Fancy Pantry

Best REUBEN SANDWICH that I have ever eaten! I am not qualified to grade, but people say it is…read moreauthentic to New York (NY). I inquired and can confirm the main ingredients actually come from NY: Rye bread, pastrami, corned beef. They also have bagels from NY, and you can buy bread/bagels to take home! Ok, let's discuss this REUBEN masterpiece. They have a few Reuben options, and I selected the NY Reuben which seemed like a good idea and comes as a triple decker. A good sandwich starts with good bread, and this IS GOOD BREAD. This rye was soft and didn't have the strong spicy rye flavors, but rather just a mild flavoring...which I really liked. The meat is critical to a Reuben and I can attest that the Pastrami and Corned Beef was phenominal, tender fall-apart deli sliced cuts of meat with incredible flavor. Next a Reuben needs good dressing. I don't know what the dressing is, but it was heavenly. Put all of this together and you have a cravevable meal that will bring you back again! I am not a COLESLAW kind of guy, but this stuff was through the roof! It was not sour like many make it, rather more creamy and watery. It also had a slight sweetness, albeit it wasn't sweet. The seating environment is clean, open and yet has a slight cafeteria feel. The wait staff was friendly and attentive, even though there were many customers at the lunch hour. My server, Amanda, was easy going and helpful when I discussed menu with her. She was not like some waiters that are not helpful in saying "it's all good". I will be back when in Sandy Springs!!!

We ordered sandwiches to pick up and they were delicious! I had the Rachel (turkey). My parents had…read morea hot pastrami and hot corned beef. All sandwiches are served with cole slaw and pickle. The ordering process was easy and the staff were friendly. Tables were full and it seemed like a great place to grab lunch. We will def be back! Clean and welcoming.

Inside

New York Reuben. Best reuben that I have ever eaten!

See all

Coleslaw was phenominal. Not sour.

The General Muir

4.0(1.3k reviews)

7.8 mi

This place is incredible. The service is awesome and the food quality never disappoints.read more

I've visited General Muir a few times for my morning coffee fix because it's the closest cafe to…read moreme. It's a spacious, comfortable spot to get some work done, although it can get a bit noisy. One thing I really like about this place is the staff; they are very friendly. I haven't tried any of the entrees yet, but I've enjoyed their pastries, especially the Cardamom Brioche Knot. For drinks, my favorites so far have been the Matcha Latte and Iced Coffee. That said, I find their coffee to be on the more bitter side. Even the Vietnamese Iced Coffee, which I typically expect to be sweeter, leans more bitter and less sweet here.

Inside dining room

Pecan Crusted French Toast

See all

Jay's Deli

4.0(27 reviews)

8.4 mi

After dining in and ordering delivery from Jay's Deli so many times, I cannot believe I have not…read morewritten a review. I love that everything is halal, so I can eat whatever I want without any worries. Personally, my top favorites are their spicy smashburger and elote hotdog. The flavors of both are just out of this world. The staff members are really nice and friendly. I also love the fun decor, including the deli/sandwich puns along the walls. Overall Jay's Deli is worth checking out and I look forward to continuing to order from them in the future.

I came here for the first time today. I ordered the hot pastrami sandwich. It was very good! I will…read moredefinitely come back to try other items. I wish it was closer to home! I live in Lilburn and I hope they open another location closer. Service was nice & friendly. Ambiance is casual and clean.

Food and drinks

See all

Jack's New Yorker Deli

4.2(424 reviews)

9.2 mi

Locally owned & operated

Free parking

My man Jack makes an excellent cheesesteak…read more I'd seen a comment or two that the meat might be a little puny, so I ordered extra meat, and it was perfect. Double meat would have been too much, it would throw off the meat to bread ratio. Plenty of thin sliced juicy steak, with the veggies and cheese just all melting together. The bread was so soft, the whole generous cheesesteak was a joy to eat, I hardly needed to chew it. I'm seriously thinking of getting another one tomorrow.

Stopped by here twice now and both times were a hit, I love a good sandwich place…read more The staff has been super friendly on both my visits. They were great at answering my questions and it helped me move around the menu. Let me start with they have hand-cut fries...they have really, really good hand-cut fries. If you have hand-cut fries, you have a friend in me, if they are really good, you have a fan! My first trip I went specifically for the Reuben. It is what I saw that they had and that was my mission. It was a good Reuben, I think enjoyed it and would go back for another. This trip I was thinking Cheesesteak, but the Outlaw caught my attention, a cheesesteak with a twist. I was a fan of the twist. The pepperoni and salami plus the grilled red onions and banana peppers with the hot sauce crushed!

Pretending I'm still in France at an outdoor café!

See all

Cordon Blue Seasoned tender chicken, ham, Swiss cheese, tomato and honey mustard.

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli

3.9(250 reviews)

8.1 mi

10:30 am on a Friday. Free parking in the plaza!…read more Service was super quick. Clean environment. Got blueberry bagel with regular cream cheese. The bagel wasn't super flavorful but it was fluffy and fresh! They do not skimp out on the CC (cream cheese). Total was under $6 and I tipped 30%+.

I was craving a bagel yesterday morning, so I finally stopped by Brooklyn Bagel Company at Ansley…read moreMall after a friend recommended it nearly a year ago. I ordered the Rio Grande with Pastrami and a plain bagel with smoked salmon cream cheese. If you're planning to visit, I'd recommend ordering through their website. The place gets busy, and I waited about 15-17 minutes for my food. Not a bad wait, but ordering ahead definetly saves time. The first thing you'll notice is the size. These bagels are huge. I ate my Rio Grande around 10 a.m. and wasn't hungry again until about 4 p.m., so they're definitely filling. I saved the smoked salmon bagel for the next morning, toasted it, and added the salmon creme cheese back on, and it was just as delicious. Overall, Brooklyn Bagel Company is a solid breakfast and deli spot with several locations around Atlanta. After trying a place with "Brooklyn" in the name, I'm genuinely curious what separates a good bagel from a great one. I finally understand why people are so passionate about them. My next order will definitely be the Nova with capers and red onions. If you're looking for a hearty breakfast that will keep you full for hours, this place is definitely worth trying.

To go items

Cousin Vinny's New York Sized on Cheddar Jalapeño Bagel

See all

Came back and managed to order for dine in. Brooklyn on Onion Bagel

Reuben's Deli

4.2(438 reviews)

11.1 mi•Downtown

Twice in one day…read more Breakfast was everything bagel and cream cheese. Good bagel for the south (I'm a Georgian, don't come at me, bread here generally doesn't compare to bread from up north). I think these are shipped in from NY, where the best bagels are, no debating that. Back for lunch for a turkey sandwich on wheat bread. Ton of perfectly sliced turkey. Really, really good. When I'm working in ATL I will visit this place each time I'm here.

Reuben's Deli is located on a quiet tree lined street with minimal vehicle access due to one side…read morebeing blocked off. I had the Reuben their #1 seller along with a side of potato salad and it did not disappoint. There are signs inside that encourage customers to YELL your order and while it was not necessary at 11am I can see how it would be once the lunch crowd arrives. Great food and a great atmosphere.

Interior

Pasta salad

See all

Loved the environment and experience. These guidelines are for REAL!

Goldbergs Fine Foods - Buckhead

3.8(305 reviews)

3.2 mi•Buckhead

Goldberg's Paces Ferry is like meeting up with a good friend - they always make you feel welcome…read moreand ready to pick up where you left off. The food is as great as you remember and the service does not disappoint. How nice to be greeted by familiar faces, who often remember how you like your iced tea! Consistent, tasty and always glad to see you.

Hands down the best breakfast and brunch in Atlanta for the price!…read more I love a good diner, and Goldbergs delivers every single time. It's light years ahead of J Christopher's, White Hall, First Watch, you game it. Now you won't get a fancy coffee or Instagram able photo, but you'll get solid food. I've been eating here for years and genuinely crave it about every three weeks...it's that good. You really can't go wrong. Portions are generous especially for the price, service is consistently solid (though wait times can vary, it's popular!), and with so many locations you can usually find one nearby. They're also great about modifying cooking oils for those of us who prefer olive oil or other healthier options. My go-to is an omelette or the nova scramble, with home fries -- big, crispy potato chunks with sautéed peppers and onions -- plus a side of toast, English muffin, or bagel (or swap for salad or fruit). My husband swears by their latkes, too. Classic, satisfying, and a total win for brunch lovers.

Set em up! Bagels and everything yummy- fresh

Special Menu Offerings

See all

"Breakfast sandwich"

O4W Market

4.5(19 reviews)

11.2 mi•Old Fourth Ward

Delicious spot in Atlanta. Stopped here during a work trip. I got the Boss (lots of turkey,…read morecranberries, Gouda cheese, and some sort of mayo) with sweet potato tots. The tots were excellent, but could have used a little more salt. A co-worker got something off of their Indian menu and it smelled amazing. I would definitely go again.

Great neighborhood market with a wide selection of higher end snacks, imported cheeses,…read morecharcuterie, pet food/treats, wine, beer, sweets and basic everyday kitchen and household items. They also have a great burger/sandwich shop and lovely Indian restaurant in the back. Staff is super friendly.

See all

Jack's New Yorker Deli

4.0(281 reviews)

4.8 mi•Buckhead

Came here off the reviews of other Yelpers, and overall it was pretty good. I ordered the roast…read morebeef (called the something 30, can't remember the exact name). The sandwich was good, nothing special though, it had roast beef, lettuce, and a tomato on a bun with some kind of sauce on it. The portion was pretty decent, I wasn't hungry afterwards but I wasn't full either. The menu is pretty vast, so if I came back I would explore the menu and try other things. Overall it's worth coming in here and trying it out.

Stopped in while in town to grab a quick lunch. Ended up getting the Roast Turkey club and it was…read morevery good! The roasted peppers I think really set the sandwich off. All the ingredients were fresh and the bread also was very fresh. Seemed like everything was made to order. Staff was nice and friendly as well and the inside was very clean as well! Also got a couple of cookies from the front that were also really good! If you are looking for a good Deli Sandwich, give them a try for sure.

Turkey club

Jacks Chicken and Dumplings

See all

Half Panini, Half Tomato Gorgonzola Soup w/fries

Fred's Meat & Bread

4.1(898 reviews)

10.8 mi•Inman Park

Craving a great classic burger!? Fred's got it!…read more Mine was delicious, perfect combo, classic ingredients, amazing flavor. You're inside Krog Street Market, so the ambiance is already nice, me and my friends got lucky to find at spot at their table, but there's plenty of room at the market. Service was fast, friendly and helpful.

Fred's is widely known to be the "best" cheesesteak in Atlanta. It has many accolades including…read morebeing on the Michelin guide. 1) Korean Ribeye Cheesesteak: - PROS: It was packed and filled to the brim with ribeye that was nicely cut with an even cheese dispersion. I loved the caramelized jalepeno slices since they added it beautiful hint of spicy sweetness to the dish. The bread has a nice chew and it does not get soggy fast. - CONS: Not that special. I dont know why it's "korean" since it tasted like a normal cheesesteak but with a few jalapenos. I also wish they added in more jalapenos (I got like 3). 2) Garlic Fries with Ranch: - PROS: Very nice texture with a crispy outside and fluffy inside that is not too dense. The flavor comes from the garlic mince that is on top. The ranch is like a mixture of an aioli and tartar sauce (I think they make it in house, correct me if I'm wrong). - CONS: Inconsistent texture as some of the fries were dense but a few had that good hollow crisp bite. Quite oily too. Overall, I enjoyed the cheesesteak but would probably skip the fries next time. I do believe it is good especially the bread. I don't think it is worth all the hype it gets, but it is good.

The counter at Krog St.

Italian Grinder

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Stacy C.

9 years ago

This place is amazing! Everything is super fresh. The cream soups are the best I've ever had. I don't typically go for a creamy spinach soup or creamy mushroom but it doesn't matter here because no matter what they put in their cream soups, they are fantastic. In the Fall, I absolutely love the Butternut Squash Bisque. Oh my, it's divine. The Appleberry salad is phenomenal as well as the Smoked Turkey Reuben. Of forget it...everything on the menu is delish :) read more

Meg H.

145

10 years ago

I still love this place and I will still drive across town for their salads.

Tamara S.

17 years ago

Great Sandwiches and salad. I will be back!

Fancy Pantry - delis - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Fancy Pantry also viewed

E. 48th Street Market

4.5

(369 reviews)

Believe the hype. I unashamedly make a 40min drive (w/ no traffic) across the perimeter just to…read morepatronize this little market. It just gets better and better with each visit. Keeping an upward trend is a rarity these days. We are not the only people obsessed here, so be prepared for a small wait if it's busy. These guys do numbers on a daily, but especially on Saturdays. There were some issues with quality control on an item (it was the last one on the shelf) that we'd purchased a week ago and we ended up having to throw it out. But that's okay. My husband gave Jake (our favorite staff member) a call just to give him a heads up, not expecting anything from it. But he offered us a complimentary Sicilian white pizza with sausage to make up for any inconvenience and to retain our long-time patronage. Wow. The emphasis on customer service and retention is admirable in today's market. The pizza was..... I mean I'm sure you can guess! Getchu some.

Such a cute place! The food is amazing, just simple fresh ingredients. We ate most of it before I…read moresnapped a pic but we got the Italian chili, Italian beef sandwich, #7, and a pizza slice. Definitely is one of our new favorite lunch spots!

Sandy Springs Diner

3.4

(255 reviews)

Everything is always good and fresh here. I ordered the Cuban Reuben special on my last visit for…read morelunch. It was excellent! This diner is exactly what you expect a diner to look like inside and their menu matches what you'd expect too! My servers have always been on top of things so no complaints there either. Give this place a try, they had something for everyone.

I was a part of a large group who all ordered individually and wanted separate checks. I was…read morehungry and for lunch chose the Sandy Springs Breakfast, which was close to being all I could eat. Every item on my plate was done correctly and was enjoyable.

Keke's Breakfast Cafe

3.7

(80 reviews)

Let's just say we have gone almost 5 Saturdays in a row I forgot to let my phone eat first a few…read moretimes but I have not been disappointed by the food they serve here. It's a very family friendly environment, they always give my son wax sticks to play with and that keeps him distracted while we wait for our food. All the servers we've had are super friendly and the food does not take long to come out. The most recent time I had the Buffalo chicken wrap and it was delicious I love this place !

I ordered the Cheese Steak Omelet because they said it was a signature item with the Home Fries…read more Both items were just bla. Decent, not great! My daughter got the Kids Favorites Combo which she really enjoyed...she got a kids pancake with Apple Cinnamon topping. The service was strange. It took a while to take our beverage order and then we had to track the server down to pay the bill. The restaurant was clean as were the restrooms that allow both genders.

Cubanos ATL- Sandy Springs

4.1

(178 reviews)

Best Cubanos in Atl in my opinion! So sad when they closed down the downtown Roswell location. Went…read morethere every Thursday after therapy ! Sandy Springs is the OG and is still incredibly good. Staff is kind. Theres is picnic bench to sit at but I prefer taking it to go or putting the windows down and eating in the car. It's totally worth it.

Craving a Cuban sandwich and this place came up near the area I was working. It's not bad by any…read moremeans, but the Tampa had a weird aftertaste. If in the area again I'll try the Miami

First Watch

3.5

(138 reviews)

The food was great. That atmosphere was great. The energy was great., Josh was wonderful with us…read morehaving a toddler & her makin a mess.

We went there today at 10am. It was not busy. I hate to sound negative but 4 people eating (3…read morewere women) and the meal with over $100. Total rip off for what you get. Here are few other issues: 1) there was no cream on the table for coffee? It's a breakfast place. Instead they have individual high sugar creamer containers we are supposed to use? 2) the table was not wiped down when we were seated. There was water and salt on the table. 3) the server never came to table. We had to go look for him after sitting there 15 minutes. 4) they want you to checkout with app but it was not working. So you have to pay up front. But there was no one working the front. So I have to wait to give this place my money. 5) also no 15% tip option. Starts at 18%. I won't go back. For the price it was a ripoff.

Savi Cafe

5.0

(2 reviews)

This is a new Savi location in the Perimeter Summit area, within a very short walk from my home…read more This place opened up earlier this year, and I decided to check this place out. It's on the 1st floor level just off of the lobby in the 4004 Summit Blvd office building. Parking is available behind the building in the parking garage. Savi is mainly a deli sandwich shop set up for the office workers, but anyone can come here to eat during business hours. The employees are quick, efficient, nice and patient. The menu doesn't have that many items on it. I love the big and open dining area. Customers place their order at the order counter, and pick up their food at the counter when their names are called. The roasted ham sandwich I got was good sized, and the ham was high quality and delicious. I ordered it with lettuce, onions, tomato, mayo, oil and vinegar on sourdough bread. It came with a big dill pickle spear. I also paid extra for a bag of bbq kettle chips (crunchy and my favorite!) and a plastic bottle of ginger ale. Customers pick out their own chips from the many shelves they have and the drinks from the refrigerator; no self serve beverage dispensers here. Through the floor-to-ceiling glass windows, customers have a great view of the tall trees in the nearby woods, and the King and Queen buildings.

Great food and service! Everything on the menu is good, and I love their specials. Cute environment…read moretoo!

La Petite Maison

4.0

(211 reviews)

•$$$

My team decided to go for lunch and we chose La Petite Maison. It's located off of Roswell Rd, not…read moreto far from the Abernathy intersection. It's a standalone build and not part of the shopping centers. Upon walking in, it has an elevated feel with White table service. We visited on a Thursday for lunch and it was fairly busy and the service was a little slow. From a food perspective- around the table, we had a couple of seafood orders, a salad, and a couple of sandwiches. Admittedly, it was just ok. The fish dishes were very dry and the salads were overdressed. The sandwich options received better feedback from the group. For lunch - there are better options. If I was going for an occasion (and for dinner), I might give it another shot.

I would give 4.5 if it was an option. Great French food experience. I had the flounder in parchment…read morewhich was delicious. It had a great sauce that I wish I knew how to make because it is great. The salads are huge and delicious. Great drinks. The bread has a great olive spread with it. Pretty inside and French style porch. Good service. Large portion not so "petite":)

Morty's Meat & Supply

4.0

(59 reviews)

Having heard a lot of hype around Morty's, I really wanted to like it. Unfortunately, it was just…read moreok. The pulled pork was tough and did not taste fresh at all. The service was fine and the atmosphere is pretty straightforward. I'm pretty mucg indifferent about this place and not sure I would go back again.

Everything about this place is a 5 star review no doubt- BUT THOSE CHAIRS- get new outside chairs…read moreman they hurt- makes me want to stand, which makes me want to walk, which makes me want to leave... maybe I'll stay and just drink more .

Savi Provisions

5.0

(2 reviews)

This Savi Provisions has only been open for 2 months. With that being said their Togo cold fridge…read moreisn't quite as full yet. But they do have my favorite Spanish cheese variety pack. The can and dry good shelves are full, along with the wine/ beer shelves and fridge. Now the hot food/ coffee counter is descent. The menus for breakfast and lunch is minimal, but I figure once they have been open for a while and learn the community the menu will expand. But ultimately this staff was very nice and my Bage & Lox was good. So if your in the neighborhood stop by an give them a try.

Need a quick snack? Savi is the place to go. They have sandwiches and breakfast. Small grocery…read moresection and next door a liquor store. What more can you ask for? And the staff is nice!

Chapmans Cafe

4.9

(28 reviews)