Absolutely delicious sandwiches at Geoff's! We had the Reuben and the pastrami sandwich and both were amazing -- fresh, flavorful, and packed with meat. The bread was perfectly toasted and every bite was incredible. You can really tell they use quality ingredients and put care into their food. We'll definitely be coming back again. Highly recommend! read more

Geoff's has been a favorite of mine since my days at Classical High in the late 80's and rediscovering it when I worked down the street from their old location back in 2010. Their sandwiches are (to steal a line) superlative! You can get an awesome plain Jane deli sandwich (ie Turkey sub, ham & cheese, corned beef, etc) OR go through the literal DOZENS of concoctions of their signature sandwiches...you can't lose! Tucked in on South Main St now down by the pedestrian bridge, you can people watch the pedestrians (usually coming & going from either financial district/Downtown or the court houses as you await your culinary masterpiece to arrive)...you won't be disappointed! My current faves are Jen & Berry or The Juggs; but I have never had something that wasn't pleasing. There are long tables, so if you are by yourself or a small party & it is packed, you might have to share; but don't look at it as a drawback...look at it as connecting with a fellow human being(s). read more

Add two more tasty sandwiches, prompt service and crunchy pickles to the list of positive lunches at Geoff's. The choices seem endless, but we finally selected: * Rachel * Roger Williams (hold the onions and tiger sauce) The former is a perennial favorite while the latter was a new choice. The Rachel was excellent, as usual, with tender pastrami, and nicely melted cheese. I also liked the Roger Williams which had a tasty stuffing. It was a huge sandwich, warm and nicely toasted. That said, I always prefer real turkey over the coldcut variety any day! 4.5 stars rounded up to 5. read more

See all

First of all the menu is huge, so many sandwiches options and on top of that you can build your own. I loved the names of their sandwiches, and each one was very unique. I tried one of the turkey sandwiches which wasn't bad, but it felt like the combination of ingredients was a little off. There's lots of seating inside which was nice, but we had a dog so we grabbed a park bench outside. It's a good spot for a quick lunch or takeout sub! read more

See all

I ordered the turkey/avocado/tomato/mustard/pickled onion sandwich on a superlative roll a few weeks ago. Sometimes a sandwich does its job in gorgeous simplicity. Very fresh. Turkey was thick and juicy. All components were fresh and texturally ideal. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

I have been gobbling up scrumptious sandwiches from Geoff's for the past 40 years! They are just as delicious as the first time I stepped into the tiny shop at the old location. Sandwiches, so many with funky names, are always stuffed with fresh ingredients. The service is prompt and very professional. Plenty of convenient street parking, a variety of different seating options plus a kiosks if you prefer to electronically send your order. I've been there so very many times over the decades and I always sit there contemplating all the sandwich choices. Hope to see you there. While you're there try and find the original pickle barrel!!! read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - The Roger Williams - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Save your money. Better off eating at subway. Terrible portion size for the price. Looked like something I'd send my first grader to school with in a lunchbox. read more

The bread was so soft and tasty, great sandwich! I got the Godzilla and really enjoyed it. The whole wall was full of options, all with clever names. Took a minute to decide! I originally was looking at the salmon but turns out they were out. There was plenty of seating, nice wooden picnic tables. I think the school crowd was away, it is right near RISD. read more

See all

Made a short day trip down to Pawtucket/Providence to visit some friends. Ended up going to Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches. As soon as you walk in, you realized you've got some choices to make. With 3 large sections of wall (floor to ceiling) listing all their premade sandwich options, there's bound to be something for everyone, and if not, you can build your own. Though they break it down into categories (meat, fowl, fish, meatless, and others), it can certainly be overwhelming. Though they had many great options, their method of naming the sandwiches doesn't make it very easy to decipher. So unless you've been before, you'll have read through many of the descriptions to find what you may be looking for. I got the "J Savage" in a superlative roll, which is basically a Buffalo chicken sandwich with honey mustard, blue cheese, Swiss and avocado. The superlative roll was a bigger bulky roll, very soft, though maybe a bit more bread than the rest of the ingredients. If I got it again, I'd go with the standard bulky roll, to get better ratios. But the staff was friendly, and once we'd placed our order, the food came out quickly. The J Savage use large chunks of chicken tossed in Buffalo sauce, and other flavorful ingredients, very tasty, but again, perhaps not the right ratios for the superlative roll. It was a good experience though, somewhere I'd try again to sample some other flavors. read more

See all

This place has a huge selection of sandwiches and line that typically goes out the door. After eating here twice, I'm baffled by what makes this place so great. Maybe I'm ordering the wrong things, but for about $11 a sandwich, I'd expect a bit more substance. I've had the Italian and The Gagger and both were lacking actual protein and the Gagger was so poorly made where almost half the sandwich was bread and spread. There should be more meat for the price! The only thing I'm gagging on is all that damn bread with no meat! Also, the bread options... be clear on these. You have to ask and they point at things similar in size. Either standardize or show examples or something. read more

See all

Awful. Couldn't have messed the order up more if they tried. Mayo on side = dripping with mayo.. it literally looked like they added a quarter of a cup of mayo in between every single slice of turkey. BLT Toasted = not toasted. Ordered chili, no chili. Beyond that: portions were awful. The BLT basically looked like half a sandwich when you took it out of the bag and weighed so little I thought the paper it was wrapped in was empty when I pulled it out of the bag - for $12. The bread was miniature and the sandwich was 1/2" thick. It should've had more than one tomato slice that was white and crunchy on it, too. Still trying to figure out this math... the girl at the register asked if we wanted the free pickles. I said "sure yes please!" She asked, "one or two?" I said "well, it's four sandwiches for four people so a couple for everyone would be great." She handed me the bag and said "great, I gave you five." (?) Cute chalkboard menu and space - beyond that absolutely all show and zero on execution, attention to detail. The funny thing is I heard the two kids behind the counter talking and once said "was this supposed to be mayo on the side?" and the other one said "no I think they wanted it on top and on the side". Actually, they didn't .. and you didn't give it on the side anyway - just tons in between every single slice of turkey it's not like it was just on the bread and you could scrape it off. So gross. I'm not kidding. I heard one say to the other "oh this is supposed to be toasted?" so they questioned themselves out loud yet never toasted it. Just bad - and I never leave bad reviews. I will give the "assistant manager" credit; when I called to give them feedback he said he was sorry and their mistake, yet didn't offer to refund the sandwich that could'nt be eaten. :-/ read more

Best sandwiches, best counter staff I've been coming to Geoff's since the 80s. In the intervening years, the snark level has gone down (no more "we reserve the right to serve refuse to anyone" sign... did that sign inspire Talking Heads to write Psycho Killer which was recorded above the old Geoff's location?) The food quality has continued to be spectacular. The meat is fresh and tasty. The bread is amazing. The toppings and menu variety is out of this world. The staff knows their sandwiches! "Would you add onions, tomatoes, or both?" Is always met with a thoughtful response. Most places fail to live up to memories... Geoff's is the exception because it's exceptional! read more

I've been meaning to check this place out for years...then I moved away...and years added on some more. OMG, I was missing out. This was located right on South Main Street. Parking was metered and on-street. We were walking and exploring and happened to stumble upon the shop, which was perfect because I've always wanted to try out their sandwiches. The service was quick and friendly. The decor was rustic and there were plenty of seats/tables. I loved their huge menu on the wall and the mostly Rhode Island theme names of the sandwiches. They have over 90 recipes and you can customize the sandwiches as you'd like. This time I tried out the "Jen and Berry" on rye; this comes with chicken salad, melted Muenster, lettuce, onions, mustard, cranberry sauce & sweet basil. Oh My Gosh. So Darn Good. The flavors intermingled so perfectly together; I wasn't a fan of their pickles but people seem to love them. I had the Dirty Potato chips with funky flavor and Empire root beer, those were great too. If I lived in RI again, I would be there weekly. I already have a list of sandwiches I want to try out next time I visit. Not surprised they're in business for over 40 years! read more

See all

Before boarding a train from Rhode Island to New Jersey, my friend offered to buy me lunch. Wanting something easy to eat on the train, we ordered sandwiches from Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches. I ordered the David Cicilline sandwich on a superlative roll. The roll was soft and held up well to the amount of ingredients in the sandwich (meats, cheese, onions, peppers, etc.) as well as the oil and vinegar. All in all it was a pretty tasty deli sandwich for the price. read more

I understand that this is primarily a lunch place and I stopped by to pick up dinner so the staff can be forgiven for being less than friendly. But they were angry that I ordered food. And I was not the only customer there so it wasn't like I was stopping them from going home. The restaurant itself stunk of cleaner; overwhelming and oppressive. After I ordered the cashier/server disappeared for a good while and was unsmiling/unfriendly throughout. The food itself was fine. I didn't enjoy my roast beef/Patsy Cline as it was generally bland. However, I tried some of the and french fries and the rueben and those were good. Basically they were saving grace of the whole experience. Otherwise, I don't have much good to say. On to price: although the portions were sizeable, nowhere does it claim to have "fresh" "organic" "local" or what have you ingredients to be as expensive as it was...and for 3 sandwiches and an order of fries... a very small order of fries by the way. read more

I went to Geoff's on a quiet day over my work's holiday break for a quick bite. The menu is huge and can be very overwhelming, but there is truly something for everyone. I opted to get a tuna sandwich that had banana peppers, balsamic, sprouts, tomato, cheese, and bacon. It seemed like a crazy combination to me, but it was so good! I ordered my sandwich on the superlative roll and it was a large portion. I ate half of the sandwich and saved the other half for later. You order with one staff member and then move down the counter where another person checks you out at the register. They also offered complimentary pickles, which is the key to my heart! There are many places to grab lunch in PVD, but Geoff's is a great option (with many menu options)! read more

The location & interior of Geoff's are probably the two best parts. Right down makes this place highly walkable & inside is large & open making it easy to meet up with friends for lunch. I usually am against looking up a menu & deciding what to order before visiting I highly recommend it for your first visit to Geoff's as the menu is large & can be intimidating if you aren't prepared. The superlative roll was delicious & the best part of the sandwich. Unfortunately I found The Providence Monthly to only be fine. There wasn't enough chicken compared to the amount of lettuce & sauce & I found the sandwich to not be filling enough because of it. This might just be a miss order & I plan on trying Geoff's at least one more time & being more prepared before going. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Sitting Area - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

My son and I stopped in to this awesome sandwich shop for an early dinner. I had a tuna melt on a fresh bulky roll, lettuce and tomato, chips and dill pickles. Fantastic. My son had a ham and cheese on a torpedo roll with potato salad and pickles. He was extremely satisfied. The owner was in the restaurant and made his feelings of appreciation known to us by thanking us for patronizing his restaurant. Very rarely has that ever happened to me in an eating establishment. The sandwich menu is written in chalk on an entire wall before the ordering station. So many options! My estimation is there were between 30-40 sandwiches all with bread and add on options. If you like a sandwiches of good portions and taste you have come to the right place. read more

I had never heard of this place until recently and once I discovered they had a thanksgiving sandwich I knew I had to try it. I got the "Roger Williams" (turkey, stuffing, bacon, cranberry, sprouts, lettuce, onion, tomato) on a spinach wrap to-go and it was amazing. I cannot attest to other menu items as I will forever only order this sandwich, but I promise you will not be disappointed if you try it. If you're not this kind of sandwich lover, there are still SO many options to choose from, even some salad options too! I also received a pickle with my sandwich (another one of my favorite foods), and I would rate it top 5 best pickles I have ever had. Although I got my food to-go, it was very comfortable inside, had lots of seating and seems like a great atmosphere to sit down and grab a bite to eat! read more

the restaurant staff witnessed a true halloween horror when they saw costumed customers enter 10 mins before closing on halloween night (sorry!) -- this didn't stop them from providing superb service & whipping up stupendously delightful sandwiches. Thanks! read more

Sandwich was good. Lots of options. Lots of choices. Free pickles is a nice touch! Good atmosphere and service was on point!

First time in and we ordered three different sandwiches. We got a traditional Rueben on rye which was very good. Only complaint was that it's not very big if you're super hungry. I ordered a roast beef with provolone and really liked it. The bulky roll is just a round soft bread which is a really nice flavor. The picture is of the chicken George. It's a chicken salad sandwich but my husband wasn't a fan of the consistency at all. It was almost a spread versus chunks of chicken so that was a miss for him. The space itself was really clean and the service was great. I'll definitely be back! read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

Great local shop for sandwiches! You also get "free" pickles but note that they are behind the counter so you have to request them. Sides are available for purchase such as chips or fries. Service is fast. I didn't interact much with the staff other than ordering. Inside, it's casual, first come first serve seating. You order at the counter then grab a table and wait for your food. Prices are comparable to a cafe or an artisanal sandwich shop. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

Hot buns food was to saucy and staff was so rude walked up to counter and bro says just wait mind you whole place is empty I took a seat for 5 minutes before he even took my 1 sandwich order then took him 10 mins to make. read more

Great place! Ate inside and it was very well decorated and very clean. The staff was very friendly. Had two wraps that were also great. A little heavy handed on the mustard for me but otherwise very delicious! read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Jen and Berry - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Had a pretty good tuna sandwich from here! The tuna tasted fresh and not too fishy, the way I like it. I took mine to go, and ate half on the walk which was not bad at all! The second half was a little soggy on the roll when I got home but I still enjoyed it. The inside was very large with lots of seating, good light, and comfortable sitting areas. I thought the huge menu was really fun, but since I don't eat meat there's not too many more for me to try. However the Steve's Cascione (tuna, spicy mustard, pepperocini) is my favorite way to eat tuna salad so I was happy :) I also witnessed a very angry customer come in and berate the staff for making a mistake on her order. To be fair I wasn't there when she ordered, so whether or not they were careless with her order I can't say, however she was very angry and the cashier (maybe the manager??) was pretty calm with her, issued the refund, and no scene was made. Hopefully the staff felt safe, people make mistakes! read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Steve Cascione - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Once you walk into Geoff's, you will see these huge chalkboards with the menu options. There is a great selection of sandwiches from different types of meat, vegetarian, fish, egg, and salads. After you have decided what you would like, you would place your order. He was great in recommending the type of bread/roll for the sandwich. Then, you will move down and pay at a different register. At the register, you will be asked if you would like any drinks or anything else and given free pickles if you like. We ordered the Banzini Brothers - roast beef, ham, turkey, cheese on a roll and Alan Shawn Feinstein - hot roast beef, Swiss & mushrooms with horseradish on rye bread. For one of the 1/2 Alan Shawn Feinstein sandwiches, the sandwich was falling apart and it was a little messy to eat. The other 1/2 of the sandwich was better put together. The bread and ingredients tasted fresh. The Banzini Brothers was good too, but the mustard wasn't too evenly spread so some bites were heavy mustard. Service was quick and people are constantly coming in. The sandwich was fulfilling. There are plenty of tables to sit down and enjoy the sandwiches. After you finish, you can empty the trays and put the trays on the table. read more

See all

There are a huge selection of sandwiches at Geoff's. The menu is arranged by protein and there are a lot of hot and cold options. They make a generously stuffed sandwich, and you get included pickles. There's also a selection of desserts like brownies and cookies, as well as chips, French fries, and bottled beverages. I recently got the Prima Donna, an egg salad sandwich with cream cheese and sprouts. I think their meat based sandwiches are better than their vegetarian selection. You order at the counter after making your selection from the wall of options, then there is seating inside and on a patio outside that overlooks the river. read more

First and last time eating at Geoff's. I don't understand how they can charge their prices while adding less than half the amount of meat and veggies needed to even cover the bread. Thank goodness the roll was yummy, because that's what made up most of the sandwich. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - David Cicillene on a superlative roll. My disappointment is immeasurable. - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

THE CHOICES! The sandwich list on the wall is so overwhelming because all of the options are delicious. We have a few favorites. Service is always so friendly. it can sometimes be slow, but only because they get a huge lunch crowd/rush and they do their best to keep up. Eating in is casual and they give so many pickles. It's a great lunch spot read more

Great selection and great ingredients, just not enough. When paying $12 or $13 for a speciality sandwich it should be packed. Overwhelming menu, underwhelmed on the portions read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

When we ordered I thought because of the price we were gonna get some very filling sandwiches. Instead, meat on 1/4, sauce forgotten, wrong cheese, maybe 1/8 of an avocado. What a terrible disappointment. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Providence Monthly Sandwich Chicken on about 1/4 of the whole sandwich, one small piece of avocado, no sauce nothing else. Stale roll. - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Honestly I was underwhelmed by my visit to Geoff's. The sandwich menu is HUGE and awesome, but the sandwiches are a bit pricey for what you get. I had the Roger Williams (basically a Thanksgiving sandwich) and it was poorly assembled. Just a huge lump of all the ingredients in the middle (the sandwich bulged in the center) rather than properly spreading the stuffing out a bit more. I also thought the spicy addition to this classic sandwich flavor profile was a little bizarre. Additionally I wished the pickles were more sour and less salty, but that's just a personal preference. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Menus - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

Great selection of sandwiches. I recommend reading the menu before you get there as it can be a bit overwhelming. Free pickles with every sandwich! Quick and friendly service with plenty of seating. Parking can be found on the street. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Reuben - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

The workers seemed annoyed we came in when they were trying to close up. (We arrived 30 minutes before the posted closing time.) Very little meat on my sandwich. For almost $15, I would expect more than a few measly slices of roast beef. Will not return read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

NEVER AGAIN!! Save yourself the heartache and go to Subway or get a premade deli sandwich from Pricerite or some ish. Wife and I pulled up and foolishly made the decision to grab an eat here instead of another location. It's a Sunday at noon and the place is not busy. So there shouldn't be any issue, right?! Nah bruv Ordered 2 sandwiches - an Antoinette Downing and Providence Monthly. Why TF did it take like 15-20m to make these simple sandwiches with lettuce, tomato and a "special sauce". The sandwiches lacked luster!! Shouldn't charge someone almost $15 for a BS poorly made sandwich on toast. Chicken looked like the grill marks came from a manufacturer and they steamed it to make it look fresh. On top of all this, my wife's sandwich had FISH BONES in it!!! She could have choked on this crap. The lack of care from the staff was insane - one person did apologize. I had to request a refund because clearly no one gave a damn. I tried to show buddy the issue and let him know that they shouldn't serve this stuff to people because someone could get seriously injured. He looked like he could give a damn and I don't even think he looked at the sandwich. With eating out being more expensive these days, you really can't settle for BS like this. I'm glad my wife looks at her food before she eats because if she just picked it up and bit into this sandwich it would have been a really bad situation. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

I've danced around ordering from Geoff's for over a year now. What kept me back were the prices. As we've all seen prices go up and up with the cost of everything rising we can often excuse them if the quality is good. But eggs are coming down so bring anything with an egg down please. But when I finally bit the silver bullet and ordered from Geoff's, well let's just say, Subway doesn't have to worry. I'm not even a fan of Subway but when everything else is too far or closed they do provide "something" in a flash. I ordered the corned beef and cole slaw with Swiss cheese on pumpernickel and added onions and horseradish. I absolutely Love corned beef and to look at the nicely cut sandwich on perfect pumpernickel I was a bit taken aback by the processed corned beef. I didn't even know they make that! I know, I know I should've gone to Maven's but I just cannot bring myself to pay $24.50 for a sandwich outside of New York (Maybe that's why I haven't been to NY in a few years...besides kinda wanting to stay alive. Yeah, I'm weird that way). The horseradish and/or cole slaw were very watery leading to a mess of a mess to eat. I would have given 3 1/2 Stars, but opted for 4 as there's no 1/2 star AND because maybe I should've left well enough alone and not ordered any additions like the horseradish. I will go back to see if this was a one-off or bad day for them. They're a local place and I want local places to thrive. But please, please take the Oscar Meyer Corned Beef, or whatever it is, off the menu if you can't make your own or bring in the real things from somewhere. It's just not the same. Like the story of the Little Train that Could...."I think you can Geoff! I think you can!". read more

One word, incredible. I can't believe my eyes. Walking into this place I was overwhelmed with the amount of options they have. Hand written chalk on the board there are well over 50 different options. Luckily, the staff helped me narrow my options down to some of the customer favorites, along with being just the most kind, patient, and outgoing sandwich staff in town. read more

A place that elevates Sandwiches to art, extensive menu and you will get more fillings than you expect. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - Inheritor - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

The sandwiches themselves are pretty good. I got the chicken salad sandwich (Jen and Berry's) and surprisingly, that cranberry sauce works pretty well with it. The biggest downfall (and reason why I gave it three stars) is that the sandwiches themselves are pretty average sized & feel small given the price point (9-13 bucks on average). For the 12 bucks I paid, I feel like I should have gotten more than a regular square sandwich and a pickle. read more

Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches - people sitting at tables in a restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island