Sorry, but I have no idea who could be reviewing this place! My daughter got breakfast food. Literally the scrambled eggs had a slice of cheese from a package layed on top, the bacon crunchy and zero flavor. The ribs my granddaughter got taste like mothballs and vinegar. Never to return. I will say the waitress was top tier, sweet young lady and very attentive. Oh, my daughter say her oatmeal was good. Again, never to return. read more

staff was quick and friendly great service. sides and pie was really good. I got the 14 oz steak. It was my first time visiting. I thought it was a poor cut of meat, poorly seasoned, and I could taste the burnt grill marks even tho it was more rear than the medium I asked for and it cost 30$. Ill definitely eat here again, ill just try the other home cooked stuff on the menu. it's not a steak house read more

Great home cooked food, menu has huge variety & breakfast is served all day. Very fast service whether you're dining alone or in a group of 20. Fun, friendly, attentive staff. prices can seem a little high for some things until you see the sheer magnitude of food in a single order, almost everyone has leftovers to take home. Warm, welcoming family atmosphere. Intriguing deco from the past. Very spacious and not crowded at their busiest. A terrific place to meet up with family, friends, coworkers, & future prospects.One of favorite places to eat. read more

This place has the best food in town!!! The wattriess s are so nice and me and my husband eat there about 2 times a week...home-cooked food and always clean!!!! read more

We went on the rib special day and they were the ! Fall of the bone tender. Very tasty. The only thing I would comment is they were a little bit on the salty side. Great portions. Service was top notch too! Highly recommend and we will be back. read more

During covid, the area is plenty spaced to allow for social distancing and the facility is very clean. The menu is vast and they have weekly special. I was so pleased to see chocolate gravy, I had not had it since I was a child from my grandmother. Their gravy did not disappoint. However, the biscuits were mediocre. You can tell it was a big pan of biscuits made on a cookie sheet and cut- was not a fan of the flavor or texture. I tried part of the omelette my partner was eating, and it was great. The bacon was cooked to crisp as I asked. The waitress was attentive and pricing fair. Great choice for families, plenty of large table and seating. read more

Historic Park Restaurant - American Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

First off, don't be fooled when you drive up and it's at the end of a strip mall. It's name makes you think you are going to a little historical building. It's not...but don't fret. Four of us stopped in for a late lunch/early dinner. Our waitress, Kim, was happy and friendly. We discussed the Beef Manhattan but all opted for sandwiches - but looked wonderful as it was delivered to nearby patrons. The Reuben sandwich was very good - tender cornbeef and the sauerkraut was drained properly so the marbled rye bread was not soggy. The only thing that would cause it to get a '9' would have been I like it toasted a tad more. One order a simple grilled cheese and for his side got the green beans - which were a '10' because they were seasoned perfectly with bacon onions and soft like they been cooked for a good long time. The onion rings were soooo good! A '10' - lightly beer battered and good greasy - perfectly cooked! The other couple decided on the Pork Tenderloin sandwich. They split it because it comes with two buns! Yes, it's that big. They opted for the side of home fries - similar to cottage fries. It lacked nothing. For dessert it was true homemade pies. Butterscotch was NOT pudding! It was cooked custard-type. Very good. The peanut butter pie was not this diner's favorite dessert but looked scrumptious. Now the blackberry cobbler - let's just say - there wasn't a crumb left. It's about 4 miles off the interstate but we'll worth the extra few minutes! read more

This is one of the most popular restaurants in New Castle. It is always busy and for a good reason. The food is always fresh and always good. They have a very extensive menu and many different options to choose from. I did notice that some items have been taken off the menu since Covid hit. This is most likely a cost saving strategy. I have not had anything that I would not get again. The staff are always busy, but at the same time they are very nice. Everything that I have tried on the menu I have enjoyed. The one downfall has recently been the price increases on the menu items. Of course, this is not necessarily their fault because the cost of everything has gone up. On Friday's, they have all you can eat fried chicken or fried fish. They are both very good. I have gotten both of them many different times. I also really like their breakfast items even though I am not a big breakfast fan. Even though I've never gotten the pancakes myself, my spouse gets them almost every time they are humongous and you get a gigantic portion. I am more of a biscuits and gravy person, so that is what I typically get. One of my absolute favorite things to get from here is actually the grilled chicken Cobb salad. The salad is so big that you cannot finish it in one meal. Unfortunately, like I have said, I know longer get this because of the cost. It is almost $15-$16 for the salad. Even though the salad is wonderful, I just cannot think of spending that price on a salad, which I could make it home for 1/3 of the price. I do highly recommend the ranch dressing if you are a ranch dressing enthusiast like I am I really enjoy dipping my fries in the ranch. Again, I would highly recommend giving this place a try because of the great atmosphere and the amazing food. I know I will personally be back many more times as there are more things that I would like to try that I have not got to try yet. read more

We went back for ribs. The food was good what there was of it. A half rack of ribs is between 6 to 7 ribs depending on the size of the ribs. Today I ordered a half rack and received 4 ribs. When I mentioned it to the waitress she said that the owner had cut do on portions. With the meal was suppose to come with 2 sides. So I ordered 2 side salads just like we always did. I was charged .49 extra for both salads and another $1.00 for an extra plate. So much for the 2 sides with the meal. The waitress never refilled our drinks while we ate. Never even asked if we wanted more drinks. Not a good idea. We have came here for several years for their baby back ribs. And usually received at least 6 ribs. I may have to find another place for my ribs. Sad situation when we have to deal with this type of service during a "plandemic". read more

Wife and I had a great time here! Food was OUTSTANDING as well as the service (as for Tonya). I had Brisket and ribs with a side onion rings and zesty cucumber salad; all way fabulous, high quality and very tasty. Wife and steak sandwich and was very impressed! Bread was fresh and the steak was juicy and tasty. Special not the location is miss marked on Yelp, it almost a crossed the street from Mc Ds. read more

Historic Park Restaurant - Restaurant interior - American Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

See all

First visit was disgusting!!! The waitress we had took 20 min to ask about drinks, then took 15 min to bring them to us! Then just walked away! It went on and we complained! One of us got our meal comped, one complained about cold meal and they did nothing for her! Well, I gave it a second chance, that waitress was not there, nor that manager! Food came pretty fast, was hot and cooked very well! Now I will recommend them to my friends!! read more

This was a delicious lunch stop in a small town. My wife had the chicken dinner special and I had the beef manhattan. Both came with potatoes and gravy and we both choose green beans for the side. This was home style cooking and we were so happy with everything. We ended with rhubarb/strawberry pie, and raspberry cobbler. Both were amazing. Friendly staff. restrooms, inside dining and carry out. Private parking lot. Don't pass this place up. read more

See all

This place is a gold mine! Very moderately priced and huge portions of fresh food! They are customer-focused and deliver a fantastic food and atmosphere. Highly recommend!!! read more

Historic Park Restaurant - Fried chicken, mashed potatoes and the best gravy I've had in a long, long time. And the best cole slaw out there, (not pictured.) - American Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

The food is great, plentiful, and well worth your dollar! Most of the wait staff are excellent, For now they are looking at keeping everyone happy! read more

Consistent good food and great service. Good home cooking with great specials. Best Patty Melt! Great Wall decor.

When we arrived it was busy with noon diners. The waitresses were hustling and friendly. Once the order was taken, it didn't take long before our food was prepared. Good food for sure. Good hometown type of restaurant. read more

Fall off the bone ribs, smoked to perfection, oh & Brisket. Best all you can eat fried chicken or fish around. Also try the Rueben sandwich, vegetable beef soup, Beef Manhattan, or the Classic club sandwich. Just a start of my favorites. read more

See all

Yum! Awesome menu and everything I've ever ordered has been great! Highly recommend it!

Excellent food- lots of choices on the extensive menu. Always busy. The plates are full of heaping portions and they are great price. The fried chicken was amazing! Good service. Good place to eat as we stepped away from camping on a rainy weekend at Summit Lake. Just a few miles away and a box of leftovers for lunch tomorrow! read more

love this place. food is always great!!and the portions are huge!you can order anything and be happy. if not they will make it right ...but never had to do that. oh almost forgot...the staff and i only say staff because all the staff are on it...really great place to get great food and service.. . read more

Oh how I have waited for this moment to finally review restaurants locally and Park Restaurant is at the top of my list. I started coming here when it was half the size it is now and they were still getting their footing in this small town. I have brought friends, family, children and even just myself at times so I can speak freely when I say this is one of the best restaurants in New Castle Indiana. Have you ever arrived in a restaurant and looked around at the drab deco or the wait staff that has disdain written all over their face and demeanor plus the food potentially coming out either to processed or over flavored? Not here you will not at least in my personal opinion and I can say between the 30 + people I brought here with me over the years we have tried every item offered either by menu or by daily specials. The Chicken club melt is humongous , tasty and one of my top favorites. DISCLAIMER: If you attempt the whole sandwich be prepared to having an extremely full stomach. To sum it up I HIGHLY recommend coming here any day or time they are open. read more

What a huge disappointment.We were looking forward to a supposedly home cooked meal. I questioned our waitress on the cube steak BUT she failed to tell me that they also serve it for Pot Roast, covered with fat and gravy. Who uses brown gravy on Cube Steak? The mashed potatoes were good and the next day I discovered it was because several tablespoons of margarine had coagulated on the left overs read more

Historic Park Restaurant - So called Cube Steak - American Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

See all

Place is the dopest spot of all eternity dont @me. Get the mush, blueberry pancakes and sausage. But before you do, remember your life as it was up to that point bc it's going to CHANGE your life. And you're welcome. read more

We stopped for breakfast on our way out of Indy toward the East Coast on I-70. It seems to be very popular with locals, who were welcomed like family. We noticed many people didn't even need menus. The staff was very friendly with everyone, including out-of-towners like us. The entrance is a little strange. You enter through a door on the side of the building not the front. Once inside you are surrounded by Americana/country decor on all of the walls. Seating was all tables, mostly 4-tops. The chairs were comfortable. They do have a limited menu, but all the food we had was done very well. The sausage patty was excellent. It was a generous size and had great seasoning. The pancakes were fluffy, but the syrup was Smuckers pre-packaged tubs. The scrambled eggs were just ok. The fried potatoes were recommended and we're ok, but lacked seasoning. We thought the hash browns were as good if not better. The Cowboy Omelette was very good. All the ingredients were chopped small enough to enjoy them all in each bite. The biscuits and gravy were great. Fluffy biscuits and a generous amount of gravy that wasn't skimpy on the sausage pieces. All of this for very good prices. It's a good thing we don't live closer. We already eat out too much. read more

See all

This place is amazing. Great food and the most amazing desert. You have to visit this place no matter what. Yummy.

My favorite in town. Food is homestyle diner with portions to fill at affordable prices. Staff is attentive and fast. Surprising place for one of the best, most tender rib eyes I've had outside a prime steakhouse (consistantly). Daily specials to keep the mix going, and Fridays have all-you-can-eat chicken and fish options. Wednesdays, Cecil will make you a burrito spicy enough to think you're no longer in Indiana. I've never been to a better restaurant in this category. read more

Always have the best food and friendly staff! If you are going through New Castle and are looking for a home cooked meal, definitely the place to stop! read more

What a hidden gem. Never new this place existed. Comfort food at its best. I had the pork chops with mashed potatos with gravy and green beans and sweet roll..Oh my, the pork chops were delicious, dont know what the seasoning was but yum. The service was great, the pricing was reasonable. The atmosphere is casual diner style. We will definitely be back. Im ready to try the pan fried chicken on my next trip. read more

All in all my first visit to the Park Restaurant was a good one. My mother had the Beef Manhattan and said the beef was very tender and lean and the gravy was quite tasty. My dad had the rib special and he said the meat was fall off the bone tender. I feasted on their Famous Tenderloin and it was nicely breaded, very tender and HUGE! I also really enjoyed my tater tots as a side because they were nice and crisp. The only real negative was the frigid air that chilled the place every time the door was opened by guest. The place has high ceilings with metal and tiled floors abd with the constant outside air it was very cold for a comfortable dining experience. I know this is their first winter so I am sure they will address the cold air. I would give the Park a thumbs up for good homestyle cooking. read more

When parks first came, I hated it. Didn't taste good to me. But now that I've been back it's amazing. Good food, okay prices, and big portions. read more

Large portions, fast and friendly service! My personal favorite is the patty melt and an order of onion rings. Their onion rings come in one size - BIG! And they are delicious. The breading is a bit flaky with just the right amount of seasoning. Make sure to get an order for the table to share! The patty melt is a perfect flat top burger with awesome flavor. I tried the club sandwich on my last trip and it was also huge. The meat and cheese portions were very generous and it tasted great. The menu has enough variety and quality anyone can find something to like here. read more

Historic Park Restaurant - Classic Club and Onion Rings - American Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

Amazing food and service! Prices are fair and the atmosphere is laid back and easy. It is a wonderful place for parties or a simple date night. The staff are friendly and caring. If you go ask for Heather, ok you don't have to, she's my wife so I had to say it lol read more

Best place in town for good homemade food. You get a ton of food for the price. Their pies are delicious as well.

Stopped on a Sunday as we traveled east toward Ohio. Small chef salad was huge!! Hamburger plate was also good! Lots of pie choices although we were too full to try any! Very busy but we only waited a short while for a table. Jo was our waitress and she was very friendly and efficient. Very good lunch stop! read more

I am giving this a two, but honestly, I am being generous I think. I had the special for Thurs which is the slab of ribs. I ate them because I was being taken out for my birthday and I wanted to be polite to my host. They were short ribs to begin with so deceiving for the price and description. I would be okay with that if they were good, but they are not. They do not see a grill or smoker it is obvious by the appearance and the falling off the bone texture. I would say they are boiled or cooked in a crock pot with sauce poured on before serving. You can also tell they do not anticipate the good grilled bone chewing diners since they do not serve wet naps, or a cloth with warm water to get off the sauce after you eat your ribs. The crockpot style cooking method makes for easy fork consumption. I also got a vinegar aroma with the sauce, yet it was not good like the southern yellow barbeque sauce that uses mustard and vinegar as a base which I do like. It was a red sauce with a hint of vinegar on the nose which was not appetizing. I did have some very tasty fried potatoes as a side. However, the girl that helped my server drop our food was wearing a black stringy bracelet. As she reached across my plate to serve the person sitting next to me her stringy, ratty bracelet drug across my fried potatoes. I would have said something to my server if I had been by myself and not a guest. To not offend my host, I discreetly pushed the top layer off, and tried to eat some that were on the portion of the pIle her bracelet did not drag over. First of all, she should have not reached over, but instead walked to the to the other side of the table to serve from behind right shoulder for proper serving etiquette, or at least used that side of the table. Secondly, stringy bracelets should not be worn as a proactive policy to make sure oF sanitary conditions. Our actual server was friendly and the overall experience with speed and accuracy were all good. I think management needs to address serving attire and board of health standards for starters. Secondly, if you are going to put a regular specIal on the menu I would invest in the best cooking method equipment or specify on the menu the cooking method to avoid disappointment to the customer that is not familiar with the restaurant. I am sure since New Castle has very few dining options they think they are safe in retaining diners no matter the quality or conditions. I would think if they strove for great service and quality they could draw from miles around. This diner will be in no hurry to ever return I can tell you which is too bad. I love mom and pops when you leave wanting more no matter how simple the meal because it is really good and reminds you of grandmas cooking. read more

Wow. If you are looking for a good breakfast spot in New Castle, look no further. Great biscuits and gravy! And the cowboy omelet was scrumdeliicious! read more

I love this place! Service was fast. Plenty of food. Delicious! Thank you for serving this town.

This is our favorite restaurant. Employees are wonderful and welcoming, but the food is AMAZING!! Everything I've had is so delicious. Our favorites are the Ruben, grilled chicken salad, burgers and the onion rings and fried pickles! Everything is wonderful. I highly recommended!. read more

This is the best American homemade style food I've ever had at a restaurant. Biscuits and gravy, hand-battered onion rings and chicken, beef manhattan, homemade pies. Everything we've ever had is delicious. read more

Stopped for lunch, found it on Yelp. Hidden location, unassuming exterior. Easily the BEST ONION RINGS I can remember eating!