We came here for a birthday dinner and it was very nice. Eric out waiter was awesome. He gave wonderful recommendations and had a great attitude. There were 7 of us and we didn't wait at all for our table (we did have reservations) nor did we have to wait a long time for our food. Everything was good. The Gimlet was one of the best I've had! Overall the food and drinks were good. read more

See all

Great experience all around! Dinned for my husbands birthday, we did not have a reservation on a Wednesday night, was promptly sat at a table near the bar. I believe our server was Brian (I should have written my review last week when it was fresh in my mind) He was very friendly and helpful with the menu and wine selections. We shared the Big A$$ 80 oz tomahawk steak!!! along with sides of parmesan risotto, and asparagus. He received a complimentary desert for his birthday and he chose cheesecake, it was so good! I look forward to our next visit :) read more

Flamestone American Grill - birthday cheesecake - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

See all

Service is great, flat bread pizza was ok, but French Dip sandwich was bland and boring. It was huge, but this shouldn't be served at a fast food restaurant. Broccoli was cold and limp. Service was good. Overall, overpriced and bland. read more

Flamestone American Grill - Pizza, sister said it was ok. - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

See all

I've read other reviews here on Yelp and I sadly have to say I'm in agreement with the majority of reviews critical of the food. The ambience is appealing and the service was spot on. What looked was the most important aspect which was the food! In all fairness I'm not particularly a guacamole fan but I did think the guacamole preparation was very tasty! I ordered the larger cut of prime rib and it was overly salty on the outside rub as well as being ridiculously tough! The prices were high for our meal. I don't see any reason to return. read more

We did not have a reservation, but we're able to quickly get seated. We met Katt, our server who made our experience special from the minute she greeted us. She asked if we've ever been there before, and we had not. She proceeded to tell us the specials, the recommended dishes and also her favorites. She was very knowledgeable about each entree and dish. I ended up with a 30-day aged, bone-in ribeye, a loaded baked potato and the skillet Mac and cheese. My wife got the 6 Oz petite filet, a loaded baked potato, and a side salad. During our meal and conversations, we told Katt it was our 33rd anniversary and discussed where we all were from. When the meals came out, the presentation was great, with the Mac and cheese still bubbling in the skillet. The baked potatoes were the size of our heads and the steaks were cooked perfectly medium. The seasoning on the steaks was so flavorful, my wife who puts steak sauce on everything did not even ask for any. When done, Katt boxed up our remaining food and bagged it. Then she told us for our anniversary, we could receive a free dessert. We couldn't decide, so we got both the bineigts and deep fried oreos. There were 5 pastries and 6 oreos served with vanilla ice cream and real Whipped cream. My steak was $55 with two sides and my wife's steak was $36. This was by far the best steaks and all around meals we've had in years. Not since the 1990's did Ruth's,Criss compare. This has now replaced our favorite restaurant and we will plan to visit every time we are in Tampa. We also met one of the managers who was also welcoming and friendly. read more

See all

My favorite thing about this restaurant is that it is family owned. The table side guacamole is a close second. We dined on a Wednesday night and they were quite busy. They take pride in the daily specials and the fact that they hand cut their steaks. From the higher end meat/seafood items to the casual sandwiches, this place is spot on. Shout out to the wines by the glass selection too! read more

Got too excited and ate half my burger before taking a picture! By far one of the best burgers I've had in a while! My burger was very flavorful and cooked to perfection. $18 for burger and fries read more

Flamestone American Grill - CEO Burger - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

Nice decorated restaurant. The servers are friendly. The food is good. We had the guacamole with nachos I like that they make the guacamole right in front of you. The prime rib was delicious. The burger was enjoyable. The beignets were still raw inside. The truffle fries were good. The Caesar salad with chicken was nice. read more

See all

The absolute worst service. Our appetizers of rolls and calamari took 25 mins. No apology. After an hour we checked on our food and they said there were several large parties and it would be 5 more minutes. No apology. No manager came over. Mind you this was LUNCH time. We had ordered burgers and salads and sandwiches not well done steaks. We ended up leaving without getting our food and on our way out we surveyed the restaurant and there was ONE large party of maybe 8 people. Honestly the rolls were great but would not go back. The service was infuriating. read more

Flamestone American Grill - Lunch menu - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

See all

Overall I still think this place is great but my most recent order was disappointing compared the first order where everything was perfect. Nothing was bad that I couldn't eat it, but I had to do some doctoring. The Rib eye was a little more charred than expected but still good pass those parts. The mashed potatoes were under-seasoned but again still good. The Parmesan risotto was the big disappointment. It was cooked so well in terms of texture, but it was also so bland. I had to add a lot of seasoning and Parmesan at home to make it decent. read more

See all

Cory was our waiter and he was great. Good personality. Atmosphere was great. Food was great. Nothing bad to say. We will definitely be back. If you're looking for good food and good staff try this place out. You won't regret read more

RUN-do not walk to Flamestone for their new lunch specials! If the Greek Salad is on the menu-it is a must try, and add the shrimp! The atmosphere and the service is always impeccable with Holly behind the bar and the Manager Michael always checking in on everyone. Highly Recommend!!! read more

See all

Why 5 Stars? Because the steaks were insane, the staff was super friendly, and the vibe made it feel like we were hanging out at a friend's place (who just happens to cook amazing food). We took the family--my wife, our son, and my mother-in-law--to Flamestone American Grill and decided to share the massive bone-in ribeye (yep, the cowboy cut). Let's just say it came out cooked to perfection, bursting with flavor, and totally worth every bite. Even my son, who's not always the most adventurous eater, loved the rare pieces. He basically inhaled his share with a side of fries before I could even blink. Ha ha! We had some Bocelli wine that also really tasted great with steak! My mother-in-law went for the French onion soup and then had a filet. Now, she can be a tough crowd, but this time she just kept nodding her head with this "oh my goodness, so good" face. Trust me, that's like a standing ovation in her book. After polishing off that huge steak, we all realized we were way too full for a heavy dessert, so the grown-ups settled for cappuccinos as a sweet finish. The cappuccinos were spot-on, with that perfect foam and smooth espresso that just makes you smile and think, "Yup, this hits the spot." All in all, Flamestone American Grill nailed it. Amazing meal, comfy atmosphere, and staff that treated us like regulars on our very first visit. I'm already planning the next trip back--maybe next time I'll manage to snag a few more fries from my son's plate! read more

See all

One of those places where everything looks nice but tastes just okay. One of our party got a ribeye with mashed potatoes and broccoli. The steak was really good and cooked as ordered but the mashed was way too salty. Another person got the French Dip and the jus was so salty it was inedible. My Flamestone salad with salmon was good if a bit sweet. The service, though, was excellent. read more

Meal was excellent Preston our server was great and friendly. Will be back and asking for him. read more

Popped in for a quick dinner. Service was top-tier. Our server, whose name escapes me, was super nice, attentive, and on top of things the entire meal. The ambiance is nice, but the food unfortunately was meh. Very mid, esp for the price. Had higher hopes, wouldn't go back. read more

A lovely place to dine- Their guacamole prepared table side is pretty great! Service is typically very good. We've never had a bad meal here and have frequented this establishment often. read more

Great place for a date night or girls night. We came on a Thursday night and it was decently crowded. It's big so no issues with parking or getting a table, but you can tell this restaurant is popular. We started with the Tableside Guacamole and got vegetables. I love that they give you a vegetable option. It is very good and you can see them cut up the avocados, so it's very avocado forward. Then for my main I got the steak salad. I asked for the steak medium rare, but it was more medium. It was still great though and I would definitely get it again. Our server was pretty slow, which I found surprising since he mentioned at the beginning he knew we were hungry. I also tried a dirty martini and it was pretty good, no complaints here. I will definitely come back. read more

Flamestone American Grill - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

So overrated. They want to be a top tier steakhouse, at least they act like it and price it that way. Food was terrible. Calamari was so greasy as was the Sea Bass. One of the worst presentations of Sea Bass I ever had. It was drowning in oil and butter. My wife had salmon that came out raw and had to be sent back to cook it longer. Eric, the waiter, was extremely nice and knowledgeable about the menu, but at the same time was more of a salesman as he explained the dishes and how they were prepared. Hard to trust the words when everything is supposedly prepared the best way ever. We preferred our meal at Whiskey Wings much more, the night before, which is right next door. read more

Great ambiance, feels upscale but prices for food is still reasonable. The server was great and answered all our group's questions. I got the maple bourbon glazed salmon which had a great sweet and salty flavor with the thick piece of salmon. The sweet mashed potato and the campfire veg (mainly green beans with bell pepper and onion) went well with it as sides. We got an extra side of lobster mac n cheese, and it was so deliciously cheesy with big chunks of lobster. I was intrigued seeing the campfire s'mores at another table, so we got that as well. It was marshmallows on sticks with a little tableside fire, so it wasn't anything sophisticated, but it was a great group dessert and fun for kids. Everyone had a good time, the food was great, and the service was quick. It was a great dining experience. read more

See all

OMG! If you ever want an incredible meat experience, you GOT TO TRY this place. Had the prime rib with Caesar salad with fresh guacamole appetizer. When I say FRESH guacamole it is table side! The Caesar salad dressing is unbelievable light and tasty. The prime rib is one the BEST EVER! Tender and juicy as well as flavorful.The side broccoli and green beans- holy Moley! Sooooo full and soooo content. The server was awesome as well. Dam! Wish they had more places. I would be here EVERY week. Ps: others had the filet mignon- VERY TENDER juicy and flavorful. read more

First time visitor... Couple bizarre things that caused me not to like the experience. Food: 6 ounce filet mignon was good. Chose mashed potatoes and vegetables. For some reason they charged an extra $4 for something unknown (see pic). The full rack of ribs was just average. Sauce was good but the meat was just a tad off. This was pared with veggies and coleslaw. Again the bill came with $3 extra tacked on for similar unknown reasons. I was with company where I didn't want to question this, but reviewed the menu afterwards and see nothing about these extras. When you add tax and tip this totals almost $9 for bogus up charges. Both meals indicated they came with two sides and none of the four chosen sides were premium. There was no complimentary bread and the appetizer menu didn't really have an affordable alternative. Believe they only offer flatbread for $15, which is ridiculous. And tea for $4.50 comes to almost $6 with tax/tip. Sodas are also this same amount. Too expensive. Our dinner and two wines was $122 after tax/tip. Ambiance: Asked for a quiet place to talk. They put us by the front door in the first row right next to the bar. This could have been better, although they did ask if the location was okay I'd never been here before so didn't know the rest of the restaurant. Service: Not the best. Our waiter seemed to have an attitude at first. Like he was annoyed when we weren't ready to order entrees just yet. And then seemed to disappear for too long in a restaurant that wasn't full. Not ideal. This is a "$$$" place so expect better... Ambiance is okay. Our table had the bar close by with all the TVs playing sports, so kind of distracting. Parking is plenty as it's in a long retail strip center. With the unknown and unexpected up-charges and mediocre food I won't come back here. Get a better meal at a way cheaper price at any of the steakhouses like Longhorn or Outback. read more

Flamestone American Grill - Bill before tax with unknown and unexpected up-charges not listed on the menu. Not good... - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

See all

Visiting from out of town. Found this on yelp and really loved the looks of the menu. Walked in at 4:45 with minimal cars in the parking lot and lots of open tables. We were told that if we didn't have reservations, that the earliest would be 8 PM. A party of 3 - with plenty of open tables could have been served and out in no time. In my business, we don't turn away paying people if we can serve them. read more

FLAMESTONE: May 30th, 2024 Getting settled in Oldsmar, FL., we all agreed on Flamestone for dinner. We got in our rental, put the address in the navi and drove approximately 400 feet. An entire 400 hundred feet?! Two + pedestrian friendly, curvy blocks! That was a laugh! The restaurant is a brisk 3 minute walk from the door of our hotel to the restaurant. My bad! Did I not realize that the restaurant was literally a cartwheel away? Nope. My Yelp brain was no where in high gear. To add to my faux pas, I didn't even check if reservations were required. I'll admit, I've been a mess these past several weeks. Anywho, despite my misguiding, as we walked in, with our non-reservation selves, the friendly and understanding hostess lead us to a round table with very comfortable seating. Describing Flamestone, with its dark woods and candled modern-type ambiance. I'd say it's like a southern cousin of Capital Grill, fulfilling all of our needs with an assortment of shareable apps and individual entrees. Food was great. Aside from the food, our server JP (Jean Paul), with his wonderful French accent was a pleasure. He was a great representation of his country plus an accommodating server, who put the cherry on top our first Flamestone experience. This once disoriented Yelper recommends. TIP: Reservations required :) read more

See all

Flamestone Grill is always a wonderful experience. The manager, Mike, is consistently present and attentive, always making sure regulars feel welcome and seating us where we're most comfortable. Our waitress, Janessa, was fantastic--friendly, happy, and very accommodating. The bartender, Leilani, is also such a bright spot of every visit; she's warm, welcoming, and always remembers us when we come in. The hosts are equally attentive--on this visit they noticed right away when I needed something and stepped in without hesitation. The food is just as impressive as the service. The guacamole, fish dishes, and steaks are always excellent, and the sourdough bread with garlic butter is the perfect start to every meal. Even though it's a polished restaurant, it feels like a true hometown place, which I think comes from it being family-owned and operated. Now that they're open for lunch, I'll be coming by even more often. Highly recommend! read more

Let me start by saying, we frequent this Flamestone location regularly, like every month and every year for New Year's Eve, our party of 12+ reserves the room by the bar for our annual New Year's Eve dinner. However, this review is about a recent visit and really, the last two times we have gone, their food and service has been 'off'. This Oldsmar location is always packed, so the wait isn't the issue, but the food for this visit was so below the usual taste and presentation, that a review was necessary. The buffalo cauliflower appetizer we ordered was delicious. The hubby ordered the grouper sandwich, fried, for his entree and it had no flavor, like unseasoned, and the remoulade sauce was not added to the sandwich. We asked our server for it, and it was brought out, but it was her lack of attention to 'care' that we aren't used to at Flamestone. She dropped off the sauce and left in a hurry. His sandwich came with cold fries and by the time a new batch came out, he had finished his food and we were ready to go. I ordered the steak fajitas and let's just say, Flamestone needs to get out of the fajita business. If fajitas don't arrive to the table still sizzling, then something was done wrong. The meat was soaked in the juice and the veggies looked like they were added after the meat was cooked, so they didn't appear to be seasoned or cooked. Again, our server didn't ask about them, only dropped them off and kept moving. My food came with truffle fries, I'm assuming, but I didn't see that on the special menu and when she dropped them off, she did just that and kept moving. Our server, Jessica, was in a rush all night. Yes the restaurant was busy, but rushing our service is never a good idea. She never asked how our food was until we asked for to go boxes. She did keep our refills on drinks, she did that in a hurry too, but again, she didn't seem to care that I packed all of my food away. She never asked how my dish was or if she could do anything to make it better. It was almost as if she was trying to rush us through our dinner so we didn't have the opportunity to let her know how our food truly was. It was a bad experience for our dinner, one that left a bad taste in our mouth (pun intended). I'm adding a pic of my 'fajitas' for reference and I only wish I would have gotten a pic of the soggy fries that went with them. This will not stop us from visiting this location, but it will make me be more vocal moving forward about the service rendered if it is below standards. And this last experience was way below standards. read more

Flamestone American Grill - Special fajitas soaked in some 'juice'. No sizzle and no flavors or cooked veggies. No bueno - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

The food was very expensive. It was over $100 for take out for a family of four. We ordered Calamari, Buffalo cauliflower, Side of risotto, Flat bread Grouper sandwich and fries, Mac n cheese, The calamari was typical. Buffalo cauliflower had blue cheese blobs all over it. Yet also two sealed sauces (blue cheese and buffalo). It was soggy from the blobs of bleu cheese. The Mac n cheese was teeny and looked like a side for $16. The grouper sandwich $22 was less than average, had too much breading and didn't really taste like grouper. The frozen fries weren't good. And the risotto wasn't cheesy rice! What a ridiculous false advertisement. Who makes white rice and throws cheese on it and calls it risotto? I've eaten risotto many times and know that was white rice and not risotto. And the best item was the flat bread. read more

Service is always good, food is always good, they never disappoint, prices a bet high but you have to pay for quality. One of my favorites

If you're looking for Amazing American food, Excellent customer service you must visit Flamestone in Oldsmar! Jen the events manager, Mike the manager & entire staff are INCREDIBLE. We had an event there in March and just wow! They were accommodating & just excellent. The brunch was so good, The Calamari, Salmon, flatbread pizzas, Salads, Steaks, pastas and of course Champagne are all delicious. You immediately feel the love from the family. Great Ambiance too. Highly recommend for events, whether networking, masterminds or celebrat read more

See all

Have eaten at Flamestine several times. The food is excellent. Prime rib is a favorite . Highly recommend !!! Ask for Preston as your serxer. He is great read more

5 star food, service and ambiance. Everyone we spoke to really went out if their way to make my friends special day awesome. Class act Flamestone- keep it going ! read more

Flamestone American Grill - Bday cheescake !! - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

This place was beyond amazing! I was in town staying across the street at a hotel before surgery. I could not believe how exceptional the table side guacamole was. Then we got French onion soup and Mile high meatloaf and when I thought it couldn't get any better it did. I loved it so much I ate there again after surgery. The sweet tea is also incredible!! The service was the best I had in years. The girl making the guacamole was so bubbly and kind. read more

Flamestone American Grill - Mike High meatloaf with the most creamy delicious mashed potatoes! - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

Waitress was amazing, told me she did not like the quality of my steak before I even saw it and was quick to replace the 9 ounce filet as I like it rare. Everything delicious and our server was amazingly attentive. read more

Flamestone American Grill - Foyer entrance - American Near Me - Oldsmar, Florida

This place never fails to impress. The food is always fabulous. The drinks are also. And you can't beat the servers ,very nice and pleasant to deal with. Best bartenders in town!!! read more

Jess was a great server and great food.!! Don't forget to ask for Jess . Gucolmolie wasmade at our table and was excellent. Highly recommend i. read more

Everything went well. The food is great and served by a great waiter, Ruby. The ambiance makes it all extra pleasant. Additionally, my wife and and I were welcomed by the hosts with a big smiling Happy 53rd Anniversary! It starts the experience off with a bang! read more

5 stars - A Total Gem in Oldsmar! FlameStone Grill is hands down one of the best dining experiences I've had in the Tampa Bay area! From the moment you walk in, the ambiance is warm and upscale without being pretentious. The service is impeccable--friendly, attentive, and truly welcoming. Let's talk about the food--wow. The tableside guacamole is a must (fresh, flavorful, and fun to watch being made), and every dish is beautifully presented and packed with flavor. There are so many dishes I've loved here--from perfectly cooked steaks to fresh seafood--all made with care and top-tier quality. The cocktails are just as impressive: creative, well-balanced, and generously poured. Whether you're celebrating something special or just want a fantastic night out, FlameStone delivers on every level. I can't wait to go back! read more

Excellent from start to finish! Everyone at our table loved their meals from filets, prime rib to Seafood risotto. The sides were incredible too. Mac & Cheese, Risotto, Huge Baked Potatoes and Broccoli all cooked and seasoned perfectly. Not to mention their tableside Guac! This place is a must visit. read more

Food, drinks, and table side service was satisfactory. the restaurant was way too hot, zero air flow. There were gnats circling our table the whole evening and the check took an unreasonable amount of time to be given after we had finished dining. read more

Very disappointed with the customer service. Ordered a medium rare steak the steak came out basically just seared cold raw in the middle. I told the waiter they just threw it in the grill and gave it back overdid it and no longer having a crust that I paid extra for. The manager found out when rounding a just blew it off no apology nothing. read more