Chicken Fingers and Fries were beyond disgusting. The grease was terribly old, the fingers burned and full of grease, the breading falling off, the fries limp and barely fried and the taste of the oil was sickening. Definitely a waste of $20 bucks. Will not be back. read more

See all

After leaving a late-night event, I had a hankering for pizza! It was 11:30 pm on a Saturday and was happy to find this place open. They had a few different styles of pizza available and they were NY style. Yum! I had trouble deciding so I grabbed a slice of cheese pizza and a slice white pizza. I enjoyed both slices. But my favorite was the white pizza for sure! There is limited seating available ... I think one booth. It's more of a takeout place. I wish it were closer to my house so I could try more items but I enjoyed my midnight snack passing thru! read more

Super impressed with how the pizza is made here! Filled with flavor and made with the perfect amount of cheese! But my true favorite dish were the wings. So well cooked, very juicy and I loved how good their BBQ sauce was. Tasted very smooth, not exaggerated with flavor like other places. Service was great and place was clean and organized! read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

That Alfredo fettuccine was nasty . So bland, sauce not seasoned, noodles flimsy , just not good at all . 0/10 couple of them weren't even cooked read more

Typical quick pizza shop. They have slices for a quick pick up. Service was nice, store was clean. Was very hot inside... they need to fix their a/c situation. They can't just expect to keep the fire open to use as a vent. The pizza was however was for a quick pick me up... it was not something to look forward to, or want to go to. This is something to pick up late at night when all else fails. It lacked flavor and there was so much grease and cheese it was almost hard to eat. Hopefully it was just the time of day we went. read more

See all

If you're seeing this, it's a sign to try their subs. After almost 8 years, I finally explored that side of the menu. I ordered a steak sub, and ho-ly shit! Mind blown! With a full sub coming in at just over $11. You can't go wrong. The flavor packed into this thing could close Jim's Steakout for good. The staff there is always great and I'm so glad they suggested this sub. See for yourself. read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - Steak and Cheese Sub With lettuce, onions, black olives, and banana peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I placed an order online through the Slice app. I realized I used the wrong form of payment and tried to change it, but Slice was unable to contact Gino's I called Gino's ,twice the girl answer the phone , said we're not excepting phone orders at this time and hung up on me both times. I wanted to cancel my order and just change the form of payment. So that was completely rude to begin with. My order was supposed to be here at one time they pushed it back. When my crappy pizza did show up, it was just like I said, crappy and cold. It taste like frozen pizza that you get from 7-Eleven except 7-Eleven pizza is actually better. The french fries are the small kind what you did not specify, and they are so stale. It's unbelievable. I will never be ordering from this place again. My whole dinner is a joke. $40 for crap !! I'm pissed read more

See all

Buffalo pizza is definitely one of a kind style pizza. Tons of dough, lot of cheese, spicy pepperoni and very heavy. This pizza is a great change of pace! I have been in Buffalo for over a decade and this is one of the few New York style pizzas that I have enjoyed. Sauce is on the sweeter side. Dough was thin, excellently cooked and traditional pepperoni. Ordered takeout online for a XL with pepperoni, two ranch add ons and the total came to about $30 which is on the expensive side for pizza in Buffalo. A very different pace for Buffalo pizza but different in a good way. Good New York style in the heart of Elmwood village, give it a shot! read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - X-Large 18" Cheese and Pepperoni with 2 Ranch - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I moved to buffalo a couple of years ago from NYC and I've searched for pizza that tasted like home and as soon as I took my first bite I almost cried...thank you so much read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Always liked the NYC style slices, tried the calzone w meatball and enjoyed it greatly

I ordered the large pizza and 10 wings combo. I choose sausage for my topping and the Gino's Secret Sauce for the wings. Both were solid . Can't quite describe the sauce flavor, but it made me think of a BBQ. The wings were good in size as well. The pizza won't be everyone's style reference but I did like it as a New York style pizza. read more

See all

I'd say 3.5. The calzone was good, the pizza and the meatballs were average nothing spectacular. read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - Food - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I think this is probably one of the best pizzas we've had in Buffalo! We ordered a Large Pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and onions and a side of fries and onion rings for pick up. The chew and texture of the dough was on spot, and the sauce was really savory. The portion of the fried and onion rings are pretty big too. Really satisfied with our order! read more

See all

I ate it way before I could take a pic bc I was hungry and this za is DANG DELICIOUS!!! I've had Ginos a few times and every time it POPS TF OFF. NY style pizza and Neapolitan are my favs and Gino's is prepping that NY style right and with that NY style price too... 2 cheese slices came to $3.60 and damn they were triangles of perfection! The crust has the French baguette taste and quality while being true to NY style thinness with tons of flavour and the floppy end. The sauce is well balanced and seasoned with tang that is not too sweet or acidic, flecks of herbs ringing through and not in an overwhelming amount (I don't like a lot of sauce so this is perfect) The cheese is the ringer, thick and melty with a pull that will go the distance from the slice to your mouth. It's a SOLID quality cheese blend too, not to greasy and incredibly flavourful. Oh Gino's I will return again and again to your glorious little piece of the world that brings NY style pizza to buffalo. Get the cheese slice ppl! read more

Loved it! Fast service and great tasting pizza! I highly recommend this place if your looking for a New York style pizza read more

The wings with Gino's sauce were so delicious! Service great and fast! Ambiance calm and relaxing! Best wing place I've had here!! read more

Little dicey pizza shop in what used to be somebody's house. Looks like they ripped out the living space, left the breakfast nook and made everything else kitchen. Couple tables inside and a couple tables on the sidewalk. Pizzas on display in the case, pick what you want and get it re-blasted to eating temperature in 3.5 minutes. Grab a couple sodas with that and relax out front. My deep dish buffalo wing slice was quite interesting with a real blue cheesey base, white cheese top and plenty of hot orange saucey chicken in between. MLB nods approvingly to the cheese... "not sure what temperature is but it's the right temperature for eating. Oily but not too oily, tip it away so you don't mess yourself." Kudos for using real garlics on the knots, they'd be fine for anyone who uses normal portions. read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - Well, yeah... - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Completely satisfied. One of the best pizza places in buffalo. True to NYC. You must try.

Gino works a diner all day. I hope it supplements his income well because his late night pizza place isn't particularly spectacular. This is pretty good pizza and in most cities it might be one of the best in the city. Unfortunately for them they exist in Buffalo New York so there are at least fifty-seven pizzerias with more amazing slices than here. However it is right in the middle of the Elmwood hipster college party District close to Buffalo State, and its open super late at night, so they get more business than 54 of the 57 afro mentioned better slices in town. It's pretty good and I get four stars All Things Considered. A lot of Buffalo Yelpers say this is one of the best slices in the region. That's because they haven't tried 95% of the slices in the region. I have. So yeah. read more

See all

I've always been a fan of Gino and Joes and I've always drove by this place and wanted to try it. This couldn't have been any further from the pizza I got at Gino's or any NY style pizza. There was about 3 lbs of low quality oily cheese and if zoom in you can tell by the way the pepperonis were just dropped on this pizza that no one cared about quality at this place. It tasted like cheap cafeteria pizza. read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Delivery driver left my food outside without a call. Manager was rude when i called about it.

Easily my favorite slice of pizza spot in Buffalo. While I'm a firm believer of there could be more pizza places throughout the Elmwood and Allen area, the selections we do have help to give a slice to everyone's personal preference. While I never truly cared for "NY style" pizza, Gino's has helped to shift my perception on this. The location is super convenient. It's perfectly located on Elmwood and the Bidwell area which is prime for a ton of foot traffic. The location itself is compact. It's not the greatest place for eating-in but they do give you a few additional seats outside the place. Again, it's compact so the inside seating tends to heat up with you sitting so close to the kitchen area - especially in the winter when the the main door is not constantly opening back and forth. Ironically, my favorite slice is the deep dish buffalo chicken. Much different than the thinner NY style slices they have. They do offer tons of different styles for you to choose so there's no lack of variety there for you picky eaters. My only qualm is the pricing is a bit higher than the other local pizza places. Nonetheless, I'll always choose Gino's over the rest of them simply due to their abundance of styles of pizza and being flat out great pizza. read more

Myself and my friend had lunch there today, the food portion is enormous, and tasted as good as it looked.. Christine there was sooo awesome, great personality, and very welcoming, hard worker, sweet girl..never caught her co workers name , but ue was gooood looooking eye candy for all you ladies out there, lol.. great experience, great food, and super friendly.. highly recommend trying them out..have a wonderful day everyone Mariann C read more

Gino's slices don't bring me back to NYC, but they're decent. They deliver to my apartment, have online ordering right on their own website, plus our delivery arrived early. At least on the Greek pizza, the crust isn't quite right if it's supposed to be NYC-style. The end crust is too thin and crisp, and the crust under the toppings is a little too thick. The Greek pizza has a ton of toppings, though, so maybe they make the crust thicker so it doesn't get soggy from all the veggies. I'll have to try another pizza with fewer toppings at some point to see if the crust thickness is better. The husband appreciates that honey mustard is a sauce choice for Gino's chicken fingers, though we're not sure why getting sauce on the side instead of on the fingers warrants an extra 50-cent charge. No complaints about the mozzarella sticks, though I can't say I've ever met a mozzarella stick I didn't like. read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - Greek pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This is what I got on the weekend of my wedding anniversary. We tried calling and no one answered. Tried calling again and no one answered. I typically LOVE Ginos but this was DISGUSTING. Still haven't gotten my money back and my dog wouldn't even eat this read more

Gino's is the best "New York style" pizza in Buffalo and has the BEST chicken fingers around! (they are huge and crispy) If you're from NYC, or have a favorite NYC pizza place, this won't be the best pizza you've ever had, but it is NY style thin crust and still very tasty. If you order a full pie vs. by the slice I recommend you ask them to make the crust crispy. Don't forget the fingers! read more

We may have waited 45 minutes for some pizza, but it was delish! DO NOT GO THROUGH GRUB HUB! We had such issues, but ended up just picking up and was great. I am used to NYC pizza and would recommend Ginos :) read more

We had the white tomato and onion pizza and it was delicious, we also had a side of french fries but they were really greasy and soggy. Not crunchy at all no season no nothing on them.. i've been here a few times and it's great service and you can get slices to go really quick. I took a star away just because of the fries I would not order them again. read more

Great pizza, great staff working there! Absolutely recommend stopping in! ! ! Stopped in on during a business trip and so glad that I did

If "NY style" is your thing, then this is a solid option. But the slices aren't as big as typical NY style I've had in NYC. It's not getting a low rating from me bc it sucks, it's just not the style i like. Give me that thicker crust with cup n char pepperoni, Buffalo Style for me please! At the end of the day, Gino's just didn't win me over to the NY Style of pizza, but I'd that's what you're looking for then i don't think you'll be disappointed read more

I'm completely obsessed with this pizza... I'm almost (just almost) sad that it's so close to home, because I've gotten it three times since discovering it last month. This is definitely a far cry from the ultra-doughy Buffalo pie with its grease-filled pepperoni cups () and I could not be happier. I love nice thin, chewy crust underneath that puffs out around the edges. Honestly, I haven't had any better pizza in the Buffalo area than Gino's. And the prices aren't bad either! I recently paid $35 for a house (XL) pie and 20 wings. That size pizza typically comes cut in 8 huge slices but the guy I placed the order with offered to cut it in 16, which was such a good call, and it was the perfect amount of food for 4 very hungry adults and two kids. The wings are good too, although certainly not the best around. read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - Pizza by the slice... huge slices and very reasonable prices. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I have been ordering BBQ chicken pizza for years from the Gino's in the Main Place Mall. I figured it would be the same food as they are affiliated with each other. I was wrong. Instead of delicious chicken fingers, they use the over-processed, mechanically-separated, added flavorings type of chicken. It's absolutely disgusting. The meat tastes fake. I'm so mad I spent 30 bucks on a pizza that will now sit in my fridge until I toss it. Buyer beware......don't order chicken pizza. read more

Love this place! Light sauce and heavy cheese, just the way I like it. The wings were super flavorful (got special sauce) and we loved that they offer RANCH (were from chicago)! Pizza crust was great, and the wings were super saucy. read more

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Best New York Style Pizza in town! The sauce is delicious and it's always fresh. The Garlic knots are always baked to perfection

Great crust. Good sauce. Mozzarella could be stringier but generally a superior pizza.

I ordered the deep dish pizza Buffalo Chicken pizza. It was ok but felt like just a thin layer of chicken and cheese over thick dough. If anything it was more dough that I was eating, the ingredients did taste good though. For me Gino's is too inconsistent, it's either doughy pizza or flubbery wings from them. read more

Ordered a large pie (half mushrooms and banana peppers and half pepperoni and onion) 10 wings and mozz sticks. The mozz sticks were great, just the way I like em. Nice seasoned batter and gooey in the middle with just a hint of grease. Sooo good. The wings were a lil soggy but the flavor for medium was there. If they were crispier they would have been much better. The pizza was forgettable. The crust was the best part. Was a bit surprised to see red onion used instead of white onion, a little too potent for my tastes. If you've never tried it here give it a shot though, maybe you'll like it. read more

My friend and I were visiting from out of town and we were within walking distance of this establishment. We loved it so much that we ate there two nights in a row... Awesome pizza! The garlic parmesan wings were good too. The staff was very friendly and welcoming to us. read more

The wife and I ventured out into the "blizzard" tonight in search of some good pizza. I mean, nothing pacifies the soul quite like a good pie during a famous buffalo snowstorm. The pizza was coming right out of the oven as we walked in. We ordered a large cheese and pep, half mushroom and the other half with banana peppers. It was absolutely delicious. Unlike most other buffalo pizzerias, Gino's pizza isn't a big ball of dough with gallons of grease dripping off of it. The dough was thin, crust had a nice crunch to it, the sauce was light and it was cooked to perfection. The only complaint I have is the fact that it took us two years to find out about Gino's. Looking forward to trying the wings next visit! read more

-the pizza was horrible. The sauce was watered down and it tasted like it was sitting for quite a while -the wings were undercooked -the garlic knots were passable but quite chewy If I liked 1/3 item I might have given this place a second chance but I will be passing on Gino's. read more