We came here with a bigger party for dinner. The place was pretty average busyness wise and we were seated right away. Our family ordered a little bit of everything and had mostly no complaints. To start i got one of their seasonal cocktails with cranberry and vodka. It was so strong i couldn't even taste the cranberry and could barely drink it. For entree i got the reuben and fries. I wasn't very hungry and still ended up eating it all! It was a pretty average reuben but i felt like the portions were pretty small especially the fries. One weird thing is that someone ordered a salad and asked for thousand island dressing that came on my reuben and they wouldn't let them order it! They said it wasn't an option which i thought it was weird being that it's on their menu elsewhere. Overall this place has pretty solid food. Some of my family loved it but i thought it was just average. I could see this place being packed in the summer time with it being right in the downtown area. read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Reuben - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

Clearly underrated based on the average. Clean trendy tavern with basic fare (burgers seafood and three types of steak) I had the main burger and it was one of the most satisfying and underrated burgers I've had. It held together but was like a gourmet version of those irreplaceable ones you might get from a drive in diner. Fries were fantastic. Also an above average wedge salad I would Definately come back! read more

Mahi over cooked like rubber Perch overpriced had bones Tuna was also cooked not just seared Location is nice read more

The Ahi tuna plate was amazing. I asked for all the extras on the side, and it was plated so nicely. Janice was so very kind and helpful. The tuna was sesame crusted, had two dips, a Wasabi that took my breath away (in a good way) and a 2nd sauce. I mixed them and thought that was terrific. I wasn't a fan of the pineapple. It wasn't ripe enough and had no taste. I don't do soy, so I nixed the edamame. I do very little gluten, so I ate a few of the fried wonton strips. Not my favorite. Oh, and the was a little side of slice avocado. The entire meal was divine. I haven't been able to find ahi like this since I left W MI in 2019, so this was a real find. Janice was a gem. Shout out to her. All in all, we left feeling "finer than frog hair." I'll be back! read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Maui Ahi plate - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

See all

Fun Bar and Food in New Baltimore! We had 8 of us and they took reservations for us the day before. Seated immediately and offered drinks right away which is the service you want!! Small but good menu. The calimari app was nice and crispy. They add some crispy banana peppers in for a good taste. We had the perch..very good. But kinda expensive. $28.00. The Bleu Burger...which was excellent!!! The Wedge salad...very good! The shrimp scampi was very good but it could have used a little more shrimp with the amount of pasta you get. Drinks were healthy. Very nice atmosphere. read more

See all

Food was pricey with marginal preparation and taste. Service was excellent. Decor was classy, bricky, woody, though the street level floor plan was odd and cramped. I felt like I was eating in a New York vestibule. A strange English-type lift/stairway has a footprint that eats up a huge portion of the first floor, hence the cramped dining. I had the Maui Ahi Tuna Salad (see pic). It was uninspired with chunks of mottled Iceberg lettuce. Who would plate this? C'mon dude, for $23 you can't mix in some romaine? Someone's smoking the Maui Wow-wee! Basically, apathetic. Won't hurry back. read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Apathetic Maui Ahi Tuna Salad with mottled Iceberg lettuce. - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

Ordered the steak bites and couldn't eat them they smelled and tasted sour. The manager did offer something new but my appetite was spoiled. Also my mother in law had a steak and it was the same way looked grey like it had been in water then put in grill. Salad was good, very disappointing read more

Food was really good, sat outside on the rooftop. Nice little place to eat. Service was very nice, our server was nice and not a bother. read more

See all

This is one of the finest place to eat in Macomb county. Parking is rough in New Baltimore but the food and service at Finns is worth the hassle. read more

We got lucky finding this gem. Great water views, food and service. Ordered walleye fish plate and a French Dip sandwich. Both were very good. read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Nice water view from upper deck - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

Seafood pasta is my favorite but everything I've tried here is amazing! The service is always quick and the staff is so welcoming.

Wife suggested we go here on Father's Day. Ahi tuna bites were very good, we split the mahi mahi dinner and it was also good. Our server Chris was polite, funny, and attentive. Good job crew! read more

One of all around favorites. Great food and service. A nice high end menus with something for everyone. Their tuna appetizer is to die for!! read more

Really great service. Our server was on point and kept checking to make sure we had everything we needed. Above average fish and chips too. We had been craving some and they did not disappoint. read more

This was my first time really exploring the downtown New Baltimore area, and there are so many cute and quaint restaurant spots downtown New Baltimore. Such a nice area, and right off of the water. One of my co-workers suggested to dine at Fin's. So a few of us decided to check it out after work. I enjoyed the food (I wish I had pictures), but the group ordered appetizers (Spinach and Artichoke Dip, Chicken Tenders, Chicken Quesadillas and Bang Bang Shrimp). The appetizers were really good. A few people in the group tried the Cream of Asparagus soup, and raved about it so much. So they really enjoyed the soup! We also ordered and shared a Michigan Salad, which was good as well! So overall a really good experience and good service! I would like to go back to try other menu options and actually take pictures next time around . I did take one picture of my he martini that I ordered, it was a Raspberry and Lemon Martini. Which was nice! And I was able to snag a fun picture of the Skeleton Barbie outside or the restaurant. read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

See all

Went here last Friday night around 7 pm they were out of almost everything we wanted to order even dessert our first time trying this place and it will be our last time read more

Went here for an anniversary dinner this past weekend. Started with the escargot appetizer, which was the highlight of the meal from my perspective. I don't think I've seen them served de-shelled before, but I appreciated not having to pull them out myself. The buttery sauce was great, and the bread served with them was great. I asked which of their salad dressing were made in-house and they said two of them, including the ranch. So I got the ranch, and kind of regretted it. It was very watery - ranch should be thick, sticking to the salad and with a creamy mouth feel - this ranch did not meet any of those criteria. The salad was fresh, though, and they let me customize which veggies I wanted on it, which I appreciated. The prime rib was pretty good. The seasoning was great on the prime rib. At the price point, though, I would have expected a bit better. I ordered medium rare, it came out medium. I would have expected some au jus to come with it - some of the bites were a bit on the dry/tough side. The most seasoned bites were also the gristle and fat, unfortunately. I scraped off some of the seasoning from the gristle and wiped in on the dry bites. We wanted to have a bit of fun after our dinner, so we went upstairs, only to be told that they were closing (it was "last call" at 8:50pm on a Friday night). How odd to have a beautiful upstairs patio with a view of the lake and to have it close that early. Due to its location, this place will always have no shortage of business, but I don't think I'd return if I find myself in New Baltimore again. read more

Restaurant has a nice atmosphere / location. Food is always served within a reasonable amount of time. Wait staff is always very friendly.

We stopped in while the farmers market was going on with 3 adults and 4 kids. Everything was clean and our waitress was great. Food was well cooked and none of us had any issues. Even the kids are their food. Would definitely recommend. read more

We came here after visiting a new spot across the street. This restaurant came highly recommend by the bartenders. It was pretty busy for a cold Thursday night! We sat at the bar and I decided to order another drink. We wanted some food and decided on the Finwhich. It was described as "large"... perfect, we will split it. Well we weren't expecting what came out! Holy smokes. It wasn't large, it was huge! Like we didn't know how to even eat it. It came with a spicy sauce that was too hot for my taste buds, but the breading on the chicken was amazing! Also... pickles!!! I love pickles so this also made me happy. I didn't really eat any of it other than a bite. But it was so big that half needed to be boxed up to go! Our bartender was super friendly. We discussed her career options and we were able to give her a bit of advice on which route to take. She told us there is a second floor dining area that is only open on weekends and a rooftop bar that's open in the summer. I love rooftop bars so I can't wait to check it out! This downtown area is only 15 mins from my house so I'm sure we will be frequenting it this summer! Cheers! read more

See all

The food is delicious. I ordered carry out, been there a couple times. Service is great. Will totally return there

Open until 8PM. They are not busy tonight. They don't take reservations either. Cozy inside. Nautical themed decor. Ordered a Caesar with salmon, scallops with veggies and a side salad, baked Brie and a crab cake apps as well. Had to ask for a clean knife. Large party came in right before 8PM and ordered just shortly before 8PM as well. The crab cake with the remoulade was good. The baked brie with apples, pecans, honey and dried cherries with butter toast points went good. The toast points were buttery, crunchy too. Gets quite sticky with the honey. The side salad is too little for the size of the bowl. The Caesar salad is topped with a ton of croutons. The salmon is well done, the salmon and Caesar is decent, but not special. The scallops are nicely cooked and tasty. Decent food and service. $80.36 for our bill tonight. read more

See all

After my grandfathers funeral today we had a very large group and Alexa, Jess and Grace were wonderful. They gave beyond exceptional service and they were so organized the entire time. Also when I went down stairs, Chris the bartender was so kind and welcoming. It was my first time here and it definitely won't be my last. Also they have an elevator for anyone that needs assistance and I thought that was amazing, especially since many relatives of mine needed that to enjoy our night. Thank you for making our rough day a wonderful night. read more

Excellent friendly service! We sat at the bar. Our lady bartender was very attentive and great with some food suggestions. I've never been here before and I will be coming back. read more

See all

Went here for a bite to eat after another restaurant up that way had closed early. Has a small outdoor eating area, bar area, and cozy seating although may have more in back. It was a little confusing as there were things that they were out of that we ordered - oysters and green beans (see surprise broccoli). Very much enjoyed my pasta dish with a glass of wine. Pleasant servie in spite of condition. Nice spot to stop. read more

See all

I love it here. The Brie appetizer is my go to every time! I have never had any issues with the staff and the food is always good

Posting new menu. Food is good. Service is good. Ambiance is good on the rooftop and inside. read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

See all

Average food and average service. Calamari needs to be crispier, not soft and mushy :( Prices are a tad high for what you get but the location dictates that I'm sure. Rooftop bar that has live music at times. Gets busy on the weekends. They should have a text msg service instead of making you stand around and check in occasionally (for :45). Nice park on the water nearby to kill time at. read more

We celebrated a birthday dinner at fins last week and they seated us underneath the stairs, so as we're sitting there and people would go up and down the stairs we realized that you could see right up the ladies dresses We could see the buts and the crouches. We were totally shocked! So I asked to see the owner he came out and said that he did tell his girls that they should wear longer pants and I looked at him and said what about the customer no one told them going up the stairs - it's clear glass so you can see right up the ladies dresses. And he did not seem to care about the customer! There was seven of us that won't be coming back and all the friends we will be telling it's just not fair. Minus 1 star. read more

The food was outstanding with exception of the side salad. Service A+. Ambiance was a bit noisy. However, best restaurant I've eaten at in a year. I'll be back. read more

I ordered the Pasta Carlo with Shrimp. It was so good and a great portion. I upgraded my side salad to a Caesar it was very good as well.

The Food was excellent and the staff was great. Especially the fish Salmon / Perch was excellent read more

Food and service were excellent! Love the location. We were glad for this recommendation and have told others about it. read more

This is Second time my wife and I purchased 2 carry out Cobb salads and there wasn't any dressing when we got home. When I called up there they told me they could gove me 5% off the next bill. Don't get carry out from them read more

Saturday evening first night eating out in a long time. I ordered fettuccini with shrimp and scallops. It was just tossed in a butter lemon garlic stock type sauce. Very watery. Small shrimp too. Wifey had the ribs and she also was underwhelmed. Our friend had another pasta dish and he also said it was bland. No bread bowl with a 22 dollar meal either. really was hoping for more to support local. Cool location. Cool building read more

It's May! We decided to stop for lunch at this up vibe tavern/restaurant for lunch. All local ingredients. I started out with hot homemade mushroom soup loaded with delicious huge mushrooms, finis lunch with the Michigan chicken salad with a generous side dish of homemade blue cheese dressing. The salad included hot grilled moist and juicy chicken, Michigan dried cherries, pecans, red onion, sliced green apples and an assortment of crunchy/crispy greens. You won't be disappointed! Oh, in keeping with the Michigan vibe, had a draft Bell's Two-Hearted ale. Now for the nap! read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - See my description above. Service by Christine and others was very pleasant and attentive. - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

We enjoy this local restaurant. Outdoor seating in the summer and the food is very good. The best menu items are escargot, spinach artichoke dip, pasta carlo, fish and chips, walleye, pot pie (super amazing) and steak tips. They have really cool specialty drinks, it's clean and atmosphere is nice. Generally speaking the service is amazing.. last summer we did have a crabby bartender :P ...but for the most part, the waitresses are amazing. read more

I have eaten at Fin's about 100 times in the past 7 years and the food has always been consistently good! Perch, wedge salad and clam chowder are my favorites! The seafood dishes have become more upscale the past year and I loved every one I tried! Beautiful decor inside and wait staff is great! The downtown New Baltimore area is also beautiful! The only recommendation is to improve on craft cocktails. So I have to give it 4 stars only because of that. read more

We spent the day at the new Baltimore park beach with the grandparents. We decided to order a Fin's carry out for lunch. We ordered two cod sandwiches with extra tartar sauce and one po boy sandwich. The cod sandwiches had NO tartar sauce. It definitely needed some it had no flavor and was pretty disappointing. It was a decent walk to go back to get some and with toddlers not so easy. The Po boy was like an open face sandwich, two pieces of Garlic bread with 3 shrimp on each. For $16 it was definitely lacking. The bread was hard the shrimp was okay. We should've known better but we took a chance seeing as their restaurant name is "Fin's." Such a bummer. No desire to go back. Definitely didn't deserve the $10 tip they received. read more

While staying in Anchor Bay, visiting family for Thanksgiving, I thought I'd treat them to a local establishment on Washington Street. Their food is wonderful, the service is great and it has a relaxing atmosphere. Only drawback was the calamari, which was a bit flavorless. It wasn't overcooked, but it was frozen and not fresh from the seafood market. I would go back for their delicious wedge salad, one of the best and most certainly, the best looking! I highly recommend this place! read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Wedge salad - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

See all