Was craving pizza: specifically a vodka and a margarita slice. I wanted to try a new place so I checked out this pizzeria that was new to me and close by. I got one vodka and one margarita slice they were $4 each. It was pretty empty and service was quick. I had the two slices to go, by the time I got home they were warm. First look, they were super oily. Already, the paper under is all covered in oil and the slices themselves look very heavily oil. Flavor wise, both slices tasted pretty good. Personally I liked the vodka slice more. They were both so floppy. It was a little difficult to eat without the oil and the sauce getting everywhere because of how floppy the slices were. The sesame crust is super interesting and tasty! The pizza dough was thin, but was not crispy. Overall: not a bad pizza slice! Tastes good but it was really too oily and too floppy for me. read more

See all

Ordered delivery and didn't have any issues. I love grandma pizza and have a favorite pizzaria for it in Bay Ridge, but I wanted to give it a try here since it's closer and I saw a lot of good reviews. It's decent but I've had better. The taste was slightly lacking and the texture was a bit off (it was crunchy but also felt a little stale at the same time). Also ordered a cheese pizza pie with sesame crust and it was decent, but there was no flavor. I liked the sesame crust, but the plain cheese was my least favorite. The garlic knots were normal and my family liked it, but it was nothing special. It was kind of doughy and packed with a lot of garlic flavor. Overall, I would give the grandma pizza another try. read more

Frateli's Pizzeria - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Ordered some pizza from here the other day to check it out. Plain Rice ball was filled with cheese instead of the typical beef and peas you find at most spots. This surprised me in a pleasant way. Chicken roll was ok. The pizza was great, they have options for sesame crust which was exciting, but got to me after two slices (I count this as personal preference - I overestimated my love of sesame seeds and that is no one's fault but my own lol). read more

See all

Sesame crust pizza! Mind blown. I love pizza crust but this took it to a whole different level. read more

Frateli's Pizzeria - cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Was served dry old over cooked chicken cutlets.I mentioned it to the guy in front, the head guy and he ignored me and is very rude and unfriendly. He shud not be working there, he looks miserable! I wasn't even given a discount for this didnt even eat it. When he knows I go there often. That was an insult. Will never go there again!!! They lost a customer !!!! read more

Like the pizza here alot but... it's doughy. Needs to be in the oven a little longer for a crisper bottom rather than doughy bread bottom. Yummy. They just need to work on that. Came here with hubby for pizza lunch on a sunday afternoon. Ordered small pizza pie (12"); half pepperoni (+ $$$) and half cheese, an order of garlic knots and 2 cans of cokes. read more

Frateli's Pizzeria - Small (12") pizza; half pepperoni (+ $$$) and half cheese - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I'm rarely on 18th Ave, got hungry for a slice. Not close enough to my favorite 18th Ave pizzeria so figured what can be bad. I'll try Frateli's. I got a regular slice and a spinach slice. I have to say I was pleasantly surprised! Dough was nice and crispy, light and the sauce was not bitter at all. The spinach slice was a white slice with sautéed spinach and garlic. It was wonderful! I'm a one slice gal but I ate the both of them! Just to think all the years I'm passing and not going in. you just never know. Go to Frateli's! read more

Walked in for a quick slice during lunch hours. The staff is kind, the pizza is fresh, and the ovens are hot! I love the grandma slice but am also a fan of the upside down slice. The Caesar salad slice was interesting and well done. 4 stars for a good quick slice and a nice crust! I'll be back! read more

The best Grandma pizza EVER!!! I've tried so many and in different states as well! nothing comes even close. DELIZIOSO!!

actually a solid pizza slice! got a pepperoni and their crust was unique because it has sesame seeds on it. chicken roll was naaaaaat great though. very average and left me sleepy like a deeky inside is so hot though holy balls i was just eating my c hicken roll and was seewating so much. do not go here for a date if you're easy to sweat or your pits will stink up a storm service was good ambiance is like a pizza place lol parking is tough on this street unfortunately. They take card and cash but i think card is an extra 4% processing fee zzz read more

I won't even sugar coat it, I wasn't a fan of the food here and I hadn't gotten food from Frateli's in a long time. My daughter's friend recommended the Spinach & Artichoke Pizza so we tried it. It is absolutely amazing. One of my favorite slices of pizza now. Just on the merit of that, Frateli's has won me over. read more

This place is the best. I really miss the sesame crust. I moved but will go back to 18th avenue for that pizza!

Better square than L&B. I have tried others to compare and half the price of spumoni gardens.

Great neighborhood pizzeria! Staff is really friendly and the pizza is delicious. The sesame seed crust is our favorite! The rice ball special is amazing and the customer service is . My pie got crushed en route when I called the resturant they immeaditely sent me a brand new one. Customer service can make or break a place for me and these guys are great! read more

Had a refreshing lemon/cherry ice while waiting for my order to be ready, owner behind counter was very nice - deal was a full size pie an order or garlic knots and two liter soda for $16 can't beat it! Especially since the pizza was so delicious with sesame seeds on the crust! I would definitely recommend you give this place a try! Check their monthly specials too! read more

Frateli's Pizzeria - Sesame seed crust! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I order delivery through seamless from Fratelli's quite regularly and they deliver a warm cheesy pizza and wings on time every time - the order is spot on and the quality of food is about as good as it can get for delivery. I personally like sesame seeds, but to each their own, I guess. read more

The pizza was HORRIBLE! I ordered from seamless today and as soon as you take a slice off the box, the cheese falls apart instantly and flopped altogether. The pizza was dripping with oil and to make matters worse, the slices were cut unevenly. Please up your quality! You deliver in Bensonhurst after all. Respect the name and reputation. read more

Frateli's Pizzeria - full of oil - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Frateli's Pizzeria has great pizza. The sauce and the cheese are like classic New York slice which is obviously very good. However, I would recommend the crust without the sesame seeds. I think that the sesame seeds ruin the flavor and don't really taste that good. Furthermore, the wait time for a fresh pie can be around 10-15 minutes. Which isn't that bad. However, pricing can be an issue. A cheese slice costs $2.50! Now, that is way above average in New York City and the taste doesn't make up for the price premium. A slice in New York City in places like Manhattan and some iconic places can cost $1 while I believe the average price is $2 a slice. In simpler terms, it costs too much for a regular slice of pizza. Overall, good pizza but high price. I would definitely go here to order a pizza pie over just going here for a quick bite to eat. read more

Panini wasn't a typical panini but more a mini sandwich small for the price. Food was average- price, first time ordering from here wasn't impressed, may or may not reorder in future read more

Their pizza is so delicious! Seriously 1 of the best I've had on 18th Avenue. & they're always so nice ! I definitely plan on trying their other dishes as well. read more

I love Their Sesame Non Cheese Vegetable Pie! Totaly Delicious! They are Wonderful ,Professional Too. Check Th

We found this place by accident. Happened to see it on 18th Ave and gave it a try. One of my better decisions. Their pizza is delicious and the sesame seed crust is great. Sandwiches and specialties are also exceptional. Fast delivery and everything comes piping hot. You need to try this place! Since my last review, Frateli's has continued to make me a happy pizza guy!! I am in love with the sesame seed crust and its always delivered HOT. And the entrees are reasonably priced and flavorful. Keep it up Fratelli!! read more

The best pizza slices I experienced back in NYC: tasty, generous, hot, really hunger killing slices with a pronounced tomato flavor. The price is very affordable without sacrificing quality. The location is accessible. The customer care is the best. I certainly would buy again when back in NYC from Brazil and that day I came all the way from Manhattan for the best two slices of my entire trip. read more

Worst service every , the pizza was overcooked call and asked for a reorder instead they yelled and hanged up NEVER ORDERING AGAIN.

The guy who made my pizza was taking the money and with the dirty hands NO GLOVES packed the slices to the box. I will not eat it and because of this I will never come back again (even though I live close and I heard that the pizza is good). I don't care about the taste if there us anti-sanitary. Very sad. read more

The food itself is pretty decent. But that's basically all I can say about this place. I have placed orders through grub hub that they have royally screwed up. Twice they say that they "didn't see" my grub hub order go through. If you participate with grub hub then it's expected for them to actually look at their grub hub orders. Once placing an order for delivery expect to wait a long time too (I'm talking over an hour). Be prepared to also call them because they screwed up your order. read more