Burgers are what we went for, and what we got! They were infact very good. The best burger I ever had? Well, not the very best, however, most likely in the top ten! The cozy feel and service did also add to why one would try lunch here. read more

I've been going to Duffy's on a regular basis for a few years now. I guess it's time I write something about them. 1.Service-Always great. There are a few regular waitresses and bar tenders there. All are friendly and fast. Very attentive and go out of their way for you. 2.Bar-If you're a beer connoisseur then this is not the place for you. They have the standard brews that every other bar carries. Maybe even less than that. Very rarely will you see anything interesting. That said, if you like pitchers of miller light for $10 bucks then you're good to go. It's not a mix drink kind of place either. Don't ask for anything too involved if you're not drinking beer. Kitchen-It's all standard bar food IMO. Nothing ground breaking or inventive. But don't get me wrong because it's very good. They have regular burger specials like their bleu cheese burger and their chicken burger. Both are very good. As for their signature Duffy burger, it's very good. Get it medium with onion rings and you'll be happy. Their waffle fries are good too. As for it being "the best burger on the island"? Well thats a stretch. They serve it on an english muffin, get it with bacon and cheese. It's good. But not the best on Staten Island. Parking-Decent. If you can get a spot around back off of Bement ave then you should be good. Parking of Forest ave can be a challenge as that neighborhood can be busy. Price-Great. You really get a lot for your money here. Great value. Atmosphere-Slightly better than a dive bar. Which IMO is just fine. read more

I happened to be on Staten Island and decided to drop by Duffy's for their storied burger. It does live up to the reputation as the best burger on Staten Island, but also one of the best in the city. The nondescript tavern can be found in a line of shops on Forest Ave, but inside it is a nice space with lots of locals, professionals and a mix of ages all who come out for its great food and drink. I did not have the Reuben sandwich, but it also appeared to be delicious, and a lot of people were ordering it. The burger is outstanding, but not my favorite in the city. It is served, similar to Rotier's in Nashville, on an English muffin and in a simple style that I like with few condiments. You have a choice to add more toppings, but I kept mine simple with cheddar cheese, onion and mayo. The burger patty is thick and juicy, and near perfect. What would make it absolutely perfect? Grilling it on a charcoal grill instead of a flame grilled -- I am picky about my burgers as my regular readers know -- I don't consider them great if they are flame grilled. Charcoal taste is required for me to be really impressed (I guess childhood nostalgia is why). However, that aside, this is a large, simple and delicious burger that is worth the trip. Drink prices were reasonable, and the service was fast and friendly. If you need a little Staten Island in your life, this is a place to get it. read more

Burger? Duffy's it is, then! I honestly don't know how anything else on the menu is-I've never had anything else. Duffy's has clearly been around forever. It's an FDNY/NYPD supportive place, it has that kind of old vibe to it--character, if you will. I also like that you can see into the kitchen-the very small kitchen. Service is good, beers are good, burgers are good-'nuff said! :o) read more

This small place really surprised me. The staff was really friendly and they were very attentive. The mozzarella sticks were amazing and the burger was as well. I don't have a single complaint and will definitely be coming back. read more

Duffy's is our neighborhood bar with plenty of regulars. My husband and I go there often. Its a small bar, dim lighting with lots of personality! The staff has been there forever and the food is consistent. The burgers are amazing! I love the chicken fingers!!! Best bar food! The portions are generous and the prices are cheap.....even the mixed drinks. We always have a great time at Duffy's! Weekends and holidays its packed! read more

Everyone is doing burgers these days, right? We'll bypass the triple bypass you will require if you try them all and just go to DUFFY's. Not enough accolades can be put forth describing one of the best burgers in the US! They win best burger on Staten Island annually and I'm sure would do equally well if the boundaries were expanded. Fresh beef, prepared fresh daily cooked to your specs. Oh yea, the fries, rings , soups, sandwiches , wraps and beers are equally impressive. Don't be fooled by the decor of this ole Irish drink hole, this place is the real deal. read more

Best burger on Staten Island (check) The OG burger on an English Muffin (check) Duffy's is the quintessential Irish pub that happens to have the best hamburgers ever. read more

Amazing burgers, I miss them during quarantine. Potato fries are really good as well. Hostess was bad one of the times we went there but it was just that one time with her. read more

I can't say anything bad about this place. I will def. recommend to everybody !!! .. 2 thumbs up... read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

There isn't too much to say except best burger in Staten Island. It's a pub so expect this when you go. There isn't much in the way of seating and the the place is pretty packed on weekends. But if you go early enough on a Friday or Saturday night, you should be able to get a small table. I can't speak for much of the menu. I can tell you that the nachos and wings are decent, not disappointing but not anything special either. The burgers, on the other hand, are much more than you'd expect from bar food and exactly what you want in a greasy-cheesy burger. In my opinion, stick with the cheeseburger on an english muffin with a side of waffle fries, a few drinks and enjoy! read more

Fun and loud place to take your family for dinner. There is not much seating so I don't know how they accommodate parties larger than four. If you want to avoid walking through the bar crowd for dinner park in the rear and come in through the back door. The staff is very friendly and attentive. The burger is definitely one of the best on the island, don't know if it is the best though. It's thick, smothered in cheese and served on a warm English muffin. Definitely a place you should stop in at least once in your lifetime. read more

Spent some time with a group of guys while the ladies were at a Bridal Shower. Great service by a waitress who seemed to be handling the whole place by herself. Delicious burger as advertised. One less star because no Guiness on tap in an Irish pub. read more

Service was good. The burger meat was perfectly cooked but the English muffin detracts from the burger experience. The side Salad was just some iceberg lettuce. The menu limited. Small place. The kitchen workers continually went out the back door causing gusts of winter attic air. The barflies sure like to use the F word in most of their conversation so be careful who you bring with you. read more

This bar is a bar I hear about from my family that have been going there forever and now I've been going there for a long time now too. This might be a pub but there is seating for kids and a nice environment for whatever the case may be. The burgers here are served on an English muffin and the sautéed onions make it a delicious and savory burger! Also for all of you that like MGD they have it on tap! Might be the only bar I've ever seen have it and it's great! read more

Known for their burgers but their wings are the best. Great portion not expensive. Duffy's is what a neighborhood bar should be. Not sure why they've never filmed a movie here. It's genuine! read more

I believe this is simply enough I love their burger and criss-cut fries......... read more

First rate hamburgers and chicken noodle soup. Can't recommend Duffy's highly enough. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Best burger My husband and I ever had!! So juicy and flavorful and cooked exactly how we asked. The onion rings were ginormous and yummy too. Definitely stop there if you're in the area. read more

Really the best burgers on the Island, maybe even best in NY. We got there 8:15 on a Saturday night. You can see families were just leaving. We ordered sangria, 2 burgers and fries. It was amazing. The bar is filled with locals. Very nice crowd. Fast service and great price! read more

Best burger on Staten Island. That is all you need to know

You do not go to duffs unless you want a bacon cheese or hamburger with waffle fries! It really is awesome! read more

Great lunch and dinner spot...Really good staff and food..Terrance is hands on bartender makes you want to come back

Not exactly what I was expecting. The menu was bland. Not many options and they charge extra for everything. Onions tomatoes lettuce. When I'm ordering a burger I'm expecting a burger. If it's the best then be the best. The muffin they put it on was soggy. And never the less I was seated next to the kitchen door and the kitchen was so filthy. The man cooking didn't even have gloves on. The waitress was more concerned on what was going on in her phone and the guy next to the bar then serving us. Don't get the buffalo chicken sandwich. Not even sure what that was. Duffys is slacking. Not sure what everyone sees in this place. And to top it off the runs was the icing on the cake. Take care Duffys. I will not be back ever.... read more

I have heard about the hamburgers here and had to have one.. I was not disappointed! As good as the burger was it was topped by the staff. This is is a cool and friendly place. Even the chef, Godfrey , not only asked how the food was- how often do you get to tell anything to the chef?- he gave us interesting beer recommendations. And our waitress, Susan, was so incredibly accommodating. I asked for a beer based on my lunch partner's recommendation, instead of committing me to that untested choice she brought me a sample. I wish I lived closer to Duffy's, I'd live atDuffy's! This place is a gem...good food and good people, winning combination! read more

Very good burgers. I ordered mine rare and got a nice medium rare which was what I wanted. Their wings are VERY good. Crunchy and delicious. Staple spot. read more

I love dive bars and bar food! What's better than a chargrilled cheeseburger on an english muffin with waffle fries? There's obviously other items on the menu but every time I come I can't get myself to pass up a Duffy's burger. read more

Best burger! So juicy. On a large English muffin. Get the waffle fries and you will not be disappointed.

They say " The best burgers on the island" NO WAY! Not even close people! It was like a thick piece of chop steak with little flavor on an English muffin! The bacon was like beef jerky and the fries were extra greasy! Very old looking too, pass up on this joint if your looking to find a great burger! read more

Came here a few times. Really love the burger on the english muffin! They always have some specialty burgers and items available. I've had fries and onion rings and they really hit the spot. I had Jackie as a waitress (but she spelled her name like Jacqueline or something like that...weird, I know). She was very attentive and burtally honest. She has a little bit of a potty mouth (and by little bit, I don't mean a little bit), but what are you expecting at an Irish pub? read more

If I was on that Food Network show "The Best Thing I've Ever Ate" Duffys would be the first thought that comes to mind when I think of the perfect burger. You really can't beat their cheeseburger. Add ons are extra but for $11, this cheeseburger and french fry meal is the best bang you will ever get for your buck. It's super small and cozy, so I imagine busy nights can be hectic but I would wait any amount of time to have this burger- that's how good it is. The english muffin is what makes this one so special. Soooo damn good. And service is on point each and every time. Love this place. read more

Duffys is the best Irish public house on the north shore of Staten Island. Friendly atmosphere though small but with really great food. I dont know who said they have the best burger, but everything they have is all good. You can actually see the cook at work if you sit at the right table. read more

"Best Burger in Staten Island"? People should raise their standards. I thought I remembered them using the large English muffins the first time I came here. That was a good burger. After that, it never tasted the same. I make a better seasoned burger at home. I love the English muffin as a bun. No one will contest that but the burger was thick, dry, and bland. The cheese was melted but quickly dried up on the bun as it was waiting or it to be delivered to my table. My meal got cold because the tomato I ordered with it didn't come and the waitress kept forgetting to get it. Onion soup was good. read more

If I am in the mood for a real deal no non-sense cheeseburger - I go to Duffy's. I like that the burger is real juicy, about 3/4 of a lb and on an English Muffin. The English Muffin takes in some of the juices which is a nice touch. I like mozzarella on mine and ask for rare or medium rare. My wife gets Cheddar which is also real good. Criss Cut Fries and Sweet Potato fries are a must. Get the chili with cheese and onions as well. I place Duffy's in the same category as PJ Clarks and Corner Bistro in Manhattan. Keep up the good work!! read more

If you say you are going to be open and serving food until 10:30 on the website and Yelp, then you shouldn't refuse to serve a burger when I come in at 10. I would have tried another restaurant at this hour. Very disappointed. read more

This place amazes me . The kitchen is the size of a walk in closet and they put out great food . Killer burgers , great onion rings , french onion soup . Would definitely recommend . read more

First time here after hearing glowing reviews of the burger. The burger, American cheese, cooked medium, living up to all the hype. Kept it simple for the first time but I'll explore different variations in my future visits. read more

See all

THE BEST BURGERS. HANDS DOWN. The burgers are huge and served on English muffins. The burgers are always cooked perfectly too. Normally, when I order a burger I'm scared to order medium because it's normally not cooked right, but Duffys ALWAYS cooks the burger right. We normally just get the chips with out burgers, not the fries. One time I went there with my husband, we shared loaded potatoes, and each had a burger with fries. We were so full that we couldn't sit up right. read more

I love this place. Great burger, good drinks, and friendly staff. The ultimate neighborhood bar. I hate that I live in NJ and this isn't down my street. I've enjoyed everything I have eaten here. Plenty of tvs if you are there for sports. read more

Came here for late lunch. The waitress was awesome. She put cartoon network on for my girlfriend son. She brought over some crayons and it kept him busy. The people were so nice and the food was great. We had appetizers and burgers and drinks. The price was right and they have plenty of street parking. I will being going here again. Nice place to stop for a quick bite or a quick drink. read more