Very generously sized lobster roll. Pickle chips yummy and balance the cold from lobster roll. No soup though when I went at 1 on a weekday. Pleasant service. read more

Best, freshest, most delicious lobster rolls (full stop) No contest in the 6+ years I've been making an annual pilgrimage to the great state of Maine. They start with a great product and improve on the classic by adding options to flavor the roll (garlic butter? yes, please!) and lobster (a dash of lemon pepper? yes, please!) . I know the purists out there might be calling sacrilege, but I think these additions accent rather than overpower the unctuous richness of the fresh lobster. Also, while I'm not really one to note the atmosphere of the establishment, the outside of the FC is a bit unassuming and does not belie the airy, quintessential ME interior with long blond communal tables which is quite charming and adds to the experience. read more

Looking for a good old fashioned lobster roll and fried seafood? This is your place. Completely unfussy fresh seafood prepared freshly. Basically everything but the lobster roll is fried, but I"m not saying that's a bad thing. You can get your lobster roll a few different ways - traditional with mayo or with butter, for example. Onion rings and french fries are good as well. It isn't anything special, but when you go to place like this, you aren't looking for special, you're just looking for great seafood, and that's what you get here! read more

This place, which we always called the a-frame, is a fish/lobster market which also has a restaurant attached. The lobsters are excellent. The fried clams are the best I have ever had. You can byob. They are nice and it's suprisngly unbusy, even in summer. The lobster roll is good. Even the French fries are worth having. read more

Fishermen's Catch - The a frame. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

Our first trip here and I was not disappointed with anything except clam cakes. We had lobster roll ($20) and fresh and very generous portion Fries and onion rings were delicious. Fresh made and cooked perfect. Cole slaw was perfect as far as I am concerned. The only disappointing item was the clam cake. Normally I would not give 4 stars if one of the entrees sucked but the exception here is they aren't made there. One of the few things they don't make fresh themselves. When asked on our way out about our meal I honestly answered and told them that clam cakes were seafood flavored breading over cooked. They shouldn't even offer these as they bring down their menu and ratings. Otherwise would go back and avoid clam cakes. Clean place. Lots of raw and cooked food to go in "store" area. Friendly staff. Enjoy! Everything except clam cakes. read more

I usually get lobster rolls at a much more expensive place in Portland, but I'm totally in love with Fisherman's Catch. I think I paid $12 for this beautiful gargantuan sandwich. They use a light hand with the mayo so you get a ton of lobster flavor, and give you choices on how you want your bun. Best of all, I waited 5 minutes for my lobster roll--compared to 15 minutes at the place in Portland. Also: it should be noted that this place is half restaurant-half seafood store. I picked up four 1.25 lb lobsters for only $20! I love my Portland place, but Fisherman's Catch runs a close second. I can't want to come back next summer. read more

A fairly mediocre lobster roll. Hot dog bun that was grilled with plenty of lobster meat, but mostly was claw scraps vs meaty tail etc. bun got soggy. Frozen fries were fine. Can get a better lobster roll and hand cut fries down the road at bobs. Was fine, but with options for your lobster roll this is certainly not special. read more

I've been going to this place for years and live locally. I can't complain about the food but do want to say that I was very disappointed with the 3 young men that were joking around and making fun of the people who were being socially respectful and wearing face coverings. They were not wearing any and had no gloves on while preparing food. I called my order in and had to wait for them to stop joking around before one of the young men, who seemed put out, decided to wait on me. I won't return until I know there are some kind of safety precautions in place and the employees take things a little more seriously. It's sad that this establishment will lose my business for now. read more

Awesome!!! No frills, fresh as it gets. Live lobsters, fresh scallops, great steamers. The Haddock sandwich was gargantuan! My seafood hating child loved the chicken sandwich. Friendly service, simple atmosphere. Sit inside or outside. Affordable and delicious. We went to a ton of restaurants during our visit, this was our fav!! GO HERE! read more

Fishermen's Catch - Huge Haddock sandwich, awesome lobster roll with O rings. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

See all

Ordered a lobster roll- specifically told them I had lots of allergies so just the meat no roll. They brought me the meat with mayo, I took it back and told them again I had lots of allergies and couldn't have the mayo so they said they'd get me just meat. They brought out meat with lemon pepper- that is not just meat! Very dissappointed. Great place to get whole lobsters - not for other food if you have allergies- they just don't get it! read more

This is the most convenient place to get seafood that's right down the road from my camp. We always get steamed lobsters for holidays when out of town company comes up. They are always friendly and have good prices. I love that they steam lobsters and clams for no additional price. The only issue I had was recently for Mother's Day I got steamers to bring to camp. They were sandy.....this year I've gotten steamers from 3 different places and they were full of grit....maybe it's the clams this year....idk. Fishermans catch were the best ones I've had this year but still a tad gritty. This is the only complaint in my 29 years of getting seafood here. read more

Fishermen's Catch - Lobsters from fishermans! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

See all

Clean, fresh, fast and delicious. Flavor of the lobster shunned bc it wasn't overly buttery. Clam strips were breaded really nicely and stuck on. No complaints, would definitely come again! read more

Fishermen's Catch - Clam strips and lobster roll - light mayo and some lemon. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

I'm beginning to think that lobster roll reviewing is like reviewing barbecue; it's all a very subjective process. One person's favorite will be another's disappointment. When it comes to lobster rolls and nothing else, the Fisherman's Catch is a great place to stop to grab a lobster roll for a great price; $12.95. That's best price we've found for a lobby roll. The restaurant is in an A-frame on Route 302, headed west, just before intersection of Route 85, in Raymond. The bun was perfectly toasted, with butter, and the Fisherman's Catch offers three choices of rolls, including the "classic," which is with light mayo, and an interesting variation on the classic theme, the lemon pepper roll. I tried that one and liked it. The mayo is very light, which I appreciated. The lobster was fresh and succulent, just like all the best rolls I've sampled the past three summers. What I found disappointing was the lack of much beyond the lobster roll. The french fries and onion rings are frozen (not made in-house). There are no chowders. They do offer other sandwiches (haddock) for those not interested in a lobster roll. Glad we tried it, and the roll was very good. I just had expected a bit more. The FC is also a seafood market, shipping lobsters "all over the world." I'm assuming they will cook a lobster to order. Service was just so-so. If in the area, I'd recommend Bob's down the road, but if you just want a lobster roll that's a bargain and nothing else, the FC won't disappoint. read more

First visit yesterday was slightly overwhelming as he doesn't really eat shellfish, and I don't really know how to purchase besides from a menu. In the end, he settled on two 1.5 lb lobsters at $6.99/lb. We took them to Andover, MA, where we joined our friends for a dinner, and the lobsters were yummy! I don't think they really moved as they traveled two hours with us in the car, so I was concerned about the taste but a little butter later, and the lobsters were in our stomachs. read more

Yummy lobster rolls overflowing with meat. I like mine with mayo and relish. Great spot for cooked or raw seafood if you're in the Sebago Lake area. read more

This place is great! The prices are excellent and the fish is delish~ I didn't get any of the dine-in food, but when I walked in it smelled excellent. We walked out with a bunch of lobsters and steamers, and they were all very, very tasty. Price-wise you get a great bang-for-your buck. Plus, the place was very clean and well-kept inside. I'm fussy when it comes to the cleanliness of a place with lots of seafood around, but this place was great! I imagine that sitting outdoors would be lots of fun too, seeing how nicely kept the picnic tables were. read more

The sign says "more lobsters than Sara Gideon commercials". Great. Lots of lobsters. But you know what was missing? Employees wearing masks. We walked out. Taking care of your customers means covid-safe practices for everyone. read more

Lobster rolls overflowing. Haddock and fried scallops amazing. Also have ordered cooked lobsters and everything in their market was fresh and delicious. read more

Wonderful lobster roll! Toasted, buttered roll and probably 1/2 lb. of lobster. Had just a light amount of mayo. read more

Fishermen's Catch - Wonderful lobster roll. Very generous!! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Raymond, Maine

See all

Upsides: Cool Mainer Vibe, very casual outdoor picnic table seating - not a sit-down, order, & tip type of place (great for rowdy kids after a day at the lake), the lobster roll is delicious (says my family), quick friendly service, fresh seafood by the pound if you're going to be grilling later. Downsides: If you don't eat seafood, this isn't the place for you. Other than sweet potato fries, french fries, cole slaw, or potato salad, seafood IS the menu. read more

Best overstuffed lobster rolls with huge chunks of fresh meat & minimal filler. I drive up from New Bedford, MA, my own local lobster haven, to visit with friends in Lovell, ME. FC has become a must-stop while I'm in the area. Great price!!! Gotta branch out & try other menu offerings, too, next time. Just wish they'd make FRIED LOBSTER! Now that would put them over the top!!! read more

Ate here several weeks ago. All 5 of us had lobster rolls for lunch, all agreed thet were excellent. Pricey, but it has to be that way for a great lobster roll. Fast friendly service. We sat outside, picnic tables with umbrellas. You're sitting right beside Rte. 302 but we didn't really mind. Inside seating and atmosphere is blah. For dinner I would want a nicer atmosphere, maybe the Galley, toward Naples. They also have great lobster rolls. read more

Was visiting the Sebago Lake area with my husband and based on the good reviews decided to stop here for a late lunch. It did not disappoint, the lobster rolls are packed with lobster, and as one reviewer said, there is enough meat in one to fill two rolls, the seasoned French fries were delicious as well, and there is a good selection of local beers. read more

I will tell you that I'm not a big lobster guy however ''tis is by far the BEST! Let's be this place. Nothing NH better!

Best lobster roll in all of Maine. Better than Red's in Wiscasset! Lightly dressed, perfect!!!!

Clean and lobster roll was stuffed full. Ambience was mediocre but folks friendly and food was great!! read more

See all

Excellent value and high quality food make this a go to. Great service. This is how a fish shack should be run. Nice serving portions as well. Had 2lbs of steamers. Yummy. Shared the fried haddock platter. Yummy. Even the onion rings were super flavorful. Going back tomorrow again before we leave area. read more

Best lobster rolls around! Packed with lobster and served on a grilled, buttery roll. Perfection in every bite. Get yours with the lemon pepper seasoning for even more added flavor. Also love that I can grab fresh scallops to cook up later! read more

We loved this place! In town for a long weekend, and we're drawn in by the classic but clean A-Frame structure, and were wowed by the quality lobster roll, amazing fries (like steak fries, but cut thin), extra crispy and delicious. Also some good fried pickles. Try it! read more

Employees waiting on people and not wearing masks. All customers were wearing, just the staff wasn't. When I asked why I was told it gets hot in the kitchen. Your decision. read more

Great, fresh lobster. I order a 1.5 lb lobster, seemed a bit smaller than the 1.5lb 'ers that I have bought in the past at other restaurants, but it was fresh and yummy read more

We ordered two seafood combo and both were well done to the point clams were hard to eat but what surprised me the most was the 3 young men behind counter cooking the food and waiting on customers had NO MASKS ON! Do you not understand the mandated rule from our governor?.... Maybe she needs to make a visit to your establishment. I was not the only one there that was upset,the man behind me was also upset. Put on a mask please,don't spread this nasty COVID 19!!!!! read more

Fantastic seafood place. Love their lobster rolls and clams. Its also very nice that they open up for the locals at Christmas time. Homemade lobster rolls at Christmas is always a treat read more

Best seafood in Windham, Raymond, Naples area. It is fresh and and delicious every time. The haddock is amazing​ as well as the scallops. The food is like off the dock and a piece of Maine. read more

Food was good and fresh however the staff was extremely rude and arrogant. Would think twice about going back based on the service

OMG!! This place is a gem! Best lobster roll I have ever had and the potato salad is spot on! I will be back here very soon!!

After looking through yelp for nearby restaurants with a lobster roll, we stumbled on this one. The lobster roll was amazing!!! I highly recommend the butter and garlic roll with the classic lobster. What a great find to the start of my vacation. read more

Excellent, amazing, incredible. This place is clean. Smells like nothing, a sure sign of a good fish market. Lobster and Steamers were perfect and sweet. Highly recommend it. Just wish they didn't use styrofoam. read more

Had one whole lobster and a lobster roll. Both very good. The lobster roll was available different ways - that was neat - and was not loaded with mayo (I could never see the point of loading a lobster with mayo like so many places do.) French fries were great (tasty and crispy) and the potato salad was absolutely delicious. read more

Seafood chowder was awesome. That said, bring your own crackers. Steamers were well priced but served without juice. Don't bring this to their attention as I'm the only person who requested it. French fries were very good as was their fish sandwich. Staff were not that interested in customer service. read more