When you hear five star your expect a lot to come from an establishment quite like this one well those expectations were quite met from the pizza to the dessert I find quite exquisite. They also provided a free magnet and coupons which I find quite unique and this is what I find very different from other pizza establishments. read more

Truly the best and fastest delivered pizza you can get. It's very similar to New York style, and it's still burning hot when delivered. They should expand their delivery a few miles (in between Gate and Baymeadows) there's a lot of students, condos, and million dollar homes in gated communities that would love to take advantage of this. Although, I'll have to say, they'll usually make an exception and deliver. So, I'll compensate the driver for his time and their exceptional customer service for delivering. read more

Wish I could give them zero stars. Just had a delivery for our school and as soon as they put their order on my counter ROACHES came out everywhere!!!!! Nasty!!! Stay away not clean at all read more

Great pizza. Fast delivery. The parmesan garlic chicken wings are the best. We order from here at least once a week!!

Great fast pizzas and great specials! Delivery driver was really nice! Definitely recommend their delivery guy should get a raise!! read more

Updating. Can't have anything delivered to you and get it even warm. Terrible quality on wings. Undercooked and no flavor. Garlic rolls are hard to mess up but when they don't have garlic sauce on them that will do it. Philly pizza is ok , again you won't get it hot or even warm unless you place an order at the store and wait. Other than that great food read more

I never thought my favorite pizza would have no meat on it Then my girlfriend turned me onto their pizza with just tomatoes and peppers and extra cheese and it was so good that we have been doing it about once a week. That Was not even the icing on the cake literally the icing on the cinnamon rolls are fantastic wrap them up and eat them for breakfast the next day or eat it for dessert that night Yum read more

Idk where to begin...let's start by the name...can we change it to match your yelp rating?? Highly disappointed after a very satisfying first try...second try it's like y'all just gave up hope...super excited to get this pizza and rolls for the draft day shenanigans we embarked on...it is like Jags fans drooling over QB Trevor Lawrence...like top notch boner excited...my buddy, GoFor, made the now dreaded phone call...he explained not 1...not 2...but 4x we wanted thin crust Chicken bacon ranch Large pizza with half side added onions...and two orders of these "fire" pepperoni rolls...the wait for it was short since they basically didn't cook the pizza or pizza rolls...ever eat pizza dough with toppings?? During this wait though we were "entertained" by perhaps the worst pregame musicians alive and a horrible rendering of our beloved National Anthem. Seriously the Draft is in Cleveland, you couldn't book MGK and Kid Cudi?? I digress though...maybe it's the yeast that we consumed that makes me...ohhh shiny quarter...wait...pizza rolls right? Trash. We got a regular hand tossed pizza... however comma they did manage to get the onions on half the pizza hence the 1 star...back to the pizza... apparently thin crust means regular...do y'all have a special name for thin crust? Skinny crust maybe? As a matter of fact as i type this in the morning to start my dreaded day (only to be blessed by the sight of my beautiful girlfriend later on) I'm "baking" my pizza in my toaster oven and just noticed that the temp was set to "off"...kinda like how y'all delivered our order... Anywho...Bears selected Justin Fields and I'm super excited for it...i just hope I can stay off the can(this is on you 5 "star" pizza) to actually watch him play... A modern day philosopher and comedian that I love like a brother once passed this knowledge down that I think you guys should heed as well- "Do better" read more

5 star all day. I placed an order through yelp (Grubhub) last night. I noticed that there wasn't an option to add mushrooms to one of the pizzas I ordered so I put it in the notes. I figured they were an additional charge and my wife basically told me if mushrooms weren't on her pizza I might not wake up in the morning. So I called and spoke to a fine young man and asked him if he could just ring me up a separate ticket and I could pay for the difference in cost. He explained to me that he couldn't do that but he would definitely add the mushrooms to the pizza for me. Good sir you saved my life last night and have forever earned my business. Don't know your name but thank you bud. The pizza mind you was amazing. Hot but not too hot where everything falls off the pizza. Crust was perfect 1 bite pizza challenge review knocked it out of the park with a solid 9.2. One bite everyone knows the rules. read more

Speaking from a delivery driver standpoint , I really love this place . The staff is always kind and working with urgency . They are as efficient as can be , especially considering they are the ONLY pizza place open until 3 am . I really just want to thank them for always being consistent , and I know my customers appreciate it as well. read more

Satisfying! I ordered pepperoni rolls and it seems in Jacksonville pepperoni rolls are hard to find, good ones at least. They were very tasty and baked well, but sat in a thick layer of hot oil. I get the cheese caused this but it may have been too much oil for my preference. However, with a little paper towel dab, not a deal breaker. The pizza is the real win, tasty all throughout. Not skimpy on cheese or pepperoni and the crust wasn't flimsy. Also the price is reasonable. I'm the type that likes stale pizza reheated in an oven for crunch quality. I ordered an x-large pie just for myself (don't judge) and it lasted days without going bad. Have to say though, the "brownies" were a miss. It was more like dense cake with brownie crust. But did I order for dessert? No. This will definitely be my go-to pizza spot. Dominos and the rest don't stand a chance. read more

Every time my boyfriend and I are in Jacksonville, this is our go to pizza place!! Always delicious pizza, wings, and pepperoni rolls.. quick delivery as well!! read more

We ordered a pizza from Five Star Pizza. They're pretty new, but have never let us down. Today? Today was different. We ordered a pizza at 7:38, it went out for delivery at 7:54, It arrived at 8:30. Luke warm and smooshed to one side. Did I mention they are only 1.4 Miles away? AND IT WAS THE WRONG PIZZA!! we calmly call back and ask for the correct pizza, we even offered to give it back. We are told a new one is being made and will head out. 90 minutes later we call inquiring about the new pizza. We are told it left 15 minutes ago. 35 minutes after that, STILL NO PIZZA!! AND, AGAIN, they are only 1.4 miles away. We wait another few minutes and call back, THEY NEVER MADE US A NEW ONE!! I called it when I said "they're going to tell us to fuck off and expect us to be happy with the free nasty ass pizza we didn't order". We demanded a refund, they asked if we wanted credit, yeah, nah fam, won't be using that anytime soon. It is now 10:45. Three hours later, and I've literally made dinner from scratch before we got a pizza from Five Star. Two stars is generous, but I consider past service. I can a tolerate being busy, but no need to lie about it. read more

Five start offers fast and efficient service. Their garlic rolls are the bomb and the garlic parm wings are finger licking good. I'm not huge on pizza but I definitely enjoyed the pizza my sister ordered as well. Everything was great! read more

I order a take out pizza.... TAMMY takes my order She asked me my address... I say I'm not having it delivered... TAMMY says I just need your address to verify your account... I reiterate "I'm picking the pizza up as I have to go to Dollar Tree on Beach.... I go to pick up my pizza.... The girl at the counter says TAMMY is delivering your pizza to your house right now... They said she left 15 minutes ago.... I live about 8 minutes away... I told the counter girl that I told TAMMY that I didn't want delivery and said that TAMMY had said she needed my address to verify my account.... So I had assumed that they called her to return to the restaurant.... Waiting in my car for her to bring back my pizza.... Ten minutes later TAMMY calls me and says " I'm outside your house..."... I said Tammy, I never wanted it delivered! She said No Problem I'm on my way back... Now 20 minutes has gone by and NO TAMMY.... When I asked for the acting manager Juan or Carlos I forget his Latin Name... He said " TAMMY'S New!" We don't have her number"... I said You mean to tell me you have a NEW delivery driver and you don't have her #.... He said " Yes, We don't have her number... Now Justin or Jason ( forget) comes out says let's talk in the waiting area (because I had one foot inside the Kitchen) I said"NO, Let's take this outside!"... I tell him my story and like the AH that he was he could hardly listen to what I was saying... Being very dismissive... All my friends order from you guys because you do have the best pizza in town (I'm from NYC) Tammy never shows up with my Original Pizza so out walks Justin with a pizza he made and hands it to me gratuitously and wants me to sign my ticket! I say "What are you going to do to accommodate this debacle.... He said "What would you like me to do?" I said well if I was the manager I would try to make my customer happy"... He said "I don't want you to tell me what you would do if you were the manager!"... "What would you like?" and I said "comp the pizza" He said OK and then walks into his restaurant and proceeds to bill me anyway!" I walked back in after observing him charging me and said "You better not be charging me or it's not going to be good!" and left the premises... HE STILL BILLED ME... WHAT? Yes he billed me! read more

The food has been hot, fresh & prepared perfectly every time we've ordered. The only thing Id change is the prices are a bit higher than other pizza places, but that won't keep us from ordering again, we love the food. read more

I'd give the pizza and delivery 5 stars but don't order ahead and expect to pick up your food at the time specified. Been waiting 20 minutes for my order that was placed online for 7:30. It's now 7:50 and I've seen people come and go. Honestly had I ordered delivery it would have been delivered in 15-20 minutes. read more

The pizza is very good. My last delivery was the incorrect pizza. Called back and since we had taken a bite, they could not make a new pizza. Said would note the account to discount the next pizza. Called to use the discount and was advised nothing was noted so there is nothing they can do about it. I'm done. Like the pizza but that is poor customer Service. I wasn't asking for a free pizza, only a discount for their error. I'm done. read more

This place i will never order from again. I order my items had a gift certificate and it says no strings attached but there is, I still ordered received it, items missing was told for 2 flipping hours it'll be delivered. Still nothing, I called the store again and spoke with a manager who was telling me I shouldn't have an attitude and of course this was unacceptable as to the fact I was screwed. THE WORST customer service I have ever had.. read more

Really delicious pizza and fast delivery also very large pizzas they are amazing very close to New York pizza

Five Star Pizza is LIGHT YEARS beyond any of those other pizza delivery chains (I am looking at you dominos, papa johns and pizza hut). Five Star makes awesome pizza AND their pepperoni rolls are addictive - not to mention their garlic rolls that come dripping in garlic butter. Everything is super fresh and their pizza crust is top notch PLUS the staff is super friendly and you can tell they love pizza. Do yourself a favor and order some delivery from these guys, you won't go back to the other sub-par chains. read more

the left over pizza still has cheese pulls when reheated in the microwave... and that's how you know this place has fire pizza

This place is DISGUSTING! Just watched the people in the back making the pizza. Answered the phone without rewashing their hands. Zero use of gloves for any food handling. Saw one guy have the dough draped over his hairy arm. No hair nets, etc. Have fun with hair and grime all in your pizza read more

Their pizza is better than domino's and pizza hut yet costs less and gets here faster. I've been a five star customer for over 10 years now and a former employee. This place rocks to eat at and to work at. read more

Been ordering from here for two years. Love how they deliver very late into the night as some people don't work the typical 9-5. Pizza is awesome and the cheese is plentiful. Only taking off one star because this pizza does give me severe heartburn compared to other pizza places. Order it on their actual site and not on Uber Eats tiger their best discount deals. Really good priced pizza + wings options on there. read more

I love their pizza! We order it all the time and they have great pepperoni rolls! The crust thin and crispy and even better when you add extra cheese! The chicken wings we got only once and they were a tiny bit soggy because they're put in sauce upon delivery but they were still tasty! Will definitely keep getting pizza from here!! read more

The pizza and garlic knots were absolutely delicious. Hit the spot, even though I was using GrubHub, I always try and support local businesses. It was fast, hot, and I'll definitely keep this place in mind the next time I'm in Jacksonville!! read more

I personally love this five star, they've never failed to disappoint and tbh that's all I need to say. Great restaurant.

This store sucks. They never want to honor their coupons or discounts they send through physical mail. They have a new "free small 1 topping pizza" mailer. But fact is, if you order, especially late night, tell them you have cardboard mailer *they sent*, you're ignored. Entire business model is counting on you to show up and just pay them full price. Buyer beware. Edit - in past store would tell you to bring mailer when picking up or to delivery driver. Perfectly acceptable. Now con practices pretend you're stupid, give you an inflated price, and hangup. Also, meat toppings incredibly low quality. This St John's bluff location opened about a year ago and Pepperoni went from quality to less than Papa John's. Better value and ingredients from Blaze or Pieology if you're in TC area. read more

My family is a regular customer (weekly) of, well one of the famous in advertising pizza, Five star pizza is sooo different, I can't say the word, but to my Family & Friends.... Trust me.... You wil not be disappointed! read more

This place is great, pizza is how it should be and the cheese sticks/bread is to die for! Better yet, it's open till 2am! Nothing better than this. Late night munchies satisfied read more

This place is ridiculously good, no joke! Late night delivery and killer pizza wings and garlic knots!! read more

See all

I was so glad when I found out there is a Five Star Pizza next to UNF. Before that I had to wait to be in Gainesville or drive out to the west side.- which I gladly would have done. If you want pizza and you're not messing around I suggest this place. The sauce is on point and they were putting cheese on my pizza like it was going out of style. You can tell they use fresh produce on their vegetable pizza too which makes such a huge difference. On top of that they are open until 3 am. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Fricken awesome every time. I'm glad they sent us hella coupons in the mail, or my cheap self probably woulda never tried them. 10 outta 10.

Nothing remarkable about their overpriced pizza. Gave it 2 stars because the people were nice. That's about it. Will never step foot in there again. read more

We love this place! We buy here at least twice a month. The food is great and the employees are even better. It helps that they stay open late too. We will continue using them over everyone else for sure! read more

I can honestly say that 5 star was the patron saint of my Thanksgiving. The deliveryman was my lucky charm.

Ordered a cheese pizza and my first bite had pork. The cross contamination is disturbing. This is not a place I would ever come to again. Luckily I'm not allergic but for religious reasons it's very frustrating. read more

If I could give 0 stars I would. I called and ordered a pizza for delivery. Gave my address to the girl on the phone. She asked me if it was a unit and I said no a house. She takes my payment and tells me 30-40 minutes. I wait about an hour and 10 minutes before I call because I'm thinking they are just busy. I call and the lady on the phone tells me they have it in for pickup. I tell her I ordered it for delivery and gave my address and everything. She proceeds to tell me that they don't deliver North of Atlantic and when you put the address in it tells you that. I said well I gave the girl my address and she never told me you don't deliver here. I told her it was for delivery and she took my address and my card. She then tells me she will find out who took the order and speak with her. Okay, what good does that do me? You could have said, "I will refund you half of your money if you come pick it up".... Nothing. Then she proceeds to tell me that I'll get my money back in 3-7 business days. 3-7 business days for something I never even got? Yeah, that's real nice. Good luck! read more

Love the pies they serve. The dough is fluffy and chewy. And the garlic bread and pepperoni rolls are delicious! Excellent price and good service. read more