Really good ice cream. The line is always long and it gets confusing on the queing- i.e. who goes next? The ice cream is really high in fat content so it melts almost as soon as you get it. I recommend getting a cup instead of a cone. My biggest complaint is no sprinkles/jimmies. Are you kidding me?? I understand not using those crappy fakes chocolate jummies but the real chocolate jimmies are delicious. Come on?? Really good ice cream, can be a long wait, No jimmies (BOOO) but I still go! read more

Great summer time spot! Ice cream and there are a ton of great flavors that are really fresh! Gets crowded but always fast service and refreshing! read more

This is simple. Best ice cream anywhere on the planet. Presidents have had it flown to the White House. The food is very simple fare, and very good. Prices are reasonable. The staff is always very friendly and helpful. Highly recommended if you are with small children. Everyone should have the Ice Cream at least once! read more

I have been coming here since I was about 6, which was longer ago than I want to think about! The ice cream is creamy, fresh, and always delicious. My favorites are Peppermint Stick and Mint Chip - both pink! I also love their Butter Crunch - also my mother's favorite. The opening day has always been a sign of summer for me, and I am thrilled that I can now buy quarts and cakes year-round! read more

All I can say is it is the best ice cream I have ever hand in my life!! Heaven on earth!!

It is an experience. The line was long but amazingly quick. The berry ice cream was the best in our group followed by vanilla chai with apple & caramel topping. read more

We always take a long time to decide on a flavor but the ice cream girl was patient and let us make our decision and made a few recommendations for us. They had a lot of simple flavors, which made it difficult for me to choose. I like these flavors better than the crazy mix a bunch of things in types of flavors so this was my type of place. The only thing I was disappointed about was that the pints were prepacked and I could only try two flavors. read more

Love this place, don't let the rustic look inside turn you away. Only downfall is that you have to buy a large to get more than one flavor. The coconut ice cream is great and the store stays open really late. read more

Great, albeit overpriced ice cream. Buy a quart and take it home to try and get your money's worth. I think I will try the penuche pecan, tonight read more

We walked in two minutes before close and while, as a person who works in the food industry, I know that this annoying, however they were blatantly rude and basically pushing us out of the door. At one point a employee locked my grandfather out after he left to get money FOR THERE TIP and proceeded to yell "WE ARE CLOSED". I really do sympathize for being kept later than expected at your job but we took up an additional 10 mins of there time and they all walked away with 2 extra dollars at that. I do not recommend due to the customer service but honestly the ice cream isn't great either. I will never go back that's for sure. read more

The place seems to be a little run down and could use a face lift. This was my least favorite creamery in the cape. Staff was friendly though. Ice cream isn't anything to scream about. A little pricey too. read more

Wanted pistachio but they weren't scooping it so I bought a quart. No pistachio nuts in the ice cream. Disappointed

We did not enjoy four seas at all!! Our bed and breakfast owners were raving about it so we couldn't wait to try it out, but left very unimpressed. All the ice creams were way too soft and it was incredibly hot inside of the place, there was no queuing of the line, just hoards of people with a bunch of different kids scooping ice cream. We got cut in front of, even though I was standing right up front... I got the chocolate almond and a scoop of vanilla chai, the chocolate tasted like they mixed some Hershey's syrup into vanilla, and the almonds inside were soggy, the chai was mediocre and did not have much flavor. Prices were astronomical, with tiny portions!! A "large" (two tiny scoops), was $6.90! We are from a town just north of Boston and can get that same amount which would be considered a small for under $4... another yucky thing was the water they were cleaning the scoops off in, it was very murky and didn't seem very sanitary to me. read more

Such a great place. Classic Ice Cream shop with so much history!

servings are extremely small for the prices. i got a small for $4.50, ridiculous price for a small but it was small size. my friend ordered a large for $7, serving was only a little larger, if you're gonna make it $2.50 extra it shouldn't look the same size as a small, very unimpressed, i work in ice cream and the portion was not a large and not okay for the price. the other parking area is also very dark at night so be careful when backing up read more

Seriously? this place is awful. overpriced and ice cream has no taste. $4.10 for a small? I get same size and MUCH better tasting ice cream in Wrentham, MA for $1.25. Avoid this place, ripoff, tourist trap, with bland ice cream read more

Have come here for years and taking family and friends that visit, but I have to say big decline on quality . Is no flavour , a simple fruit ice cream is no flavour . I am not sure who is in charge, but don't drive that far to have ice cream here. Take this is a positive review and fix the quality . read more

Over all the ice cream shops in Cape Cod, this wasn't my favorite. It's super crowded and the ice cream place is extremely small. I ordered the Banana Ice Cream and they poured tons of Hot Fudge all over it and you couldn't taste the Banana. There's defiantly better like Cape Cod Creamery. But, they sell Merchandise but it's pretty pricey. It's a cute idea but not worth as much money they charge. If you live near bye though, check it out! read more

Surprised this place passes health code every year. The inside is disgusting. But the ice cream on the other hand is second to none. Can't beat this ice cream anywhere on the cape read more

My family has been going there for decades and always loved what we got. On our last trip I ordered a sundae with whipped cream. The scooper comes to show me my order and say this is how the whipped cream is coming out - it looked like some milk had been poured on top. Why bother showing me - like I would want it that way - just say the machine is down. Not really a big deal, I just asked for marshmellow instead. Then he went on to make my wife's banana split sundae. He used a brown mushy banana. You could see through the clear boat/bowl that the whole banana was brown. We said something and he assured us the banana was fresh and that he would ask his manager about it. He came back and said the bananas were purchased each day and stored in a 28 degree freezer so they brown fast. I doubted that because the thing was not frozen but we didn't really want to make a big fuss. Also, my wife is shy and didn't want to reject it. She took a couple of small bites and decided to just keep it. Well she ended up only eating the ice cream and toppings and then just threw out one whole banana slice and the rest of the melted stuff on the bottom which is often the best part. The banana had just become a long clump of mush. For $8.25 you should at least get a good banana. The bananas may have been bought that day but maybe they are saving money by buying old ones. Nonetheless - stop storing them in the freezer if that is ruining them. I think they did change owners fairly recently, maybe the business is just not what it once was. read more

Four Seas is a must for a Cape Cod vacation. But we love it, too. Doug and Peggy are doing a great job with new innovations like Four Seas quarts all year round. Nothing make you happier than turning the corner in November and seeing the sign that they are open. Four Seas is a jewel. Don't miss it when you are in Centerville. read more

I am responding to a listing on Boston.com of the best places in New England for ice cream. Four Seas in Centerville was among them. We live locally, and last summer, during strawberry season, we took a friend to Four Seas. I expected to have the fresh strawberry ice cream of my youth, with shreds of tart fresh strawberries in contrast to the sweetness of the ice cream. Well, there was no sign of fresh anything. The ice cream was pink, and barely tasted of strawberries. We sat down with our ice cream. The table and the seating was sticky and smelly, and the place smelled like mouse droppings. It was absolutely disgusting. We will not return, and we certainly won't take guests there. We will go to Gelato on Pearl Street in Hyannis, where the product is bright, full of flavor and delicious. The store is pristine, and the owners seem to love what they do--make the best gelato my husband and I have ever eaten. read more

Yeah well the Ice Cream is off the charts good & the place has that old time parlor look and feel so what could go wrong?? The lines so when you go be sure to go off hours maybe a sunny day while everyone else is @ the beach....Trust me it's worth the effort. read more

Ice cream just cannot be beat! Absolutely amazing! You have to try the chocolate chip, unbelievable!

Good ice-cream, and friendly service. Definitely worth a try if you're in the area.

I live on Cape Cod year-round and consider myself to be something of an icecream connoisseur (in other words, I just really love icecream). Four Seas icecream is, in fact, delicious. It's very creamy and there's a decent variety. However. I'm not sure it's worth the headache that comes with all the hype and hence the very VERY long lines of summer tourists. It's not actually all of the people that cause the headache, it's the fact that this absurdly popular icecream destination has never bothered to create a more efficient strategy for serving their customers. Once you actually make it through the door and into the shop, you're greeted with a somewhat chaotic scene that reminds me a bit of a crowded bar; servers rushing to and fro' behind the counter, customers vying for their attention. As someone who's never been good at summoning a bartender, this isn't my favorite setup. When the servers are finished with one order they yell "next separate party!!". Oh ok...the separate party (say what?). I became so bewildered by all of the people squished into the tiny space around me and all of the confusion that I wasn't even sure who was next (and believe me, they leave it entirely up to you to decide). So, we ended up waiting much longer than we probably should have, while we tried to be overly considerate of a whole lot of nonreciprocating patrons. Further, they advertise expanded parking to allow more room for customers, but have never added picnic tables or any type of outdoor seating area (there's a small brick pavillion-type area with a few stone benches). Take your icecream to the asphalt parking lot folks, because there's not really another option. To wrap it all up, Four Seas is a very successful icecream business that should put a little more of its likely vast resources into enhancing the customer experience, instead of relying on their quaint, family-run icecream shop theme. While, again, the icecream is superb, I would not say it's "un-matched" (as one of the other reviewers claimed) by any means. Personally, I'll stick to exploring Cape Cod's many MANY other more customer accomodating icecream jems. *As a side note, you can buy Four Seas icecream at many of our local grocery stores. I would recommend grabbing a pint and taking it home over a visit to the shop. read more

Went today 8/29 at 330pm. Staff too busy socializing with each other, milk shake (ordered a frappe) was very watery and missing 4 ounces also charged us a medium for 1.5 scoops ice cream dish. Don't waste your money. Today wasn't even busy. Pretty sad really. Hasn't been up to par in our opinion in 3 years We are locals as well! Portions look like they have been cut in half read more

As an ice cream lover that travels through out USA, I have a prospective on Four Sea's Ice Cream that carry's depth. The quality of Four Sea's Ice Cream is second to none. The freindly out going staff get the orders right and are cheerful and glad to scoop out a treat for every customer. One unique part of teh Four Sea's experience is the line that goes out the door. Waiting in line in most ice cream places is boring! At Four Sea's is a social happening. I dont have "roots" in Barnstable, but when in line, every one is socable and easy to talk to. Four Sea's get the highest marks possible!! Hope to get back in line soon! A happy Ice Cream Lover, living in Lancaster PA read more

A fun experience. Local & tourist come together as one! Yummy Ice Cream. Best idea is go inside and sit down for quick service. I would return again and again...Glad I do not live close as it would not be good for my waistline! Yummy, Yummy, Yummy. read more

Second only to toscannini in Cambridge which is consistently superior in every flavor.

Cape Cod tradition gone wrong. If you enjoy smelly, unsanitary, chaotic conditions than this place is for you. I had not been to Four Seas in years and was very excited that I had the opportunity to try it again tonight. I was annoyed before I even ordered ice cream by the chaos of the ordering process. There was no way of telling who should order next and the wait was unbearable. Once we ordered the young children I was with got their ice cream. One bite into theirs the older child found a piece of green plastic in his. We brought it to their attention and they have him another, only to find a gigantic chunk of ice in that one. My friend ordered a mint chip, that minus well had been called ice cream soup, and she was unable to eat it because of the rancid taste. Mine had some sort of black stuff in a fruit ice cream. Saying we were disappointed is an understatement. We had to leave and go to Gone Chocolate. If you want to enjoy your ice cream, buy it elsewhere. read more

My family and I went to Four Seas today. There ice cream is ok. There staff STINKS. I asked for a Mint Chocolate Chip frap " Thick." The little kid behind the counter adds the ice cream to a cup then adds milk. Then she mixes it for 10 min on high. Then when its done she adds more milk so it was like drinking water. My dad got a small ice cream sunday. He asked for whip cream she gives him marshmallow. Some how she was able to get my mothers order right. So if your going to go there make sure you tell the little kids working behind the counter your order twice. Maybe someday the management staff will train them to listen customers. read more

Very disappointed with our visits here this summer. My daughter ordered a milkshake. After the server prepared it, the cup was 2/3's full. I watched expecting her to add more. Instead, she flipped the cup over with the lid on so the top was coated in milkshake. We thought this had to be a mistake of young teen just learning. Because we live in Centerville, we gave it another chance. My husband ordered a shake. The server, a different person this time, did the same thing! Flip the cup. Make it look full. His shake was a bit over half full. And the cost -- $6. For a long-standing ice cream shop, they should not be trying to deceive customers. Not fooled. Won't be back. In addition, the ice cream is always melted. Go to the Smugglers in Dennis. Worth the drive!! read more

I use to beg my parents to take my here when i was a kid. When you are a kid you don't understand what you are eating just that it tastes great! Well the time of being oblivious of whats in foods is a thing of the past and I am an ingredient hound. You put in cheap ingredients and I will find out. This ice cream is soft and odd tasting. Does not harden in the freezer just stays a pleasant mushy texture. Ben and Jerry's is a better choice for ice cream if you really want something made with decent ingredients. The thing that makes people like this ice cream is that its made with liquour and it just doesn't do it for me anymore, real ice cream is real because its made with real ingredients not with corn syrup and odds and ends that somehow others just don't read or care to know. read more

Simply the Best. I lived in Centerville for 20 years, and since I have moved away, I have never found better Ice Cream. Each time I return to Cape Cod, I make several visits to Four Seas. The ice cream is very creamy. Flavors are fabulous, service is great. The environment has a great vibe! Honor students from Barnstable high school keep the line moving nicely. It is a landmark on Cape Cod NOT to be missed. As a local and now a visitor, I give it a BIG thumbs up!!!! read more

I love this place. I live in Southern California but visit the Cape frequently and always make sure to stop at Four Seas. The ice cream is so creamy it doesn't even freeze. The best ice cream hands down. read more

Been here in past- a few years ago-- great ice cream then- not from this area but always wanted to return. Went there last weekend to bring a friend. They were open with limited menu. Walked in and I was shocked! The place was a mess. Half of the store looked like it was under construction or the inside of an old garage filled with junk. The counter, serving area was covered with packing supplies. The woman handed me a scrap of paper with the flavors (7). I was afraid to order. We did order a "tot" size cone which was less than 1/2 scoop-- $3! No explanation or acknowledgement of the condition of the inside. It was like going to a hoarder's ice cream shop! What happened? This place should have beened closed until it was cleaned up properly. I was shocked and sooooo disappointed . It was also disrepectful to the customers that have made this place so renowned over the years. Will NOT return! read more

Yes, I am tough when reviewing ice cream, because I know what I like, and I've made several batches of ice cream at home. Let's start with the good. The service was good, and the employees stood by waiting while we were making up our minds on what flavor we would like to try. The shack was clean, and had no bad odors, (which is a very hard thing with kids spilling ice cream everywhere). However, the ice cream itself had a few flaws. The ice cream could be described by some as creamy, but there is a fine line between creamy and sticky. The texture was almost of glue mixed with putty, which didn't make the flavor seem any better. The ice cream also had a very strong, bold flavor that left a bad aftertaste in my mouth. It had a certain bitterness to it, meaning that the ice cream needed lots of sugary additives or toppings to balance the flavor. This, in my opinion, was not something I would like to have again. read more

Just not as good as it used to be. We've come here multiple times (a week) every summer for 20 years. This year, things have declined- service is slow and somehow the high school kids who work there aren't so friendly. We've twice had cookies so burnt we asked for replacement ice cream sandwiches. Sadly we've taken to driving by Four Seas on our way to Katie's or Steve and Sue's. read more

Best ice cream on the Cape and I have tried many others. Service is also great. Lines are usually long but they move you through quickly.