My total came out to $19 combo w/a chocolate mousse cheesecake on the side. Everything was so delicious! I got the Fall items. Some kind of viral bacon sandwich that I had on wheat. It was so bougie lol and I loved every bit of it hahaha fresh apples, carmelized onions, bacon grilled cheese say whaaaaat?!? It was deliciously bougie and I give it a 10/10. The pumpkin chorizo soup was so flavorful you might want 2 breads lol and it was flavorful in a good way ;) The mousse cheesecake melted in my mouth, if you like chocolate mousse like me you'll love it! I devoured everything on my tray! I'll be back because I have got to try more sandwiches & soups. I sampled the mushroom bisque and that was so good, that'll be on my next trip. Place was clean and crowded, that is for a reason. This place deserves 5 stars!!!

    Photos
    Café Zupas
    Café Zupas
    Café Zupas

    See all

    Cutler Cookie Co. - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...