Yum!!! This is the pizza I have been looking for in RI. The crust is thin and crunchy and the "aloha" pizza was easily the best Hawaiian I have ever tasted. For those Bostonians in the area...this is as close to Regina as you can get. If you like that pizza...this is the place for you! On top of the pizza, they have a great beer selection and a large menu for those not interested in pizza. We tried the fried ravioli as well and they were very good. The service was great and they were able to accommodate our party of 8 on a Saturday night which was really nice. Check it out if you are in the area! read more

Very good cross between Neapolitan and for lack of a better term, Italian style American pizza with a bright, tangy sauce and very fresh mozzarella. The dough is the champion here. Wish it was cooked a bit more, but a very tasty, good pie . Taste wise, it is up there with any pizza in RI. I saw Dave Portnoy's review and I disagree on his score, which was a 6.7. He thought it was too floppy. I agree that it could be cooked so it is a tad more crisp, but the taste of the dough, sauce and cheese merits an 8.1 at least. They also make great burgers and meat balls. read more

Excellent spot for lunch breaks and full meals. I highly recommend the "Zorba the Greek" pizza read more

Federal Hill Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

We had heard from multiple friends that this place made a great pie. Today we had to stop in at a nearby soccer store to pick up supplies for the kids. After finding a place to park on the street (probably the only negative) we stopped in. The waitress was quick to greet us at the door. We explained that we were going to place a to go order. She handed us menus and told us to meet her at the register once we were ready. We decided on a large prosciutto and cheese pizza and penne with grilled chicken and red sauce for our family of 4. I'll get to the food review shortly. Since we had a few minutes to wait I decided to have a beer. They have an excellent selection of various types of draught beer. The yelper that said they don't give samples couldn't be more incorrect. They gave me samples and I decided on the Mad Hatter IPA. Very tasty! The food came out quickly and we drove home to sample the cuisine. The pizza dough is excellent! It's perfectly crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. The prosciutto was the ideal amount of salty and the cheese was great. The grilled chicken and red sauce on the pasta was incredible. On top of all of this they offer 50% off during lunch! What a deal! Can't wait to go back! read more

Ok I rarely write reviews, if ever. Since I use Yelp myself to find places, I felt compelled to tell any/everyone that this place is a gem. The Craft Beer selection is the perfect size, not too many that the kegs and lines get old, just enough constantly rotating drafts that include local and hard-to-find beers. And the Pizza is amazing...the crust is that perfect crust that everyone looks for whenever they get a pizza, the sauce is out of this world. If you are trying to decide where to go in the Warren/Bristol/Swansea area...just go to this place, you will enjoy it. *****EDIT****** I have one problem that I was hoping would be realized but has not yet. This place has such a great beer list, but served them all in the same, plain Pint glasses. I really wish that this place used proper glassware for it's craft beer, it make such a difference to drink an Imperial IPA out of a Tulip Glass rather than a Pint/Drinking glass, which makes it less than ideal. I appeal to the owner to please consider bringing in some proper glassware for your great Beer Selection. read more

So this little gem has been open for over 2 years and I have avoided it due to the fact I thought it was another fly by night trying to live off a big name. Well, I was pleasantly surprised to say the least. After spending a full day on the boat with a 3 and 5 year old (my kids) the last thing I wanted was a busy restaurant but I was craving savory Italian. I did a quick yelp search and FHP came up just a few miles from my house. I was happy to see the old school red and white checked table clothes and homey decor. We started with the sicilian rice balls. The rice was a little toothy but the red sauce amazing. I could have have eaten a bowl of it with fresh bread and called it a day. Our main was "the way it should be" pizza. Cheese, fresh mozz, pepperoni, mushrooms, and finished with a touch of truffle oil. Wow! Fresh taste from the tomato, savory / creamy cheese, spicey pepperoni, earthy finish from the shrooms and just enough truffle oil. This food took my wife and I back to an afternoon we spent in Capri. Complimenting the meal was a glass of merlot which I can't remeber the name of but it went perfect. Warren has become a great little town to discover new restaurants and shops. Check out the restaurant and antique scene down on the scenic water street. There are some gems down there too. read more

Best Gluten free pizza in the area! I'm pretty sure their crust is homemade and what a difference it makes! It actually tastes like really pizza dough and not like cardboard gluten free (read: bhop, the wave, pomodoro). We got the aloha and I am blown away. A good dough makes a huge difference read more

Not much of a "yelper" but wanted to give this place a shout out. I stop in with my buddies or solo to grab pizza and always a draft beer. They never disappoint. Someone puts a lot of thought into the selection they offer. My friends say I only go to stare at the pretty blonde who works behind the bar...they're only half right. Do yourself a favor and try this place out next time you're in the area! read more

This is a pizza shop that uses fresh ingredients. I'm not a big pizza connoisseur, but I can tell the crusts are made fresh, and the pizza sauce, cheese and basil toppings all "pop". I especially love the way the crust is grilled (brick/wood oven?). It is an inconsistent bake, leaving spots where you can taste the smokiness. This is a good thing! :) I think they are a bit pricey for what they offer, but if they can make it in Providence, they are probably pretty good pizza. read more

What can I say, we sat at the bar so we got to see the show in the kitchen. Chef William Manzo Jr did not disappoint. We had 2 pizzas East side and the Aloha. Absolutely perfect. Chef comes out of the kitchen to talk to his very happy diners. Atmosphere is great, service was awesome. Very diverse menu. Great value. A MUST! We will be back read more

See all

Family dinner @ Federal Hill Pizza was exceptional. The restaurant is warm and inviting and has both old world charm and a personal touch (cloth napkins, local artist works) that make it feel special. Our service was impeccable: we were treated like family, as was everyone else who came in while we were there. The holiday music was a festive touch and just the right volume to be in the background. We ordered a large Greek salad to share among 4 - and it was definitely enough. It was served on a platter plate. No pic because we dove right in. But, the lettuces were tender and flavorful, the kalamata olives were fresh (room temp) and aromatic, and the cherry tomatoes were ridiculously tasty for this time if year. There wasn't enough feta and parmesan cheese for my liking, but I'm sure if I asked we would have been given more. I ordered a glass of Chianti which was refreshing and plentiful. But the very best part, as it should have been, was the pizza. We ordered two 16" pies: one Mama's and one Roman. I barely got pics before they were devoured. The sauce was just enough tomato flavor to enhance the pie, but light and subtle enough to allow the cheese and basil a starring role. The meats were delightfully flavorful and a great complement to the cheese. The onions on the Roman were a perfect side note adding excellent depth, but not overpowering all the other ingredients. And the crust was perfect, thin, chewy and a flavor all its own. We had three pieces left over, but they didn't make it past 9:00 this morning. The Boy ate two last night and I scarfed the last one for an early morning pick-me-up. Federal Hill Pizza would make a killing in the DMV. And, we'll definitely be back on our next visit, even if we don't stay in the area. *I don't usually give 5 star reviews on a first visit, but I couldn't bring myself to give only 4 this time. Everything was excellent! read more

See all

Amazing pizza!!! Best pizza I've had in a long time. I'm sad it took me so long to discover it but will definitely be ordering again. The service was also great. Contactless delivery but the driver called me to let me know when it arrived. Great service and food! read more

The good: I eat here several times a month usually. The pizza is the best around and lots of the other food looks good although I have not tried it. The only complaint is that sometimes the pizza is slightly burnt, I don't really mind, but it could be off putting to some people. The bad: Waitstaff is not efficient. They are friendly enough, but they are clearly not trained correctly, the tables close to the bar get frequent service, the seats near the door get neglected. read more

I really wish I could say that this was amazing pizza and I can't wait to go back. But it really wasn't. The highlight of the dinner was the appetizer- fried rice balls with gravy. Sounds iffy, but tasted delish. My group ordered two different pizzas. Neither of them were anything great. In fact, we didn't even want to take home our leftovers. We did, though; I tried to eat it for dinner later, and couldn't. The ingredients were ok, but the crust was lackluster. I will happily go back to give it another try next time I'm nearby, but I'm not going to recommend it yet, or go out of my way to go back soon. :-/ read more

The pizza is really good. I like the craft beers they keep on tap, however sometimes I really just want a beer that's not so expensive. I do understand this place is about showcasing the local craft beers but it tends to get costly quickly. Service is about the same as any other pizza place. My favorite is the Buffalo chicken pizza and I will continue to go back for more. read more

We went after my daughters softball game. Service started off as a 6. We sat down and waited 10 minutes before anybody checked in. Waitress rebounded to get her score to a 7. Food came out fast. We got two pizzas and chicken parm dinner. Pizza crust was the star of the show. Sauce wasn't the best or the worst. Overall pizza was a 7.5, chicken Parmesan gets an 8. read more

I don't think you can really call this place a restaurant because all their cooking will not meet the standard. The chicken wings were under cooked, we returned it. The garlic white sauce chicken pasta was tasteless with noodles sticking together, and the chicken burger had a odor of a left over chicken, but u get used to the left over chicken smell after few more bites. The entrees are around 16 dollars, so you don't want to waste it. We had a carry out, an order of Mac and cheese, but my son at home said it is not a Mac and cheese. I tried with it takes like they boiled up the pasta and put some butter on the top. Service was friendly, but the girl forgot our drink order and appetizer. we have to remind her. I don't know how good is there drinks, but if you looking for a place for nice dinner. I would recommend ordering dominos over coming here to eat. read more

Oh my gosh. For a state that thrives on its pizza joints, with each local having a favorite, Federal Hill Pizza seriously knocks it out of the park! I still can't believe how impressed I am by the perfection they have achieved, one that would make both thin and thick crust fans rejoice. After one bite of the heaven I found in their appropriately named pizza "The Way It Should Be", I couldn't stop. You know when your belly says no but your heart says yes? Mhmm, that kind of meal. I even woke up the next morning wanting more! Final point: the name and it's location in Warren may sound like a cheap ploy to get folks in the door, but don't be fooled - this place deserves a spot in every pizza lover's heart. read more

Cute little place on Main .street in Warren. Incredibly authentic interior, not a pre-packaged suburban mall venue. Friendly owner and staff. Lots of beers on tap and the selection changes often. Pizzas are round and a little thin for my taste, more like Jersey Shore type but not as greasy. Sauce is excellent, on the sweet side. Sausage, sweet Italian and plenty of cheese. We took out but eating in would have been fine. Drawback: delivery. Not during the day. Closing: too early for us but, I presume, it's in line with demand. We just need To get our act together earlier. DOG/PET FRIENDLY OUTSIDE read more

Been coming here for a few years and have always enjoyed the pizza. One of the best pizza spots in this region, by far. Staff is friendly, and the owner has always been welcoming and fun to interact with, which makes some of the other reviews very surprising and a little odd, frankly. Tried a lot of different pies here and the Margherita is a consistent favorite. The buffalo chicken is also very good. Wish I lived closer, but it's probably good for my wallet and waistline that I don't. read more

Great brick oven pizza and super friendly and helpful staff. They stayed open for us so that I could pick up one of their pizzas on my way home from the airport after numerous delays, thank you!! read more

Wife and I stopped in while we were in town. We shared the East Street pizza (Meatball and Roasted Red Pepper). Great flavor, the peppers were perfectly cooked, nice roasted flavor. Nice relaxing atmosphere, wait staff was very attentive. Will be back next time we are in town. read more

Federal Hill Pizza - Meatball and Roasted Red Pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

Okay, it's not what it was and, sadly, most likely will never be again; however, the pizza, sandwiches, and beer list are still strong, but my wife and I no longer take a risk on the salads. Seems as though Prov location got all the attention, love and $. I still go for Way It Should Be and a few beers, just not the same attention to detail and quality. Ironically, I miss the Way It Was read more

I've ordered dinner from Federal Hill Pizza dozens of times, and I've always been happy. Tonight, however was the worst experience I've ever had with ANY take-out food. The food showed up cold and took over 90 minutes to arrive. When I called to let them know, the guy on the phone was laughing into the phone as he picked up phone and put me on hold. He never came back. I called a second time and he said they'd put a $10 credit on our account and then hung up on me. It's too bad a great place with the best pizza in town is being run so poorly. Time to find a new place for pizza in Warren. read more

I don't know what is going on here I've gone here about six times since my review 4 out of six times the food was still good .the last two times ..... not so much...last night was the worst I ordered the same pizza I gave the review on totally different from the first I asked for extra olives on the pizza which to me had a lot to do with the taste of this pizza .it came out with less than half the original amount I told the waitress .a guy comes over and tells me I'm sorry we ran out that is all we have ...i said she should have told me I would have ordered another kind of pizza ...he said sorry but nothing he could do we orders two meatballs they were not too good either..sauce not what it has been in the past .....buffalo shrimp was not to bad...we get the bill ....and notice we were charged for extra olives on the pizza a manager came over now and told us they put extra olives on the pizza thats why we ran out.......WHAT....another guy told me sorry we ran out thats why your pizza was light .....I WON'T BE BACK ANY TIME SOON HOPEFULLY THEY CAN FIX THEIR PROBLEMS....TO BAD ....WAS A GOOD PLACE ...I HOPE THE OWNER READS YELP.... read more

We are not local... accidentally ordered takeout from the providence location and when we realized the mistake we called to say we would pay for the order but couldn't make it out to pick it up. They delivered it 1/2 hour away after hours! Insanely grateful. And when I insisted on a tip they refused and will be donating it. Excellent food, better people. Would give 10 stars if I could. read more

Time to find a new local! So sad (see my review 4 months ago) but it's gone down (Federal) hill so fast and Alexis's account is not surprising. We'll miss it, but it's not the same experience. Not even close. Maybe the Prov location is the bomb, but we're not going to find out. read more

Shredded mozz is where it's at! Made the pizza extra cheesy and yummy. I got a pepperoni pizza and there was just something missing for this to be 4 stars. Honestly it might be the sauce? All I could taste was the cheese so a little amp on flavor would be helpful. The crust was average and the sauce kind of weak. Was kind of hoping for a wow factor, but at least the cheese was good and service was friendly! read more

Ordered a make your own pizza and a veggie burger. Ordered and specified light cook which it appeared to be. However the toppings tasted burnt. Payed extra for truffle oil, but the was no hint of the flavor at all. Payed extra for goat cheese there were 5 tiny spots on the pizza. Just burnt. I threw the whole thing out because it was inedible. Veggie burger was great! Lots of flavor, great consistency, nicely grilled bun, can't say enough. Unfortunate that it's federal hill pizza and the pizza was so disappointing. read more

We have been regulars here for years, but since they opened the Providence location, the quality has plummeted in Warren. For example, the salads and pizzas ordered with roasted red peppers now come with lame, vinegary canned peppers. Disappointing. Beers don't rotate as much and the selection is no longer intriguing. Recent delivery was no better - skimpy meat and terrible peppers. I guess we'll need to find a new local. read more

I am going to preface this review with the fact that I have eaten pizza three times this week at various places in Rhode Island, and this was my favorite. I had the federal hill salad and the owner's favorite pizza (mushroom, goat cheese, and prosciutto). The crisp crust has great texture- thinnish and crispy throughout just they way I like it! They have so many options for toppings and specials that change daily. All of the pizzas sounded so good that it was hard to pick just one to try! They offer a lot of beers on tap too. With a hungry boyfriend and a 10 mile run before, we polished off a 16 inch pizza and half salad between the two of us, but I think the 16 incher could feed 3-4 people easily with sides. It was very quiet here on a Saturday afternoon and service was great. I would definitely return if I were in the area, but I'm not quite sure how often I'd make the trip here from Providence as Providence has a fair amount of good pizzerias. Regardless, worth it to come out and try! read more

So; this place wasn't bad. The atmosphere was okay. The service was okay. The pizza was okay. I don't think I'd come back but it wasn't horrible. The price was a little high but that's what you find at brick over pizza places I think. read more

Must Try! Delicious NY style thin crust. Had an antipasto for appetizer and it was very fresh! Margarita pizza was awesome. One of the best pizza places in the East Bay. read more

Best wings and pizza around! What else can I say that hasn't already been said? You can literally taste every ingredient they use to make their food. read more

Hands down best pizza in rhode island. Some reason this state doesn't get pizza right, but FHP knows what to do. Brick oven pizza, perfect crust. Just delicious. Service can either be good or not so good, but the incredible pizza makes up for it. No other pizza in RI. read more

The pizza gets 5 stars, the apps get 3. For pizza, the sizes and prices are pretty self-explanatory and fair. For the other items, the prices seem a little high, but the portions are huge so the prices are actually very reasonable! The pizza is delicious! Thin yet chewy, un-burnt crust, delicious, sweet sauce, and generous toppings. The salads are not impressive. They serve the ribs of the lettuce chopped up with store bought dressing and cheap shaker parmesan. Great beer selection and even root beer on tap! read more

Been dying to try this place and finally made it there late on a Thursday night. Did take out and ordered a large margarita and a large mama's special (sweet onions, sausage and fresh mozzarella). LOVE. Fresh quality ingredients put together into a great pizza. Will be back ASAP. Staff was nice. Watched them making dough while I waited for my pies. read more

I am a pizza snob of sorts. Hands down, Federal Hill has the best pizza I've ever had and I've been to Naples and ate pizza. Try the truffle oil on your pizza. Paired with the best tasting sauce and crust it is incredible. Worth the drive. Tell all your friends, wake the kids and call the neighbors....go there. You won't be sorry. read more

I really really like this place. Having grown up next to New Haven,CT I grew up on Pepe's pizza which is world class pie. Then I moved to Boston and fell in love with Santarpio's in East Boston. So, a few years back I moved down here to RI and was sure that this densely Italian populated area would put up big points in the Pizza category. Wow was I wrong. I've tried most places in the area and until I stumbled upon Federal Hill Pizza in Warren I am ashamed to say I simply ordered Dominos to get the job done. I apologize for that by the way. FHP gets it! It's all about fresh ingredients, insanely hot ovens and a super friendly staff. A+ guys. Job well done. Just don't go Hollywood on us like Pepe's did. read more

Sorry, worst pizza ever. Burnt, flavorless. Like cardboard. Place is cute. Wished it was better.