Amazing ice cream and even better ice cream sandwiches. The owner Lisa was very helpful and…read morerespectful of my time and the people around. Outside reminds me of a nostalgic 2000s ice cream parkour. Would definitely come again.

OMG. The best ice cream on the North Fork. So much better than Magic Fountain which has an…read moreaftertaste on most of their flavors in my opinion.

Honestly will never stop raving about this place. I love how they have rotating flavors so it never…read moregets boring. I come to Mattituck every summer so it's always a treat to come here for ice cream. My personal favorite flavors are Cookie Monster, Lots of Stuff, and Krispy Kreme. They even have pints to take home and treats for your pet!

I've been coming to Magic Fountain since I was a kid, and for good reason! They have delicious ice…read morecream from a rotating menu of flavors that has so many interesting concoctions. On my most recent trip, they had Dubai Chocolate and Spicy Mango, both really fun and delicious in their own way. I ended up getting a scoop of the North Fork, and it was delicious. My friend got a vanilla milkshake and gave rave reviews as well. There's usually a line snaking out the door (the inside isn't very big), but they've got a good system for keeping things moving, so don't be dissuaded. If you're driving to/from the North Fork, make the drive even better with a stop here!

My dad and I stopped by for a scoop and had a lovely experience. I misunderstood one of the topping…read moreoptions and the fantastic team at Gemelli were so accommodating in redoing my scoop. Great service and delicious gelato. The outside is so cute too, perfect for a relaxing summer night!!

Cute little gelato shop right off the highway that satisfy the need for something cold on a sunny…read moreday. The owner was originally from Jackson Heights, where one of my friends with me is currently living. He and the server were both quite friendly. Three of us enjoyed their product over the weekend and felt that it was good, but melted a bit too easily, which made it messy to eat. My favorite flavor was definitely Hazelnut, but Pistachio was good too.

Some of the best pies you can get on Long Island! It's definitely worth the trip even though it's…read morepretty far east and north. Saw NJ and CT licenses so people are coming from out of state just to get these pies. We got the raspberry cream and peach cherry. Both delicious but will try more next time because I'm positive they all taste amazing! There's not much parking but people come in and out within 15 minutes typically. The pie line is usually outside the store since the inside is so small. I recommend knowing what you want before going in so they can just pack it for you immediately and keep the line moving. There's a nice field next to the store if you want to walk around a bit after the drive. There's a porta-potty

The raspberry cream pie was delicious. Would get it again. It was so hard to pick a pie, wish they…read morehad slices so we could try more. Guess we have to go back again LoL. The carrot cake with walnut was alright. Nothing special. Thin layer of frosting.

Love Ben and Jerry's so very excited one opened up close by! It's brand new so it was clean, the…read moretables were dirty but we just wiped them down ourselves. Ordered 3 comes and it came close to $30, ouch! 2 of the three cones were suppose to have sprinkles in them, but I guess the employees were told how much to put on, the barely covered the ice-cream we seriously could count the sprinkles lol It was good. Do better with the toppings! Good Luck

From the owner: Head to our Riverhead ice cream shop and dig into any of our euphoric Ben & Jerry's ice cream…read moreflavors in the way the first scoops were served up by Ben and Jerry back in 1978. Come enjoy a freshly baked waffle cone, shake or sundae with your favorite flavors.

Came here for dinner and had a decent experience…read more We ordered a few appetizers (we wanted to try the pizza balls but they were out) and everything was good, especially the garlic Parmesan wings. We got the chili poutine which was more of a sauce with beans and the shrimp ceviche was very vinegary. Entrees are sizable and a lot can be prepared GF. The lasagna was decent and everything tasted good. The service was friendly all though it did take a hot minute to get our drinks despite the place having been empty. Prices are a little high but that's fine. The restaurant itself is quite nice and cozy.

Went at lunch on a Saturday and we asked to be seated outside. We chose the enclosed patio. We were…read moreseated upon arrival. Our waitress Sue was very attentive. Everything came out in a timely manner and was delicious. Burger was great, wings were crispy. We highly recommend the Banana Caramel Cheesecake.

This place is hidden on Main Street next to a little coffee shop. It seems to have all the little…read moretrendy snacks seen on social media. They have many things in the menu: ice cream, smoothies, crepes, and many other things. We chose the eloté con taki's. It was hot and fresh and everything you would expect it to be. They had Guatemala merch like bags and shirts and even some of the prepackaged snacks they offered were from Guatemala. If you're in the area and looking for a snack this place will have you taken care of. The family who operates it was very nice and friendly. They were quick and all of our order was correct. Tip: the temperature inside is warmer than most places in the area would typically be.