A fantastic spot in downtown Neenah for a great wood fire pizza. The Haley's Comet (added…read moremushrooms) has great flavor combinations. The chicken, bacon, artichokes and onions all play well together. Adding the mushrooms brought a nice umami/earthy flavor to already solid flavor profile. My only small criticism, the pizza could've used another 20-30 seconds. It would've given more crisp to the middle of the pie, and a touch more char would've been . I would recommend swinging in and giving Broken Tree Pizza a try, I will when back in the area.

I rarely give 5 stars. This place rates it. An unassuming little place in downtown Neenah Wisconsin…read moredelivers some of the best pizza I've ever had. Wood fired, with a delicious thin crust. Comes in one size only, 12". I had a "That's Life": house red sauce base, house blend cheese, calabrese salami, Italian seasoning, finished with arugula, balsamic glaze and shredded parmesan. My wife ordered a "Hailey's Comet": creamy garlic sauce base, house blend cheese, chicken, bacon, spinach, artichoke. Both were delicious *chef's kiss*! They have a nice selection of local craft beers. The place is neat, clean, and unassuming. The kitchen is right there, you can watch the wood burn in the oven. Great little place, service was quick and efficient.

Tried Stucs Pizza while I was in Appleton and went with the BBQ Chicken Pizza…read more It wasn't my favorite pizza spot in the area, but the pizza was still really tasty and the overall food quality was good. The dough was a little thicker than my personal preference, but the flavors were on point. The service was excellent, which definitely goes a long way for me. The ambiance has that classic, casual sit-down pizza joint feel, and they have a solid variety of options on the menu. Overall, while there are a few pizza spots I preferred in Appleton, Sticks is still worth checking out--especially if great service and a good selection matter to you. 5/5

Ordered Stucs from Grubhub/DoorDash? through Yelp…read more The experience doing that was about 2-stars, because the delivery time was off and the driver did not view or was unable to view my directions. One of the options was for the driver to text when dropping off the pizza in the hotel lobby. He did not, so the concierge had to call my cell phone. Not a big deal, but also not seamless. Because of this, the pizza was lukewarm. Again, not ideal, but we had a microwave in the room. That said, the pizza was delicious. We got a regular pan type 3-meat pizza and we loved it. There was just the right meat to cheese ratio, where you could taste all ingredients and not feel overwhelmed by one element over another. That can be a huge challenge with these meat pizzas. I would come back, but definitely will not use the Yelp app to order delivery. I think we want to try the deep dish next, since I am a self-proclaimed expert on the topic. With the delivery issues, I would have rated 3-stars or less, but I know that the experience was not Stucs-related.

Amazing pizza a little pricey but worth it. 1 large pizza fed 5 people in the house so that's not…read morebad at all

Before coming up to Appleton, I looked at all the pizza places in the area and the pictures of…read moretheir pizza. Sammy looked most like Chicago pizza that I like. I was not disappointed. I came in for the lunch special. There are maybe four or five booths and I would say about the same for tables. They also have seats at the counter like a diner. The gentleman who waited on me was pleasant and helpful. I ordered the lunch special which is between 11 AM and 1 PM. It is a 9 inch pizza with one topping for $7.25. He brought it out to me with my can of soda. It did not disappoint. I watched the people coming in and out. It seem to be a steady stream also it seem to be like Cheers where everyone knows everyone. They all seem to have a personal connection with the owner. What an unassuming place to come and get great pizza. Would you believe I left having met a new friend. When I come back to Neena we're going to get together again.

Great place! We love our wood fired pizza. We were there…read moreearly so not anyone in the restaurant but they slowly trickled in. Nice selection of mixers with apple cider; Apple cider mule and apple cider mimosa. Nice list of beers! Ordered a pizza each, always great next morning. I had Dad's very good; my wife did the classic; Both good but I liked the onions on the classic as well; we exchanged a taste of each. Nice place; big place. Definitely stop in for a good pizza!

Great family place. Nice people and quick service. Crust was not overcooked compared to some other…read morewood fired pizza places. Clean and Christmas decor. Lots of pesto on the pizza. Lots of plates, napkins, to go containers available.

Great pizza cooked in a Faulds oven old school. Supper thin full of flavor. This is a must try if…read moreyou're a pizza snob.

Well, I have lived in Appleton for six years. Why didn't I find this place before?! Cracker thin…read morecrust and just the right amount of toppings. The only improvement would be better napkins. I will be back again and again.

My boyfriend and I walked in 10 min till the all you can eat pizza was over, the man working was…read moresuper nice and gave us the kids price of $10. The pizza was good, especially for $10 :) you can't beat that. I got an icy root beer on tap and my boyfriend got a beer, both were delicious. It was a great way to refuel after a long bike ride. We would defiantly return!

Cute place by the river. Good views. Slow when we went for dinner on a weekend, but had just…read moresnowed. Overall, ambiance is darker and good for dates. Not the most quiet, some privacy depending on where you are seated. There is a bar with several beers on tap. Food menu does not seem to change much. Pizza sizes good for individual if hungry or sharing for 2 if not that hungry. Truthfully, for a place that specializes in pizza, it was a bit disappointing. Some friends had recommended it, but again, we came for the vibes, beer, and company. We will be back and give the food another try. Happy eating!

Atmosphere: Really relaxed vibe. Nice indoor and outdoor seating areas. There is a water refill…read morestation by the patio doors. They have an ordering station to place your orders for food/beer. They have a ton of board games to play while you drink or wait for your food. Great place to meet up to wind down. I've been here twice, once for drinks and once for food. Great experiences both times. Service: Friendly and informative. They have a slim team but are incredibly efficient. Food: They pizza is incredible, the crust is untouchable. I ordered the Dirty Martini pizza (they don't have it anymore *cries in salty olive tears*). This pizza is one of a kind. If anyone else had this available in the Fox Valley I would go there every week to get my fix. It's salty, savory, creamy, crunchy and CRAVE-ABLE. We ordered one other pizza on the menu that is a standard offering, The 99 Corvette. This was okay but we both fought over who got more pieces of the Dirty Martini Pizza. I can't wait to come back here for more fun.

Hop Yard has a relaxed, casual atmosphere and seems consciously geared toward the hipster/affluent…read moreworking professional crowd. Their staff are friendly and seem to enjoy themselves. They do not have physical menus or servers to take people's orders; customers scan a QR code to get the online menu and order at the bar area. I can't speak to the craft beer and wine aspect to the restaurant, but they do offer some delicious craft sodas for people looking for nonalcoholic options. Although they have "normal" woodfire pizza choices (traditional pepperoni, cheese, etc.), the highlight is their rotating menu of inventive specialty savory and dessert pizzas. I found their "normal" pizza to be just ok, but the tomato soup pizza (Souper Slice) was incredibly flavorful and unique! It's definitely worth taking the leap of faith for some of their more out-there sounding pizza options. Since they have limited oven space to cook the pizzas, food can take a while to come out if it's busy. Plan ahead and use that time to relax and enjoy their drinks, or come during an off-peak time for less wait.

I usually try to find hidden gems wherever I travel, and I came across this place from one of the…read moreNFL Packer player's wives Instagram. This place is such a hit for me that I will absolutely be coming back the next time I'm in town. The food/ingredients are so fresh and you can tell they are local. It provided such a great combo of flavors but wasn't heavy or overpowering... honestly, it was just right and hit the spot. The place is also such a cute little place and has a great ambience for a date night especially. It's tucked away from downtown yet it's right by it. I highly recommend anyone to try this spot.. just be sure to make reservations since it's a small space and it fills up very quickly, even on weeknights. It could be difficult to get a table as a walk in.

This was our second time in ellinor, which I felt had a better menu offering. The roasted…read morecauliflower was a light but delicious start for dinner. For the main course, I had the duck breast which was tender with light sauce. My wife had the Carbonara pizza which was great. We had the Panna Cotta for desert which was flavorful. Service was superb. Do not worry if they sit you in the counter, it gives a perfect view of kitchen activity.