We had dinner here with a couple friends. I ordered the steak hoagie on the recommendation of one of them. It was excellent!! The steak was flavored perfectly, nice and tender, no fat or grizzle, was a generous portion and was served on soft roll. I'd give the fries that came with it an 'ok'. My husband got some sort of wrap (sorry, no details). There was also a cheeseburger and another sandwich of some sort. Lol sorry for the lack of details on them all. Food was overall pretty good. The service was a bit 'off'. Examples, there was a sign in the entrance saying they had happy hour special daily. We asked about them & were told. 'Nope, we don't'. No explanation. I asked for a bag to put the leftover containers in. The server came right back with the check but no bag. Little things... maybe an off night? I'd definitely return to try other items on the menu. 2026-18 read more

See all

I work very close to this restaurant so I occasionally come here for a chicken salad sandwich and a bowl of tomato soup. I get that because it's the fastest thing I can get on a 30 minute lunch break. The service is fast and the server always remembers me. I like sitting at the bar because it's quick and comfortable seating. I'm always satisfied with the whole experience when I leave. read more

Stopped in on a Saturday night and got a table in the bar as we did not have a reservation. Our waitress was very friendly and helpful. I decided to have the steak sandwich...delicious !!! I very much enjoyed it. I got the potato salad for my side which was good but a little too creamy. Overall a very good experience...I definitely plan to make a return visit !!! read more

My Tomato Pie - Steak sandwich with potato salad - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

We came by on a Saturday evening and got seated immediately, although we were told we had to sit in the bar because they had numerous reservations that night. I ordered the steak portobello focaccia with macaroni salad as a side. I requested a steak knife, which was brought promptly, since I like to make an open face sandwich with steak. The steak was properly cooked medium rare and I took some home. Our waiter was quite prompt with his service. My wife ordered the steak sandwich and potato salad which she enjoyed. We had an overall good experience and will be sure to come back. read more

My Tomato Pie - Steak portobello focaccia with macaroni salad - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

See all

Insanely good burger! Very juicy and perfect mix of cheese and spinach. Sides weren't as flavorful but edible nevertheless. Waitress was attentive but not in the way, great atmosphere and loved the lighting! read more

My Tomato Pie - Spinach Burger Cajun Tossed Fries (Basket) Steak Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

The food was ok. I had the cheese tortellini with the cream sauce and it was not very good. It was way too salty and the tortellini was under cooked. I wish they had free bread before the food came out but they didn't. The service was ok it took a wile to be seated. I have heard the pizza is good so hopefully it would be better next time. The ambiance was nice with a nice feeling but there was a lot of sports tvs. read more

Had lunch there. Food was amazing. Service was quick and friendly. Definitely recommend! read more

My Tomato Pie - Chicken Caesar Salad (Large) - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

See all

I loveeee the Cobb salad at My Tomato Pie. My favorite Cobb was always at Friday's and now that they're closed I'm looking for a close comparison and this one is the closest I've gotten. The dressing makes your mouth water and if you get a breadstick, the meal hits As the saying goes, consistency is key. And they've got it here. read more

My Tomato Pie - Cobb Salad - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

Omg! Delicious! And takeout is nicely packed up. We visit often and always pleased. Open at lunchtime as well!! read more

Best pizza in the area! All the food is amazing. The service is exceptional! Dawn is the best server ever but all servers are great. The owners are kind and welcoming. The atmosphere is fun. MTP is definitely worth a visit! read more

My Tomato Pie - Cheese and pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

this past friday barb &i ate here. we both had the beer battered fish fry. let me tell you that it was the best fish fry i ate in the last 20 years!!! i've got 55+ years of hospitality experience so i know what i'm talking about. great service and very comfortable atmoshere !!! grrat job tony!!! read more

We've been loyal customers for over 20 years, both when they were at the old location and their "new" one. We have so many favorites in the menu: creamy tomato soup, pizza salad, veggie hummus pita, just to name a few. Highly recommend! read more

No longer has a pizza worth ordering. This place use to have great food, last 2 times it was mediocre. The pizza had very little sauce and cheese and skimpy with the pepperoni. There was at least 2 inches of crust before the sauce and cheese started. Will not be going back. Many other pizzerias in area with consistent quality food. Lost this loyal customer. read more

Ordered the zesty chicken pasta, which was very good. Also ordered the spaghetti with a meatball. Wasn't a huge fan of the red sauce and the meatball was tender, but flavor was just ok. Wish I would have thought to order extra Parmesan for this dish. Really appreciated them putting the Caesar salad dressing on the side so the lettuce wasn't wilted when it was delivered. read more

Wonderful food with generous portions. I had a portobello mushroom veggie wrap and it was absolutely wonderful. Could only eat half of it. I definitely recommend. read more

My Tomato Pie - Portabella mushroom veggie wrap - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

I would like to start with the hostess very unfriendly i Asked for a booth got seated at a table that only could fit a minion?,next I got up and asked for a bigger table gave me attitude! Next waitress comes to the table saying she lost the bet on who was going to wait on us and she lost! Next we placed our order and it came out pizza was ice cold and salad was soggy! What a disappointment to say the least!I would like my money to reimbursed! read more

We had a family birthday party with approximately25 people. It was such a great experience. They accommodated diet restrictions/allergies despite using the buffet menu. Food was excellent. Our server Lauren was so nice and did a great job with our chaos with little ones running around. We felt like we were the only ones there. Thank you so much for a special celebration! read more

Excellent food so many choices on the menu!. Friendly staff always willing to accommodate your needs and help with any questions you may have!! Very clean! read more

What happened? Are you kidding? Lasagna for $30. No way. The food there is just mediocre but they charge premium prices like the best restaurants in Buffalo.. Sorry, never again. read more

We ordered dinner for pick up tonight. I had cheese ravioli and my husband had the Pork Chop special. Apple Sage Brined Bone in pork chop. He specifically stated it was one of the best meals he's had in a long time. The pork chop was perfectly cooked and the sides were delicious as well. My ravioli were also delicious as were the 2 garlic breadsticks. We also took the time to call to restaurant to tell them how happy we are. read more

I just had an amazing turkey club wrap. What made it standout from the rest was the garlic mayo...delicious! Staff service was very friendly and a relax family ambiance. read more

My Tomato Pie - Turkey Club Wrap - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

We love eating here. Food is very yummy & reasonably priced Would highly recommend!! read more

The food is amazing and the service couldn't be better!! Highly recommend My Tomato Pie!

So in this crazy #stayathome time, we want to support our favorites! We ordered a smorgasbord of entrees to fuel us through the night and the next few days. They have AWESOME, CLEAN, curbside delivery with you calling ahead for your order. They have been so organized, professional, and courteous before this "new world", and we truly entrust good meals from them curbside until we can all reconnect. Thank you, and keep up the AMAZING work! read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch on a Tuesday in July. The place was not crowded. We sat in a booth which I prefer over a table. I had the Turkey focaccia sandwich with potato salad as the side. It was quite tasty. The service was prompt and professional. I will be back for lunch. read more

My Tomato Pie - Turkey focaccia sandwich with potato salad side - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

Food was excellent as always- one of our favorite places! Service is always on point and friendly!

Visited My Tomato Pie on Tuesday night. The best part of the experience was the staff. I had a portobello steak sandwich which was disappointing for $28.00. The steak, nor the spinach was seasoned, and the fries were under cooked. We also ordered a portobello calzone which was lacking portobello mushrooms. For some reason, it had a lot of cut up red peppers in it, but the portobello mushrooms were also cut the same size and there were barely any. My daughter ordered the chicken parm. The portion of chicken was small considering the size of a pounded out chicken breast, and the spaghetti was lacking sauce. The atmosphere was very nice. The wait staff was great, but the food was subpar. Possibly they are known for other foods and we were just not aware. I would not recommend the restaurant if you're going for items that I mentioned. Disappointing considering it's a nice restaurant with great staff! read more

I had a 7 inch personal pan pizza with caramelized onions. It was delicious. The pizzas are all "build your own". On the 7 inch pizza, most of the many topping choices are $1.25. There are 20-25 choices including onions, caramelized onions, black olives, hot peppers, mushrooms, sweet peppers, jalapeño peppers. The service was very fast, with our waitress stopping to ask how our pizzas tasted. We were probably very lucky that we got there shortly after 5 as many patrons started coming in just after we were seated. read more

We're celebrating our dear friend's belated birthday, and quite frankly our unbirthdays too, because we want an excuse to spend time together and eat good food. Unfortunately, most of the town seems to be closed on Mondays, so we went with plan C. Maybe I should say fortunately, as I was pleasantly surprised. I've been in this plaza plenty of times, and came in once before with someone who didn't like their food. He's entitled to his opinion, but I think they were worth a second chance. I waited in the vestibule with my friend and we immediately got a TARDIS feel as we walked in. Definitely bigger on the inside than you'd guess. A nice gent took our drink orders (they swing Coke, for the record) and gave us time to look over the expansive menu. We all got the pizza bread to split. None of us touched the sauces, partly due to my nut allergy (it's in a container, so no worries), but partly due to the fact that it tastes good without it. I used mine to sop up the soup from my bowl. Believe the reviews, that tomato basil soup is what that first impression should of been, what would have brought me back sooner. Creamy, with strands of cheese and homemade croutons that had soaked in enough cream to make you feel like you are eating pizza with a spoon. I'm not even a tomato soup person, and there I was, sopping away as the table looked on in envy. Two of my pals got burgers. They're tall, and juicy to a point of soaking the bottom bun. One removed her tomatoes and flipped it to solve the problem. The other used a fork. Whatever works, as both happily cleared their plates. My other pal got loaded fries. The serving is generous and she had to pack it to go. The waiter had the sense to ask about separate bills and the patience to accept our stack of pooled cash as we giggled out the door. Overall, it's a good place to have a girls night, guys night, an order that soup to go because it's that good night...just bring your own napkins. You have one cloth one to make your way through the meal, and if you're anything like us, you feel guilty as you stain them with the remnants of food well enjoyed. read more

See all

I recently attended a bridal shower at My Tomato Pie. I have never been to the new location, but was very pleased that there was lots of available parking and the space was lovely. Our server was wonderful, and very polite. I must rave about my menu selection: Cranberry walnut chicken salad sandwich on a croissant. This is now my new favorite sandwich! This sandwich is amazingly delicious and so fresh. I have never had a better croissant, not even in Paris! I don't know if it was baked on site, but it sure tasted like it had just come out of the oven. Magnifique! read more

Visited for lunch today with some coworkers. The service was a little slow today but not terrible. It's been a couple months since we came for lunch so I forgot how big the menu is. 3 of us opted for the steak wrap and the tomato basil soup and my boss opted for the meatball calzone. The soup was incredible - absolutely delicious - and I'd order that every single time I come here. The steak wrap was just okay. A bit too heavy and greasy and it was more like a Philly cheese steak wrap than an actual steak wrap. The pasta salad was pretty good but a little dry. My boss said his calzone was pretty good but could be a little crispier. Overall, everything was decent but the real winner with the soup. read more

See all

Never having been here, I wasn't sure what to expect. There were 9 of us walking in and we were seated quickly with no problem. The place was much nicer than I expected. not just a pizzeria but upscale with plenty of craft beers and all the flavors of the week. We shared a buffalo chicken pizza which was very good and a meatball pizza with ricotta which was even better. as there was young people with us we shared a large platter of french fries and onion rings. everything came out very timely and hot. our server was very nice and checked in a couple of times. I wouldn't hesitate to go back and try some of the other pies. A good time was had by all. read more

From the outside, My Tomato Pie looks like a small pizza place you might run into to grab a slice and go, however the inside is a massive dining room that's nice on the eyes with a friendly staff and large menu featuring all the pizza, calzones, subs, salads, and appetizers you could possibly want. I came here for lunch on Friday with a friend and although I've eaten the food from here before, this was my first time actually dining with them. I had a craving I couldn't fight and I had to order the meatball calzone with that beautiful red sauce. The food didn't take too long to come out and when it did I was pleasantly surprised with both the size and taste of the calzone. The meatball inside was delicious and they packed it with cheese. The dough was just the right amount of soft and although I definitely could of had more red sauce, it was a darn good calzone. Overall, My Tomato Pie did me good and left both of us fat and full. The staff was nice, the food was tasty, and the Restaurant itself was super nice. Come check this place out if you haven't already! read more

My Tomato Pie - My calzone pie. - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

Stopped here on a bike ride from Buffalo to Syracuse. Food was solid. We had a couple of salads. I added grilled shrimp which were done perfectly. My partner had a cob salad. Not as good as my Mediterranean salad. read more

Haven't been here since they were at the plaza at Sheridan and the Blvd. Overall good service, waitress reciting the longest beer menus ever. Impressive. And she was very friendly. Food had generous portions and was delicious. I order the chicken Caesar wrap which was basically an overflowing salad partially in a pita. But it was delicious. Little hard to get the check and get our food we ordered to go. That was the longest wait. But overall a good experience. read more

My Tomato Pie - Chicken Caesar Wrap and sweet potatoes fries - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

So glad I gave My Tomato Pie another chance. I ate there once 6 years ago and my chicken parm calzone had so much onion I couldn't eat it. I tried it again , minus the onion , and it was everything I was hoping for. The calzone was huge and are a little more than half. The crust was crispy and tasted great too. We also ordered a pasta special, chicken Alfredo with broccoli and sun dried tomatoes. It was good as well. Will be adding this as a go to restaurant. read more

My Tomato Pie - Chicken Parmesan calzone - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

Visited the restaurant for first time in new location. We were regulars at their old location. The new location is far better and food as good as it used to be. Ordered two large pizzas (they do toppings by the quarter(4 different toppings for each quarter of the pie for the same price as one!). Also got the pizza bread appetizer and the large salad. Pizza was like warm and had to be reheated! Tasted great although the crust was soggy and could be improved. Lots of cheese and sauce was decent. The pizza bread was great and the salad looked like the spring mix and lettuce could be fresher. Hoping to have a better experience the next visit. read more

See all

I had the chicken marsala and it was delicious. My husband had a huge fish fry which was also great. And I need to compliment the helpful staff which seem to work together as a wonderful team making our dining experience so enjoyable. I hope we can go back again soon. read more

Great service, and the pizza I ordered was great. I had a personal size pizza with pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms. It was outstanding. read more

I've been here once before and it was pretty good. Went on a Friday this time during the day and surprisingly there was a good amount of people here. They had a Friday fish fry that seemed popular and a private room with some kind of lunch going on. Inside is dim and has a bunch of tables and booths along with a bar. They were out of ginger ale and sprite though which was wierd. The food can be a little pricey depending on what you get, I got 7 fingers and that was almost $20 alone with NO Fries, they were good but to me that's a lot to not include fries. I guess it's expensive at restaurants these days. We also got pizza and a chicken sandwich. Personal build your own pizza with steak was ok, I'd get something different next time though. Chicken sandwich had fresh bread. Overall pretty good food and I'd go back read more