the food was phenomenal; not pretentious, just solidly good start to finish…read more I highly recommend Rich as your server; yaknow how people only notice when they get bad service? well he was kind of great at not just providing a good dining experience, but kind of... predicting what we needed before we knew it ourselves; and also doing it with ease and putting us at peace. (Not easy since we all showed up in a bad mood :))

The food here was outstanding. Service was friendly. There is limited seating, so we did have to…read morewait, but the food was worth it!

First off, the sausage bacon pepperoni pizza is amazing! And it's BTS(by the slice, not Korean boy…read moreband!) The bread on the sub is good- does the job. The cheesesteak filling is great- a nice portion! Wings are a great deal on Mondays (not sure if it continues in summer season) but are still a good deal any time of the week. I believe you get 13 wings for 15 bucks; That's pretty darn good. For me, though, although the buffalo flavoring, which is a good flavoring, It isnt as buffalo-y as I've had. Vinegar? Spice? Not sure. But it still really deserves a try! Overall- great happy people, a very good restaurant... and it's a very good value for the beach. Strongly recommend.

We did delivery so can't speak to ambiance . Really good pizza . everyone liked it (big age range…read moreand pickiness range in our house ) wings were solid , sauce was tasty and crust was perfect

I've been a fan of Nicola for years. I miss them at the beach, but this location is large and…read morecomfortable, with plenty of indoor and outdoor seating and ample parking. I've always enjoyed a salad and either pizza or a Nicoboli when I come here. Today, I tried the "heart healthy" fare, including a tossed salad, a mini pizza (fat free dough and no cheese) and Nicoboli (fat free dough, no cheese with veggies snd sweet peppers. Honestly, I didn't know what to expect. But I can say that the no-fat versions of the pizza and Nicoboli were both tasty and satisfying. The dough for both items was cooked perfectly, with a nice crunch and the pizza had a good amount of veggies and sauce. The Nicoboli was larger than I thought, with veggies and sweet peppers. (I might ask for a tiny amount of cheese in the Boli next time. It was good, but a little cheese inside would help hold the ingredients together. Once we cut the Boli in half and bit it, the veggies started pouring out.) I'm pleased there are a number of items on the menu for dietary concerns, including fats and cheese, which are accommodated here. I thought my time at pizza places might be over, or, at least, awkward (pulling cheese off from a slice, eating half a slice), but this is great news. The salad (shared between two people) was ample as a side salad and was fresh. The service was good.

I've only eaten here a few times, but I think it's pretty decent food! I have gotten takeout with…read moresome family and we all seemed to agree that the cheese is very thick and rubbery. I haven't gotten their regular pizzas yet, but the Pepperoni Pizza Bites are very good! One of my family members also LOVES their Fried Zucchini Bites! However I think the ranch would be better if it wasn't Hidden Valley ranch and it was restaurant made. I would give it five stars, but, make the ranch restaurant made, make the cheese less rubbery, and it'd be great and worth a 5 star review! I recommend going here if you and your family love pizza and want to eat out!

I liked Mr. P's. You go to the beach, you're hungry and you want a pizza. It's a solid choice…read more Pizza is wood fired and thicker... but good. I'm more a NY style pizza fan, but it was good. Casual. Good service. It is cash only, but they do have an ATM onsite. Definitely worth checking it out.

We've lived all over and have been so disappointed in both the food scene and specifically pizza…read morehere in DE. BUT Mr. P's was great. We decided to finally drive over and try it after an appointment in the area. I'm Gluten Free not by choice and even ordered a second pie to take home! I was really impressed with them immediately asking "Allergy or Preference", it seems like a small detail to others but truly isn't. We'll definitely be back and hope that the quality is still as good. We went mid-afternoon on a weekday and service was great as far as we were concerned.

Went recently, in the off season, when they offered a 25% off the total check special…read more Walking in sat with friends in a booth. Bar and restaurant have a comfortable homey local hangout vibe. Started my visit with a Maker's peach crush cocktail, which consisted of Maker's bourbon, triple sec, peach puree and sprite. Completely refreshing. Dined on the sweet dreams wood fire pizza, a ny style thin crust, (mmmm), topped with only cheeses, mozzarella pecorino, fontina, Parmesan, sharp provolone, ricotta, fresh garlic and thyme. One of the best white pizzas I ever had. Wood fire makes for a deliciously crispy crust. This delicious pizza was enjoyed with a flight of local lagers, and pilsners. Service was very expeditious and friendly. This place would have been a winner even if there wasn't a 25% off offer.

Delicious pizza and love their beet salad. Definitely have a variety of beers to try…read more Very smartly, decor, and very clean. Would definitely suggest trying.

I updated the hours in yelp since I think it was reflecting winter or spring hours...they're open…read morefor lunch on Saturday! When we arrived a few minutes after noon, we were the only patrons. We ordered the eggplant stack and a carbonara "sorta" pizza. The eggplant stack was like a deconstructed eggplant parmesan . The eggplant was perfectly fried and the ricotta mix in between the fried eggplant was flavorful. I would return for this alone! And yet when they brought out the pizza, I was mesmerized. I've never eaten peas on a pizza before and this was just divine! Cheesy pizza with slices of ham, dollops of more of the delicious flavored ricotta on top. WOW. Vibe was cool. Red checked table cloth and those big ol' plastic cups à la my favorite pizza joint from when I was a kid in NJ. Lots of Dalmatian art inside.

Some of the best pizza I've had. The kitchen was having some mechanical issues but the staff was…read morevery gracious and gave our kids lots of crayons to keep them busy. Despite the issues we got our pizza within 15 minutes. Amazing crispy crust.

It looks like this spot recently got renovated. We went in today for lunch and it was huge and…read moreclean! We had the sweetest server ever. It was so refreshing to have a more mature server who was just so genuine and attentive. The pizza was fantastic. I've been eating Grottos since I was a kid and I've definitely had some pies that were better than others. This location nailed it!

I am upping this to a 4 because we finally ate inside. My daughter still really likes this pizza,…read moreespecially the barbecue chicken pizza. We all really enjoyed the fried zucchini. I really liked the Verdi boli. The service was fine. The place is clean enough. If you're looking to watch some sports, it's good to have the TVs in the background, but if you're not, it could be distracting.

Focaccia blew my mind!…read more Pizza was really good. Pasta was to die for. Oh and then strolling out the door - why yes I will take some amazing cookies and a piece of cheesecake to go!

So sad! when this place opened a few years ago it was fantastic addition to the very good…read morerestaurants lining Second Street. Quite authentic southern Italian cooking & (my test) their fantastic Sfogliotelli (oh well, spell check-those flaky clamshell pastries filled with custard). We are bi-yearly visitors & make sure we have at least one meal there. Last year's was quite good. But yesterday for our last lunch before we left town, we ordered takeaway subs that were a complete disaster. Wow. Chewy, tasteless hero-loaf bread filled with dissicated (seriously--that is the word--dry & tasteless Eggplant parmesan & another with a skimpy portion of mozzarella , tomato & pesto. That and two small ice teas--cost $39. I ate about half of a half of the eggplant sub. If it had not been so hot, I might have walked back & asked for a refund. Anyway--our friends said they had a decent dinner there the other night, so maybe it's the takeout that's the issue. Great wine selection & my guess is the pastries are still good-- & other 'Italian' products that are nice to be able to buy--.