Excellent quality takeout pizzeria We've been ordering from Domenico's Pizzeria & Pasta of Prince's Bay for over 12 years, and it has consistently delivered fresh, delicious pizza with a crunchy crust (regular or thin) and generous toppings. Our top favorites include the Veggie pie (not on the menu - ask for it!), the Buffalo Chicken pie, the MVP pie (marinara, vodka, pesto), and the White pie. And of course, we've had countless regular pies at children's parties over the years:) Orders are always ready on time, and the staff is polite, quick and efficient. Occasionally, during very busy times, the toppings may be somewhat uneven or sparse lacking near the edges - something for the bakers to watch closely when the rush is on. Overall, we are very happy with Domenico's and don't order our pizza from anywhere else. We definitely recommend this place if you're looking for great takeout pizza in Prince's Bay area. read more

See all

They are so generous with the pizza sizes here, but it does take a bit of time to be served the pizza. There are seats inside and they play some music, but it wasn't super crowded. We got the buffalo chicken and bbq chicken pizzas and since we'd never been here before, both my friend and I ordered a large to share. We were both shocked by how big the pizzas actually were. The flavors of all the sauces and toppings on the pizzas mixed well together, and the pizza lasted us several days and held up well as leftovers in the fridge. read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - BBQ Chicken Pizza, Buffalo Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Love the food and they deliver on time. The people are very polite and helpful I've been going there for a long time.

Delicious food at domenicos!!!! I love their hero's!!! Today i tried the chicken cutlet with fresh mozzarella with balsamic on the side and it was absolutely delicious!!! I also recently had a chicken cutlet vodka slice and it was amazing- the slices are huge they are not a regular slice size. Fast delivery and great food highly recommend !!! read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - Chicken cutlet with fresh mozzarella hero. - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I was visiting a family member at the hospital and saw this pizzeria so my husband and I just ordered a pie to take home. My husband ordered and told the guy he was going to wait in the car and told him when the pizza is done just wave to me and I will come back in. The next thing we know they brought the pizza to the car that was so nice of them didn't expect that at all. Since then we order from them all the time. Their food is great. The girl answering the phone for orders is so nice. Sometimes it's the little things in life that makes a big impact. The other day I ordered 5 pies ( had company) and I got a free bottle of soda and 1 set of garlic knots. Thank you Domenicos I really appreciate the little things that you do! Forever a customer! read more

I had to order again last night. I know that's 2 times in the matter of 3 days. My husband got a chicken roll which was jam packed with chicken. I'm not really sure how they put that much meat in the roll it was huge. Very moist chicken cutlets not dried out or over fried. We got our favorite 2 staples :grandma pie and vodka sauce parm. My in laws were over and we ordered vodka parm rice balls. I'm pretty sure I secretly insulted my mother in law by saying these are the best rice I have ever had. In my defense she doesn't make vodka parm rice balls. I feel like I would like the old lady from the Frank's read hot commercial when she says "I put that ---- on everything" I seriously can put their vodka sauce on everything. read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - Vodka parm garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Solid 4. We ordered delivery from this pizzeria and I had the Veal Parm which was damn new perfect. The veal itself was tender and was loaded with sauce and cheese. What more could you ask for? The hero was delivered in a box which was new for me. Never saw anything like this but what it did do was keep it ultra hot. This needs to be a thing! I'd try them again! read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - Veal parm - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Fast delivery and great pizza and the food is good nothing negative about this place I recommend it

My husband and I ordered pizza from Domenico's last night. We got a Grandma pie and a pepperoni pie. It's been a long time since we've had great pizza!!! The Grandma pie was amazing and the pepperoni pie was delish!! We only waited about 35 minutes for our delivery. We highly recommend Domenico's. read more

Hands down a 5 star venue! I've been getting delivery or pick up from here for about 3 months now. They have the BEST salads! The baby spinach salad with walnuts and grilled chicken is my favorite. They are about $13 but well worth it. The size of the salad and quality of the grilled chicken can't be beat. Typically I'll have half the salad and save it for later. The garlic bread is great that comes free, though I usually share it because of the "carbs". I've also had the spinach roll and chicken wings. Both very good. I believe if you order online they offer a 10% discount. I spoke with Chris several times, and met him one day when I went in for a pickup. Very nice staff! Excellent food. read more

I love the pizza here. I got the potatoes and egg hero and a square pie. They were top notch The counter service was great. read more

Pizza like it's meant to be! The slice was nice and large, like back in the day slices. I did have to add sausage and extra cheese, that's the only way to eat pizza in my opinions! I'm not for all this vodka sauce and chicken on a pizza!!! They had a wide selection, but just give me plain! Now the price, still not happy. $5.50! One slice with pepperoni, sausage and extra cheese. Tell me that's the going rate and I will chill! I'm saying, the people behind me ordered 5 slices of that foofoo stuff, chicken, vodka, etc and the total was $17!!! Do the math that's $3.40 for one slice with extra stuff!!! So I wonder how much is a plain pepperoni slice? Well, despite the price, the pizza was the best I had since my visit to ny! So I guess the $5.50 was worth it! read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - $5.50 slice with sausage pepperoni and extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

If you remember or enjoy the pizza from public school lunch. Come here and order the Sicilian pie. What a disappointment, barely any sauce and unmelted cheese. Ill have to come back and order a plain pie to update my review but i will never be ordering the Sicilian from here again. read more

Really delicious pizza, which I know, I know... We're on Staten Island. But because I'm at expert on SI and its pizza, I can tell you what's better. My in laws order from here and it's soooo good. We love their sausage rolls and grandma's pie. It's also kind of fun that they have a special: two round pies with 1 topping each for $18. Conveniently located near places to run errands and pick up food on the way back. read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - Storefront - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I haven't left a review in so long but I re-downloaded the yelp app so that I could leave a review for Dominico's. I ordered food for pick up and got a chicken Parm pie and two bread bowls stuffed with pasta. The owner threw in some free garlic knots because my husband and I were first-time customers. We are sitting here in awe because this is some of the best food we have had in a long time. Everything is so fresh and delicious and the portions are so big we will definitely have food for the next few days LOL. Can't wait to tell everyone I know about this spot- and not to mention the beyond friendly owner who personally took my order. Thank you so much you definitely have some new customers! read more

See all

me and my bf love the meatball hero's here they're so good and everytime i've ordered from here i've never been disappointed in the food. and it's always comes out so fast :). read more

Never again I'll order from this place, they are thieves, last time I came they were trying to charge $17 for small chicken soup, when I asked, they apologized and said it was a mistake, fine, I understand mistakes happen. Later when I brought my soup home, they didn't give me a garlic bread that comes with it. I guess it was a mistake too, looks like all mistakes they do in their own favor. Never again !!! read more

I buy from there a few times a month. Pizza good but not the best. Very expensive to me.

Pizza is a hit or miss. Watch out for delivery service the person likes to add more on your credit card slip for tip

We ordered a large pie (half chicken vodka, half margherita), Greek salad and broccoli garlic and olive oil linguine for delivery. Everything had large portions and tasted amazing! Especially the pizza. The pasta could've used a little bit more salt but it's better for the food to be bland than overly salty in my opinion! They also threw in some garlic bread with the order which we all enjoyed. Would definitely order from this place again the next time we're near the area read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I feel like this for sure calls for a refund but the owner thinks otherwise. I mean can u blame me for not wanting to eat a new one after getting this read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - Am I wrong for wanting my money back or ??? - Rice Ball Vodka Parmigiana SOUP - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Great pizza and friendly professional staff. The owner is really nice and handles the evening rush really well. They have great selection and make everything super fresh and fast. Highly recommend this place. read more

Great service. Great food. I would definitely recommend this pizzeria. It's a wonderful new neighborhood establishment.

Previously I complained about their expensive margherita pie with little cheese. Forget this place, it's not even worth considering anymore. I uploaded a photo of the margherita from tonight. Same issue with barely any cheese, but this time they didn't even put any basil on it. I gave them too many second chances. How are you going to charge $20 for dough and sauce and be that skimpy on everything else? read more

See all

Great neighborhood pizza spot. Friendly staff and owner. Food always delicious and on point. Vodka sauce is a must try!

Possibly the worst pizza I've ever tasted in my entire life. I happen to be at the CVS pharmacy to drop off a prescription and they told me it would take about 45 minutes so I figured I would wait around and grab something to eat. There was a girl behind the counter and I told her I wanted to slices warmed up. Obviously this was an issue because what she has made it to slices they were still warm so we repeated the process again. Wanna slices were given back to me in all honesty this Pizza was disgusting..It tasted like it was sitting there for two days and it seem like no one cared. I was the only one in the place and when I said something to her she said "sorry" .WTF Does sorry have to do with spending over six dollars on two slices & a Coke? read more

I can say anymore. The food was delicious. The service was great and the owner is even better. I had some friends over and they all loved the food. Definitely ordering from them again. read more

Catered food from here last weekend for a birthday party. The food was served hot and fresh. Tasted great. My guests loved it, including children!! They even had seconds! read more

This is my favorite pizzeria!! My 1st stop when i come home to visit. It feels like home and the food is delicious. I always have Penne vodka with grilled chicken. The pizza is amazing too!! read more

Just had a great Shrimp Parmigiana Hero. Took a chance, ordered online. It took a little longer then expected but the weather is crappy. The food arrived hot and tasted great so no complaints. I will order again read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - Great way to deliver a hot sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Food in Staten Island is very hit or miss. This is my 4th time ordering from this wonderful place. First thing, delivery was early and prompt. Secondly food was so hot as if there was an oven in the delivery guys car. The pasta... UH-MAZING. Their Alfredo sauce is something else. Their vodka garlic knots is a must buy also. To all the staff in this magical restaurant, keep doing what ya doing. The food is amazing, service is great, delivery is fast. You guys and gals are awesome. read more

Ordered delivery tonight and everything was beyond delicious!! The order (with many add ons and special requests) was 100% correct! We had the baked ziti with chicken, and vodka sauce instead of red sauce, a personal vodka pie with sausage and also the mini rice balls. I wish I took a picture but it was too good and we finished it before thinking of taking one :) and they sent these garlic breadsticks that were great! Good job tonight Domenicos staff! After a long week, this perfectly made meal made our night!! read more

So good! Love their vodka pies, especially with extra sauce. I come back every time I visit my parents.

Consistent, friendly, great service and fast. For the south shore of Staten Island, this is the ultimate take-out spot. Domenico's nails all of the basics and is reliable. The owner, or one of them, Chris, is hands-on and extremely friendly -- he's helpful and the whole staff tends to be similar to Chris. Their specialty pizza is what makes this place... and their pastas. They kill the Italian basics. read more

We had the Chicken Bacon Ranch and it is great pizza place with great people. Definitely a must try

This is a great local pizzeria with great food. They have great specialty pizzas. I love there buffalo chicken pizza read more

Domenico's Pizzeria you are absolutely awesome, I had a spectacular experience here yesterday. Excellent location and service was terrific. Fantastic menu items, Grandma Pie was my choice and it was really fantastic. The staff are really attentive and nice and they're great at giving recommendations. Domenico's Pizzeria....Love it. read more

This review is just for the pizza, haven't eaten anything else. Stopped in for a quick slice, very over priced for just a plain slice, and it was just not that good. For the price they charged for a plain slice that wasn't even big I will not be going back. read more

They really found a sweet spot of making the crust crisp without letting it get even a little burned. That sweet spot extends to its cheese which melts almost perfectly into the pie. read more

Domenico's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This is my family's regular Friday night pizza place and for good reason. The pies are consistently baked to perfection. We also really like their fried calamari- lightly fried, but still crisp. The staff is friendly and orders are promptly served. read more