A great kept secret Pizza spot for the Dyker Bensonhurst area. Bring your basket ball , soccer ball or just your appetite for some high quality pizza . So many types to choose from or customize your own. My favorite is a well done large with mushrooms and fresh Garlic . The delivery service is also top notch and they always deliver within a respectable time . Call and ask about their large room that can be rented and or host a large family . Tell them I sent you and ask for Marlyn . read more

This place has terrible customer service apparently you cannot get a delivery if they are busy if you aren't spending over 20 dollars

Every time I go in here it takes an absurdly long time for just mozzarella sticks and one slice of pizza. The worst part is that while the mozzarella sticks took borderline 20-25 minutes my pizza is just sitting there for all that time getting cold and soggy... I was practically the first person in there and about 5-6 people came in after all got there orders before? This long wait for no reason is not the first time this has happened so I will not be back... also 6 dollars for one margarita pizza is too much for that long wait. I understand rushes happen but when I worked in food service the in person orders came first... read more

This is not my go to pizzeria and the reviews are very mixed. In my opinion the place needs a facelift although the food is good. I usually just stop by to have a slice to go and that's it. If you can get paste the decor you will be fine. I did have a great experience on my last visit and that's why I'm writing the review. I came by for one of their chicken fajita slices which was great the last time I had it. The time was around 9:00 pm and they were out. The pizza man behind the counter offered to make me a few individual slices. Now that's going out of your way to delivery outstanding customer service. As it was a cold night I decided to order their minestrone soup which was tomato based and was freshly made. It was great. Even though I don't think they offer waiter service the woman behind the counter brought everything over to the table. Very cordial and nice. The prices were extremely reasonable, the soup came with warm Italian bread and the pizza was awesome. The pizza and soup came out in a shorter amount of time than I would have expected. I would recommend them for a quick stop when you are not expecting anything fancy. It's not a place for a date although it's great for a reasonable priced meal that tastes good. read more

Bklyn's Pizza - Chicken Fajita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I live in the neighborhood..I have been ordering food from here once a week for years..When I ordered my meal tonight they left out the seltzer..When I called to tell them the person who answered the phone was soon nasty and hung up on me twice..He was talking fast and with his accent I asked him to repeat himself so he got annoyed and spoke to me like garbage..I never ever complain..but this is the 3rd time this person hung up on me because I asked a question..it really upset me..The delivery person said we told him never to answer the phone..so obviously there's been other issues with this worker..I will NEVER NEVER EVER order food from this place again...there not the only game in town!! read more

I was working at PS 229, doing several Lunch & Learn presentations for teachers. I asked the Principal for the name of a nearby pizza place that they usually ordered delivery from. He gave this place's name. I called yesterday & placed the order. I needed 3 different delivery times & they were happy to oblige. On presentation day, the food came on time & hot. The delivery guy was friendly and placed the food & soda exactly where I asked him to place it. I did manage to sneak a couple of slices between sessions. Pretty good. If I need a pizza place in the neighborhood again for lunches, I know who I will call. Thanks guys. read more

This is the family go to pizzerias during covid. Pizza is not bad especially with their family specials. Also the panini's are stuffed with chicken unlike competing pizzerias around the neighborhood. Prices are great with the specials so check this place out. read more

Not sure what this slice is called, maybe Grilled chicken veggie slice? ‍ either way ITS AMAZING! I've had it more then one time and every time it's been very crunchy and fresh. Absolutely DELICIOUS and flavorful. read more

Bklyn's Pizza - Grilled chicken veggie slice. ? - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pizza arrived almost 2 hours after ordering. The name for order was given to courier and shouted for him to come back but he still went to next door neighbor. Red pepper flakes spilled out of the bag and pizza tasted okay. read more

Ordered on a busy Saturday night for 2. Good price and very delicious!! Ordered Margherita pizza, mini potato croquettes, cheese rice ball and onion rings all under $20! Super full and even had some left over. read more

Bklyn's Pizza - Margherita Pizza, Potato Croquettes, Rice Ball, Onion Rings - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Awesome service and friendly staff. The pizza sauce was also really fresh. Highly recommend if you're in the area.

Not good for walk-ins. I just walked in and ordered a panini and a wrap. It's been 30 minutes, and I'm still waiting. This must be a place where you're supposed to order deliver or call in before you pick it up. I wish I was told that the wait was going to be this long when I ordered, especially since I was a walk-in. read more

Best Margarita Pizza I've had! Made the way I like it! Friendly neighborhood place and great people! Have the Margarita at least 3 times every week! read more

Bklyn's Pizza - Master Pizza maker with personal Margarita Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

They took too long to deliver half and hour and I live down the block from them , they do this every time I place a delivery

I placed an online order through GrubHub for pickup for lunch since I was hungry and at the spur of the moment just thought why not my local pizza joint. I've been here more than once. Decor - The outside of the restaurant is fairly well kept and presentable. Once inside there is seating to the left and a standing area to the right where you can place orders and pick-up orders. They have their selection of special pizza's on display by pies but sliced up ready to throw into the oven and order along with some calzones and rolls on display. Service - Friendly service and attentive. They greet you once they see you and ask what would you like to order. They don't rush you even if you're standing around. This seems to be a seat yourself pizza restaurant as all majority local shops are. So there would be no waiter service here. I've never eaten in here, majority it is always take-out. Price - Fairly reasonable for this area. Much cheaper than the city of course. I ordered (1) slice of regular pizza for $2.30, a Chicken Parmigiana hero for $7.50 and (1) potato croquette for $0.80. Total was $11 and change but I had a discount from GrubHub so my order came out to $6 and change. Portion - The size is comparable to a regular slice in the $1.00 pizza shops in the city. Nothing special. The Chicken Parmigiana was a good size for a hero, had a couple of chicken cutlets inside along with an average amount of mozzarella cheese and marina sauce. The potato croquette was the size of a small hot dog. Just stuffed with potato the outside layer was a thin bread crumbed layer. Taste - The chicken was not too dry with not too much sauce to over salt your taste buds. Good amount of cheese to mix in with the sauce and chicken. The regular slice had a good amount of cheese and sauce mixed in. Again nothing special for a regular slice. The potato croquette I'm really not a fan of. It was stuffed with potato filling and the layer outside was soft. I didn't really like the taste of it, it had a bland taste to it. It definitely needed some sauce to go with it, but there wasn't any. Overall - Your average go to local pizza joint if you're in the area and crazy for a regular slice pizza or hero and not that papa john's crap. Average pricing for a local pizza shop in the Bensonhurst area. I definitely would order from here again if I'm craving for a regular slice of pizza or a nice hero. read more

I am impressed, Brooklyn's Pizza Joint was simply fantastic. Awesome menu. Every single item that we have purchased was extra fresh and yummy. Crew is really polite and can help you with everything. It was great. read more

lady! You're rude! If this is your business what a shame. The guys working behind to counter always look overworked and overwhelmed. If I could give half a star I would. read more

Loved this little spot. Monday deal: $9 for large pie and pitcher of soda! We got a small and it easily fed our family of 3. A small and 3 drinks was $16! Good pizza at a good price! read more

Bklyn's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I order two family special pie that came with drinks,. Garlic knots and cheese stick. I place the order on seamless. Suppose to take 45 minutes but it took almost an hour to get to my work. My coworkers was hungry. I told them to call my cell phone when arrive. They rang the doorbell instead. The pizza taste ok. The cheese stick seams bland and garlic knots are too oily. I ask for Pepsi and sienna mist. They gave sienna mist and diet pepsi. So not only they are late they gave the wrong soda. read more

Decent pizza joint, they have a nice space by Dyker Park that used to be a Chinese food spot many years ago. There's plenty of room to sit and eat along with a private party area in the back. Standard round pie is good, on par with many of the other pizza joints in the area (see what i did there?) It's a popular spot with the kids coming out of school on weekdays so prepared for loudness and on and off crowding during the times when school is let out. I'm not a fan of their Sicilian pies but the chicken rolls and calzones are pretty good, Solid overall spot if it's convenient for you. read more

The minute I walked in and saw the vegetables slice of pizza, I wanted a slice but I wasn't in the mood for pizza so Had the small spinach roll for $ .80 and garlic knots for $1.50. The spinach roll is so good but wished it was more crispy. But the garlic knots was really salty. Next time, I'm getting the vegetable slice. read more

As a Chinese, I'm not a big fan of pizza and won't miss it for long time don't have it. But this place, u gotta try! It's soooo good, that's the one I always want to go back if want pizza read more

First time ordering from here and definitely my last!! My partner and I were torn between subs and pizza for dinner and found this place on Grubhub. The menu and reviews seemed decent enough so we figured we'd go for it. I ordered an Italian Combo sub and asked to substitute provolone cheese with muenster. I added a can of orange soda to go with it. My partner ordered a sausage parm along with a bottle of cream soda. We settled on splitting mozzarella sticks, garlic knots and an order of mini bites and made a note for each order to add a side of marinara sauce for dipping. As soon as the food arrived we noticed that the bottle of cream soda wasn't included and neither were any of the marinara sauce sides we asked for. No big deal, we figured we'd just call the place to let them know and see if they could just redeliver the missing items. Immediately the man on the phone started to argue with me saying that I never ordered the bottle of cream soda, only the orange can. I told them that this wasn't the case, and they proceeded to get more aggressive. It's bad enough the man I was speaking to was talking down to me in a condescending tone, but I could hear another woman and man in the back yelling over him into the phone saying "tell her to look at the receipt she didn't order any bottle, she got her can she didn't order any bottle!!". I asked the man to tell whoever was yelling over me to stop as they were being incredibly disrespectful and that I am simply trying to explain the missing items from my order, to which he responded that I should "just open up my phone and look more closely at the receipt because I wasn't charged for any bottle". I tried to explain to him that I had my Grubhub order receipt open on the computer and clearly saw that I was charged for the bottle of cream soda, to which he proceeded to talk over me telling me I'm not looking hard enough because on their end I got everything I needed. He was completely rude and continued talking over me and telling me I was wrong. There was absolutely zero desire to even attempt to tend to the issue at hand on their part. Frustrated, I hung up the phone and decided to contact Grubhub. I did not pay $30 to be yelled at and called a liar over something as minuscule as a soda bottle. The missing items themselves weren't even that big of an issue but their response left me in absolute shock at the horrendous customer service and lack of professionalism. While trying to get this matter resolved with the help of a very apologetic Grubhub rep (who by the way confirmed our cream soda bottle and additional sauce orders), I realized that my hero came with no mayo whatsoever and was burnt. It was the driest hero I've ever tasted, and they didn't even bother replacing the provolone cheese with muenster as I had noted on the order. It's as if they didn't bother reading any of the instructions we had provided and just proceeded to pack up and deliver whatever they saw fit. We were advised by the Grubhub rep that the manager agreed to refund just the missing the soda bottle. No apologies or anything. The mozzarella sticks were cold and dry and while the mini bites were pretty good the rest of the meal went down much like the pizzeria's behavior and customer service attitude- completely distasteful. Never again. read more

Waited over an hour for a pie, some garlic knots and potato croquettes. The is pizza barely lukewarm, no sauces came with the sides. I'm So disappointed the pizza could have at least been hot! It's ridiculous to have to wait so long to get cold food. We normally order from the same pizzeria and decided to try this place out and will definitely not be ordering from here again. read more

Food is good, good service. There were kids running around and constantly staring at me. I'm assuming its the owners/workers children, c'mon this is a place of business. There was this one annoying fly pestering me but disappeared when I started this review very odd. read more

Bklyn's Pizza - a kitchen with a checkered floor - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is a story about the delivery man who was "too new" to realize that stealing is not ok. Also known as- the worst customer service of all time, ever. It all began on a snowy night, a friend and I decided that the only thing that would warm our cold hearts would be a delicious slice of pizza. It's late, not much is open, but Bklyns pizza is, and the reviews aren't bad. I order a pie on seamless, pay with my card, and wait for it's arrival. A little over an hour later a decent pie makes it's way to my apartment and I feel satisfied. That is until I realize that this pizza cost us $50. A fifty dollar pizza you ask? Yes, you read right. I sent my friend down to get the pizza, he tells me he covered it and we eat. We were drinking wine, so it took me a minute, but it finally hit me, why did he pay for the pizza when I already had put it on my card? Well because the delivery guy said it was not paid for, my friend had no idea, and he wouldn't even give him the receipt. By this time the place was closed and I had to wait till morning to call the restaurant. The next morning I called and spoke to the manager. He told me he had to ask the delivery guy if this was true and if i wasn't a bored lying jerk, I would get my money back. He called back an hour later, told me he was sorry, that the delivery guy was new and he would send the money back. No, false, he took the money because he could. He knew it was paid for and pocketed $25. He took it because he's a thief. I asked the manager, if he was new, but not a thief, did he give you the $25 when he got back, to pay for the meal? After a long pause I got a short yes. Lies. So Mr.Manager, what you're saying is, he gave YOU the money and YOU thought it was ok to keep it as long as I didn't notice? Why didn't someone call to tell me I paid twice? Why didnt you at least refund my card and keep the cash? If you had the money, had this all worked out, and planned on giving it back, why did I have to wait an hour for you to verify my story?? I will tell you why kids, because the delivery guy is a liar, the manager is a liar, and the restaurant is untrustworthy and does not mind scamming a customer out of money. I waited a total of 4 hour to get my money back, and that was it. They clearly did not need my business. The manager lied and argued with me and that was where it ended. I am so completely outraged at the lack of not only customer service but morals in general. After speaking with the person who runs this establishment I am not surprised by the criminal they hired as a delivery man. My recommendation- do not order. The pissed off end. read more

The service here is great. The servers are friendly, and the delivery is quick. There are games for kids in the back and there are TVs, usually playing a good movie. The food is really good, though sometimes it can be a hit or miss. The vodka slice here is by far the best I've had - I highly recommend it. The regular slices are also delicious. My only complaint about the pizza is sometimes the dough is too thick on specialty slices like the buffalo chicken or chicken/bacon/ranch. Other than that, it's great! The chicken roll is also really good, but for less than $2 more you can get a chicken hero, which is what I suggest doing. All in all, Bklyn's Pizza Joint is very good, and I intend to remain a regular customer. read more

Pizza is ok, never tried their dinners, I have Krispy not too far from me so I think their pizza is a little better so I usually only go to this place if I'm in a rush since it's closer to me read more

First off the staff is always friendly. Secondly the prices are reasonable for the food your getting. It's quality stuff and great pizza. Always here when the wife doesn't cook. Love it times 10 read more

Not sure where they came up with the name of this pizzeria because the slices do not live up to the standards of Brooklyn pizza. You can get a much better slice just a few streets away. They do offer a lot of speciality slices and rolls, but if the cheese slice is any indication of the rest of the menu, I'd keep walking. (granted, I did not try the others). Garlic knots were hard and tasteless. Mozzarella sticks were good, but those are pretty hard to screw up when they just need to be deep fried. The dipping sauce was nothing to be desired. They have a nice party room in the back, which is great for a kid's party (and my reason for being there). Overall, it was edible, but I would not go back. read more

My go to spot to get a slice of pizza. There is a big selection of pizza and other foods. I always get a buffalo chicken slice because there is nothing else like it in the area. Pizza crust is crisp and the toppings are really good. No complaints about this place. read more

Consistantly delicious, very clean, great group of guys they're always nice and sometimes they give me a free roll here and there. One of the better pizzerias in the area.if L and B is too crowded I come here. Never had a bad experience yet. read more

Friendly workers & many varieties of pizza to choose one. I had the vodka slice and it was creamy and rich. They also have a chicken salad pizza that looked amazing. Regular slice was thin and not too greasy. Def will become a regular now. read more

Bklyn's Pizza - Vodka pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The best Pizza in town..Meatball parm is amazing too..prompt delivery and courteous service...thanks guys

Pizza is acceptable Dough is good it's the cheese that is crap, not a deal breaker on the pizza but definitely don't bother with the lasagna or other dishes, I had the lasagna last night cause they are on seamless but chef-boyardee would have been better Stopped in to the store tonight because every pizzaria between pizza den and this place was closed read more

It serves good pizza. I normally get the stuffed pizza so I know they aren't cheap when it comes to the portion sizes. I recommend it.

Greattttt Pizza and AMAZING customer service! This is by far my new favorite local pizzeria! There food tastes great and they will GO OUT OF THERE WAY to satisfy all needs! Thank You Brooklyn's Pizza Joint!!! read more

if you want good pizza this is the place to order. Have got pizza from this place since the day it started always been really good.

Well I was hungry had friends over and we wanted pizza . I called them even though the first time I called was horrible experience . I called the second time and ordered a large well done pizza I repeated WELL DONE I DONT CARE BURN IT IF YOU WANT. So I wait 45 minutes the pie comes driver leaves and I get a regular pie lightly cooked SURPRIZE I should have known better. I call ask the guy on the phone if hes the guy who took my order for the WELL DONE PIE BURN IT he said yes then I tell him didn't I ask you for well done ? He said why ITS NOT ? IF IT WAS WOULD I BE CALLING YOU WHAT STUPID PEOPLE WORK THERE !!!!!! DONT ORDER HERE IF YOU WANT TO GET SOMETHING YOUR WAY. Try any other pizzeria they care about customers read more

As if the service wasn't bad enough, the pizza was a joke! Ordered the pizza and was told to wait 10 mins. which was no problem but I waited 30 mins!!! No apology or whatsoever! Just took the damn pizza and the two rolls I ordered home. I couldn't be more upset when I got home, I opened the box and the pizza barely had any cheese on it and the whole pie looked undone. Are you serious??? Owner, please check on your staff more and train them to more polite toward customer. I'm your regular customer but I don't think I'd be going back anytime soon. Very disappointed! Waste my $32 on crappy pizza and crappy service. read more