Here you will find a quaint pizzeria on the outskirts of Farmingdale. Brand: 4/5 Geo's Pizza is a simple pizzeria in Farmingdale next to JB's Diner. It would appear unassuming on the outside, however you would be surprised if you stepped inside and described a cozy interior filled with many Italian memorabilia upon the walls, including other places like Montana and Guatemala. The interior definitely had the Italian pizzeria aesthetic, which works with its warm, brown walls and the table cloths that contrasted in color with them. Website: 4/5 It was pretty basic in design, since it makes use of the Milkshake app. Instead of scrolling on a desktop or laptop, it functions more on a phone, while also retaining universal functionality. You get an introduction to their menu items and quick access to ordering forms, which did not need multiple buttons. Ambiance: 5/5 While no music played, the distant sounds of the traffic provided an unusually calm ambiance. The whooshing of the vehicles frequently proliferate on the highway, but only from a distance that would not make their noises intrusive. It does not get noisy despite having short space. The tables were well-spaced and had enough room to accommodate two people. Service: 5/5 Only the owners work in this establishment and make sure that you are accommodated. Wait Time: 5/5 We waited for our orders without delay or issues of any kind. Food: 5/5 I ordered the medium-sized Stromboli without additional fillings. I will say that bread held its form without the cheese melting through. The cheese also coagulated quickly and gave it a stringy, cheese stretch. The warm, buttery surface of the bread complements cheese with its warm texture, and the tomato sauce with its spiciness. The Stromboli had a little grease, but not enough to completely saturate my fingers. Worth The Money?: 3/5 Despite having so little, I can see how Geo's Pizza would make the most of it. In the case of menu items, I do not expect a large menu. They managed to put emphasis on their website on their most popular dishes, which definitely helps them. I will say that the Taco Pizza they offered looked delicious as their signature dish. Although I chose Stromboli because I endeavored to eat more Italian food beyond pizza, I could see how Taco Pizza could set Geo's Pizza apart. The simple website fits the simple restaurant. I will say that using a Milkshake app would help any restaurant or a food truck just starting out, however Geo's Pizza has been around for years now and they would benefit from updating to a more detailed website. Location is an important advertiser in itself, because its exterior can easily bring people in from a highway. The unassuming appearance of Geo's Pizza betrays its vibrant interior. If any slow days occur, the owners tend to make use of that time by working on the maintenance of the establishment. I can see how successful they were, since the establishment appears clean and well-kept. The minimalist soundscape also helped ease me into the wait time as I wrote without interruptions. While some things did work for this establishment, and while the wait time was appropriate for the preparation of the Stromboli, ultimately I did think that a plain cheese Stromboli with the tomato sauce did cost too high. This would be the part where I make suggestions, however I do not have any strong suggestions in mind; however, I am curious as to how Geo's Pizza would work if it had more employees and smaller menu items. Rating: 4/5 Stars I did think that Geo's Pizza was a pleasant-enough experience. Recommend To... Anyone interested in Italian culture looking for a quaint pizzeria interior. read more

Geo's Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New Jersey

Ordered pizza and 10 minutes later it was delivered and really good. Would 100% recommend Geo's. Prices are also really good. Top notch quality read more

This was the first time I tried Geos pizza it was the best Jersey pizza I have had and the best deal for a family

The food tasted great and lord have mercy on the size of there sandwiches. I got a meatball parm, the meatballs were great and the sandwich was like 2-3 meals and shall I say more. The service was great the owner is very nice. And the ambiance is great. Of course I need to add the garlic knots are a 500 out of 10 love the place I highly recommend it read more

The pizza is delicious and the service is great. They can customize anything you want. And the weekly specials are awesome too. Go to pizza place. read more

Geo's is amazing! The best thin crust on the jersey shore. Geo's recently moved to their own building and it won't disappoint. There are a few tables and a few counter chairs but we took it home to relax. We ordered a ham & cheese Stromboli and a grandma thin crust pie. We even saved 10% on our first online order. Everything was so delicious. The grandma pie had just the right amount of garlic & pesto. The Stromboli was cooked to perfection and not runny. I can't wait to go back!! read more

Geo's Pizza - Store front - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New Jersey

Great food, friendly staff , and small location clean location. Great for take out ! They accept Venmo or cash, no cards !

Stopped past here kinda late .Power out at home .the food was good but the lady who was there was mad at the world . My money is green just like everyone else.. I'll never be back due to her additude. read more

Geo's is amazing. We stumbled upon it after lessons at the Jersey Shore Arena and now stop every weekend. The sauce on their pizza is amazing and both my daughter and I finally agree on something! The folks there are great too. read more

We have passed this pizza place 100s of times. Today decided to order a large pie, $12 cash - Monday -Wednesday. Ordered online, ready when it said it would be. Geo, was friendly and welcoming. The pizza was delicious. Cooked the way I asked for it - Well Done. Will definitely be going back. Try it for yourself. You won't be disappointed! read more

My first time here and we will definitely be back. My new favorite pizza place. Geo is very cool and friendly. Split a half pepperoni have sausage with my wife and it was one of the best pizzas I've ever tasted. Cooked perfectly and quality cheese, sauce and meats. The Anti-pasta chopped salad was fresh and delicious. I washed it down with a bottle of Jarritos Guava soda (it happens to be my favorite soda). read more

awesome pizza... fast and friendly service... affordable prices especially their Lg pizza special Mon- Wed .. my family loves Geo's pizza..