We ended up coming to Lobster Landing twice during our trip -- once on the way to Mystic and again…read moreon the way back -- which probably says everything you need to know. It's definitely a little more expensive than some of the other lobster spots we tried, but I honestly liked the food here the most. The lobster meat is lightly seasoned with what tasted like butter and lemon, and it all worked perfectly together without overpowering the lobster. The bun was incredibly soft and loaded with so much meat that it was practically falling apart in the middle. We got the half-pound lobster roll both times and would absolutely order it again, but it is $60. The clam chowder was also excellent. It's creamy without being too thick, and you can really taste all the ingredients. The hot dogs seem to be really popular -- almost everyone was ordering a lobster roll and a hot dog combo. My son loved them so much he had two the first visit! The outdoor seating and water views make it such a relaxing place to sit and eat, and there's also a market on-site where you can buy lobster and shellfish. Definitely one of our favorite stops and somewhere we'd happily return to.

Great lobster roll, the meat was perfection, the bun unique and hearty, nice views of the harbor,…read moresturdy seating. Wish there was the option of fries but I get it more money on ventilation etc. they offer bagged chips, lobster bisque (which I wish we got to dip in) the tables are also a bit gross on some (due to weather and birds) but since it's outside this is inevitable. You're here for the lobster and water and you get it. Pure summer vibes.

We only get take out Fast service Mounds of delicious…read moreseafood We live near the Lenny Joes Fish Tale and have tried many menu items We love them all

Love this place! The staff is always super nice. I always get the hot lobster roll, which is always…read morereliably good! I like that the fries are on the thicker side and that the lobster roll comes with Cole slaw!

The food from beginning with appetizers, main course and desserts!…read more The service was phenomenally excellent as they were right there on point without having to have glasses filled with water, checked to see if another glass of wine was wanted and totally respectful! The Manager checked on various times to make sure we were satisfied.

We arrived around 4:15 to catch the Happy Hour. When we arrived, we noticed the slight musty smell…read moreright at the entryway...not a good impression. We asked the bartender if we could enjoy the Happy Hour at one of the tables, he said, No. Only at the bar. Something that was not spelled out on the menu nor the website. We sat at the bar. The menu listed the house gin at $5. I asked which Gin did they use as House Gin. The bartender said, I can give you Tanqueray but the price is not $5 like the menu says, it's $7. He said that menu was from Milford, not Westbrook. Weird...so I get a glass of wine, which did ring at $6 like the menu said. We ordered a few "tapas". Out of the four that we tried, the best one was the turnover (empanada), then the meatballs (tiny meatballs), then the fried calamari (which tasted and looked out of a frozen wholesale fried calamari bag) and last the pork medallion (not tasty at all). When the bill came, two of the tapas had the wrong price (higher than what the menu said)....I had to ask the bartender to rectify, which he did.....Poor people the ones that do not check their bills....they can easily be overcharged here....Big time..... Not recommended....not coming back.

There are several seafood stores in Old Saybrook but Atlantic is the best. They have the largest…read moreselection- including frozen items that are difficult to find elsewhere (like large lobster tails- as big as 16 ounces!). Their fresh seafood selection is also huge, and they also stock homemade items like soups/chowder, etc. Love this store!

We rent a cottage in Old Saybrook for one week every summer, and one night of that week we have…read morefriends over and do a lobster pot from Atlantic Seafood. It couldn't be easier. Corn, potatoes, mussels or clams, and lobsters are all in one pot--add 3 cups water, boil for about 30 minutes, melt some butter, and serve. Order ahead, pick up at about the appointed time, bring the pot back at your leisure the next day. It's always a special and festive meal and the service is friendly and quick.

haven't been in here in a while, dad wanted to be by the shore so made a reservation for Fathers…read moreDay. There was 7 in our party, seated quickly, drink orders taken. Server was absolutely amazing. I was slightly bummed when entrees came out as everyone's came but mine. It was another 10 minutes, some folks were halfway through dinner. The reason I still have this five stars is this.... The server before I even had a chance to say, hey where's my food, walked up, apologized, bought me a drink. My response was simple. I'm in the industry, it happens, thanks so much for the beverage. (I am in industry I run ops for 22 kitchens, love how your staff got in front of something before it became a thing)

We've been here several times when out this way for the outlets. We like to sit in the bar area,…read morewhich is more our vibe. The service is always great. I get the lobster roll every time. This past time, it didn't taste fresh. The lobster was a little chewy. It's been great every other time I've ordered it, so I will try again!

It is a log Cabin! Highly recommend if you are hungry! The food was delicious and the service was…read moresuper friendly! We took home tons of leftovers because the portions were so large. The prices were very reasonable too. The best part was how good the food tasted and it was in such a friendly, casual setting!

Food - top shelf. Portions huge. Prices very reasonable. The brunette appetizer was off the…read morecharts good. The meat ball is a must - tender, soft, and the tase - superb. We got the sauce on the side with our "pasta bowl". As good as the homemade red sauce - the oil and garlic sauce was incredible. My osso bucco fell off the bone and was perfection. My wife's veal w eggplant - tender, tasted great, and we too home enough for another meal! We will be back. Next time try to leave room for dessert.

Superior food,ultimately fresh, delicious. Atmosphere is…read moremellow yet by the sea, very relaxing. Service is excellent !

I used to LOVE this restaurant and visited frequently. However my experiences within the past year…read morehave been disappointing. For one, I ordered a lobster roll and a week later I got another. The second time I was given about half the amount of lobster. Same price, of course! I was able to get that resolved but they have to be consistent in their serving sizes. Get a damn scale in the kitchen! Went there this past Monday (Memorial Day) and ordered some calamari. The portion is about half of what it used to be but the price is high. I'm done.

Swung by here on a Saturday afternoon, and they were open. Apparently they close for the winter,…read morebecause I've tried a couple other times. We sat outside to enjoy the view. Our waitress was lovely. We ordered cocktails, which were pretty good, and the bang bang shrimp- yum!!! As well as the fried calamari (pretty good). We followed up with a second round of drinks- another cocktail for my husband, which was unique and tasty , and a glass of wine for me. Honestly...my rating may have been a 5 if the pour on the glass of wine wasn't so stingy. My husband said "it looks like that was what was left in the bottle and they didn't feel like opening another." As we were there midday, we opted for sandwiches: lobster roll (a little pricier than most places, but I get todays market), and a BLT, which was very much enjoyed. The fries were delicious. Our waitress, Abby, was delightful, and the food was good. Again... it wasn't cheap, so a bigger pour on the wine would have been appreciated, but service and ambience go a long way. Summer is just beginning, so we'll probably be back.

Pretty spot on water. Food took 45 mins which was excessive. We had a 6 pm reservation, so they…read moreweren't very busy yet. Food was ok. Nothing to write home about. Go for the view, not for the food.