Very good fish and chips, polite staff. Only issue if you haven't been before it's a bit confusing…read moreto find it as it's pretty far into the building when you enter the marked side entrance, it's in the center of the building. You will pass a section that has seating for a very large dining crowd, ATM and server statue, Its a little past that point. Recommended.

Rumsey Tavern is a solid choice if you're spending time around Shepherdstown and want a reliable…read moreplace with a relaxed, comfortable vibe. The menu focuses on classic American bar food -- burgers, wings, and familiar favorites -- and everything we had was well prepared and satisfying. It's not trying to be flashy, just consistently good. What really sets this place apart is the service. Grant, the manager, deserves major credit for being attentive, professional, and clearly invested in making sure guests have a great experience. That kind of hands-on management shows and elevates the entire visit. Whether you're exploring the area for the first time or just looking for an easy, no-stress spot to grab a meal, Rumsey Tavern is a dependable option. Good food, friendly service, and a comfortable atmosphere earn this place a solid four stars.

Just a quick update since last time I was in. They switched to hand cut fries and now these are…read moreeasily the best fries in the area!

Recently had a birthday dinner there. Previewed the menu in advance, but when we arrived, we found…read morethat a lot of the menu items that were advertised they were out of. They were also very understaffed, and took a long time to get our meals, which came out in segments over a period of 20 minutes. I understand it's more of a bar than a restaurant, and I will say the lady server did an incredible job and took great care of us. It was just disappointing that they were out of so many things such as chicken, shrimp, and other things that are mainstays of a dinner. The food tasted OK, nothing to really complain about, but nothing special either.

Fantastic service, cold beer, and friendly local crowd, we loved this little dive bar with…read moreincredible bites! We had the chicken tenders for an appetizer and it was way too much. Juicy, lightly breaded and their sauces taste like my grandma whipped them up We both had burgers medium rare and they were cooked PERFECTLY! Loved the fresh toppings. Honestly, it was a wonderful all around experience!

Just left an hour ago. When we arrived the hostess told us we could sit at one of a few tables…read moreavailable. So we picked one and ordered food. As we sat and waited forever for our food we saw reserved signs all around us. Seemed like an event was going on. The tavern filled up and everyone was staring at us like we weren't supposed to be there including the staff. Our hostess seated us at a round table toward the back. It was quite obvious they needed more seats and it was awkward even sitting there. Food was ok. Fryer oil tasted old. $25 for crab Mac and cheese that had a slight hint of a crab taste. Ordered a medium burger and it was well done. Ordered a pretzel with cheese sauce and the cheese was off color/old/ burnt. The deviled eggs were fantastic. When we finished our dinner we were waiting to see a waiter to get the check and no one was available so I walked up to the bar and paid. After i paid the hostess put a reserved sign on our table while we were sitting there and said "no rush" I don't usually write reviews. But I wanted to have a nice night with my wife and daughter and it was ruined

Great time last night. Food was great and staff took great care of us. Lots of room for a group to…read moreget together.

Just great food and drinks! Simple local place with great people and service.... Just changed…read moreownership. If you have not tried it.... Give it a try.

I decided to try the "whole hog" and from the size of the sandwich, they aren't kidding. It is so…read morelarge, one has to use the giant knife stabbed in the top of the sandwich to cut it into bite-size pieces. The combo of meats, sauce and seasoning makes for a delicious meal. The mashed potatoes and gravy was also good. Our server was excellent. He kept my sweet tea, and it was nice and sweet, full. He even brought me a to-go glass. The interior is decorated nicely, but some of the music they play, not so good. Overall, a great place to get a fast, hot, tasty meal.

Fabulous!!!!!!! The service was great. The wings were tasty and not dried out. The pickle dip is an…read moreabsolute must. It's served with ruffles. The restaurant was clean and the location is great because it's in the same parking lot as a great ice cream shop. We will be back again and again.i should have taken a picture but it was eaten so fast!!

Please come see Zach the bartender and get you a green Tea shot. They are 8 dollars and they are…read moregood and better than I've had them anywhere else. I ended up getting the bacon burger . It was massive with bacon and cheddar and tomato and lettuce and seasoned fries . My wife had the 8 buffalo wings with a side of fries , the portions are plentiful everything is huge in West Virginia well at least at this location.

If I could give this place a 0 I would. Went there tonight for dinner with friends for my wife's…read morebirthday. Let's say what could go wrong, it went very wrong! Our waitress was horrible. Took part of the tables order and never came back for the rest. She disappeared and we had to call over other staff to handle the problems. First off many items on the menu they did not have such as French onion soup. Mind you they only gave two soups to begin with. My wife and our friend ordered loaded baked potato but we only received one of them until we asked for the manager. The manager saud the kitchen was backed up because they had a party of 20 who ordered different items on the menu. Isn't that a possibility if you let them orderI from the menu? I did not get the chipotle aioli with my fried green tomato blt and had to wait till we got another wait staff to get it. Service was horrible. The food subpar. The whole experience was hideous. As a chef of 45 years I had to wonder why a party of 20 people would throw the service off in the restaurant??? Made no sense at all. The place also needs some upgrades like tables that don't tilt and backs of seats that don't move. Just was not very clean or well maintained. My silverware looked as though it was already used. Needless to say we will never be back! Horrible experience on all levels!

This place never disappoints! From the customer service to the delicious food! Thanks to Alex for…read morethe extra attention to detail and for making the customer feel welcome. Also, for multitasking--thanks for the excellent service!

Came here for the second time and honestly gotta say wasn't that bad at all. The staff was friendly…read moreand helpful and the food came out a minute after I placed the order. The food was pretty good, cant complain about fried chicken and fries. The inside is small and just used to order, the seating is outside. All together pretty good and very close to where I live so I'll definitely come again if I want a quick bite.

Walked over yesterday to have a couple drinks in the beautiful weather on the patio. The business…read moreappears to be under some kind of renovation and you have to enter through the side patio door. Service appeared a tad disorganized. But overall, our waitress was decent and so were our drinks! A great way to cool off in the coming spring and summer days.

Non-issue with their parking. The restaurant has bar and table settings. It is more of a sports…read morethemed restaurant. We were immediately greeted by their waitresses. The table we had smelled like....piss. Later, we joined our peers at another table which also smelled the same and many of us made the same comment. The food and drinks were served within timely manners. The waitresses were friendly. We just weren't impressed and definitely did not like the scent at the table. By the way. It was the table close to the restroom but the scent was coming from the table or seat itself. The check out process was easy. You can pay by credit card or contact less card via phone. Overall, it gets a 1.9 out of 5. The whole place needs some serious cleaning.

You can definitely tell this is family owned. And I mean this in the best way possible. Great…read moreburger and great vibes.

What a cute little place... and LOVE the owners!…read more We were recently in the area for a drive to look at the fall foliage and discovered this little spot, which we heard was pretty popular with the locals. We definitely understand the appeal, as the food was good, the drinks were good, and the staff were great. We likely ordered too much fried food while there (and it all tasted great), but next time I might substitute some of the fried fare with a salad. But our eyes were drawn to the other tables around us where patrons were chomping on fried pickles (yum), French fries (tasty enough), and onion rings (outstanding). My only recommendations to the owners would be to stick a few more healthy items. Before I close out, I must send another shout out to the owners (a husband and wife team who were staffing the place the day we visited). They are awesome!! I loved the conversations with them and would return to Horseshoe just for drinks and a chuckle... and the onion rings! Final thoughts = check this place out if nearby, but be sure to balance the fried food with a salad.

Delicious pizza and their sauce and ingredients were very good. Delivered on time and hot on a…read morevery cold night.

Just moments ago they delievered these to my house calling them break sticks. The dough obviously…read moredidn't rinse and they are hard as a rock.