$12.50 for two slices and a drink is absurd. Is it worth it? No, not really. That is not to suggest the pizza is terrible. It is not. My two slices, a Plain and a Buffalo Chicken, were well cooked and did not break up upon folding, but nothing to compete against the giants further down the Brighton Line like Di Fara and Pizza Time. Unfortunately for the Plain slice it needs an injection of garlic to make it halfway decent, as the tomato sauce has a weird sweetness to it, and the cheese is a little too melty. The crust is good, nicely thin with a good crispiness. I would just like a little more flavor and maybe the review rating goes up a tick or two. But I have to judge what I got. The Buffalo Chicken slice has good flavor, again with a nice crispy (but not overly crispy) crust. The Buffalo flavor is not overwhelming but I found the chicken on the slice to be a little too dry. I am not writing this shop off, but based on my experience, there is plenty of room for improvement. Overall pizza rating: 3.2/5 read more

This place has been a staple of my upbringing, back in the old neighborhood and I'm glad I stopped by. Pizza has been solid for 50+ years! read more

Delmar Pizzeria - This place has been a staple of my upbringing, back in the old neighborhood and I'm glad I stopped by. Pizza has been solid for 50+ years! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I thought I knew great pizza until I tried Delmar Pizzeria. I stopped by on a weekend for lunch, just before the crowd hit, and ended up ordering two slices of plain cheese pizza and a chicken roll. From the very first bite, I was blown away. Even though it was just a plain cheese pizza, the flavors exploded in my mouth. The sauce, cheese, and crust all hit that perfect balance. The chicken roll was tasty too, packed with chicken and cheese, but honestly, the pizza stole the spotlight. The friendly staff and the clean, inviting atmosphere only added to the experience. Delmar Pizzeria has definitely earned a spot as one of my favorites now. read more

Pizza quality has seriously leveled up -- the crust, sauce, and overall flavor are on point. The eggplant topping is a standout: tender, rich, and perfectly balanced with the rest of the pie. Unexpectedly fantastic. Pretty great sandys too read more

BUSSIN If I was to give it 10 stars, I would. Only Italian pizza place in sheepshead bay that make you more New Yorker then ever because DAYUM they mastered the greasiness and flavor combination (can't forget to season your shit ever) This spot needs to be a tourist attraction, it's the neighborhood's favorite, even better then that fuckass Joe's pizza ppl b yearing for Downsides tho, the price for a regular slice can be expensive And a pie costs 22 For what I see it's worth, it has to be worth $2. Lookin forward to eat another pizza from Delmar read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ten stars & beyond! My preferred pizza of my youth is as good as ever & I can't praise them enough. Went in Sunday and first question is warm or hot for the slice? The $100k question & my always is warm! We had the grandma and last minute I opted for the square. My step daughter said her grandma slice was better than L&B & my SUPERSTAR square a serious rival. This PIZZA is top of the pops forever & ever! read more

See all

I placed an order today for one large pizza pie, it never was delivered and they refused to refund me my money The order was supposed to be delivered between 6:29 PM to 6:44 PM. I waited by the door between those times, nobody drove up to the door to deliver anything. Total lack of customer, empathy, and customer service, I believe all the other negative reviews on this place. I recommend to find a better location read more

Always delicious! This neighborhood pizzeria never disappoints. Great quality, great flavor, and the perfect spot for a reliable, tasty slice. read more

They are awesome and always were. Hands down, nothing bad here. Pizza is delicious and the plates are perfect. They haven't changed at all. Quality and consistency. read more

You'll see a mix of regulars and newcomers filling tables. With eyes shut, I felt the food melt and wished it wouldn't end. Every worker delivered top-quality service. The meal quality stands out, portion sizes impress, and prices stay reasonable. The experience amazed me completely. read more

Well done pepperoni slice very good. Spent about $15 for 3 slices and a Diet Coke 12oz. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

You standing on line and the guy is so busy he takes people who just walk in. Terrible service I would not recommend him to my enemy.

Delmar pizza is so good the little ones always ask "is it from Delmar?" Before eating any pizza. I have even begun lying and always saying "it's from delmar" even when we are in a different state. Delmar has their seal of approval. Stromboli is good . Vodka pie is good. Remember after sandy they didn't even want to reopen when they lost the old stove. Glad they did. read more

Everything. Throw the whole place away. The pizza arrived like cardboard. Reheated and gross. Are Ate a half a slice each and tossed the rest. Ruined our dinner and the manager refused to pick it up and refund our money. Other reviews definitely said they gave them old food as well. Never again. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Pizza is horrible!! (barely warm) you can tell it's been reheated. No fresh, cardboard and not hot - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Very friendly staff. Fast service and crispy hot pizza. Tried the vodka and a pepperoni. Tv showing sports games and a plenty of space. Pretty clean and lots of light. read more

Definitely a solid slice of pizza! Can't say its my best but its my first in the area and I'm content! The crust was super thin and crispy like I like it, the sauce wasn't overpowering and it was melty and yummy. I got the vodka slice as it was the last one left so I thought it was calling my name. Very yummy but I wish there was more mozz and maybe even a touch more sauce. Also we used the Yelp Check In Offer to get a free order of garlic knots!! The cashier tried to tell me "that promotion ended, but we'll take it" and I was just happy w free knots lol! Also check out this picture of their prices from the 50's -- I wish !!!! read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Prices from 1957 whaaaaat - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Let's start this review by stating that their pizza is always fresh. Fast and friendly are my words of choice in regards to the service. I usually dine in . It is always kept clean here . This is a perfect example how a pizzeria should be . Fast , friendly and fresh. read more

Where are the prices of pies and why aren't they listed on the board in store? There are no prices listed on their site either. Ordered an Alfredo pie for pickup and gave $40 only to get $11 and some change back. Really? You're telling me one pie cost nearly $29 in Brooklyn? Really? I'm all for supporting local businesses but sometimes these businesses just aren't setting realistic standards for locals. I've been coming here since young since I grew up in the area and my gym was a block away, but over the years I've just kept seeing the prices hike up and up. Literally a dollar for every year. I remember when an Alfredo pie used to be just under $20. This place has been renovated and it looks much cleaner and brighter, but what's the point if the actual food isn't improving? The workers were also unsociable. In the middle of my transaction my cashier for some reason got changed and she said nothing to me. Not a hello, didn't tell me the amount of my payment or change, and no thank you. Honestly, I'm just sad at what Del Mar has become. I won't be coming back unfortunately. read more

See all

The ny slice is a perfect amount of cheese to tomato sauce so that it forms a harmonious tangy layer that is soft and chewy to the palate and inevitably the orange oil spills from either side of the pizza or around the corner of your mouth. The crust is indiscernible from the tip to the center as it acts like an invisible vehicle for the cheese sauce and oil but makes its presence known with its ascending thickness and crunch as you reach the crust. Mini rice balls are glutinous well blended spheres of rice to Parmesan cheese. And the outside fried to an airy panko crisp. Dipped in the marinara to break up the cheesy goodness if you'd please. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pie at 8:43PM and it arrived at my doorstep at 9:08. Just here to say, these guys don't play and this is your spot for pizza. I love ordering and they never ever disappoint. Thanks Delmar! Buffalo Pizza $28 Call for delivery to save surcharge on apps. read more

See all

Ordered the Delmar special ($29) and garlic bread for delivery. The pizza was way too salty because of the anchovies. Perhaps, if they used less it would've been better. It also lacked cheese. Other than that, I did like that the slice was thin and not doughy. Some of the garlic bread was burnt on the bottom so it wasn't pleasant to eat. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Delmar special - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza here is very good; they make several types from traditional cheese to grandma's squares. The place is always busy; the staff is okay but the star of the place is the pizza. read more

Underrated With all of the great pizza shops in Brooklyn, here is one that falls under the radar. What a delicious slice of pie. Great thin crust, crispy, good sauce, and just the right toppings. This a fairly small shop that you just walk in a grab a slice. Nothing formal or even restaurant like. You order at the counter and pickup your food as well. The cool exterior entrance has not been restored which gives the place some character. I guess it's been around for 60 years. If your in the area and walk by Delmar, stop in. You won't regret it. Thanks read more

Coming to Delmar Pizza for many years. Pizza,and Food are delicious..Very clean and Has a restroom.Everyone who works there is friendly. Chicken Parmigiana is delicious.huge Portions! The Best!! read more

Your phones are too busy and delivery is Very slow. Tonight I waited 1hour and 30 minutes for my order

Pizza 10+ Eggplant Parm Hero 8.0 Service friendly and fast. Ambiance super clean and smells awesome. read more

I'm a pizza lover and I can honestly say that Delmar's pizza is consistently great. I have enjoyed their pizza for years, their vegetable pizza is the best there is. read more

A pizza is a very rare treat for me, so I was so excited to try out this popular neighborhood pizzeria. What comes to mind when you think of a Sicilian slice? Thin, crispy, delicious sauce, fresh mozz. Unfortunately my experience was anything but this. I picked up the pie straight out of the oven and was home in under 10 minutes. Opening the box I was perplexed to see a thicker than usual crust. Okay I thought, let's try it out.... Steaming pile of crap. Greasy undercooked chewy dough. Cheap cheese. Sauce was nothing special at all. The amount of water content this pizza had was hilarious. Every bite sent water bursting in all directions. Delmar, you take the crown for the worst pizza I've ever had, anywhere. Employees were unfriendly and had to yell multiple times to ask about my order. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Greasy watery mess. Sicilian should be crispy and sauce bursting with flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been eating Delmar's food for the last 30 years. I don't know how I've never reviewed this gem, so here I go. The pizza is cheesy perfection. Thin crust and excellent cheese with the perfect chew. Not greasy at all. I gravitate towards the alfredo slice, which is a white slice with bits of bacon and I'm assuming some Alfredo sauce. All I know each bite melts in my mouth. I'm also partial to the white slice, which is what I had tonight. Can't speak to the regular slice as I can't have tomato sauce, but my mom loves it and she has very refined taste buds. The sausage and pepper roll is legendary with the crust having the perfect amount of crispiness on the outside and tender chew on the inside. Sausage and peppers inside are extremely flavorful and are of high quality. I was craving a Caesar salad like crazy and this more than satisfied that craving. Salad was fresh with homemade croutons and a very flavorful, creamy Caesar dressing. Last but not least is the penne with broccoli with garlic and oil. Pasta was cooked perfectly and I found this dish delicious yet subtle and perfectly satisfied my pasta craving. It is just as good, if not better than any Italian restaurant. Delivery was friendly and quick and portions were plentiful. Will definitely have leftovers! The guys that work there have always been friendly and terrific to me. Delmar is a real gem. read more

See all

Been going here for 12 years and it only gets better. The dough impeccable the sauce touches your tastebuds like no one has touched it before. I've been touched all over but not like this pizza. Now the baked ziti just has that pull and zest that hits your parietal lobe like your mom when you bring home an F. In all best pizzareia ever. Best, Pizza Enthusiast read more

So I went to order couple time to this place becouse it's close to my job where I work , I don't care ‍ how tasty the pizza can be if the service it's zero Some of my coworkers told me to go to this place to try but for me this place it's like the pizzeria on 1967. The pizza it's so classic and to me the pizza it's not to good , I went to to many places they have I lot of options to choose and I don't know who it's the boss but the employees are so aggressive it's like they give you free pizza sorry guys I try other places read more

Is it possible. Their pizza got even better. A near perfect pizza. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Their pizza only gets better. It is a perfect pizza.  Large regular 18" pie. 7-20-19. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is my go to pizza spot but I love their spinach roll. Got have the veggies. The staff is polite and great service.

Nicely nestled (say that four times fast!) on the four blocks of Sheepshead Bay road sits @delmarpizzeria . The place has been around 60+ years here in the Bay and staple of this community. 63 years is a long time for a spot to be making pizza, and Delmar has that recipe down pat! This trip, I had my usual: 1+1 hot plus opted for the Alfredo slice. That's got Alfredo sauce, fresh mozzarella, and bacon. I remember this slice being a bit more appetizing, but the trip wasn't standing out. Of course, the square stood out for me, but the regular took the reheat a bit too much. I can't complain much about Delmar. It can get a pass, and I'll be back. Old habits die hard. More pics here ! https://www.instagram.com/marcoskicks/?hl=en read more

See all

I ordered a regular cheese slice and a vodka slice. Both were pretty tasty. Didn't have as much cheese as I prefer but I still ate it down to the crust. There was a large variety and the workers weren't hanging around talking. Every few mins new items were being brought to the front. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The best pizza! Been coming here since I was a kid. Thin crisp old school pizza. That's why this place has been around so long. This is always a stop when I'm in the neighborhood- casual setting. read more

Best pizzeria hands down in south Brooklyn. It's always consistent, fresh, and perfect. The pizza is just the right amount of dough and crunch. My favorites are the Alfredo bacon and the vodka slice. Their pizza is freshly made and you will always get a fresh slice because it doesn't have enough time to stand there for long. Hands down my go to pizzeria! read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Old school Brooklyn pizza. Unique and delicious chicken rolls with grilled chicken and fresh veggies. Friendly atmosphere.

The best pizza in Brooklyn hands-down. The pepperoni pizza is unmatchable and top-tier. I must visit in Brooklyn Sheepshead Bay

This review is strictly for the plain pizza. Yelp does not allow half stars which I found this to be 3.5 stars. Its good pizza not great. The sauce is the beat part- very tasty with a lunch when you bite in, crust and cheese are just a standard new york slice. Some New York flop to the slice. If you live in sheepshead bay I see this being the best spot for pizza. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York