This is my favorite pizzeria in a 45 min radius (yes, better than V Pizza!) it's a tad pricey but it's totally worth it for us. We typically get 2 medium pies for about $48 including the tip (med. GF pepperoni/mushroom/pineapple & med. pepperoni/onion/banana peppers). Their lunch specials are great for my WFH days. Their Gluten-Free crust is my FAVORITE that I've been able to find but be aware that it might not be fully "# ppm" Celiac safe (same oven & counter space). Whenever we call to place the order for pickup, they always ask "Gluten allergy or preference?". I am NOT Celiac, but I try to avoid gluten for other health reasons - I always answer it's a preference. Ambiance... ideal for pickup only. But I love hanging out in there during lunch... definitely not somewhere you bring your family "out" to eat at. read more

Not impressed. I was really craving bruschetta and ordered takeout from here since it's a small restaurant with limited seating. Unfortunately, what I got was super heavy, buttered garlic toast with tomatoes and cheese in cups on the side. No balsamic drizzle either, which is kind of a key part of bruschetta in my opinion. The bread was greasy and smelled so strongly of butter and garlic that it honestly made me feel sick. It didn't feel fresh or balanced at all, just really heavy. Maybe it's my fault for ordering bruschetta to go it, but this just didn't resemble the bruschetta I was expecting. It ended up being a waste of money since I couldn't even finish it and had to go somewhere else to get dinner. Pretty disappointing experience overall. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Bruschetta - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Was ok. Appreciate that they have the option to add green olives though! Wouldn't recommend getting through door dash as a medium pizza and five mozzarella sticks is over $40. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Great pizza and great cannoli. Service was quick and everyone was polite. Lots of people getting food Togo.

This place always hits the spot. I'm from NY and it's just as good! The owner is always super friendly and welcoming. They have really good options and I've never had any bad experiences with them. I'll continue to use them as my go to pizza spot! read more

in my opinion, it's the best pizza in Jacksonville absolutely and they're always happy to serve you. It's an excellent place to eat.

We've had there pizza before and it was really good. Decided to try a stromboli and a Italian sub. Had it delivered. The stromboli was small but wife said it was ok. The sub was terrible. Not a lot of meat. Hardly any lettuce, and very soggy. Very disappointed. With prices the way they are felt like we wasted $35.00. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Italian sub. - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Wow, the calzones and Stromboli here used to be huge. They used to be delicious.. yesterday, I ordered 2 calzones and 1stromboli. All 3 were in the same box. The flavor was not as good as they used to be. The size was about half the previous size but the cost was increased. Almost $60.00 for the 3 items. Don't think I will order again. We used to love Brooklyn Pizza. The pizza was as close to a New York pizza as you could find in Jacksonville. Not anymore. Sorry. read more

Extremely decent pizza. Taste, sauce, amount of cheese all on point except for the size of the slice (could have been slight larger), and while I love NY style, I want to be able to fold the slide and not have the tip of it flop down (middle of the pizza is too think. This is totally splitting hairs, but 100% I'll be back! UPDATE: I also ordered one to go. read more

See all

Garbage. They are legit walking over and buying dough from Publix. The chemical, nasty flavor of prefab dough is super apparent in the "Sicilian" which just looks like a French bread pizza. Save your money. Don't pay for this dogshit read more

A Pizza Shop That Doesn't Sell Pizza? What a Joke. I've been coming to this place once or twice a week -- probably one of their most loyal customers. The pizza is good, no question. But the business? The service? Terrible. Tonight I took my wife here to grab some pizza and celebrate her birthday week. While waiting for our usual large to-go order, I asked to buy 4-6 slices. Not free -- buy. The same slices that are clearly listed on the menu. The woman at the counter said no. Her reason? "We don't want to make a pie just to sell slices because we might not sell the rest." It was 6 PM on a Saturday -- two hours before they close. And I'm already buying a whole pie. This made no sense. Let me get this straight: You're a pizza shop, it's dinner time, you're open, your slice prices are on the board... and you're refusing to sell pizza? This isn't about slices. It's about how you treat people who support your business. I've spent a lot of money here, regularly, and I got treated like a burden for trying to order more. That's enough for me. Friendly folks, decent storefront, good pizza. But good pizza alone doesn't make up for bad business. I'm not coming back. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I needed a quick spot for lunch with my daughter. We drive by Brooklyn Pizza every day and I've always wanted to try it! We did the 2 slides & drink special for $6.99. It was fantastic! I had the pepperoni and my daughter had the cheese. Both were perfect with a nice thin crust! Absolutely will return for more pizza! read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - So fresh!!!! Pepperoni & Cheese slices! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Eh. Medium pepperoni only had 2 pepperonis per slice. Ton of flour on bottom made it almost sandy. Cheese was dark and crispy which I like. Crust thin. Just seems rushed and skimpy. Mozzarella sticks were good. Crunchy and hot even Togo. read more

Excellent NY-crust and marinara. Garlic knots are a treat. Brooklyn Special Stromboli was amazing. read more

Have you ever stepped into a hole-in-the-wall and wished they would just win the lottery already? Well, that's Brooklyn Pizza. This is a family-owned, family-run hole-in-the-wall shop. Don't expect table service or fine china, but you can bet your bottom dollar on getting a great slice of pizza. The pizza is truly authentic New York-style--crispy, thin dough (not thin crust, though!) topped with the perfect marinara sauce. The sauce is rich with a sweet and tangy tomato flavor that hits all the right notes. We've tried their cheese, pepperoni, Hawaiian, meat lovers, and margherita pizzas, and you really can't go wrong with anything they serve. The margherita comes with dried basil and minced garlic. The meat lovers pizza features a fantastic range of meats: pepperoni, bacon, ham, and sausage. And let me tell you, it's not that greasy, balled-up sausage--it's sliced sausage. We also tried their garlic bread, garlic knots, and cheesy garlic bread. If you're a garlic *guurrrl* like me, you're going to be obsessed with the garlic butter they slather on their breads. It's absolutely addicting! Beyond pizza, they have a wide menu with many Italian dishes and desserts. We tried the filled-to-order cannolis and tiramisu. The cannoli was better than any you can get street-side in Little Italy, New York. The shell was crisp, and the filling was rich yet light, not overly sweet. The tiramisu was just as great--the ladyfingers weren't mushy and had the perfect coffee flavor, while the mascarpone was creamy, light, and airy. Overall, this is a hidden local gem tucked away near Publix in Bartram Park. I'd recommend it to anyone craving a slice of authentic New York pizza or a taste of Italy. read more

Stromboli tasty - service was good- ambiance ok Yes I would and I do continue to order from Brooklyn Pizza- the employees are always very kind read more

Great New York style pizza. Family owned is cute stop for a slice and special sodas. Service is super and efficient. Our steady shop for pizza that's good. read more

Pleasantly surprised by the pizza- Thin crust, crispy, good cheese/sauce amount, and good prices. I havent been here in maybe 4-5 years, but this pizza was def better than what I remember. I requested it well done, not sure if that helped. Will def be back. Cant beat two slice and a drink for $6.99. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - two slices of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Exactly what I was looking for! Thin, crispy crust with generous toppings!! 2 large slices and a drink for 6.99. read more

This place is exactly what it promises. Some cheap tasty pizza and very casual vibes. The $6.99 2 slices and a soda deal is pretty great. The cheese is oh so yummy. I have been here twice and both times the soda machine was out. The wings are ok. I had to get more sauce cuz I liked mine dunked. I am very curious about the coffee soda. We shall see how it is. I think the best way to describe it is a great stop on the way home after the middle school volleyball game. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Coffee soda?! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

New family ownership within the past few months! But they did say they kept all of the recipes! Their Mother(in-law I believe)was working at the counter and their chef were both as sweet as can be! So friendly!! We got the Lunch Pizza Special and added some toppings! I had to drive about 30 mins so we knew we might need to heat it up again! We actually at our first slices room temp and they were delicious! Put both the 2nd slices in the oven for about 10 mins to reheat and very tasty!! And you get a Can of pop which is so much better! The restaurant is your typical quick service pizza shop feel with the big pizza oven on display! Will definitely go back again! read more

For a classic New York City style Cheese Pizza in the South Jacksonville/St. John's area, look no further! If you grew up in NY and miss pizza from home, this is your spot! We usually order extra cheese extra sauce and are never disappointed! We've order Italian Sausage and Mushroom Pizza as well as Meatball pizza, all delicious!!! read more

order two pizzas did not like the taste at all dough was not soft and chewy plus too thin the pie

All I got was the slice combo (cheese). Wasn't expecting it to be so great. Perfect amount of cheese - and the sauce was tasty (not like the battery acid other places serve). But the real star was the crust. Wasn't soaky and had a great flavor. I'm definitely going back! read more

Cheese Crispy Pizza its my favorite with garlic knots with sauce all so delicious, good ambience and good service, I prefer this place Highly Recommended... Test it!! read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Pizza was undercooked. Felt like I was eating raw dough. Unfortunately I got the pizza to go, so there was no recourse having it re-cooked.

Just moved from St Augustine to Jacksonville . We had heard about Brooklyn Pizza many times and drove past it but never stopped in . The day we moved we ordered delivery and let me tell you their pizza is the best . Tastes like Brooklyn pizza. Next time we ordered the calzone and again we're not disappointed. This has now become our go to place for pizza . Be sure to stop by and try it read more

Sadly, this place is lacking a lot. I was hoping for some good pizza... but unfortunately, when I ordered the slices during the day... they just added the toppings to an already cooked and sitting cheese pizza on the counter at room temp. I saw they were hiring, and applied... got a call back, and worked 1 day. The people in the back making the dough balls don't wash their hands and don't wear gloves or anything to keep their hair out of the food. All of the dishes sit in water and are covered in rust, and not cleaned properly. The quality is nothing to be excited about and the price isn't that great. If you want rubber pizza and the entire staffs hands in your food... go here. read more

I didn't care for this place.Very un exciting flavor of the pizza and garlic knots. I gave my leftover garlic knots to my neighbor, and he didn't care for them either. My soda was good. I was glad that it wasn't watered down. Staff is friendly. I wasn't offered a receipt which irritated me. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

First of all this is the best pizza to get in north east Florida. Second of all it's a crime to say anything negative about their traditional cheese or pepperoni. The only reason for someone to not think this is not an 8 out of 10 is because they're used to bad florida pizza. Inside feels like a real ny pizza spot. Service is great and they'll keep the pizza warm for you. I don't have a picture review but I recently saw their review on the one bite app and it's criminally underrated. read more

Nothing says pizza like Brooklyn pizza. There is always Pizza Hut. Dominoes, Papa John's and Little Caesar just a telephone call away. However, I have a soft spot for Broolyn Pizza in St John's county. I always pre-order and ask for complimentary garlic. No, I'm not trying to battle vampires. This time around ordered extra cheese and did not see any. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Pizza with extra cheese??? - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Always hot and fresh NY style pizza! Friendly employees. Clean dining area and kitchen (from what I can see). Nice pizza joint close to home read more

As a New Yorker, I had big hopes for this pizza. Unfortunately, it was worse than fast food pizza (dominos, Pizza Hut, etc). I do not recommend. read more

I've loved this place for atleast half a decade that I've lived in this neighborhood. Love my favorite cheese pizza, but, they have all choices from veggie, to all meats, to pepperoni, to Sicilian, to combination of veggies and meats. Absolutely love their homemade recipes of the margarita sauce that's sold there as well. Have made some great pastas at home, for the significant other, using that sauce! It's a hidden gem- if you are in the neighborhood for a pizza night. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Basic cheese pizza, that doesn't beat anything! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I have no complaints with the service but I won't order here again. Pizza is nothing special, at all. I would rather have papa John's over this. Pizza is thin, lacking sauce and flavor. Honestly, Stonerz is my favorite in the area. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

It's pizza. It's at the best frozen pizza, it's definitely not Brooklyn pizza or New York pizza or even New England pizza. It's average.

This was our third try with Brooklyn Pizza. We called the order in for pickup. I repeated the order a number of times (at least 3x)... pizza with pepperoni, salad no cucumbers, and 10 wings flats only. Went to pick up the order and the salad wasn't on the list (after repeating the items 3+ times when I ordered) I agreed to wait for the salad, paid for the entire order, and left a tip. The young man who waited on me went in the back. I waited a few moments for the salad to be brought up by another employee (nice woman) and I told her the rest of my order was by the oven, as well as telling her I'm all taken care of/paid up. Another young man (who was making the pizzas close to the front within earshot when I was first waited on) retrieved the rest of my order. I thanked them, grabbed my order, and proceeded to leave when this young man barked at me "did you pay for the salad?" Hmm. I patiently waited for them to complete my order after they got it wrong, paid for it in full, and also left a tip in which I'm not required to, and this kid literally BARKED at me thinking I'm trying to skip out on him not paying for a salad, which was grossly overpriced to begin with? On top of that, we get home to find out that the pizza that we ordered was wrong too (no pepperoni), and the wings were undercooked. I've been a business owner for over 15 years, and how you treat your customers is EVERYTHING, especially when you - the business - gets it wrong. Needless to say we will NEVER order again from Brooklyn pizza due to their lackluster customer service, poor communication, and subpar food quality. read more

Great love Brooklyn pizza ,their pizza reminds me of back of back home real Italian pizza and so delicious yummy I can eat their delicious Brooklyn pizza every day. yummy yummy pizza. read more

I wish there was a zero star. I ordered two pepperoni slices and two Meat Lovers slices. The pizza was old, dry, and hard. I called and asked for them to remake it. The guy on the phone said no problem just bring them back and we will make it right. I get there and I ask for something else. Before he can even answer me this old lady comes and says nothing is wrong with the pizza and she is not going to do anything for me. I told her the pizza is hard and has been sitting she said its not. She claims the pizza is made fresh you can tell its been sitting for hours. The pizza would have cut the roof on my mouth if I would have eaten it. I spent $22.00 dollars on food that I did not even eat. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

A wave of nostalgia (plus the fact that I'm pretty much always in the mood for pizza) led me to Brooklyn Pizza this week. I used to live practically across the street from here, but sadly I'm on the other side of town now, so coming to Brooklyn isn't as frequent as it used to be. I remember back in its prime, Brooklyn Pizza had three locations around Jacksonville; but unfortunately they are now reduced down to just this spot in Bartram Park. But they must be doing something right, because they've stood the test of time in an area that's seen substantial restaurant growth over the past five years. I'm happy to report that they are still putting out quality pizza. I stopped in at lunch, so I just had them throw a couple slices in the oven for me. I love black olives, but honestly their plain cheese is almost even better. They have an amazing (on the sweeter side) sauce that shines through and compliments the cheese and crust very well. They sell it by the jar, and I was very tempted to get one on my way out. Overall, they may not be my favorite pizza place in Jax anymore (back when they had the location on San Jose, I would practically get one every weekend!); but they're still making great pies with a solid NYC atmosphere. Next time I'm in the Bartram Park area, I'm certainly more prone to stop in here over any of the dozens of chains that have popped up around it. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park - Not a bad deal... - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all