Redemption! I always…read moretry to keep an open mind when visiting a restaurant, especially if it's new. Well, I'm happy to say this one has matured very well. Just walking in, we were warmly greeted, then quickly seated. This place is "picnic style", so you're given menus at your table, but order at the counter (I personally like that vibe). Anyway, we ordered their 1/4 pound, five-meat sampler (pulled pork, pulled chicken, brisket, a competition-style rib and a whole smoked sausage) and they converted me. Everything was nothing short of awesome. Both the pork and chicken were juicy and tender, the brisket this time around was smoked to succulent perfection and the rib was nothing short of excellent (not 'fall off the bone", but with that perfect competition "pull" that really won me over). The sausage I learned was locally sourced and a great compliment to the platter. Enough for two with small appetites to share. The sauce is still in small cups, but as I was told, there had been so much waste left on empty plates, that they had no choice to serve it that way, and I get that. Restaurants run on very thin margins these days. I had the spicy version again and really enjoyed it. Add in some live music played by a couple of good ole boys and since my first visit 9 months ago, this place has turned into a legit Long Island BBQ joint and will now be part of my usual rotation. I still think the hush puppies could have used a few seconds less in the fryer, but the flavor profile was spot on as was the corn fritters. But we left happy and full...I'm glad I was able to get back and try it again. Plenty of parking, all cards and a very laid back experience. Great for families or a stop by while cruising the north fork of Long Island. It's a gotta-go in my opinion. Nicely done!

Stopped in for lunch while we were visiting from Connecticut. We ordered the back plate rib…read morespecial. and wow, was it ever special! We also ordered pulled pork and brisket. Everything was delicious. The smoke flavor was just right and the meat was so tender. The service was friendly and that really makes a difference. After May of 2025 they will have a full bar. There is plenty of parking and a ramp if needed. There's a bar and an eating area. There's also an outside area that looks like it is pet friendly. This is a very nice place. I wish we lived closer.

We had such an amazing dinner here. Sydney was such a fantastic and friendly server who went above…read moreand beyond. The crab Rangoon dip, and fried pickles were delicious appetizers and we loved the sushi and bento boxes. We will be back! Thank you!

I've been to Cowfish a few times, but this visit was so good that I had to write about it…read more The property is gorgeous, located on the South Shore of Long Island in the Hampton Bays. The restaurant is huge and always busy. They have two levels, and while I prefer sitting upstairs, both spaces are great. This time, I tried their New England Clam Chowder for the first time, and it was phenomenal. There wasn't a grain of sand to be found, and it was absolutely loaded with meaty, perfectly cooked, tender clams. The flavor was unforgettable. It managed to be creamy without feeling heavy. You know when a chowder leaves a thick coating of cream in your mouth that lingers long after each bite? This wasn't like that at all, and it was perfect. I also enjoyed the Caesar salad. I've seen it presented this way before, and while it does put a little more work on the diner, it's really not a big deal to use a fork and knife. The lettuce was crisp and cold, the dressing tasted homemade, and the crouton crumble was a game changer. I decided to add the seared blackened scallops, and they were cooked perfectly. The upcharge was a little more than I would have liked for the amount, but it was worth it. After all, who doesn't love a scallop straight from Montauk? That scallop traveled less to get to my plate than I did to get to Hampton Bays. The drinks were festive, the wine was cold, and the atmosphere was lively. It's the perfect place to bring friends and family and have a great time.

The Everest of pizza ,Hot Honey Pepperoni , simple and perfect brick oven fired personal pizza…read more Simone puts all his love in it. Scotto's, a long tradition in the hamptons and an iconic family with roots to our community always delivers the full gamut of Italian cuisine with a warm friendly hand. Here for the weekend , grab a pie (most certainly the perfectly balance Hot Honey Pepperoni) and stock up with the highest quality Italian fare and aged meat.

Local favorite, friendly, clean, lunch specials, little spot to eat outside in a covered arearead more

Great views in Hampton Bays overlooking the water. We stop every time we're on the way to Montauk…read more Food is very good in a casual atmosphere.

I been wanting to come here for years and I finally made it to Rumba! Was it worth the hype and was…read morethe food great? Absolutely yes, and the service and workers here are great. You walk in here and you feel like you're on an island. The food is cart bean inspired and just packing flavor and cooked with love. For appetizers we got the Dominican ribs and sriracha chicken wings! Both appetizers were out of this world. I got a variety of tacos that were awesome. My wife's sister's husband got a burger he loved and his wife got some type of a risotto dish. Everyone's food was great and the drinks were amazing as well. I really loved this place and look forward to coming back. Great place to play the bar and watch sports. They offer valet parking and it is located on shinecock bay with a beautiful view! Great place for summertime eats! I really loved this restaurant and look forward to coming back.

Farm Country Kitchen is one of my favorite local spots and somewhere I find myself coming back to…read moretime and time again. The food is consistently fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared, and the atmosphere is charming and welcoming every single visit. My absolute favorites are the Goat Cheese Bruschetta, the Grilled Strip Steak, the Filet Mignon, and the Chicken Marsala. Every dish is cooked perfectly and made with high-quality ingredients that you can truly taste. Whether you're stopping in for a casual lunch or a special dinner, Farm Country Kitchen doesn't disappoint. If you haven't been yet, you're missing out. Highly recommend!

I used to come here all the time and tonight reminded me why. Food is always fresh and delicious…read more Though it's an old building, seating is outside overlooking a beautiful lake which is perfect for a summers day. Friendly and attentive staff and reasonably priced. Truffle Ricotta was a massive hit, creamy and bright. Also seemed to be extremely popular as anyone coming out of the kitchen was carrying a plate of it to bring to a table. Arugula Salad was solid, asked for rare steak and came out perfectly cooked. Pork Chop Milanese was outstanding. Will definitely not be waiting so long to make a return trip.

First time trying this place, steak for the adults, potpies for the kiddos-everything was amazing…read moreand PS- the prices aren't insane for a real butcher shop. Just tried some of the potpie today.... OMGOSH!! I highly recommend this place!! And the potpies!

I really enjoyed the smashburger. When a lot of other places prices have gone up in the last couple…read moreyears center cuts hasn't gone up that much which was one of my criticisms from my last review a couple years ago. All in all a fine butcher & sandwich shop.

What a nice store! Stopped in for a freshly made smashburger after hearing about them and we ended…read moreup getting the "signature burger" and "Justin's burger". Was very surprised when they came out so small literally like sliders. At $12 a piece, even though they came with some fries, I thought the price was high. I do understand we're paying a premium for a burger from a quality butcher but probably wouldn't order again. Although very tasty! Loved the chopped pickles. They have a nice selection of gluten free pasta products from Italy which I hadn't seen before. Got a few of those and some pickles, chips and sauces too. Nicely organized produce section, friendly staff and overall a very nice business to frequent!

Very nice set up. Pleasant staff. Not cheap. We just purchased some side dishes. We have water…read moreburgers from Justin's and they were excellent. Looking forward to trying more of their offerings.

I was craving a hot dog and saw this restaurant nearby. I was pleasantly surprised by just how good…read morethe chili cheese and sauerkraut dogs were! Nothing like a Nathan's dog on a hot day. We also tried the honey bbq wings. They were very delicious and saucy but could be a bit meatier. I would definitely recommend the spicy feta fries to anyone who likes feta! The food came out in 5 minutes or less and the service was perfect. I will be back for sure.

I went to Hampton Gyro for the first time. I made the mistake of ordering at the Riverhead location…read morethrough the app instead of ordering for pick up at the Hampton Bays location. I was running late to get back to work on time and would have gone back to work without lunch. The gentlemen running the counter was extremely helpful. He let me know that he will contact the Riverhead location for me as well as remake my entire order at the correct location. On top of the amazing service the food is amazing!!! I recommend this place to anyone just on how they treat their customers!!! Customer service is truly everything!!!!