I have eaten at Fin's about 100 times in the past 7 years and the food has always been consistently good! Perch, wedge salad and clam chowder are my favorites! The seafood dishes have become more upscale the past year and I loved every one I tried! Beautiful decor inside and wait staff is great! The downtown New Baltimore area is also beautiful! The only recommendation is to improve on craft cocktails. So I have to give it 4 stars only because of that. read more

This is Second time my wife and I purchased 2 carry out Cobb salads and there wasn't any dressing when we got home. When I called up there they told me they could gove me 5% off the next bill. Don't get carry out from them read more

While staying in Anchor Bay, visiting family for Thanksgiving, I thought I'd treat them to a local establishment on Washington Street. Their food is wonderful, the service is great and it has a relaxing atmosphere. Only drawback was the calamari, which was a bit flavorless. It wasn't overcooked, but it was frozen and not fresh from the seafood market. I would go back for their delicious wedge salad, one of the best and most certainly, the best looking! I highly recommend this place! read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Wedge salad - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

See all

A former Oxford Inn of Royal Oak Establishment No more needed to say Order the ribs if you are not in the know read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

See all

We went in for a late lunch. We had two servers, the first was gruff but the second was nice. The food was good. I had the fish sandwich and my partner had the perch dinner. The fish sandwich was especially good. My main complaint is with the price of the beer. A Stella is $8! That is more than most of the wines on the menu. I'm also complaining about it because the beer list doesn't include prices. Please add prices to the drink menu so people aren't caught off guard with high priced beers! read more

The service was very good. The food was awesome. All of us enjoyed it very much. The upstairs outside patio looks amazing. Unfortunately it was too windy to sit there. Next time for sure!! read more

I wish it was better... I want to love this place, but can't. The kitchen is inconsistent, as is the service. "Rare" prime rib can sometimes be had, other times they serve it medium well, and call it rare, dried out and nasty. Baked potatoes are often under cooked. Burgers are horrible, and seem like they start out their life in the kitchen as a frozen patty. The shrimp po boy is equally as bad (way too much bread, the bread is hard, not enough shrimp). Chicken pot pie is devoid of chicken (and it costs something like $18!... you'd think they could put a few cubes of chicken with some gravy under a damn puff pastry for $18!). Their old fashioned is one of the worst I've ever had (I will gladly make you a proper one... and would gladly make mine myself if you set the ingredients on the bar...), and they lied when they said that their margaritas are made with fresh lime juice... They're not. What is good? Fish specials are generally good. Bang bang shrimp is delicious. Prime rib is good, when it's cooked right. Spanish coffees are delicious. Club sandwich is good, but nix that Texas toast... way too much bread. Don't sit by the high top near the bathroom, you'll hear nothing but drama. Apparently Jesse got sent home, and Chelsea kept seating the section, even though there's no one serving it, and some 50 year old waitress with an ankle tat thinks its the worst thing in the world that she worked a double on Saturday, and she's back to work on Sunday... while that damn Jesse got the day off... Save your drama, your customer's do not need to hear it. Your shit attitude, and constant bitching is costing you tips. read more

I've been here a handful of times during the past year-ish or so and it's always been great. Normally come on Sunday morning for the bloody mary bar and brunch. I've always found the service and cleanliness of the place to be completely acceptable. Nothing that wowed me in any way, but certainly serviceable or better. Breakfast items are reasonably priced but lunch and dinner items can start getting pricey. I typically order the 2 eggs and meat breakfast which also comes with hash-browns and toast. Not hard to mess that up. It's good but nothing to rave over. the BM bar is great, 2 you break even on the cost, any more than that your doing yourself a favor. they have great toppings and options on the bar, so you cant complain there! read more

Great spot! Never had a bad meal or service. I have been here a dozen plus times for work and personal meals. The cheeseburger soup is the best I have had, hands down. The wraps and sandwiches are great! I highly recommend this spot if you are in town! read more

We had a fabulous dinner at Fins it is my third visit bag we come by boat and park in the new Baltimore public marina. Bob has really made us some special things over our last three visits. We love Bob and we Love Fins!! read more

See all

A neighborhood sport bar, a place to get above average dining for a small town? How about a place to come after work? This is a fine establishment that doesn't overreach. They provide great fare for the local clientle and for those passing through. The ribs. To die for. Alfredo Carlo to die for. Blackened salmon? To die for. And a good beer menu. Hey, cant have it all. It's a charming place, larger than you would think. You can even sit in a patio out front and dine, if the weather is polite. read more

Excellent! Sat in the upper deck and enjoyed a beautiful view and afternoon lunch. Everyone loved their food and drinks! French dip full of meat, walleye, finch and tuna salad. All delicious. Alexa provided great service too! read more

I'm gonna start with I used to not like this place. Forced into carry out group order, the food was pretty damn impressive. Meet friends for lunch and boy has this place changed. The food and the service are on point. I felt like I was Birmingham. With the deck and refresh I see many visits this summer! read more

Sad sad.. this place needs some management.. disorganized.. poor bartender is actually a waitress.. kitchen is disorganized.. and the manager walks back and forth!!! 3rd times a strike!!! Asked for another Bloody Mary ... they were out of mix.. brought everything at once.. hubby had fish and chips... greasy as hell and I got their special of pasta.. noodles were hard. Shrimp was fishy.. last time we will be back.. sorry.. used to he a great place.. someone needs to get it together... read more

The salad was good.... but the pieces of lettuce were huge... you definitely had to chop it yourself. My friend and I ordered the surf and turf. It's NYE. The turf was like eating turf. There was a piece I couldn't chew. The loaded potato tasted like it had been sitting out and reheated. Then I ordered a coffee, which was cold and they didn't have a coffee cup available. So it was served in a cocktail glass. Also the surf was supposed to be 4 oz... it was more like 2. First and last time here. $70.00 just for mine. I did have a drink and a glass of wine. Definitely not worth those prices. read more

Awesome view of the bay. Had excellent service and very good food at the rooftop bar.

Excellent dining experience. Food was fresh and hot. Service was on top of it even as busy as they were. Great menu too. AAA+++

Great food and great service. We visit multiple times per month and have never had a negative experience. Fins is my favorite!

Average place to eat. Most stuff is pretty good. Don't get the booze drinks that have milk in them.

Excellent experience at Fin's. Slightly pricey, but it is well worth it. The drinks and food were great, as was the service.

Fries were drenched in oil and fish was undercooked, batter was soggy Nasty! Nice roof top deck, very limited menu you'd expect they at least take pride in what little they do offer. read more

I've been here a handful of times during the past year-ish or so and it's always been great. However, when I came here for dinner this past Saturday, it left a lot to be desired. I'm not picky when it comes to where I sit. Like, at all. Booth or table? Doesn't matter. Inside or outside? Wherever you have room is fine. But when the patio is absolutely coated in fish flies, reeks of decaying something and the heat is quite intense, I do mind being told by the hostess as soon as we request a table for two, "You HAVE to sit outside." Now, the place was decently packed, but I could clearly see that there were one or two smaller tables being turned, which I assumed we could have been sat at if the hostess requested us to wait x amount of minutes for an inside seat. Then comes our waitress. Like I said, it was packed, but the lady who was serving us was definitely scattered. First, she gave us water and left for 10 mins. Then came back, took my partner's beer order - a tall Two-Hearted - and left for another 10. And this repeated. All. Night. Long. But when she did come back with his beer, it was a short instead of a tall. If you're having a busy night, that's an easy mistake - but it's also easy to fix. It's too bad the waitress didn't notice until my partner said, "Could I please have another TALL Two-Hearted?" Though he declined the free short beer she offered because he was driving, it was brought anyways. Kind of...rude, in my opinion. And lastly, our dinner. It was nothing special. I got the shrimp alfredo and my partner got the cod. My shrimp were juuuuust about done, but I requested them to be cooked a bit longer. Oh, well. At least they were cooked. And his cod was kinda soggy and flavorless. Again, nothing special. This specific visit doesn't deserve more than 3 stars, in my opinion. It wasn't awesome, but it definitely could have been or gotten worse. I will update my review the next time I'm here. read more

See all

Five star food and service! Never disappointed when we visit Fins! Cant wait for patio to open this spring

I am a creature of habit and once I find a dish, as infrequently as I eat downtown New Baltimore, I generally stick with it. The fettuccine Alfredo with salmon is excellent! The consistency is staggering and I love going someplace to eat where I can expect the salmon to be cooked perfectly every single time! Also, I am a big fan of their clam chowder! read more

The food was good and I thought it was a little pricey, waitress could've been nicer. We sat outside for dinner during the week. She did find out about some gluten free options for me, which was helpful. When we got our salads, it was like she threw them in front of us. I was a little taken back. Maybe she was in a rush to get to the other table?? Idk. read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

See all

We brought our pups and ate on the patio. They were very nice and welcoming and brought them a bowl of water. The food was excellent! Wish we came here earlier in our trip read more

Oh boy where to start I have eaten here before about 6 months ago it was pretty good anyway went there for my birthday today different story I am a FOOD SERVICE SPECIALIST taken many courses on food safety (servesafe) and some first I ordered fish and chips greasy fish no flavor fries were soggy also fried in the same oil as the fish. My daughter who has a fish allergy got chicken tenders that were also fried in fish oil she boxed it up looked at me we paid and left (shes ok took her medication) the other is where was the manager why was this going on inside the kitchen then I got home sick to my stomach I don't need to say anymore I was with 4 others who all have stomach issues after this cross contamination big time all the food was fried in the same oil read more

Nothing but great food and great service! Lots of delicious specialty drinks as well to go with your meal!

This is a neat place but we came here for mimosas and breakfast. The mimosas were just okay; a little too much OJ. We had to have the second ones with just a little OJ. The breakfast was overpriced for what I got. We asked for bacon to be crispy and had to send it back. Hash-browns were good. The patio is cute and it's a great location. I'd go back for a cocktail, but I think it's over priced for food and service could definitely improve. read more

See all

First time at Fin's, my wife and I live in Algonac, and was told the Restaurant had great food and service. We started with a wonderful hostess, she explained there was an upstairs (With/View), but we opted for downstairs. We had the best waitress, she asked us for drinks, choice, and explained the specials and menu. We started with spinach and artichoke dip (starter) came with toasted French bread, by far the best we have ever had. I also ordered the clam chowder also, the best l have had. What makes this a 5-Star is the personal contact, we had with owners/manager, wanting to make sure of a positive experience. We already have our next lunch or dinner planned, I want to try there onion soup and my wife wants to try there chicken quesadilla. We love this place, and felt at home. read more

A group of us went to Fin's. We ordered a variety of items, from cheeseburgers, and Prime Rib to oysters. All of the food was prepared perfectly. The service was outstanding, even though it was very busy. I highly recommend Fin's as a fun and delicious place to eat. We took a walk down to the park after dinner. It was perfect. read more

Love this spot! They have an amazing caprese sandwich... I'd literally have it everyday of my life. It's SOOOOO good! They have nice staff whether you have kiddos or not and their upstairs seating is pretty cool. We've brought friends and family there and everyone is always leaving satisfied. Great work! read more

What a great dinner tonight! Alexyss was fabulous! Great Spanish Coffee and great service. The food was also great.

Food and service were both very good. French onion soup and French dip were delicious! read more

Nice place on Main Street in New Baltimore. Lots of fish and shrimp, good tap selection and really nice bottle beer selection. I had the corned beef, very good, the fries are super thin-I prefer a thicker cut but that's just me, they tasted fine. Service was prompt and polite including a visit from the manager. Historic building, once the Anchor Bay Pharmacy. Simple decor of historic pictures and shiny car body parts. We will be back. read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - people sitting at the bar - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

The manager could be less of a jack ass. Other than that the food is good! I felt like I was treated like an idiot when I had brought the wrong purse and didn't have my cards on me but I had Apple Pay, he spoke to me as if I was a broke idiot and his demeanor was quite rude. I'm the type of person who is quick to have a solution to a problem and I offered one, and he still treated me like some idiot and it was very unnecessary. I actually came to here to apply for a interview before for a job that I didn't even need just to make my mom happy, I have lots of money saved. And this fool treated me like some broke idiot when very time I come in there I tip over 20%. read more

Shared 1/2 corned beef sandwich, cup of clam chowder along with a roast beef sandwich. Beef came with homemade chips that were pretty good. The rest of the food didn't disappoint either. Service was very slow and it was freezing inside. read more

We started with calamari which was amazing! We are calamari connoisseurs. Lol Alexa was our waitress. She was awesome. Drinks were not strong my friend had the cucumber Fresca. She didn't taste alcohol in hers and I barely did in mines. However my drink was tasty. Lol. The white fish was amazing! I also had a side of green beans. They were bland looking so I added lemon, salt and pepper and they were perfect. Tasted better than a restaurant I tried in Birmingham, MI. Fish and chips was delicious! They originally put a scoop of fries on the plate which appeared to be the bottom of the bag initially but Alexa replaced them right away! I'll just make sure to have a few drinks before I go to the restaurant or after I leave. Customer service was great and the food matched. I would definitely return. read more

We haven't been here in a while and I was in the mood for some good food. And I love their cosmos. They did not let me down. This is got to be the best salmon I've ever had. I love the rice with it. And yes that calamari was as good as it looks. read more

Fin's Eatery & Spirits - Calamari - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

See all

I had won a gift card to Fin's at a golf outing. We finally got there to use it and we were very impressed. Nice spot right by the water, bars upstairs and on the main floor, cool decor with great wood details, great food, and excellent service. Reasonable prices as well. We will definitely go back when we are in the area. read more