We were in there the other night for dinner , GREAT restaurant , the sauce is outstanding and the…read moredishes are out of this world chicken Parm the soups are very good along with the Aranci's for appetizers Great workers and service

The food here is delicious! Lasagna and the sauce is so good! Kim our waitress took very good care…read moreof Alice on her 96th birthday. You can tell the food is made with love. Support local family restaurants and especially Montemaggiore Italian Restaurant .

Ordered a ham sub and 2 slices of pizza with pop…read more Delicious! The family deserves all the credit for putting out outstanding food each and every time. Very easy to order takeout and pay online.

This place is a hidden gem in Elma! We were driving by after being in East Aurora. We had the…read morebuffalo chicken pizza. The cheese was really good. "Amazing cheese pull" as my son put it! We had the crab rangoons that they advertise on their sign. Probably the best crab Rangoon's I've had! Crispy, a nice size and flavorful! It's super casual. You order at the counter. Take out available. Seating for maybe 10ish people. The staff were friendly and helpful. I highly recommend.

My friend brought the Cacio e Pepe as her favorite local pie to our pizza party, and it hit all the…read moreright notes! Salty and peppery, with that nutty, creamy flavor. She remembered to order it mid-afternoon (thankfully) because otherwise, we probably wouldn't have been able to get one close to party time. It's pretty clear why this pizzeria has such a great reputation!

This place was average for me so 3 stars it is! Wish I could do maybe 3.5. My 2 major complaints…read moreare the fact that there are no signs outside to tell you where this place is. You have to actually go inside the small vestibule area where prima oliva is to see the carpet for pizzeria Florian. I get that they are so busy that they don't need signs but I felt like it was very odd. Also the cleanliness of the floors was a bit of a turn off. Again, I understand they're really busy and just trying to seat people but if you are wiping the tables it would help to sweep the floors too. With all of that aside I actually REALLY loved the pizza! Of course I order the top choices- Calabrian crunch and the cacio e Pepe. Both were absolutely amazing, full of flavor and delicious crisp of the crust. One of the best pizzas in the area, of this style (not traditional Buffalo). The chopped salad was also good and had a great dressing that definitely tasted like a good quality balsamic vinegar. I would highly recommend both for future guests! Staff are fantastic and really work hard to get everyone's orders taken and food out as quickly as possible!

If this pizza was a college, it'd be my Elma Mater…read more You see, Buffalo pizza is unlike any other in the world... except perhaps Detroit. Homey, greasy, expertly made, incomparably good. Sure, several of the best slices may come from in or near NYC, and sure, the best deep dish pies certainly come from Chicago (but decidedly not from the national Chicagoan chains, at all). But when it comes to consistent, basic, perfect greasy Italian American pizza, nobody does it like Buffalo and Detroit. And here, yet again, we have another perfect example of WNY's greatest and most underrated delicacy... it's pizza. Even as nearby as Rochester, Syracuse, Ithaca, Toronto, Erie and Cleveland, they simply can't do it like WNY does. Elma Pizza is a pretty amazing Pizzeria and really underrated. It's thick and chunky and greasy and delicious and the person at home who loves pizza really loved it and helped me wolf it down (or Fox it down in my case). I'm surprised that it doesn't have more fans and reviews, considering how good it is, which might be because it closed down and then opened up again. In any case it's really great and you need to come out to Elma and give it a try if you want to try all the great slices of Western New York - this is definitely one of them and it's cheaper than most, with good service. While you're at it, you must also try Imperial, Bella, Mineo's, Franco's (Eggert), Mattina's, Pizza Oven/Ventry's (NF), Good Guys (NT), and more. Now I hate to be like Elma Fudd, but I have to go find me some wabbits.

In the last couple of months we've gotten pizza and wings on occasion here, the pizza has a bit of…read morea garlic taste that's great ( wish they had sweet hot peppers although) I like my pizza baked well and they do it. But the first time we ordered subs, chicken fingers and I got a stinger sub which was so delicious had had to post a comment, I don't know what happened here but keep up the fantastic food coming, If you live in the area or close try it, I think you'll be pleasantly pleased... Oh if you ask for extra crispy wings they do that too but don't keep the box closed on the way home, they will be steamed...(soggy) I only gave 4 stars because I like sweet Hot peppers and they don't have them Yet.....

Placed an order for 11 o'clock in the morning and picked up a cheesy breadstick order for my two…read moreboys. Our order came out fresh and hot, exactly the way we like it! Counter staff was extremely friendly, and had our order ready when we walked in. This is that one place that I know my kids won't turn their noses up at the pizza. Highly recommended by my panel of taste experts.

I love how much this pizzeria does for their community - hosting Girl Scout cookie booths,…read moresports/club fundraisers, etc. Very friendly staff. Top-notch service. And decent menu prices.

Was moving and I still haven't been here yet heard good things! So I ordered a sheet pizza and a…read morelarge one and a ham sub! Pizza was great plenty of cheese and pepperoni everyone asking where did I get it ! My daughter loved her sub plenty of ham and vegetables. We had to stop again couple days later to get another sub it was that good . And it didn't break the bank when I'm in the area i'll be back for the pizza again and sub and I'll have to try wings too

A go to place for food. Pizza, wings, subs, you can't go wrong. The any 3 subs & large c&p pizza…read moredeal is the best !

Pleasantly surprised. I wasn't sure what to expect as it was not crowded. The pizza was great and…read morethe employees were helpful. Pizzas came out quickly. I would go back.

Pleasantly surprised by this spot once again. I came here…read morefor a mother-daughter date with a friend; we wanted a quick bite before heading to a school play. The setup is very Panera-esque: order at the register, pour your own fountain drink, and bus your table. They do bring the food out to you, though, which is a nice touch. I ordered the Power Bowl -- a huge, vibrant salad with great texture and flavor. Definitely a lot of value for the price. My friend tried the vegan pizza on a gluten-free crust, and it was loaded with fresh vegetables. She said the dairy-free cheese was the creamiest she's ever had. If you're looking for fast, good-quality food, this is a great spot to keep on your list.

We were craving authentic NY style pizza, but live in Cleveland so we researched places a few hours…read moreaway and landed in Brooklyns Finest. A 3 hour drive and so worth it! I think we tried almost every flavor, but the standouts were the Buffalo Chicken - which I would never order but it was so incredibly good and the crust is perfection. The White Pizza with the ricotta was amazing, the Pepperoni was small and crisp and so tasty and the Margarita pizza had crushed tomatoes on it which was a first but so good. I think we got 10 slices, and ended up getting 2 more slices of the Buffalo Chicken to take home - yes we ate pizza for 3 days and so worth it lol. It heated up perfectly in the oven for 10 minutes and tasted just as good as it did at the restaurant. So worth 6 hours of driving.

Traditional NY Pizza, in all ways! In an assuming plaza, it has the nostalgic pizza place feel -…read morewith a Buffalo Bills twist. When you first enter, there is a phenomenal selection of specialty pies, and all are included in their two slice & soda special for $9. They offer both fountain sodas and a generous selection of refrigerated drink options also. Once you order, there is a back dining room with several different size tables, but all with Bills chairs, which is a neat trend we loved seeing in this area, despite being from Florida. The man who greeted us was kind helpful and I was impressed with the pizza options. We ordered: - Buffalo Chicken: had a really good flavor & was my favorite! - BBQ Chicken: my son loved it - Margerhita: also had a good flavor - Pickle: the best we've had by far - Beef Pattie: looks like a Jamaican one but isn't spicy and had a very strange almost veal or lamb taste. Overall the flavors of the pizzas were really very good, but unfortunately every slice was so overcooked and burnt that it quickly overtook the great flavor of each bite. Now, the thing is, everyone likes different kinds of pizza, and apparently Brooklyn style isn't necessarily our jam, but for something we really don't like (black crust), it was still very good and we would highly recommend it to people who like more cooked pizza.

It was Wednesday pizza night with gym girlfriends. One of my friends who lives in Alden picked up…read morethis Detroit style pie from her favorite spot, and she raved about their wings and all the fun flavors, especially the BBQ Bourbon. I really enjoyed this style of pizza. The tomatoes and cheese paired so well with the thick, chewy crust. Definitely adding this spot to my pizza bucket list!

This is your exact prototypical neighborhood pizza. You know what you're getting every time and…read morewhile it isn't the greatest, it'll never let you down. $22 for a large cheese pepperoni pie is a good price these days. Sauce was sweeter, I enjoyed it. A little too doughy, wish it were crispier underneath so it held its form and not flopped while eating it. We also ordered the spicy sausage rolls, thinking they were similar to a pepperoni roll, with a pillowy bun stuffed with sausage and peppers, instead it was an egg roll type appetizer. Not bad, but it could be refined better. $9 for 3 smaller egg rolls cut in half. Atmosphere itself seems to be strictly a takeout joint. There are tables but it's not a particularly sit down place. Staff was friendly both on the phone and in person. Always prefer to support local food, will try other items in the future.

Just Pizza is a good little addition to the Niagara Produce on Transit. Especially after you've…read morebeen shopping or looking in the garden center, sometimes you need to recharge with some food. We ordered a couple of slices and took them home since we had some groceries in the car. We ended up with some Buffalo Chicken and pepperoni slices. They were good! I enjoyed them both. Are they the best dinner I have ever had? Probably not but they are just pizza. Maybe if I had some fresh right out of the oven, I'd feel different but they were good either way. Service was fast and friendly and they looked like they were making some more fresh slices too. With this being just a little corner inside of Niagara Produce, they have a good amount of indoor and outdoor seating available too.

Ordered a fish fry from Just pIzza in Niagara Produce. Did not disappoint. Haddock, French fries, 4…read morehomemade salads ,rye bread and tartar sauce came with it. The staff was very pleasant and my fish fry was enough for two meals. Definitely will order agin.