This place was busy for the lunch special of two large slices of pizza & a drink, but the service…read morewas fast. I ordered the lunch special and spaghetti. The pasta came with 3 garlic knots and was exactly what I wanted to eat. Spaghetti and pizza tasted great!

Best Buffalo Chicken Pizza I've ever had. I could see why Josh Allen loves this place. The regular…read morepizza is great too and probably the closest to a NY style pizza we have around here. I wish I lived closer

Now that I've had every single thing on the menu from Great Lakes pizza, I feel like I can give a…read morefair review. That's right! I've had their pizza, subs, wings, chicken fingers, salads, tacos, burgers, quesadillas, sides, and so on. I've even had their lent fish fry. This is the BEST quality pizzeria that I've been to. Everything is fresh and delicious every single time. The staff is great, food is always ready within its quoted time range, and I've even had food delivered and it was on time and still nice and hot! The prices are very reasonable for the quality and quantity. A few highlights as far as the food for me, would be their pizza, specifically their dough and sauce (I always get extra sauce because it's that good), but if you're looking for a specialty pizza, I'd recommend the steak Huron. It's like a steak sub, in pizza form! Delicious. Their chicken finger subs are miles better than anywhere else in the area, and I recommend their death sauce if you love spice. Although I have to say, their cold cut subs are better than anywhere else too, the cold cuts are always sliced nice and thin, and they're always piled high. For a cold cut sub, I'd have to recommend the American assorted! Their tacos, don't even get me started. Go with beef, chicken, or chicken finger, you can't go wrong. All amazing, and they're a great size. Salads, again, they're all fantastic! The beef taco salad and the julienne salad are my 2 favorites. It's hard for me to choose what I want to order from here, it really is THAT good! Adding a photo of the beef taco salad I ordered for lunch today, with nacho cheese and death sauce, and I added sour cream at home. It was so good, I could cry.

Back again, Once again I was quickly greeted by one of the…read morestaff at the desk, and within moments I had my chicken finger pizza (and chicken finger meal/salad//all not pictured). The chicken finger pizza was done perfectly, good size chunks and it was ordered the only way it should be made, with a bleu cheese base. Spot on pizza, also so good my 3 year old had to get in on it. Chicken fingers were of good size and came with a fair amount of fries. ( I don't want to give a crispy rating due to in box sweating). Salad... container was completely full and appears to be quite fresh. Well done GL team..

Great tasting New York style slices at reasonable prices. Good selection of different toppings…read more Plenty of bottled drinks to choose from as well. Staff was very friendly.

Stopped at lunchtime for a sub. While waiting, I watched the pizza/sub "constructor" at work. I was…read moreabsolutely taken aback noticing that he was using his BARE HANDS on All of the ingredients he was working with!!!!!! I told the "manager" who said that they recently had a health inspection and wasn't written up for no gloves!!! I got my money back and left. Make sure your health insurance is paid up if you eat there!!!

Still very good after all these years!…read more The pizza got better, the subs went way up in price and lost quality over the years. (I remember $8.50 subs!) The pizza here reminds me of what WNY pizza used to be. Chewy dough, fluffy on the inside. A crust worth eating. Not too much sauce and the pepperoni are as greasy as you need and with good flavor. The ordering on the phone and picking up in person is friendly and swift. I highly recommend this as a top pizza spot in WNY! The sub was okay too, but not great. I wish they had sub deals because I'd happily pay $9 maybe $10 for the chicken finger sub as it is, but $13? Still a very solid spot. I look forward to ordering again!

I called and asked if they could do a buffalo chicken calzone and boy did they deliver! It was one…read moreof the best I've ever have. This place rocks!

Not like I needed a reminder, but One Pie Pizza Co. serves up an excellent, truly authentic…read moreBuffalo-style pizza. This time I ordered their take on a WNY specialty pizza: the chicken finger pizza. In short, it was fantastic! Since I'm a member of their rewards program, I received a "$5 off your next order" code and figured it'd been a couple months since my last visit. The coupon couldn't have come at a better time. I placed my order online on a Saturday around 4:15pm for a 5:05pm pick-up. I know, you lose a bit of the personability when you don't call the restaurant to place an order, but online ordering is so easy and quick, and I love being able to pick my pick-up time and know my order will be ready, and paid for, when I arrive. As of 07/2026, the inside of One Pie Pizza Co. underwent a remodel. It's not as spacious, but I think it opens up their kitchen more, which I'm 100% on-board with since that means more pizza and other goodies. The staff are just as friendly and courteous as ever, I'm glad that hasn't changed. So, for dinner, I ordered a QTR Sheet (six slice) from their "SUPER Specialty Pizza" menu - The BFLO Chicken Finger (blue cheese base) cooked "LIGHT WELL DONE", which is a choice between their homemade red sauce or blue cheese base that is topped with diced chicken fingers, mozzarella cheese, and Frank's (medium) sauce. The "LIGHT WELL DONE" option is for cooking the dough underneath a bit more, firming it up, making it crispier. I like a little extra cook on my pizza as, sometimes, the Buffalo-style dough is a bit too limp, almost soggy/wet, which makes holding a slice... challenging. haha Now, I've had a few chicken finger pizzas throughout the years and while I love them, they don't always love me back. They're typically very dense pizzas thanks to all the cheese (blue cheese base AND cheese blends on top) but I was impressed with how well One Pie Pizza Co.'s sat. Don't get me wrong, this pizza is absolutely loaded. When I opened the box, I was worried how I was going to pick it up as it looked messy, but as they say, appearances can be deceiving! I was impressed and didn't finish my meal wearing it all over my hands and face. Every slice was generously topped, the flavor was spot-on. Now, I love a cheesy pizza, but I really appreciate the constraint One Pie Pizza Co. showed with not going overboard with a "blend" of cheeses on top of a blue cheese base - The layer of mozzarella was plenty, a great flavor on its own. As with all of their pizza, this left me happy and full. With that $5 off coupon, this brought the price to under $20, an incredible price, especially in 2026! One Pie Pizza Co. remains one of my favorite pizzas in Buffalo. I'm glad I finally tried their chicken finger pizza, this was excellent. With how well it agreed with me, I'm pretty confident in saying One Pie Pizza Co. will be where I order chicken finger pizzas from exclusively going forward!

Ordered a vegan pizza and was advised twice they had vegan pepperoni. After getting the pizza home…read moreand consuming some, reached out again to find out they don't carry vegan pepperoni. Brought the situation to their attention and not only did they not accept responsibly, they did not offer a refund and they essentially called me a liar. Will never order again nor recommend them. Edit: They called and left a voice mail explaining they reviewed tape and reprimanded the employee. Refunded the whole check. While the overall resolution is satisfactory, it took for days of attempted communication, of which many of my attempts when unanswered.

Ginos brings a classic new york slice to the heart of buffalo. They are my go to, and I don't think…read moreanything will change that. Gino is pretty cute too.

Ginos for pizza and buffalo wings! Had the special. Well…read moredone, we had 1/2 pepperoni and 1-2 cheese pie. Gino is from Sicily, good place. Great for takeout.

After leaving a late-night event, I had a hankering for pizza! It was 11:30 pm on a Saturday and…read morewas happy to find this place open. They had a few different styles of pizza available and they were NY style. Yum! I had trouble deciding so I grabbed a slice of cheese pizza and a slice white pizza. I enjoyed both slices. But my favorite was the white pizza for sure! There is limited seating available ... I think one booth. It's more of a takeout place. I wish it were closer to my house so I could try more items but I enjoyed my midnight snack passing thru!

Chicken Fingers and Fries were beyond disgusting. The grease was terribly old, the fingers burned…read moreand full of grease, the breading falling off, the fries limp and barely fried and the taste of the oil was sickening. Definitely a waste of $20 bucks. Will not be back.

Always good. I always recommend this place. Quality food that is perfect every time. Pick up only,…read moreno delivery. Parking right out front. In-house made dough for their pizzas. Typical pizzeria. In and out quickly

Consistent quality pizza. Pizza was cooked to perfection…read more(well done, as requested) not over cooked but cooked enough to teacup most of the pepperoni. The surface of the crust and body of the pizza is crispy on the outside and soft and light on the inside. The sauce, cheese and topping ratios were on point. Thanks for the treat Roz's