Had a wonderful experience until we asked for more rolls with our dinner and we're surprised when we got our bill and we're charged for them. We have never been somewhere where they charged us for asking for more bread. read more

Great experience overall. Slow service & food was mediocre. There were quite a few things on the menu that tickled my fancy; however, the apricot/cajun salmon spoke to me. Portion sizes are generous, so order accordingly! Salmon was pretty good but not spectacular. I was lucky enough to sit outside and had an amazing view which was so lovely. Their drinks are pretty good & they have a decent selection of beers, if that's your thing. I tried one of their fruity concoctions & wasn't disappointed. Overall experience was great but don't get your hopes up with the food. If you're a food snob like me, you probably won't be blown away. read more

Fireside Tavern - Bars Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

We are in town on a cycling tour and stopped in here for dinner. Very large, covid friendly outdoor dining area. Our server Megan was fabulous. We all enjoyed our dinners. Highlight was the apricot salmon. The blackened rub sandwich was also very good. read more

Nice restaurant with tasty food. Best to make reservations! Love the blackened prime rib sandwich. Was sad when I called for a take out order of blackened prime rib sandwich and was told that my take out order would not be started for an hour. They get busy! Need more help?? read more

If you are looking for excellent service, food, and atmosphere, Fireside is the place to be. The owners and staff are passionate and caring and treat all guests with respect from the moment they walk through the door. The Fireside stays busy so it is best to make reservations if possible. The bartenders are quick and personable and are always coming up with delicious new combos. Also, if you are gluten free, you will not be disappointed! They have a wide variety of gluten free options and if it's not already gluten free, they can most likely prepare it that way if requested! They also have several great spaces for larger events and their prices are competitive and reasonable! I highly recommend the Fireside Tavern for an overall wonderful dining experience! read more

This restaurant is beautiful both inside and outside. The food completely matches the decor and the service is exceptional. Make sure you try to Tavern fries they are the best that I have ever had. The Catfish Jambalaya was superb and unlike any other jambalaya I've had before. If I lived nearby I would frequent this place multiple times a month. You won't be disappointed. read more

My husband and I, always enjoy dining here! We are greeted well and the wait staff, are so attentive.

Excellent food, excellent service...warm and inviting atmosphere...a definite must on our next trip to Strasberg!

Delicious food. The lightful weight staff. I highly recommend getting reservations ahead of time. It is worth it. Every time we are in town, we have dinner or lunch at this restaurant. read more

Food was excellent! Service was exceptional! Can't ask for much more than that. I love it when servers automatically fill up your glass and you barely notice because they don't bother to ask, they just do the right thing! read more

Wonderful meal, great atmosphere and service! We really enjoyed the mussels. The steak was delicious too'

It was so good we went back the next night during our weekend trip. The food was wonderful and we were able to try several different cocktails from the extensive drink menu, all of which were delicious. The second night we all got a dessert and they were also amazing. The restaurant itself is cozy, especially all decorated for Christmas. Staff was friendly and accommodating. 5 stars all around! read more

We have enjoyed the Fireside from the time they opened. Lovely atmosphere - classy but comfortable. I've enjoyed everything I've had there. Really enjoy their outside deck as well. One of my favorites! read more

Huge serving sizes of tasty food. Enjoyed the homemade onion rings. Bar area was a little loud but iverall enjoyed our meal.

Great onion rings, Great burgers, great fish sandwich. Defiantly a great place to eat.

Got takeout last week and we'll do it again tomorrow. Love their chili"got 2 qts for future " Crab cakes were terrific. True Md crab cakes. No filler. Love you guys. Don't forget to tip the staff read more

We had a most enjoyable evening at the fireside Tavern. I had a group of approximately 14 people for drinks and dinner. Everyone agreed that the food was fantastic. We were amazed at the service, given the large group that we had. I don't think our waiter wrote down any of our orders, but they came out perfectly, the fireside Tavern is a lovely place to have dinner out with family or friends. The drink offerings are really great and out of the ordinary I highly recommend it. read more

I have never posted a Yelp review, but for a pricier restaurant, this was one of the worst meals we've ever ordered. The $40+ twin crab cake plate came with two small crab cakes and mushy vegetables (see attached). The $20+ black bean burger was a frozen patty that was microwaved until it was too hard to even take a bite, the lettuce was black around the edges, and the bun was stale. There was a small, black HAIR in the vegetables. The chicken wings, salmon, and burgers were mediocre. The fries and fish tacos were good, otherwise, I would try to give 0 stars. read more

See all

Food is like cafeteria, weak french fries with that coating, chicken tenders meh, bloody mary not sure what the deal was, I've had them all over the country and i could not stomach the smokey flavor, less liquid smoke more v8 needed, I'm pretty sure the pickle that was in there wasn't the one advertised, waitress was friendly and attentive. I guess when you cater to the seniors you don't get to many cretics. Crab cake was stellar. read more

All in all I had a pleasant dinner experience here. It was your typical ordinary American food restaurant. Decent food. Friendly staff. Clean and welcoming atmosphere. No complaints. However, the only reason I'm giving 4 starts instead of 5 is because nothing about my experience wowed me or "knocked my socks off". If you're looking for a casual, upscale Cracker Barrel this is your place! I would definitely eat here again but I don't know that it'd be my first choice as I've eaten at many places that have gone above and beyond! read more

Fireside Tavern - Apricot Salmon with Vegetable of the Day and Rice - Bars Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

Came here for a wedding after-party. The guests were the only people here and it was nice to have a place to have a few drinks and finish off the night. The Astarte was great even with how late it was. Thanks for making a great night even better! read more

This was a nice place inside. The service was a bit slow for not having a whole lot of tables. Although our waitress was really sweet. We tried the famous turtle soup, and it was good. The meals were pretty good, but some of the people in our party were not able to get mash since they ran out of it. We all had steaks and steak salads. They meats were delicious and they were all cooked very well. I do think the place was a bit overpriced but overall we had a good dinner. read more

We made reservations but we're attempting to get outside dining. I was told that it's first come first serve for that area. So we went a little earlier to attempt that. However, once arrived we were informed they aren't doing outside seatings at all as like most places now, they are short staffed. Wished they'd have told me that on the phone. Luckily I made those reservations for inside as a back up (the older I get the wiser to always make back up plans. Keep that in mind so that these places don't rock your precious, valuable fun time). The restaurant was a good pick. Nicely decorated, clean, comfortable, and we were quickly seated. The waiter was exceptionally good. Very professional but not snooty. Our drinks came quickly followed by our appetizer at just the perfect time. Then our salads arrived a little later and 15 more minutes our main meals. It was like clock work. Bravo! The food was definitely delicious, nothing overly grand but presented well and flavorful. Two of us had the braised beef which was tender and didn't even need to be cut, with mashed potatoes that were an average staple style. The nacho plater was packed with meat, cheese, peppers, etc. The side salad fresh and the typical mix of greens. Desserts were good too but the basic manufactured ones like one can buy in the frozen section at the grocery store. I had peanut butter pie that I liked but was too full to eat it all (a good portion). The apple crisp was descent too but not as crispy as preferred. We were there catching up with extended family after not seeing them for over a year so we lingered a bit long, although we weren't rushed at all (they had a few empty tables so we didn't feel we needed to depart quickly). Over all a good experience. We recommend it when in the Lancaster area. read more

If you happen to be staying at one of the two hotels Fireside Tavern is planted between, you must dine here. Even if you're not, like I was, try to stop by anyways. My family and I chose to dine outdoors for lunch here. Their seating outside is under a beautiful willow tree that provides just enough shade on a summer day. On top of that, the food and service was good. Highly recommend the mussels, as they were a table favorite. read more

Fireside Tavern - Mussels appetizer. Table favorite! - Bars Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Food was excellent, our hotel recommended the restaurant. The place was really nice. My only complaint was we were eating the appetizers and before we were even finished they brought us the main meal. I wished they gave us a bit more time to enjoy the first course before the main. The service was wonderful. Would definitely go back hopefully they give people a chance to enjoy all the courses. read more

Wow, such great food. We ordered two really different dishes (crab cakes and ribs) and they were both perfect. Wonderful little place to grab a meal, and if you're in town, I suggest it. read more

Great atmosphere and the food was amazing. It's a great place to hang out after a good meal.

Very nice restaurant in middle of farmers and buggy rides The bar is very nice - set up away from the restaurant- Very good food !! read more

This is a very nice tavern. The food portions were huge and very well made. The ceasar dude salad was a meal on its self. The hogues are filled to the brim with meat and extremely tasty. Ur waitress was very pleasant but she was not all that attentive to us as she also worked the bar. Our experience here was very good and would highly recommend coming here. read more

See all

We had a great experience here. It was kid friendly, the food was good, our server was friendly and helpful. Try the tomato soup it was delicious! read more

My husband and I decided to try this place while we were in PA. We were told the wait would be 40 minutes, it ended up being around 20 so that's good. Staff was friendly and food was alright. I was expecting more from the new burger on the menu the one with bacon jam. It hit the spot but sometimes missing. The fries definitely weren't as good as they could have been, lacked on flavor, but cooked well. I wish I could remember the name of the amaretto drink I had, that was delish. read more

Fireside Tavern - Kids menu - Bars Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Food was excellent. Service was attentive and helpful. Ambiance was a cross between old pub in new building and neighborhood bar. A little hard to find initially read more

Nice place (for rural PA). Coming from DC, I would prefer kids Mac and Cheese to be not from the box and for apple crisp to be at least as good as what I can make, but I guess I have high standards. Very nice draft beer selection though! read more

This place is absolutely wonderful!! We come here twice a year when we camp nearby. The drinks are excellent and the food is very good too!!! The service is wonderful. The staff is so nice! Love it read more

Was in town for an event staying at the adjacent Holiday Inn Express and decided to walk here for dinner. 3 of us ate and I think the bill was around $125. Value and ambience were great. Service wasn't horrible but was a little rough around the edges, hence the 4 star instead of 5. All in all I'd stop again when I'm in town. read more

I have always enjoyed this establishment. I will be going next Friday for my wedding anniversary. I can't wait to see what the specials are.

This has been one of my families favorite restaurants for years! I was so excited to see they had a Mother's Day brunch and it did not disappoint. The service was excellent (which is SO hard to find these days) but the food was even better. It's hard to beat hand carved prime rib, but the amazing pork and salmon and shrimp were a close second. And their Maryland style crab soups is the best I have ever had. I am hoping to see a Father's Day brunch soon! read more

Excellent service and good food! The cocktails were also excellent. We ordered the New Fashion and it didn't disappoint.

The Fireside Tavern seems to be a consistent place to get a meal, but you will not be overwhelmed by anything. It is located at the Clarion Hotel in Historic Strasburg, PA, which is not loaded with dining selections, so the Fireside is a hotspot. They have a large menu and respectable beer selection for PA (read: a few micros in addition to the usual East Coast subjects). The service is good and friendly, which is nice. The noise level is a bit high, though. I love trying chili, so I tackled a "crock" of chili and a cheeseburger in the same sitting. Whoops! Way too much food. The chili was good and bad: chock full of meat but basically flavorless. It needed more spice at the very least. The burger was a 1/2 pound, juicy patty, that was cooked to a perfect medium. Other than the way-to-big bun, it was pretty good. Fireside is decent and a good place when everyone wants a choice. read more

Fireside Tavern - Chili - Bars Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Perfect Lancaster restaurant! Overlooking beautiful Amish farmland and rolling hills, the scenery can't be beat. Everyone in my party got something on the Specials menu, which is updated daily. The drinks were great; variety of craft beers, and unique cocktails. A must-visit on your trip to Lancaster! PS, ask for Ian's homemade blondie brownies. read more

Fireside Tavern - Joe after the best blondie brownie in the state of PA! - Bars Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania