I'm so happy they deliver now... we ordered a large pizza...half with pepperoni and it arrived steaming hot...the price is definitely worth it....everything about the pizza was great..... Don't feel like cooking then order a pizza...you won't regret it read more

HORRIBLE service! We had ordered a pizza at 5:00 pm, arrived to pick them up 30 minutes later and they were holding our pizzas off to the side on a shelf. We were told that they can only take cash because their machines were down the minute before we came into the store, then sarcastically asked if we had cash on us. We weren't notified that their machines were down at all. We then left and called the place to speak to the manager, Rachel, who was the same person who treated us unkindly in the store too. We were also mocked by being told that they don't give out free pizzas when asked if a check could be taken as an exception. I definitely do not recommend coming here to order pizzas. Very disgusting service. Bad, Bad, BAD! She was supposed to have the owner, Robert, call us back but we have yet to hear anything from him. They have lost a good and loyal customer in us being treated in this manner read more

Well i had a taste for some good pizza and found this place and ordered a powerhouse pepperoni and it was a large pizza with extra pepperoni and cheese for $16 and i can say it was better than pizza hut and i got some garlic butter on the side and it was great. The building its small but you only order and pick-up from a window near the entrance so its planty of standing room. All together it was good & they're open to 2am so i see myself ordering again. read more

Five Star Pizza - Powerhouse pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Every five star but this five star is open until at least 2am. The whole point of five star is to be open late. Closing at 12am is ridiculous. They close at 12am on new years. I have worked new years at other five stars and the business received after 12am is insane. This place has no idea what business they are missing. They should call themselves 2 star because they close at 12am. Basically every other five star is open late. This one is located in a prime location for late night business yet they close at 12am.someone else should run this business and do it right read more

I was hungry ordered a supreme Pizza garlic bread rolls allsome the dough great no shits after eating the Pizza

We have ordered delivery from 5 Star for a few years. The delivery is always quick and pleasant. Unfortunately the last 2 orders are sub par. We have 1/2 veggie and 1/2 extra pepperoni. The pizza is soggy..under baked and soupy. The taste is a bit spicy, not bad,not good. We will be look elsewhere. read more

Requested to cut squares for my kids easy to eat but they didn't cut squares even though it is so easy to cut in 5 seconds even the manager said they can't do it! I used to work for pizza and I would willing to do customer wishes. I give this 1-star pizza. read more

The pizza is decent but the thing that I dislike is the hidden ILLEGAL charge for those paying by credit. This establishment charges an additional $.50 to your order when you pay by credit. NO WHERE IS THIS ADVERTISED. Charging a few to pay by credit not only violates their Visa Merchant agreement it also violates Florida Law. Statute 501.0117 Check here if you have any doubts http://www.flsenate.gov/STATUTES/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&Search_String=&URL=0500-0599/0501/Sections/0501.0117.html I know the State Attorney's office is aware and has sent them notification to stop, but still they impose this fee. They are so sneaky that unless you calculate your bill yourself, you probably won't even notice it. I actually had to ask why there was such a discrepancy. The staff is aware of the fee but only mentions it if you ask... My problem is I like the pizza here. I do continue to order from them, but now I just pay by cash. read more

Yelp helped me find this pizza joint. Take out or delivery only, but so worth it. Staff is friendly and funny. They always have a smile. Now onto the pizza. So good, the crust is perfect to hold any toppings you may desire. I recommend the Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza. So much BACON!!! So much HAMBURGER! I love it. This is a go to spot for my pizza craving. read more

This is great, cheap, easy pizza. It isn't the best I've ever had, and they definitely don't have the interesting gourmet pizzas that Carmine's or Moon River have, but it's absolutely our new go-to delivery / pickup pizza. I ordered on a Monday night around 6, and it was ready in about 30 minutes. We ordered a half white, half "all the meats" pizza. The man taking the order warned us on the phone that since we were ordering a two-sauce pizza, there would be a certain amount in the middle where the sauces might mix a little. He said people had complained about that in the past- seriously? Who expects perfect pizza sauce lines?? Based on previous yelp reviews, we also added on an order of their garlic rolls. GET THE GARLIC ROLLS. They were soaked in delicious garlicky butter, with oodles of actual minced garlic on top. My husband and I agreed that it was now our go-to side, and with marinara sauce for dipping (which we added on to our order), it could've been a meal! The pizza was good too- the white pizza had ricotta, which I wasn't used to, and it could've been more flavorful overall, but it was definitely worth four stars. The meats one was good- large chunks of meat, and literally, it had "all the meats" on it. Our mix of specialty pizzas plus garlic knots made it a less-than-cheap dinner, but you can get a one typing pizza for $9. They only do delivery or carry out, but if you order at their window, they'll walk it out to your car for you so you don't have to stand in the Florida heat. This is now our go-to pizza place, you should definitely check it out. read more

Let me start by saying Five Star has great pizza. We've lived in Five Points for four years, and ordered from them on average I would say your to six times a month, every month, since we've lived here. Whenever the husband or kids want pizza, we never considered anyone else. Until recently... In the past month, we had an order over thirty dollars, and an order nearly thirty dollars delivered (normally, we do carry-out, but we've had delivery before). BOTH times the order was wrong. When I called in, they didn't appologized, blamed "a lot of new people" being the problem, and swore up and down they'd send out corrections. WE NEVER RECEIVED THEM, EITHER TIME. So, NO APPOLOGY, NO REFUND, AND NO CORRECTION. Today, we called for carry-out to circumvent that problem. The same female answered the phone. This time, they didn't even ask for our number, which always tells them our account info. Then I was told they don't do their carry-out special they have advertised on the front of the building. So instead of ten dollars, it would be almost sixteen. I hung up. Good-bye Five Star. Thanks for crapping all over your loyal customers after years of great service. I don't know what changed, but we'll definitely not be back. read more

I traveled from Brooklyn, New York yesterday by car. After checking into my Airbnb, I was dog tired! I wanted my favorite pizza to celebrate being back in Duval. I was so excited to get some good customer service and good food after months of disgusting, overpriced food and terrible customer service in New York. I ordered a barbecue chicken and bacon pizza only to get home and realize there was not ONE DROP of barbecue sauce. The pizza was DRY! I forced myself to eat what I could, showered and went to bed after that long drive. I called at 11 a.m. the next day willing to bring the remainder of the pizza back and the receipt. The manager refused to do anything about it. He didn't care about anything I said about being EXHAUSTED from my drive and having to eat GARBAGE. I will be going to another location because what I'm realizing is this one has gone to the gutter since I've been gone. I could've stayed in New York for horrible food and service. I'm glad I didn't get the garlic Parmesan wings because they probably would've been bloody and undercooked! HOW DO YOU NOT PUT ANY SAUCE ON A PIZZA? A COMPLETE WASTE OF MONEY! read more

Stopped by this little spot last night; I was a little concerned at first as there was no inside dining and the area is questionable. But once you place your order you begin to realize that these individuals are just doing what they love to do, living life and making damn good pizza. Customer service was well displayed as they brought the pizza out to our car and I enjoyed watching to very grown men come outside, possibly on a bet, to play pizza box frisbee...that displays the culture of five star, the pizza was delicious! I was a little sad I had to share it with the wife and kids. I'm a dough guy and enjoyed the flavor/texture. If I do go back (I'm from out of town) I'll be sure to grab the piezilla instead of the large. Thanks for a great pizza guys read more

This placed saved my butt!!! Shacked up in my buddies apartment without access to food. Who is still delivering at 11pm!!! Five Star Pizza to the rescue! Not a lot of delivery options in J-ville after 11pm. This place has delivery on most days til 12 am and on Fri and Saturday till 2am. The guy on the phone was very nice and didn't seem in the least bit stoned at all. He assured me my pizza and salad would be there 23 minutes. My pizza pie arrived in 20 minutes right to my door on the 18th floor! Wow! Here I thought dinner would be thawing out a frozen Lunchables box I found in the back of the freezer! For delivery pizza, it is pretty standard but so much more appreciated due to the circumstances and service they get an extra star! read more

I was a bit skeptical when I got a coupon for a free pizza with no strings attached. Turned out to be true! And even better the pizza was great! I am one of those weird people who dont like marinara on pizza and they have options. I could have alfredo, a butter sauce or ricotta cheese. I have tried the ricotta and butter, both being very good. Been back multiple times now! read more

Fast delivery, excellent prices and I was impressed with the pizza. The wings were a little underdone for me but a few minutes in the oven fixed that problem. I'd call back just to flirt with the delivery girl, but seriously five star is legit. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Best pizza in JAX hands down! Also love their wings! Usually get two large pizzas and wings and its typically around $30, definitely a good price for such good quality, fresh food. Try it for yourself, definitely won't be disappointed! read more

The wait time wasn't long, the service was friendly, and the pizza was very good. The garlic knots were really good as well. I would definitely recommend giving them a try. read more

Another year, another review of pizza delivery. Living in Riverside seems like it should be a great place for pizza, and it absolutely is. However, most of the best and unique places don't deliver. I had been alternating between Al's and Vino's when I found out that Five Star delivered. I had never eaten there, but was familiar with Five Star since I grew up in Orlando and spent a lot of time around the resorts that the Orlando Five Star locations serve. My girlfriend and I split an extra large, and this thing was HUGE for the price. If you've ever eaten at a Costco food court, this pizza was almost identical. And let me tell you, in my opinion that is a great thing. So much delicious cheese, crispy thin crust, with a little bit too much sauce. Just like a Costco slice! Although unlike Costco they will bring it to my doorstep which is a huge advantage. I will definitely order again. Based off of my difficulties in finding a consistent and delicious DELIVERY pizza in Riverside, this would be 5 stars if not for a few minor things. First, while the pizza did taste great, it had a funky smell. It didn't taste like that until it was reheated the next day, where I could taste it and it was rather unpleasant. I'm hoping it was just a fluke. Second, no online ordering. One of the reasons I really like Vino's is the multitude of options to get it to you - Five Star is phone only. A true first world problem I suppose. Anyway, if you're in the area and aren't actually going out in person for pizza give Five Star a call. read more

After delivering pizza to my place of business on more than one occasion, they would not deliver today, stating that they do not come to this location. I told him that this location is often confused with another area of town and that we're about 4 miles from them but that we've had multiple deliveries in the past. When questioned about their delivery radius, the person would not answer, repeating they do not come here and stating the manager said they couldn't so they couldn't go against the manager. When asking them to look back at previous orders, the person stated they did see that they have delivered here before, yet still would not take an order for delivery now and would not provide an answer as to their delivery radius and then hung up on me. I just wanted to understand why they were refusing delivery service when they've clearly delivered to this address before and the person on the phone became flustered, not knowing how to answer what should have been very simple questions regarding their delivery policy. And to hang up on someone is absolutely poor customer service. read more

First time ordering from this place. I'm was on a business trip in Jacksonville FL 11.21 - 11.24. Pizza/dough was tough. The taste was not good at all. The wings were indescribable other than saying nasty. What a waste of $30.00. read more

Delicious no nonsense pizza. Fast service, fresh, quality ingredients and yummy fresh tasting crust. Delivery too!

Always on point! Best pizza around for delivery and pick up, especially late night.way better than Papa John's, pizza slut or dominoes. Appreciate the friendly service. read more

This is my favorite pizza in Jax. My opinion may not matter though because I don't like cheese. I order my cheeseless deluxe with bacon and olives added and it's the best in Jax. read more

Been great for more than a decade now in my life; still the best delivery in town; the name is well earned. The food has continued to be very solid in quality, if not improved over time, in my experience. Late night delivery is a bonus! (and please people, tip your delivery driver!! I delivered years ago elsewhere, and I cannot tell you how heartless the average customer can be ..not to mention it's a dangerous job in more ways than one would think - show some respect!) read more

Well five star pizza is going to get five stars from me, their staff is always super friendly. They'll even bring your food out and put it in your trunk. They have great pizza specials! Pizza is always very good and has lots of cheese, fresh toppings. Their hours are great, delivery speed could use some improvement but this place is awesome! Our go to pizza place , typically our Friday night favorite! read more

order here a few times a week they know me by name ordered tonight driver showed up pizza box covered in garlic juice im allergic to garlic he apologized called the store they said they were closed i work in a pizza place i would have had it remade and sent back to customer even if we were closed gave a credit for next time i order but what do i do now for dinner tonight. gonna call and and talk to manager tomorrow!! read more

This was my first time coming to your establishment and I am appalled at the service and the food. We placed an order online and when we arrived for pick up, we were met with hostile employees who did not have the food ready or correct. The food was burnt and the order was missing items that had already been paid for upon my arrival. When I told the cashier that my chicken was incorrect, he responded with "I'm not making it over, because it was an online order and YOU did it wrong ". I understand that people may make wrong orders all the time but it's my understanding that if a customer request for something to be made over or they are dissatisfied with the product that it can be made again, as a first time customer I am disappointed in the service and the quality in which I was handled tonight. I will make this available to all my social media platforms as this place does not deserve any business if this is how they treat their customers!!!! read more

cheap, fast delivery, great service, yummy pizza, and garlic rolls. I've ordered and waited at the bar next door, and the kind gentleman brought it over in under 15 minutes. I've also ordered delivery to two different locations, and it always arrives fast and hot! This is my go-to for ordering pizza or when I'm nearby to pick up! Thanks, Five Star! read more

The pizza was huge! And the garlic knots were fire! The pizzas lasted me two days in the fridge, still tasting as good as when I first picked it up from the window. Yes window, there is no seating in this place just a pick up window into the gates of pizza heaven. They do deliver though! read more

I have not Ordered pizza from five Star in a very long time. You know the whole healthy eating thing. But I really wanted that big awesome pizza! The guys that work there are so laid-back and super nice. And the pizza and wings were mouth watering good. I got a veggie pizza and you should too ! read more

Whenever we get delivered pizza, we order Five Star. It's pretty generic, but hits the spot. No, it's not Carmine's or Moon River, but those places don't deliver. I tend to pick up a lot too. A large 1 topping pizza is $8.99 plus tax, when carrying out. You can stuff 2 adults with above average pizza for less than $10. This is why I am a frequent customer. read more

I'm visiting JAX and found 5 Star on yelp using the open now feature. Called at 1:45 am and they delivered a delicious pie in 20 minutes! Ps I'm kinda a pizza snob. read more

Great pizza and wings. Delivered fast too. Will def order again!

Awesome pizza and fantastic customer service! Best pizza delivery in town - by a landslide. You won't be disappointed :)

Five Star Pizza is very good the first time I ate there I received a coupon for a free large pizza the place is located on Plymouth St.

LOVE these guys! They're so fast and the foods always hot. The pizza sauce and crust are delicious. The Wings are melt in your mouth yum! They win over all the major chains like Pizza Hut and Dominos or Papa Johns any day! I'd honestly say their only competition for us is Mellow Mushroom (they have more veggie options) but they don't deliver to us so this is our go to delivery place. read more

Fast delivery, awesome prices, and garlic rolls to kill for. I recommend the family special. Get pineapple and bacon. You won't regret it.

I've ordered from there 3 times now. The pizza has been consistently good and the employees are very friendly.

DO NOT ORDER THE WHITE PIZZA!! It's disgusting. 2 stars only because the pepperoni rolls were really great. Chicken wings sucked too