Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fadely’s Tavern

    2.5 (2 reviews)
    Open 9:00 am - 3:00 AM (Next day)

    Fadely’s Tavern Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fadely’s Tavern

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 276 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Iron Kettle - Sausage and kraut special. Delish

    Iron Kettle

    4.5(19 reviews)
    5.9 mi
    $

    What an amazing gem! I was fortunate enough to visit with family who are local to the area and know…read moresome of the staff and management. But every customer I saw here was treated like family! Most importantly - I had the best pork tenderloin sandwich I've ever had in my life. Having moved from Indiana to Michigan 22 years ago - I can't find a decent one and have resorted to making my own. Although I'm doing a decent job - this is a "next-level" sandwich. My party also ordered a burger, some country fried steak, a breakfast combo - everything was fantastic. My kids, myself, and my wife keep mentioning this meal even a couple months later. I rarely say this - but to me, Iron Kettle is a destination dining location - worth driving half an hour out of your way just to give it a try. The service was fantastic, the atmosphere "casual diner" but comfortable, and the food exceeded my expectations by far. I am already planning a visit back to the area. Not just to see family, but also to see my new friends at Iron Kettle again and sample more of their menu!

    Girlfriend.....you will love everything! chicken and…read moredumplings are stellar. Melinda is amazing and all of her girls there are great. 765-533-4744....call it and ask for specials amazing tenderloin you just can't find food and attitude like this anywhere! Carol-Ann Caine

    Photos
    Iron Kettle - Always a cheery homey atmosphere to enjoy your homemade meal.

    Always a cheery homey atmosphere to enjoy your homemade meal.

    Iron Kettle - Excellent breakfast made as per my request- well done fried potatoes! Eggs, bacon, biscuits & gravy with coffee in a cup & saucer.

    Excellent breakfast made as per my request- well done fried potatoes! Eggs, bacon, biscuits & gravy with coffee in a cup & saucer.

    Iron Kettle - The beef and noodles were so warm and comforting.

    See all

    The beef and noodles were so warm and comforting.

    The Grill A - Big, thick, juicy, and crunchy the tenderloin was absolutely delicious

    The Grill A

    4.9(23 reviews)
    6.8 mi

    They have the best tenderloin in the state, hands down. The fries are amazing too. Everyone I know…read moresays the same thing about this place. It's a gem and worth the roadtrip. Seating is somewhat limited but they are exapnding. They are also known for their pizza and burgers although I've heard everything is great. I have had the tenderloin twice now and it's consistently perfect.

    Grill-A Grill only opened in 2024 and is one of the top contenders for best hand-breaded…read moretenderloins in Indiana. Indeed, the tiny restaurant on Main Street in Markleville (population 484) is filled most evenings and weekend lunch with guests anxious for the hand breaded sandwiches, hand cut fries, burgers, wings and more. The owner, Doug, began restoring the historic building in 2019. Now he is working to add dining space upstairs for another 15 tables to help accommodate the demand. I was steered to the restaurant by a fellow Yelper from Virginia. I did not hesitate to make the 90 mile round trip drive for lunch. The dining room is small with a couple cloth covered tables and a bar seating. Soft country music fills the room and a gorilla hangs from the ceiling. The tenderloin is incredibly tender, fresh, juicy and hot with a perfectly seasoned breading. I ordered the regular size tenderloin, Doug also serves a larger version that is about a pound of meat. And don't skip the fries - hand cut and crisp. The fries are 5 star too. The service is impeccable, the kind of small town service that makes you feel special. We loved hearing Doug's story. There is street parking on the side of the building. They do a robust carry-out business, as well. They are not currently serving alcohol. They are not opened mid week for lunch- check the hours. It's worth the drive, even from out of state. So good!

    Photos
    The Grill A - Ordering at the bar

    Ordering at the bar

    The Grill A - Grill-A Wings

    Grill-A Wings

    The Grill A

    See all

    Montana Mike's Steakhouse

    Montana Mike's Steakhouse

    3.7(137 reviews)
    6.3 mi
    $$

    Rustic charm of the exterior and mis-identification of this as another chain of steakhouses drew me…read morein. I will not be back, even though I am in town once per year. When I tried order off the menu to see if I could get a trout and steak combo, my server tried very hard to make this happen, but gave up. She could have asked a manager, but it was not important enough for me to pursue the matter. But, she was very sweet and was very helprul the rest of the time. Pittsburgh Rare steak preparation involves charring the exterior on a very hot flat-top and serving it rare. What I got was not this, as I could immediately tell by the fact that it had noticeable grill marks. They just cooked as usual for a rare order. With a NY Strip steak, you expect some connective tissue, but not this much. It was hidden also in the muscle of the steak. I had trouble hiding all the half chewed offal on my plate. Neither did it have a great beef flavor. This summary from the internet agrees with my idea of rice pilaf, "Pilaf is a rice dish where grains are toasted in oil or butter with aromatics like onion and garlic before being simmered in seasoned broth, resulting in fluffy, separate grains." What I was served was nothing like this as I got buttered rice that clumped together. No effort was employed in plating for appearance. I got a steak on a plate and a silver colored boat on which the rice was piled. The Cole slaw served as a salad was very good. The beer was cold and as expected.

    We had dinner here last night and the food and service was great. We got the hand breaded tenders…read morewith a salad and sweet potato, a pulled pork sandwich which they make the bbq sauce and it was delicious. Their fries are thicker with some crunchy breading and they were okay to me but everyone else at the table loved them. We got a bacon mushroom Swiss burger and it was delicious. They do have a rewards program so be sure to signup for that.

    Photos
    Montana Mike's Steakhouse
    Montana Mike's Steakhouse
    Montana Mike's Steakhouse

    See all

    Fadely’s Tavern - tradamerican - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...