My wife and I have been coming here for a couple of years now and the owners are some of the…read moreloveliest people I've ever met. If you are looking for an honest jeweler I would recommend Two Sisters to anyone and everyone.

I seem to collect gray-haired male comedians. My ophthalmologist is one. My dentist is another. And…read morenow I've collected yet a third: a jovial gray-haired gentleman who gave me advice on caring for my freshly-cleaned shiny, sparkly wedding ring that I can completely ignore--but was truly funny. But we need to work backward. After 40 years of marriage and weight gain, I needed my wedding ring resized. Two jewelers I checked with estimated a 2-3 week turnaround, longer with the 1st store since the jeweler was on vacation. My wife looked online, found Two Sisters and saw the business had great reviews. The reviews were right. Dropped the ring off yesterday and picked it up today. Not only was my ring perfectly resized (which was determined yesterday by a very friendly lady behind the counter) but thanks to an expert cleaning my ring shines and sparkles just like on the day my bride slipped it onto my finger at our wedding. When I picked up the ring, the lady wasn't there but there was a friendly young man and...the gray-haired male comedian. His advice for caring for the shiny ring? On a sunny day when I'm driving, hang my hand with the wedding ring out the car window, point it at the other cars and blind them with my bling. I intend to use that. Believe me, he had other suggestions, one potentially painful but might just work. This is our go-to jewelers now. It's a great store doing fine work, and with at least one person doing standup as you pay the bill. What more could you ask for?

Tucked into a cozy spot in Gig Harbor, Maritime Jewelers is a true family-run gem. Eric and his son…read moreown and operate this little shop alongside other nearby boutique businesses, and every time I visit the staff members are always accommodating knowledgeable, with zero-pressure...exactly what you want when you're browsing something as personal as jewelry. Their selection is impressive for the size of the store: rings, necklaces, bracelets, watches, and more. If what you're picturing isn't on the shelf, they'll sketch it, source the stones, and craft it right there. I asked for a custom Viking-inspired piece to honor my Norwegian roots--think bold silver, knotwork, and a Thor hammer pendant. Eric and the team nailed every detail, and the finished necklace feels like it sailed straight out of a saga. Quality is top-tier, prices are fair, and the whole experience is relaxed and fun. Worth the drive from anywhere in the Puget Sound area. If you leave without something that sends you to Valhalla (in the best possible way), you're doing it wrong. Highly recommend Eric and his crew!

I found this business by mistake when I stopped into a restaurant in Gig Harbor. What a treasure…read moretrove! Erick and Ruth are wonderful and they are honest in a business where that is truly hard to find. I bought my first piece from them in October and fast forward to January - I have purchased a beautiful estate ring for my 25th wedding anniversary and as it turns out, it is worth double the amount I paid for it according to an independent appraiser. They have worked on some antique time pieces that belonged to my great grandfather and for the first time in 70 years, it is keeping perfect time! Stop by and say HI to them if you are in the market for a gift or goodie for yourself! You wont be sorry!!

I have known John for many years and I trust him completely. He is very knowledgeable, and I have…read morepurchased items from him and he is my go to for repairs, the sizing of rings and watch bands, and battery replacements. He is honest and fair in all his dealings. I highly recommend Kiro's Diamonds and John Peters In particular.

I did not purchase my engagement ring here but I came to have it resized. He was very professional…read moreand it took less than 24 hours! I then came back a few months later because I felt like maybe we didn't go small enough. He installed a small spacer in my ring just in case my fingers were just changing with the weather, free of charge. Definitely will be going back!

Very nice staff--all family. Spacious, bright store. Style of jewelry wasn't mine and the prices…read morewere pretty high. They do offer custom work and stock many gems and pearls. But I felt the prices were significantly higher than the other jewelers I have shopped at. Like that this is a family business. Definitely prefer this to the mall stores.

So far so good! Thought I had a platinum ring to resize and it was white gold! Whew... platinum was…read morereally expensive. They actually called me and enlightened me! That was awesome! Great folks. Waiting till my ring is done now.

I had an unbelievably heartbreaking experience involving Castellano Jewelers and a family heirloom…read morea year ago that I feel is my responsibility to share. It has sincerely taken me a year to process the grief from what transpired in order to be able to write this review. My mother and I took my grandmother's ring (her late mother's) to Connie at Castellano's, looking to resize it as my engagement ring and to replace one of the stones, since a large gouge was in one of them. This gouge is very important to the unfolding of our experience. Initially, Connie and her staff seemed incredibly knowledgeable. They explained that the vintage stones that were in the ring weren't genuine emeralds, but had value due to the fact they were no longer manufactured in the same way, so Connie recommended against exposing them to heat and preserving them along with the flaw, which my mother and I appreciated. They also explained that the delicate nature of the setting would make it virtually impossible to replace the stones without significantly altering the appearance of the ring, adding to their recommendation to preserve it aside from a resize. I am a deeply sentimental person, and therefore I appreciated and trusted this careful and conservative assessment by the jeweler. When I went back to drop off the ring for service, the jeweler insisted I also have it "re-tipped so that the stones don't fall out." I asked if this was in line with keeping the stones preserved and protected from heat, and she said yes. We trusted her professional judgment, thinking it would complement the previous assessment about preserving the ring. We did not hear from Castellano's for almost six months. When I called in to inquire about the ring, they could not find it. Thankfully, they did find it, said it was ready for pickup. It was an emotional rollercoaster to think they had lost it, and I found it odd they had never called me to tell me it was ready, but I was just excited for my fiancé and I to finally have our ring. When my fiancé and I picked up the ring, I immediately felt that something was very wrong. The gouge was no longer in the top stone and the emeralds were a distinctly different color; surely they had not replaced my grandmother's original stones without informing me? I did not want to make such a large accusation after just having back it my hands for a few minutes. I was in utter shock, so we left after signing off on the work. It took me until my fiancé and I had driven a couple blocks before I called back right away to ask how the gouge had managed to disappear, since we were explicitly told nothing could be done about it, and that it would be preserving the ring to keep it as is. The woman who we picked up the ring from at the front desk (not Connie), insisted that the color change was from cleaning (which seems totally reasonable to me) and the gouge was "buffed out from polishing." I asked if it was filled, since it didn't make sense for such a deep gouge to suddenly be level with the rest of the stone. She insisted - and I quote - that the stones were "1000% the original stones." This turned out to be far from the truth. We arranged to meet with the owner, Connie, hoping for some explanation. She was incredibly defensive and unprofessional. Instead of addressing my concerns, she started divulging, in great detail, her personal struggles, which I will not share here. I truly sympathize with anyone going through a hard time, but it was absolutely inappropriate given our professional relationship. When I explained what I felt was wrong with the ring, her response left me speechless. She casually mentioned and confirmed that the old stones had shattered when exposed heat during repairs, and she had used - and I quote directly here - "whatever five dollar stones they had on hand and did not charge for them." A far cry from the insistence that they were "1000% the original stones." She suggested she would "look for and gather any leftover dust." I never heard from her again. I feel like I lost a piece of my family's history and had no say in now what is a permanent installation of "five dollar stones" in the ring. We took the ring to another local jeweler who was astonished as to how they managed to replace the stones -- and were aghast when learning Castellano's denied us the chance to choose our own replacements. The monetary value doesn't matter to me at all. The lack of honesty, professionalism, and care left a scar on my family an heirloom bigger than the one we came in hoping to fix. Stay away from Castellano's.

Only praise and thanks to give to Castellano Fine Jewelry! Truly beautiful creations by helpful and…read moreknowledgeable Jeweler, Connie Castellano! What an incredible artist! I've had jewelry repaired, created my own lovely piece with Connie's expertise & have requested specific pieces to select from. I've referred friends to Castellano Fine Jewelry who are as happy as I am to have discovered Connie Castellan!

Alina is the Queen of Jewelry, not just on Bainbridge Island, but in the US. She is a smart…read moredesigner, manufacturer, and person. She makes everything in house and is super honest and transparent so you get exactly what you want for a fair price. I bought my wife's second wedding ring and we could not have been more impressed at how simple the process was and her work is the highest level of quality. We are lucky to have Alina and her company here on our small island!

Highly recommend Alina Korotkina's Fine Jewelry. Alina's attention to detail, professionalism, and…read moreproficiency are outstanding. She creates heirloom pieces for the ages. So happy to have her here on the island!

My wife and I had our wedding rings designed and made here. The process is absolutely wonderful and…read morepersonal. Cindi and Mary were amazing to work with and we are soo happy with our rings. We've been married now 13 years and rings still look amazing! Wish we still lived nearby so we could have our anniversary ring made there!

Special people step up to the challenge of special occasions. Mary E. and her staff are those…read morepeople. I was looking for someone to create a unique gift for my wife for our 50th wedding anniversary. My idea was to present her with a golden gift for our golden anniversary, but who to bring the idea to fruition. I miraculously found Gold Mine Design and presented my idea. My wife loves frogs, so what better than a frog of 24K solid gold set on a heart shaped lily pad. Mary and crew jumped at the idea and gleefully went about bringing my idea to reality. This hand crafted creation, a true one of a kind, was everything I had hoped for and a gift that truly wowed my wife. Bring your ideas to these people for absolutely stunning creations.

Loved their reasonable price and quick service!! I think I have found my new jeweler!read more

Came in to get a price quote to get my daughters chain repaired which was broken in 3 pieces , was…read morequoted an extremely fair price and was given of eta of next day. - Was given a courtesy call the same evening letting me know it was repaired & ready. Repair was done masterfully where you can't even tell where it was broken . Honest people here , will continue to do business in the future, thank you