Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fratelli's Pizza NY Style

    3.7 (281 reviews)
    ModeratePizza, Italian, Seafood
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Fratelli's Pizza NY Style Takeout or Delivery

    Fratelli's Pizza NY Style Photos

    FRATELLI'S PIZZA NY STYLE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for groups
    Happy hour specials

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fratelli's Pizza NY Style

    Public Attention Alert

    Public Attention Alert

    This business recently received increased public attention resulting in an influx of people posting their views to this page, so we have temporarily disabled the ability to post here as we work to investigate the content. While activity or content supporting racism, discrimination, or bigotry have no place on Yelp and we unequivocally reject them in any form, all reviews on Yelp must reflect an actual first-hand consumer experience (even if that means disabling the ability for users to express points of view we might agree with). Learn more on Yelp Support.

    If you’re here to leave a review based on a first-hand experience with the business, please check back at a later date.

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    BBQ wings
    Katrina F.

    Fratelli's has truly become our go-to spot whenever we find ourselves in town. It feels like dining at a beloved relative's home--except this relative happens to be a culinary genius! We kicked off our meal with their complimentary garlic knots, and let me tell you, if you're a vampire or just someone who avoids garlic, you might want to think twice. But for everyone else? Get ready to fall head over heels for these warm, garlicky, and delightfully oily bites of heaven! The wings stole the show--plump, crispy, and perfectly cooked. The steak was so tender and seasoned just right, while the Stromboli and calzone overflowed with cheesy goodness that made our taste buds sing. Everyone raved about the chicken Parmigiano, and my salmon was cooked to perfection; flaky and flavorful, it was a treat I won't forget anytime soon. As incredible as the food was, the service took it to another level. Being family-owned and operated, you can really feel the warmth and care in every aspect. If you're craving Italian, pizza, or even Peruvian cuisine, Fratelli's is the place that will definitely satisfy your cravings! By the way, they have a Santa ready and available to take pictures!! I'm telling you, this place is amazing!

    Jeff O.

    I grew up around Italian families, an uncle 100% Italian so to find this place here in the south was such a treat. Cannelloni w ricotta was excellent, pasta was cooked just right. My wife had the Fettuccini Antonio - shrimp salmon vodka sauce. I love seafood but the sauce alone made that entree delicious. Our waitress Tabby was attentive without being annoying. She knew each dish and recommended a wine that went well with dinner. Interior was nice spacious and accommodating. It's not a coat and tie place which to me made it more like home. By the end of the meal we felt more like family than guests. Will definitely be a go to for us.

    Spaghetti and meatballs
    Raymond L.

    This has become our go to Italian place. I brought my grandson here several months ago and he loved it. That required that I take his brother a few weeks later. Now my wife likes to come here (she enjoys the chocolate mousse cake). We especially like the garlic rolls. They have even made sausage and peppers for me (not on the menu... should be) a couple of times.

    Denise B.

    Each visit, I receive great customer service. The staff is always attentive. I have tried various items on the menu, but the Fettucine Antonio is absolutely amazing. I would have given them 5 stars, however; there was no crabmeat in the dish the last few times. It's still worth a try without the crabmeat.

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Page 8 of 8

    Ask the Community - Fratelli's Pizza NY Style

    You might also consider

    Provino's

    Provino's

    3.8
    (355 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    $$

    This my absolute favorite Italian restaurant I always are…read morewith them at their Duluth location years ago then they moved to Snellville Few years later I moved to Lawrenceville and now I'm back Everything is still deliciously prepared If you have been before GO

    I had my birthday dinner there last night June 29th and as usual the food was delicious! Provinos…read moregives you $14.50 towards any meal for your birthday but you must go on your actual birthday and show ID. The only meal that you can get absolutely free is the spaghetti with meat sauce or marinara as it is $14.50. I think when the pandemic was over you were able to get anything but in today's economy I'm happy with the $14.50! My friend and I both love the salad (I get all the beets bc he doesn't like them ) plus he gets his rolls sans garlic whereas I love garlic! I got my usual Canneloni El Bianco which is SO GOOD that you know it has to be bad for you but what the heck it's once a year! He chose sausage and peppers and for once he couldn't clean his plate! The birthday person also gets a scoop of ice cream with a cookie and candle. Our waitress Allie was great with us but she forgot several items for the table next to us that was my birthday twin Mary who turned 83. Of course, Mary kept her on her toes . The ambiance here is lovely except the place could use a deep cleaning until they do it don't look at the lamps on the tables if dust offends you. The health score was perfect. We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves once again!

    Photos
    Provino's
    Provino's
    Provino's

    See all

    Osteria Olio

    Osteria Olio

    4.1
    (78 reviews)
    34.6 mi

    If you had told me Athens had a spot with this level of elegance and ambiance, I probably would've…read moreasked, "Where has it been hiding?" This was my first visit, but my friend had been before and couldn't wait to bring me. Now I completely understand why. From the moment we pulled up, the valet parking set the tone for what turned out to be a wonderful experience. It's such a nice touch and instantly made the visit feel special. Inside, everything felt elevated without being pretentious. The atmosphere was beautiful, the service was warm and attentive, and the food absolutely delivered. Every bite was flavorful, and the cocktails were just as impressive. What made the experience even better was discovering the spa next door after brunch. We took a peek, and now we're already planning our next visit--a relaxing spa day followed by another amazing dinner. It's always exciting to find a place that feels like a little getaway without leaving home. If you're looking for great food, handcrafted cocktails, exceptional service, complimentary valet parking, and a sophisticated vibe right here in Athens, this spot deserves a visit. We left already planning our next visit, and I can't wait to experience it all over again!

    Five stars all the way for Osteria Olio. The food and service were both outstanding, but their…read morehospitality really set them apart. We originally had a 7:45 PM reservation, but showed up early hoping for a change. They were incredibly accommodating and got us seated immediately at 6:30 PM on the patio. It turned out to be the highlight of the night--we absolutely loved the atmosphere out there. Even for an early spring evening in Athens, the heaters were positioned perfectly and kept us comfortable the entire time. It's rare to find a spot that's this flexible and still executes at such a high level. Highly recommend.

    Photos
    Osteria Olio's bar and lounge seating
    Osteria Olio's bar and lounge seating
    Osteria Olio
    Dining Room of Osteria Olio

    See all

    Dining Room of Osteria Olio
    Luciano's Ristorante Italiano

    Luciano's Ristorante Italiano

    3.9
    (667 reviews)
    11.3 mi
    $$$

    I've driven by this place countless times and when my husband came here for a work event and raved…read moreabout it, I knew it was time to try it. We were here on a Monday night (President's day holiday) and it was crowded. I'm glad I made a reservation through OpenTable. Once seated at a table in the middle of the dining area, I noticed it was a little stuffy. The table can seat four but I think it would be very packed with all the plates. I noticed the plate I had when I sat was dirty so I just switched it with another vacant plate. The server took away occupied silverware and plates. It felt more spacious. Focaccia bread was brought out with sun dried tomatoes dip and it was delicious!! Not tarty at all and I wish there was more of that dip because it was so good. My husband warned me that their portions were dainty so we ordered calamari appetizer (I highly recommend) and caprese salad (also good and fresh). My husband got tomato basil Alfredo fettuccini with chicken and I had Alfredo fettuccini with salmon. The salmon was cooked to perfection. I found it odd that the server asked how I liked it cooked and I elected for well done. It was so tender and buttery just melts in your mouth. The fettuccini was okay. The texture of the noodles were dumpling like maybe it's homemade but still good. I did order broccolini as a side but someone dropped the ball and that's why I had to dock a star. Overall, I think it's a romantic place to bring a date but the servers aren't too warm but still professional. My husband said there's a business event section upstairs and offers privacy. I think his only complaint was that the logistics of the "buffet" appetizers was awkward so a lot of the food went to waste. I think he mentioned more serving ware like plates and serving spoons would have been helpful. I also think the to go bag is very nice. It's like a reusable grocery bag and fairly large. It's a nice touch. I saw a lady bring her dog. I don't remember seeing an outside patio and I have a dog myself and am a dog lover. I'm not sure what that was about (is there a separate area?).

    Pretty place, really crowded. I liked the complimentary cheese bread with tomato dip. We also liked…read moreour martinis! We got the artichokes appetizer which was good. Then we got entrees. Not the best. The tomato basil fettuccine Alfredo - it was recommended as being "amazing" and the "most popular" dish.... It left a lot to be desired. The noodles were extremely over done with some noodles actually burnt. A lot of noodles were actually stuck together. The noodles were worse than if a college kid boiled store bought noodles and then forgot about them on the stove. The Alfredo sauce wasn't necessarily bad but it needed to be creamier and needed more flavor. I will say there was a lot of blackened chicken on the pasta, but again, needed more flavor. The pepperoni flatbread was ok. Extremely thin. The server told us it had the pepperoni that curls into little cups. That was false. It was regular pepperoni - which is fine!! But the flatbread overall just wasn't great. I know this is an Italian place in a shopping center in Gwinnett, but I was still disappointed.

    Photos
    Inside
    Inside
    Chicken Parmigiana
    Chicken Parmigiana
    Luciano's Ristorante Italiano

    See all

    Luciani's Italian Restaurant

    Luciani's Italian Restaurant

    4.5
    (69 reviews)
    19.3 mi

    The food here was OK nothing special. I really don't like the bar being the first thing when you…read morewalk in the door, as the wind and Street noise hits you every time someone walks in. Service was very good though. I tried this place twice and just won't go back.

    Luciani's Italian Restaurant is a great date night spot. Pizza, pasta, salad, and amazing…read moreappetizers all wrapped up together - what more can you ask for? The location recently expanded its dining room, giving the location an even more authentic cozy dining feel. The associates are all very attentive. Our waitress for instance walked by regularly to check in on us while other associates also came by and asked if we needed anything. My husband and I have visited this place many times and have tried multiple items off the menu. On this visit we shared a salad and appetizer and each had our own "main course." We shared a small Greek Salad which was quite large if you ask me. The flavor on this salad is what I will ramble on about to anyone that wants to hear about where they can get an authentic salad of this caliber. We also shared the Spinach and Artichoke dip which was really yummy and very creamy. My husband ordered Stromboli (he took half of it home), and I ordered a slice of Sicilian Pizza (topped with pepperoni, jalapeños, and spinach). So great, especially for the price paid!

    Photos
    Luciani's Italian Restaurant
    Pasta Creations (angel hair, pink sauce, chicken) and Chicken Parmigiana Hero
    Pasta Creations (angel hair, pink sauce, chicken) and Chicken Parmigiana Hero
    Small Greek Salad

    See all

    Small Greek Salad
    Roma Italiano Ristorante

    Roma Italiano Ristorante

    4.1
    (352 reviews)
    14.8 mi
    $$

    We have driven by this place countless times, and never stopped...shame on us! It's a pretty small…read moreplace, but comfortable spacing, atmosphere was very good, and staff were all very friendly and attentive. We ordered the calamari and bruschetta for appetizers and we were asked if we wanted the free garlic knots (BIG MISTAKE) The calamari were good especially because my husband and son prefer the rings and the whole plate were rings. My mother had never had them before (we didn't tell her what they were) and she also thoroughly enjoyed them. The bruschetta was ok; it was very different than I'm used to because it had tiny mozzarella balls in it, which were nice, but seriously lacked garlic and the tomatoes were blah. The thing I like about the most were the slices of bread around the bruschetta because they were soft and crunchy in all the right places. Those garlic knots on the other hand are trouble ...the dough was so fresh and had so much flavor, I ate 2 of them and couldn't really eat my entree, but they were incredibly worth every bite! For our entrees I ordered penne alla vodka (I wish the made it with rigatoni. I thought it was ok. It seems too thick and not as good as I've had elsewhere, but maybe I was too full already because my husband thought it was very good. My husband had eggplant Parmesan which was a very nice portion and cooked perfectly. My mother had a cheese calzone which was probably the biggest and nicest cook on one I've ever seen and she really enjoyed it. My son had sausage and peppers and he really like it even though he doesn't generally like red sauce, but the sauce that came with garlic knots and calamari was all the same, and he loved it. The only thing he wasn't thrilled with was the sausage were all sliced. We all expected to have whole links, but they were thinly sliced longways. I wouldn't say I'm in a hurry to go back, but I would again and maybe get one of those calzones for myself or try pizza .

    I sat at the bar for about 10 min before someone asked me "if I was picking up an order" or "if I…read morewas placing an order." Service could be better. Nobody was in the restaurant. I think 2 tables inside and 1 table outside. Ambiance was pretty cool. I ordered the chicken florentino which was a chicken breast with a demi glaze sage sauce, topped with mushrooms, & mozzarella cheese and mashed potatoes. The food was really good. It's very flavorful and very appetizing. Next time I will stop by and dine in, instead of do a to go order maybe my experience will be different.

    Photos
    Restaurant
    Restaurant
    Valentines special spaghetti pesto with blackened shrimp
    Valentines special spaghetti pesto with blackened shrimp
    Shrimp Diablo

    See all

    Shrimp Diablo

    Fratelli's Pizza NY Style - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...