My husband and I recently stumbled upon Gio's Pizza & Restaurant during an extended stay in Islip…read more We moved from New York to the West Coast and have been dying for some quality, delicious New York pizza. Gio's Pizza & Restaurant was everything we loved and missed. It truly tasted like a slice of home for us. Delicious and fresh slices with friendly and quick service, we could not have asked for a better experience. We found ourselves coming back several times during our trip. Gio's Pizza & Restaurant is located in a small strip of shops with free parking shared among the businesses. The establishment has several chairs and tables for customers to sit and enjoy their slices. Many people at the time of our visits took their food to go, but it's nice that they have the option to eat in if people would prefer that. They offered many different types of pies on display and also had some awesome daily specials. I'm fairly simple with my order with a plain slice and some garlic knots, but my husband tried an array of things and enjoyed everything. Gio's Pizza & Restaurant is going to be a staple place for us to visit the next time we're in Islip. Excellent food, good service, and fair pricing.

Absolutely terrific Pizza you call your order you pick it up everybody's so nice there we go back…read morethere every single time we fly into New York and go visit Long Island

Francesco's is consistently a solid choice. Their shrimp…read morenight is delicious and a great deal

Absolutely wonderful experience tonight! My wife and I enjoyed the Chicken Night special that…read moreincluded soup or salad with a wide variety of delicious choices for entree. The Picata was plentiful and delicious and the chicken parm with vodka sauce and hot cherry peppers was sublime. Tremendous portions that include warm and fresh garlic knots and a cannoli with coffee or tea to finish. The restaurant could not be more hometown with its cozy decor and local youth working hard with great attitudes. Highly recommended on any night. Great job, Frank!

Da Noi is the great Italian restaurant you might not know about. Situated on Montauk Highway in…read moreIslip, Da Noi serves Italian-American cuisine that competes with the best. Baked clams are my "litmus test" for Italian restaurants, and theirs are in my top 10. Their menu is insane! So many choices, so many specials each day, and a huge assortment of desserts. If you cannot find something to eat, there is something wrong. The bar area is very small, so don't plan on spending too much time there before you get seated. Their staff is attentive without being annoying, and their dining room is large and welcoming. Once seated, you are greeted with complimentary bruschetta and their ample bread basket. Two things I recommend ordering are their clams and if you eat rabbit, definitely get theirs when it is offered. Portions are huge and the quality of seafood is always fresh. They have a small lot in the rear of the restaurant, with both a rear and front entrance. There is also street parking available (do NOT park in the bank lot across the street--you will get towed).

I recently went to DA NOI restaurant in Islip on May 5th 2026 for my husband's birthday. We also…read morehad a friend with Us. Right out of the gate the male host was rude. He wanted my friend to sit in a certain seat and my friend preferred to sit in a different seat. The male host responded with sly remarks. My friend ordered a glass of Chianti and told the Male host that it tasted off. The male host told him it was not and begrudgingly brought him another glass. The wait staff acted like we were a bother to them. They were cold and distant, and did not make us feel welcome. The food was just OK. We spent $300 with tip and the service and food did not meet up to this expectation. It was a Tuesday night and it was quiet in the restaurant.

Been a customer since they opened their doors. They're devoted to providing excellence and they…read morelive up to it. Food is prepared fresh daily, staff is polite and everything is delicious

If you want a run of the mill meatball parm hero that consists of 2 meatballs cut in half for thie…read moreproce of $15 I suggest you go here.

If you're having trouble finding street parking keep a look out for free parking lots you can park…read morein. My friend and I were welcomed wonderfully by the staff. We got a table fairly quickly and were greeted by a wonderful waiter Dennis! He was sooo happy and greeted us with a smile! The food was DELICIOUS! The Troffolini was incredible! What made the sauce special was the sweetness of a pair. The baked clams were incredible! Not only did our main dishes look beautiful, but they tasted fantastic! A perfect place to catch up with a friend or go for a date! Thank you to everyone at Americano Pie Bar for their great service!

Attentive service and great value with generous portions. Perfect for casual dining and large…read moregroups. Excellent cocktails, and a huge beautiful bar. A neighborhood staple. Love the gf pizza options.

We needed a break from watching little league baseball games. After the final inning, we headed…read morewest from the field, and I initially thought we were heading south toward the beach. Instead, we found ourselves wandering into Vinnie's Mulberry Street. From what I had read, it is a classic Italian eatery known for its simple pasta dishes, brick-oven pizza, and traditional entrees. We decided to sit at the bar, seeking a relaxed atmosphere and a few drinks to unwind from the long, boring games. The bartender greeted us warmly, and his friendly, accommodating demeanor immediately made us feel at home. We did not come for a full meal this time; our main goal was to enjoy some drinks and a bit of downtime. I have to say, I really loved the bartender, His easygoing nature and attentiveness made the experience memorable. I am sure the food is fantastic, but that is a visit for another day. For now, it was the perfect spot to relax and recharge after a day of little league baseball.

Always a good slice, quick service, ample seating for pizza and dinner. Nice variety of slices to…read moreenjoy. Isabella is a favorite of my kids, and I love their mac and cheese slice and sausage and broccoli rabe slice.

I like Mary's and we have gone there for years, but lately there seems to be less attention to…read moredetail. The last three times I have ordered take out there are ingredients missing from parts of my order. Twice I paid extra to add cheese to a chopped salad and the salad had no cheese. Today I ordered a panini that is supposed to come with pesto and it came plain. It would just be nice to get what you ordered, especially when I am paying extra for some things.

Still five stars for food, service and ambiance. Best pizza place on Long Island, hands down…read more Changed it up this time and also got some chopped baked clams, scrumptious.