First time ordering from here and the delivery was fast and quick. Ordered a medium pepperoni pizza pie and spaghetti with meatballs. The spaghetti arrived hot but the pizza was a tad warm and looked dry. Though it tasted ok it just looked it had been sitting on the counter and just placed in the box. The spaghetti and meatballs are delicious. The pasta is al dente and the meatballs and very flavorful. The sauce is quite tangy without being too tomatoey. Will give them another chance and will try just the regular cheese pizza. read more

See all

New location but still amazing ! The food was delicious , very tasty and fresh , service was fast and friendly ! read more

Sofia Pizza - Stuffed Shells - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ok, now this is a go-back-to spot! Delicious crispy crust without being burnt; well formed pies that include just the right amount of ingredients makes for very tasty bites as you satisfy your cravings!! Oooh, so yummy; I got both a cheese pie with sausage & pepperoni as well as a Margherita pie! Both were absolutely gorgeous to both eyes & mouth. Thanks so very much Sofia for quick delivery!! read more

Sofia Pizza - Cheese pie with both pepperoni and sausage throughout. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came for 2 slices with a topping each & was quoted $14. Delmar's in sheepshead is the best pizza in area and don't even charge $10 for 2 toppings. They cost more than all the high end pizzerias I've ate at in the city. P.S they keep all their premade dough UNDER the oven ON THE FLOOR. Would not recommend. Pricey and disgusting read more

The pizza is very good! I haven't had anything bad to say about this place! It's another good pizzeria! Thumbs up!

Really great pizza dough. I enjoyed their cheese slices as well as pepperoni. Timely delivery. Will definitely be ordering from here again in the near future. read more

Usually I'm not a big fan of the Italian American style when is about restaruants and food in general . I've been ordering online from Sofia since I've moved to Brooklyn . Sofia is just amazing! Delivery comes always earlier than scheduled time. Portions are super generous. If ask extra bread , instead one they send me 3! Lasagna is tasty and cooked with good ingredients finally! Meatballs soft tasty and fresh ! ( maybe a bit too much garlic for an Italian by birth like me ) Rolls , pizzas and Dough in general are always fresh and perfectly cooked . Bravi read more

Picture this, it's New Year's Eve and you're spending it with your ninety-eight (98) year old grandmother who never has a craving for anything but now somehow wants pizza. You haven't lived at home I'm almost twenty (20) years and your go to place has gone out of business and your other standby is closed. Enter Grubhub and Sofia Pizza to save the day. I ordered a large cheese pie, garlic knots with a side of marinara and soda. Shortly after placing my order I got a call from Sofia Pizza informing me that I wasn't the only one wanting garlic knots and they were sold out. They replaced the knots with garlic bread and the wait for delivery began. Grubhub estimated at least an hour wait for delivery but the food arrived hot and fast in about forty-five (45) minutes. The pizza was absolutely delicious with the perfect amount of cheese with a crispy crust. The garlic bread was meh, but that pizza was phenomenally delicious. My grandma who we usually have to cajole into eating tore the pizza apart too so she also gives it two thumbs up. Next time I'm in New York, I'll definitely be ordering again and hopefully it will include garlic knots. :) read more

Sofia Pizza - Large Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My favorites are their garlic knots, burger and fries, really good pizza as well. Pasta dishes are always super tasty as well, you can't go wrong! Reasonably priced, definitely recommend read more

Wonderfully made pizza. The buffalo chicken is my fave. Thicker crust lots of cheese and that hit of spice. So good! I used to go here to lunch all the time when i worked in the area. read more

The best! I always order from here and they always come quick and food is always on point! Great portions too! Thanks Sofia's pizza

Excellent shrimp parmigiana hero. Service was good, they called when they were out of one of the items I ordered, had a great meal and delivery was super quick. Definitely will order again read more

Best food you will ever try from such a small location. The pasta ( pene alla vodka with grill chicken ) was so amazing. Pizza buffalo chicken nice and spicy. Food was good, fresh, warm, fast delivery. read more

Sofia Pizza - Penne alla Vodka with Grill Chicken Broccoli Rabe Hero - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Love their pizza, but most of all their service. Always a pleasant experience. Yesterday we ordered 2 salads on their menu, the new Apple, Orange, and walnut arugula salad and Caprese Salad. One word-- Yum! read more

Sofia Pizza - Apple Walnut Orange and Arugula Salad - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Baked ziti - 2/5 - Didn't really look like baked ziti. Looked more like ziti marinara. Barely any mozzarella or ricotta. But otherwise, ok. Fettucini Alfredo - 5/5 Creamy, perfectly cooked noodles, delicious sauce, a hearty portion - Absolutely fantastic. Penne alla vodka - 3 out of 5. Large portions. It smelled fantastic. They gave a nice serving of Italian bread on the side, but the sauce had an odd taste - like burnt plastic. I find this to be the case with a few pizza places in this area - not sure why. The pasta was cooked well, they gave ample sauce, and I loved that they even included a side of Parmesan without me asking. But the after-taste of the sauce just wasn't enjoyable, and it was far too tomato-based with very little cream. I'd probably opt for another pasta dish next time I come here, and pass on the penne alla vodka in the future. [edit] - I added some light cream to the sauce and it improved it 10-fold. Covered up the plastic-taste and I'm now able to enjoy my meal! Hurrah! But if you don't have cream at your disposal, expect to be slightly disappointed. :\ Caesar salad - 5 out of 5. For a family-run pizza joint, this Caesar salad is everything you'd expect. A nice portion size, croutons, Parmesan, and they don't skimp on the dressing (which is quite flavorful). This will be my new go-to spot for Caesar salads Spinach roll - 4.5 out of 5. Quite delicious. And they actually cream the spinach here, instead of putting whole leaves in the roll, which is always appreciated. They don't skimp on the cheese, which doesn't have a cheap taste, and the dough is well flavored and cooked perfectly. There's even some sauteed garlic in there for good measure! My new go-to spinach roll in the area as well. Garlic knots - 5 out of 5. They don't skimp on the quantity, and they're *super* garlicky and flavorful. I'm not sure why they appear green (perhaps parsley?) Either way - delicious! Shrimp parm - 3.5 (rated by my boyfriend) - shrimp is breaded and deep fried, good cheese distribution, bread is warm and crusty.. Only issue comes from a lot of mouthfuls of nothing but bread and sauce. Definitely could've used some more shrimp. Still, good flavor. Overall, outside of the plain slices (I find something a little off with them, but can't pinpoint what...), the lack of cream in the penne alla vodka, and the lack of ricotta and mozzarella in the baked ziti, I really like this place. By far the 2nd best Italian food options within delivery of my apartment (2nd to Anthony's on Ave. X - which pretty much blows everyone else out of the water). But I would recommend this place to anyone looking to get pizza in the South Brooklyn area. read more

See all

Best Italian food in the area. I recommend sausage hero, grandma pizza. Also like their chicken fingers and hamburger delux.

Sophia Pizza is on the block that was flooded out during Hurricane Sandy, so this place is relatively new. As such, there isn't much to tweak. It fits the mold of a reliably good pepperoni and buffalo chicken pizza place. The decor is basic and the pricing isn't posted (don't worry, there are to-go menus). A word on the pricing, the per slice cost is a little higher than I would expect for the neighborhood. This place is in the Coney Island/Sheepshead Bay/Gravesend area not the East Village, but two slices should be enough for a hungry person, so I guess volume wise the pricing is consistent. Maybe, I'm just a spoiled, hard-to-impress, Brooklynite? I gave it three stars because it is a good restaurant but not a place you would go to try something new, unless you were from out of town and categorically unfamiliar with the concept of a pizza-by-the-slice shop. $3 for a pepperoni slice? Yeah, okay. read more

See all

great food would order from here every time ! i think it's one of the. wat pizza places around !!!!!! read more

I came here for a good ol' regular slice a few months ago so I came back again to pickup a few mushroom and pepperoni slices for family. Unfortunately, the pizza wasn't good this time. The cheese, sauce, and dough just wasn't well proportioned. read more

Sofia Pizza - three slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

If you are a local and need a quick bite- nothing extravagant- Sofia pizza is your place. Their food is average pizza fare with borderline long wait times. It did its job, if your hungry and looking for a quick cheap meal- Love it or dump it- I'm in the middle- Sofia pizza does its job. It's not anything memorable or worth craving a return, check it out if you are looking for a unmemorable quick cheap eat. read more

We've ordered large pizza pie. Medium-sized pizza was delivered cut in 16 pieces. Very disappointed. Our kids stayed hungry. Will not order from here again read more

Ordered via Doordash. Had item missing but since this store has a different delivery mechanism (they deliver on their own or other couriers) Doordash redirected me to the store for help. Called the store, no one picked up, left a voicemail but no one ever responded. Horrible service!!! read more

I believe I paid 4.50 a slice for regular Sicilian Pizza that was sitting there for awhile. read more

After 1.5 hours after placing my delivery, I called to see if it left. Got the normal yeah, yeah, yeah it's on its way. Waited another half hour, and called back and the $&@$ over there did me the favor of ACTUALLY checking this time. Turned out they never started my order for my pregnant wife. Knapp Street Pizza is much better anyway. Cue paste and copy apology here. read more

Best pizza place in the neighborhood. I have had almost every type of pizza they offer and they are all great tasting.

i literally ordered a pizza and waited 2 hours for it.. wasn't even that good like wtf is going on for 2 hours.. they charged me and everything, they promised to come at a certain time but didn't even show up. i tried calling them too but they didn't pick up and i was sent to voicemail.. i don't recommend this place unless you don't mind waiting 1-3 hours for a pizza delivered to your house. read more

I got a regular slice and Margarita. Pizza was really good, especially the margarita slice. I liked this place - doesn't seat too many people but it's a cozy place for a quick bite. Plus they have a clean bathroom with soap available. You'd be surprised how many pizzerias DONT read more

I just ordered pizza for my kids start 3:45 to 6:00 it not coming yet... I called them.. they said not received my order yet.. when they charged my credit already... it's terrible... my kids waitting and waiting.. they're so hungry...it's so bad service and store.. never again.. read more

If you're solely rating Sofia based on Pizza (which I have not tried), you're totally missing out because their entrees are top notch! My family and I have ordered regularly and have not been disappointed. Their Chicken Francese is better then some high end Italian Restaurants in Bay Ridge and is of the perfect blend and preparation - lemon, broth and spices cooked to perfection. Mixed vegetables(broccoli and string beans) sautéed in garlic (the garlic was thinly sliced and cooked golden brown) and oil were absolutely delicious! read more

I really wanted to like them. Unfortunately I was not impressed and will continue to look for the perfect pizza delivery place. POSITIVES: - Great fresh Greek Salad. Had I only ordered the salads, I would have given this place 5 stars. - Delivery time EXACTLY as promised. NEGATIVES -With delivery time EXACTLY as promised, my hot food was cold. Grandma's pie, cold. Two orders of buffalo wings, cold. -Grandma's pie was burned. I like my pizza crispy (thus the thinner crust grandma's pie order), but I don't want my crust to be black. And cold. Don't forget it was cold. Had I eaten in I assume the food would taste good, even with the burned crust. read more

Enthusiastic service, delicious food, and kind handoff delivery. Their Stuffed Pizza Pie is to Die for!!! Thanks @Sofia Pizza, great to have you in the neighborhood:) read more

Worst delivery person. He is always with an attitude. Like, dude. I thought maybe it was just one day because everyone has a bad day and I completely understand that too but no! Every time I call this store and that delivery person drops it off. It's always with an attitude! The store is fine! Everyone is nice there but that delivery person not ok. He is like this older Mexican guy, dark skin and skinny. read more

I was dying for an decent Italian sub and gave this place a try. They weren't cheap with cold cuts. It was delicious. We also tried their cheesy bread and ordered potato croquettes but they ran out so we substituted for the rice balls. All very tasty. I'll be back to try their pizza! read more

Sofia Pizza - Rice balls! Mmm - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This is probably the worst tasting pizza I have ever tried. The margarita pizza has absolutely no flavor. The marinara sauce tastes stale and like it's from the jar. The mozzarella or dough was not seasoned at all. Would not recommend. read more

*****This is a great pizza place. They have slices, pies, salads, wings, and even whole lunch/dinner entrees. Even their sandwiches, heros & appetizers are awesome; A few of the sandwiches are great, and tasty! The food there is just amazing. The whole pies are so great, they look, taste, and are perfectly created. I love their delivery, in that they bring me everything, and its always soo good.; They also have great service right to my door! I'm also glad they have hours past regular lunch and dinner times, since I'm sometimes back home later and appreciate the convince of being available. I highly recommend Sofia's Pizza to everyone. ***** read more

Pepperoni is good. The sausage/ricotta we had was burned and hard on the bottom. Eh pizza.

I've been coming to this place for over 8 years now. Lovely little place,always delicious pizza. Not like all the chains stores you see nowadays. read more

My friend and I visited Sofia Pizza this past Wednesday. Serge's eggplant pizza is delicious, and his lentil soup is out of this world, with carrots and spinach in it! We loved the delicious garlic bread with Serge's special herb melange (WOW!!), as well as the Italian bread which came with the soup. The broccoli sauteed with olive oil and thinly sliced garlic was cooked just perfectly. It was a wonderful, satisfying meal. Service was excellent and delivered in a friendly manner. Can't wait to return: thank you, Serge, and thanks to your terrific staff! read more

Love this place. Not many good pizza places left on this side of Brooklyn. We order everything on the menu. Their food , dinners, rolls, sandwiches, etc is always fresh and really delicious. read more

I came in for a recovery slice of pizza after a weekend festival. Definitely have to say the Sicilian slice I'm eating right now is fresh, descent size square and amazing sauce and cheese. I would definitely come here again to try a special slice. read more