Good is good. We had mahi- mahi & bourchatta. Delicious.... Service is great by the server- noodles. Thank you for the experience. Ambiance is good Highly recommended to have the pain in the ass drink... read more

If I could give this place zero stars, I absolutely would. This has been one of the most disappointing and upsetting experiences I've ever had with a restaurant. On Saturday night, I ate a shrimp quesadilla here, and by Sunday morning I was violently sick. I had nonstop vomiting and severe liquid diarrhea for hours, couldn't keep down even tiny sips of water or Pedialyte, and the cramping became so intense I could barely stand or walk without help. Things got so bad that by Sunday evening I ended up in the emergency room due to extreme dehydration. I needed IV fluids, medications, and hours of treatment. I was vomiting bile, hyperventilating, extremely weak, and dealing with muscle tingling and cramping from how dehydrated my body became. What makes me the most angry is that food poisoning is NOT something minor, especially when seafood is involved. Situations like this can become life-threatening, and restaurants should understand the seriousness and responsibility that comes with serving food safely. Nobody should go out to eat and end up in the hospital less than 24 hours later. Now I'm left dealing with recovery, stress, and expensive medical bills from an experience that should never have happened in the first place. I genuinely hope this restaurant immediately takes a serious look at its food handling and safety practices before someone else goes through something even worse. Lastly, if it were up to me, this place should be shut down until they can guarantee proper food safety standards. I will also be looking into taking legal action because nobody should have to go through something like this from simply going out to eat. read more

Terrible customer service experience. The four of us were looking for a break from walking around, so I told the hostess that we just wanted to grab drinks and maybe some appetizers, not at bar. We were seated at a table, and the waitress was initially very friendly and asked for our order. We said we'd just have drinks for now. However, she then asked us if we wanted to move to the bar. We declined, but one of our party members asked if they had chicken wings. The waitress said no, and then she immediately went to the hostess. They discussed us, pointed at us, ready to move us. We just got up and left, but on our way out, they were rude and said, "Have a nice day." In an extremely snarky tone. I had been to this place years ago and wasn't impressed, but this really made a worse impression. As a multi-business owner, I would fire this waitress and not make judgments based on her prediction of making lack of money. We went next door to Fat Tuesday's instead, and we spent a hundred dollars there. They were much more welcoming and friendly. read more

Went to Foggartys on a Wednesday night with a party of 3. Its outside on the corner in a very lively area. You can sit and ppl watch and listen to the live music across the street. There was a parking lot pretty close by with paid parking. The place wasnt too busy when we got there. We started of with the tex mex rolls as our appetizer. They were so good. Very fresh and flavorful. I got the Philly chicken with fries. The other ppl in my party got the ribs which they really enjoyed. The Philly chicken was really good. It was well seasoned. Not salty. The fries though, were fried hard and seemed like they had been sitting out for a while before it got to me. The waitress did bring me some more fries and although they were hot, they were still fried way too hard to the point where they were brown, so I definitely didnt eat them. We also tried the baklava cheesecake. Coincidentally, I had tried baklava for the first time 3 weeks prior which I enjoyed. So I decided to give the baklava cheesecake a try. It was actually pretty tasty. Although my friends had never had baklava before, they also enjoyed the cheesecake. The waitress was nice and the manager came around to apologize for the fries which was appreciated. read more

See all

Heavy traffic area. Staff was kind. I ordered the Mahi Mahi sandwich, it really lacked flavor. I also had the banana freeze which is a frozen daiquiri. Highly recommend the daiquiri. read more

See all

Best in Key West. Best Mahi Mahi sandwich on the island. Best burger. Doesn't get any better.

This place was right next to our inn and we had walked by it a bunch of times before deciding to peek in and try it. So glad we did! Our server Sara was fantastic. She was the perfect blend of chatting-with-an-old-friend meets professional waitress. Genuinely talkative friendliness that knew when to leave us to our drinks and food. It's the best kind of server! Another thing I have her to thank for is the tip on the frozen drinks... they use real fruit! SO delicious. I needed some ruffage and have a weak spot for Asian salads... and now I've gone and done it because this was one of the best I've ever had and I can't exactly order it for delivery to Texas! There's so much food but it travels well and you can eat it cold later on right from the fridge and it's still scrumptious. Don't pass this place up! read more

Fogarty's Restaurant & Bar - Asian chicken salad - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Y'all, I LOVED my salad. We were at First Flight and I saw the same salad for about double the price. I would have eaten there, but my husband didn't really like the atmosphere. But this place really like everything, the atmosphere was great. The service is excellent, but they were terrific. When they sat us down, I didn't ask for the bathroom, but they told me so sweetly, so nicely. read more

See all

Unseasonably empty, but great service. Fantastic music, fantastic food. The tacos were huge and flavorful, as well as the shrimp read more

See all

I go to Key West annually, everyday at 3pm I pull up to the bar and have my daily frozen Margarita the best on Duval. The bartenders are always friendly. I love this place and staple in every trip, I have done an annual trip 9+ years and have yet to find a better Margarita! read more

The food here was so good. The ambiance is very laid back with plenty of seating outside and inside. The service was EXCEPTIONAL thanks to BRANDON! Brandon, your sweet demeanor and attention to every detail was outstanding! You are Great At what you do and when we come back we will definitely ask for you. Brandon you made our experience an amazing one. Thank you read more

See all

There are many restaurant-bars along Duval Street but Fogarty's seemed a bit better and it was. We sat outside and our waitress came by right away. She was pleasant and efficient. Our meals were unexpectedly good. The Blackened Fish Tacos had a good amount of Mahi and were very flavorful. The broccolini was tasty and the portions were very good. I would definitely recommend Fogarty's if you are looking for a good meal at reasonable prices in Key West. read more

See all

Had a wonderful lunch! Prompt and friendly service, delicious bruschetta to start, followed by some outstanding tile fish, sautéed. Place filled up for lunch! Right in the heart of the Key West vibe! read more

Best mahi mahi on the island! The service is great. The dining is all outside, and the birds take advantage of that. There are signs not to feed the birds but the dodos still feed them, people not the extinct birds. So you do have a little bit of shooing away you have to do. Everything was delicious especially the mahi mahi. We had salads and shrimp as well and it was all super fresh and delicious. read more

Fogarty's Restaurant & Bar - Don't feed the birds! - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Conch fritters and asian chicken salad. Both were very good. The sale had sliced almonds and mandarin oranges with other "crunchies" that really made the asian salad dressing pop! The chicken had a nice asian sauce - not spicy but sweet and the chicken was moist on the inside and crunchy on the outside Enjoyed sitting outside people watching. There is A/C seating inside. Great place for the kids to eat as well. Our waiter was good and always came back and asked if we needed anything. read more

See all

Ok, my son is complaining that I give too many 5 star reviews, but I tell him that I just pick great places to eat. In the past I generally bypass Fogarty's and just grab a Frozen Rum Rummer for the walk down Duval, but this time I was with a friend and we decided to grab a bite. This is a very casual place with overhead umbrellas and plastic chairs. Not fine dining, but we really enjoyed the whole experiences. The host was very friendly and accommodating when we asked for a table on the porch. The waiter was also very friendly and attentive. One of the managers or owners came by several times with a smile to make sure all was good. It was actually great. This was lunch so I ordered a Frozen Rum Runner and my friend ordered a home brewed Ive Tea. I ordered the Oriental Chicken Salad and she ordered a Chicken Cobb Salad. I have to say, they were really great. If I had one suggestion it would be to go a little lighter on the dressing or serve it on the side, but that is just personal preference. Overall, we really enjoyed having lunch at Fogarty's and will definitely try it again. Cheers! read more

Food was delicious and they were not holding back on the amount of shrimp! Food came out pretty fast too. The vibe was pretty chill and the staff was nice! They also gave very good recommendations for things to do and sights to see. The 16oz slushie is definitely big enough and unless you are going to be staying there awhile or like brain freezes you don't need the big ones. Would recommend to everyone and would go back again! read more

See all

Service was horrible waitress did a terrible job. Got order wrong. Wait an hour for our food and it's not even busy at 1 o'clock. Manager did a poor job of taking care of us made excuses that we're not up to par. read more

Outside restaurant with laid back vibe, but not so laid back that service or food lack. Service was attentive. Started with conch balls, very good and then had blackened shrimp wrap. It was huge and so good! Also tried key lime pie, perfect. read more

Such fast friendly service, waitress was amazing. Food fantastic! Highly recommend !!

A favorite place to grab some good food while in town every year. Plenty of outdoor seating with fans and shade for the hot days. Indoor available with AC also. Staff is always friendly and helpful. Manager stopped by to check on the visit which was nice. Lots of Frozen Drink offerings as well to pair up with the food. read more

See all

We loved this place!! The mahi mahi bites were delicious!! Perfectly fried and yummy! The flying monkey frozen drink was AMAZING as well!! We loved to sit outside at the tables by the sidewalk so we could do all the people watching! It was so so fun! read more

Fogarty's Restaurant & Bar - Flying monkey! - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

We ate there and loved the place!! We had read reviews about a Wait Staff named "Tim" and were excited when he ended up as our Waiter!! What a sweet guy!! Just a great person!! We weren't starving so had the bruschetta and buffalo chicken fingers! Both were delicious and HUGE portions for an appetizer! Would definitely go back again if we weren't leaving tomorrow!! read more

Everything about this visit was amazing. We didn't have a clue where to eat when we got to Key West for our quick overnight. We ended up at Fogarty's and it was the best decision ever. We ended up with koozie drinks, which we refilled twice. Our food was out of this world. I had steak medallions and my husband had a shrimp sandwhich. Had it not been such a long walk from the car the next day, we would have eaten there again. Now, while we were there, a customer tried getting her food for free. She said it tasted spoiled, yet continued eating it. How the manager, Ryan, handled it was amazing and how all customers trying to get free food should handle it. He brought the invoice showing that it was fresh seafood. The customer proceeded to call him a cuss word as he was walking away. He turned around, picked up her plate, tasted it to confirm it was good. Said he would take it off her bill and she needed to pay for her drinks immediately and leave. He didn't need someone treating staff as she was. Even her friends agreed with his response to her. She made sure he knew that she would be reaching out to his boss. I hope he doesn't get in trouble because he handled everything very well. read more

See all

Server shattered a glass and drew blood on my wife. Filled out an incendent report and then they charged us for everything. They cleaned the table into the plate and then asked if we wanted a to go box. Wtf read more

Our first night in Key West, and we picked Fogartys for dinner. Upon arrival, we were amazed at the beautiful atmosphere. We only had maybe a 10 min wait for a table. Tons of outdoor seating, lights, trees, great ambiance. We were seated up on the porch and loved all the people watching! Apparently, they are known for frozen drinks, so I had to order a miami vice! For appetizers, we had the conch fritters (when in Key West), which was a first for all of us, and we all enjoyed them! For dinner, I had the key lime shrimp, which was fantastic and had a bit of a cuban flair with a chimichurri sauce. Would definitely return next time I am in Key West! read more

See all

So much live music from every restaurant along Duval St was pulling our attention as we pondered hard on where to go for dinner. But the bops here ultimately drew us in. Unfortunately, only their drinks were good. All their cocktails came frozen, and I got the Miami Vice, which was pina colada and strawberry daiquiri. I had to question myself twice on if they added ice cream in it, cause it was so creamy. Their Pecan Catch ($29) sounded like a catch, and while the fish was deliciously unique, with the way honeyed pecans coat the fish, the rice and vegetables had no love to them, like they were simply steamed and thrown in to take up space. That is an expensive $29 fish. The outside ambiance and lively music was fantastic, but I would just get something less pricey next time to make up for the lack in quality. read more

Fogarty's Restaurant & Bar - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

This place is great! I Recommend! I visited here while I was in town. Hannah gave great service with a smile. I loved the outdoor patio & bar. I had the shrimp wrap, which was so huge I had to take it to go and eat it as two meals. read more

Frozen drinks were fun. Portion size and food quality was great. Outdoor atmosphere was very nice. Fans around the dinning area are extremely loud and disruptive. read more

Food was pretty good. Atmosphere is great. Right in the middle of everything. Service wasn't the best but still a good place to visit. The flying monkey bar is our favorite daiquiri spot read more

See all

The food was quite delicious. I appreciate them being able to accommodate a party of 14 so last minute. Our server was on top of the ball with such a great a party she did a great job of meeting the customers needs. It was a great spot bc we're were right smack in the middle of the party of key west. I wasn't super sold on the inch fritters but they were t terrible. Everything ultimately tasted great to me. read more

See all

I like the outside garden seating. It is nice to seat in garden after sunset. Temperature is nice during that time. Table start filling up at after sunset. It is important to get to table immediately after sunset. The restaurant is combined with Fly Monkey Bar. You can get a 16oz alcohol drink with souvenirs cup. I got the strawberry margarita. It is nice frozen drink. We have conch fritters as an appetizer. I think the conch has good chunk but quantity of conch is not there. My main dish is the Caribbean steak. It is a marinated skirt steak. It has lime in it. I prefer the lime not add in the steak. Good size of steak. Come with rice and bean and plantains. Good amount of food to fill a hungry person. Service is good. Food come out quick too. read more

See all

Absolutely loved this place! Food is excellent! Lots of choices on the menu and the dishes are packed with flavor! Not to mention, the portions will actually fill you up! Great vibe here as well, perfect for a date spot! No complaints about the service here. 10/10 would recommend! read more

Fogarty's Restaurant & Bar - Key lime shrimp with rice and vegetables - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Nice outside place on corner. 2 bars- sat at one & ordered fried fish sandwich that was the size of a small child. Portion was HUGE but so damn good with the fries. Entertainment was the people watching. Bar tender gave us some good recommendations- some bars open till 4am. Def go! read more

Typical outdoor restaurant in Key West. They have a decent selection of foods. They were packed. It was peak lunchtime. So, service was kinda scarce. I finally gave up on a refill. And just left cash for my bill. As I didn't want to wait on the busy server to process and return a credit card. But overall. As expected. I only wish I didn't have to remove all the tails from my shrimp before enjoying my entree. That made it a bit messy. But it tasted good. I'd say, more like 3.5 stars. But I can't give fractions on Google reviews unless I write them out like I just did. Enjoy! read more

Walked by this place and decided to make a stop after spending majority of the day barely eating anything. I got the great catch, which was far from great, it tasted like nothing. The rice was hard, with no flavor, my company got the ribs, commented that the sauce tasted off. They also don't have sweet tea. Service was good, Sarah, the waitress is kind, friendly and does well but wouldn't stop by here again read more

Fogarty's is one of our must have for lunch spots while in Key West. I choose the Chicken Quesadilla this trip And it didn't disappoint. It was delicious and very filling. Our server was polite and very attentive. While a little hot not at a table that was serviced by a fan, we still had a great time. read more

Fogarty's Restaurant & Bar - Chicken quesadilla. - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great place to eat. I always seat in the back bar area always perfect back there .. I'm huge a fan of the ribs. So good

The food was fine till they broke a glass, and the chards cut me. They had to fill out an incident report which I get but then tried to slide in a waver. The worst part was, they asked if we wanted a to go box for the food that had glass all over it and the charged us for everything. I would go across the street to Carolines read more

Found a spot to get some food, and we were not disappointed. Max was our waiter and Bartender, we got lucky. Food and drinks were fantastic. What staff we interacted with were pleasant and smiling. We met a couple that stated this was their regular spot, I see why. The drinks were fantastic! Check this place out. read more