Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Goodfellas Pizza And Wings

    3.1 (8 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Order Goodfellas Pizza And Wings Takeout or Delivery

    Goodfellas Pizza And Wings Photos

    Business Info

    GOODFELLAS PIZZA AND WINGS ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Goodfellas Pizza And Wings

    Recommended Reviews - Goodfellas Pizza And Wings

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Enna J.

    Friendly staff. Fairly quick service. Clean establishment. Only a few dine-in tables. The fries were seasoned well. The cheese pizza had a good amount of cheese pull to it. Nothing really spectacular about the crust or sauce. The wings are bigger here than at some other places. The lemon pepper seasoning for the wings tastes more like lemon pepper BUTTER like you'd find in a seafood boil. Which is fine if you like that. They have a pretty huge menu and a lot of really great combo priced meals.

    Main area

    See all

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Enna J.
    603
    764
    2903

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Service was amazing Ryan was very kind and patient with me as i was having a hard time choosing what i wanted from all the amazing options!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Goodfellas Pizza And Wings

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 18,919 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Trap Wingz ATL

    Trap Wingz ATL

    4.0
    (89 reviews)
    7.2 mi

    Gas station wings did not have to go this harddd!…read more I visited this food stall located inside of a gas station and the food I had here was really good! My friend and I split the 5 Borough Trapper Combo for $19.99 which comes with chopped cheese, 6 piece wings of your choice, and fries. The chopped cheese was pretty good. It was meaty and cheesy. I also liked the bun which was buttery. For the wings, we got the wet lemon pepper wings and those were so so good. I'm not usually a wings person, but these were delicious. I loved the buttery, peppery, and tangy flavor of the wings which were nicely fried and crispy. The meat was moist and succulent. Just wow. The fries were also good and standard and I liked dipping them in the ranch (you get a choice of ranch or blue cheese for your wings). I also loved the service. The girl helping me with my order was super friendly and engaging. Would highly recommend this spot and next time I'm in Atlanta, you best know I'm coming back for the lemon pepper wings!

    I visited Trap Wingz on a Sunday afternoon around 6pm. It's located inside the gas station, pretty…read moreeasy to find once inside. I ordered the combo that includes 5 piece of wings and a chopped cheese. The chopped cheese had no visible cheese which was very disappointing. I'd rate it 2/5. The wings were okay 2/5. Customer service 1/5. In my opinion Not worth another visit.

    Photos
    Interior
    Interior
    Trap wings in the front and hot lemon pepper in the back
    Trap wings in the front and hot lemon pepper in the back
    15 piece tiny wings.

    See all

    15 piece tiny wings.
    The Local

    The Local

    4.0
    (460 reviews)
    3.9 mi
    $

    Walked up around 20 min before opening on a Sunday and were the second people in line, but the line…read morequickly grew after that. Went straight to order while the husb nabbed a table. Ordered 10 wings: half buffalo-lemon pepper/half lemon pepper, 5 wings in Korean-buffalo with a side of chili cheese fries, and 2 Coors Banquets (cuz we're classy like that. Food came out probably 15 min after and I was ready to dig in. These wings were pretty hyped and with anything popular, I'm always worried I'm going to be disappointed. But OMG these wings are worthy of their hype. The flavor of their sauces is incredible and they hit that desired balance of crispy and juicy. The meat falls off the bone. Tell you what, I'll definitely be back. I've also heard great things about their karaoke nights so that's going on my list as well

    i don't understand how you post pictures of wings (which actually looked really good from the…read morepictures hence my disappointment) and then we show up and you say you have no wings and then proceed to have an attitude when we ask if there are wings. they quite literally have a *tiny* sign that says "we don't have wings, don't even ask." funny sure but also no. not at all. take the pictures down im begging you. we are now at strikeout wings where they actually have the wings they advertised AND they're good. so shoutout strikeout. boo the local

    Photos
    Dancing area
    Dancing area
    Korean-buffalo with chili cheese fries
    Korean-buffalo with chili cheese fries
    Creature Comfort Sun Glow

    See all

    Creature Comfort Sun Glow
    The Original J.R. Crickets in Midtown Atlanta

    The Original J.R. Crickets in Midtown Atlanta

    3.2
    (534 reviews)
    2.9 mi
    $$

    Was told that I had to try lemony pepper wet wings when in Atlanta, Georgia, and that J.R. Crickets…read morewas a decent, reliable spot. The interior gives off a modest, no-frills type of vibe. It wasn't busy at all on a Wednesday night. Signs indicate that you should seat yourself wherever available and to head to the counter to make your order. I ordered takeout, so I can't speak about the dine-in experience here. FOOD: We ordered a double order of the wings and asked for their two most popular flavors, which were the lemony pepper wet wings and some other flavor (couldn't hear the worker clearly, but just went with it). The order came with fries and a choice between ranch or blue cheese dipping sauce. Maybe I am not used to the flavor profile here, but I found the wings to be excessively salty (and I have a preference for salty food). My tongue is still tingling as I write this review. Also, the lemony pepper wings tasted like they were coated in pure citric acid. The other flavor was drowning in sauce. The wings themselves were so dry that it felt like I was eating chicken jerky. SERVICE: Food came out within ten minutes of us ordering. No frills place, so expect no frills service. No complaints. They have a bag-it-yourself policy. TLDR// This might be the first place to actually convince me that overseasoning is actually a thing. Excessively salty, dry chicken wings that my tongue is still paying the price for. Would not come back, and I would try a different spot for lemony pepper wet wings.

    Open late and always reliable--definitely a go-to spot…read more Personally, I think their wings are the best in ATL in terms of size, juiciness, and bold flavor. One thing to note: even when ordering through Uber Eats, my order wasn't ready, so I'd recommend ordering directly at the store.

    Photos
    The Original J.R. Crickets in Midtown Atlanta
    Barbecue wings & fries
    Barbecue wings & fries
    Lemony pepper wet wings

    See all

    Lemony pepper wet wings
    Strikeout Wingz

    Strikeout Wingz

    4.0
    (67 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    $$

    Got the 12 wing box split into lemon pepper and sweet n sassy combo , all flats , Nice n crispy the…read moreway I love'm , Sorry no pic they was that good !!

    My flight was delayed in Atlanta, and it was past midnight, so I took a uber to this place,…read moreaccording to ChatGPT's recommendation. The chicken wings were just okay, but the main reason I came was because the place was open so late, making it convenient to try Atlanta's specialties. It was a limited-time experience! Sweet & Sassy Wingz: Their signature flavor. The chicken was over-fried, and the meat was a bit dry. Most importantly, it was coated in a thick layer of sauce, so sweet it was almost too sweet to eat... L. Pepper Wet Wingz: As an Atlanta specialty, this chicken wing was relatively interesting. The initial taste was an intense lemon sourness, almost making you shiver, followed by the warm spicy aroma of black pepper. If the sourness could be toned down, it would be quite good. The chicken wings were still overcooked, and because there was no sauce, the meat was even drier. But I don't know if this is a problem or part of their specialty? Season Friez: Although it was hot, it was already soggy and soft. I consoled myself, "Just grab something quick..." Side Salad: A meatless version of Caesar salad. The bread was so hard I couldn't even stick it in with a fork, but thankfully the lettuce was fairly fresh. Google Maps shows they're open until 3 AM, but they actually don't offer dine-in service after midnight, and the area outside is practically homeless's paradise. Please be careful!

    Photos
    Inside dinning room
    Inside dinning room
    Strikeout Wingz
    Strikeout Wingz

    See all

    The Wing Bar

    The Wing Bar

    3.9
    (212 reviews)
    4.1 mi
    $$

    Busssss down shortie! ATL the home of many wing joints, but there's only one WING BAR! Located in…read moreEastwood Village, Wing Bar boast a robust selection of flavors. Our go-to this trip was the hot honey & garlic parmesan, both FIRE but I'm giving the nod to the hot honey! The combination of hot & sticky was on point. Wings were most definitely fresh & shout-out to home girl working the counter. My order took a lil longer than usual so we got 10 on the house. Overall, the 10pc pricing could be said to be a little high, but post pandemic inflation is real. Pull up when you on the east side and give Wing Bar a try, they even got vegans covered with Vegan wings.

    Worth every cent! And having a Bday celebration discount made this recent visit even more…read morememorable. I had received an email last month celebrating my April birth with a $10 discount good until June. Since I was in the neighborhood, I decided to stop bye and redeem my delicious gift. Greeted upon arrival, and made mention of the discount before I place my order. The young man at the register promotion, and immediately called to get clarification later the Wing Bar guru, Tori, showed up and was able to apply the discount. Note: discount was linked to my phone on account, and was applied when I signed into system. Select in my favorite, lemon pepper and medium sauce mixture on wings and made a combo with crinkle fries and canned beverage or water. There was an option to have the fries with sauce, but there was enough sauce in my order as expected to dip. Also paired with ranch dressing for extra flavor. There were several other sauces, now, interesting, including some larger bottles available for purchase. I truly appreciate first day gesture, great customer, service, and exceptional flavor of the wings definitely an EAV gem!

    Photos
    Awesome sauce!
    Awesome sauce!
    10pcs Combo. 1/2 Hot 1/2 LemonPepper!! 100% Delish!
    10pcs Combo. 1/2 Hot 1/2 LemonPepper!! 100% Delish!
    The Wing Bar

    See all

    Hattie B's Hot Chicken - Atlanta East

    Hattie B's Hot Chicken - Atlanta East

    4.3
    (2.3k reviews)
    4.2 mi
    $$

    Excellent service and even better food! Alan was absolutely amazing, friendly, welcoming, and…read moreincredibly knowledgeable about the menu. He took the time to patiently explain all of the options to my mom and sister, who were visiting for the first time, and made us all feel right at home. The bacon cheddar grits were delicious! They were perfectly creamy, and seasoned so well that they were unforgettable! Every bite of our meal was fantastic. Between the exceptional food and the top-notch service, this was a wonderful dining experience. We will definitely be back!

    Good southern spot!…read more My friend came by here for a snack, and they did not disappoint. There is a good amount of parking for Hattie B's, and there is a pay to park lot next door as well. We got the pimento Mac and cheese cups, some miller lites, and the peach cobbler. The Mac and cheese was amazing, definitely a must try. The peach cobbler was good but the filling tasted like it was canned and the crust wasn't crispy. Next time I come by, I'd definitely want to try their banana pudding. The employees working were super nice and helpful. They were quick to take our orders and brought out our food very fast. I also liked that they had a combination of indoor and outdoor seating, this seems like a fun place to grab a drink with friends.

    Photos
    Indoor dining area
    Indoor dining area
    2 piece Wings
    2 piece Wings
    Chicken sandwich dam hot!! Flavor and bacon grits

    See all

    Chicken sandwich dam hot!! Flavor and bacon grits
    Magic City Kitchen

    Magic City Kitchen

    3.9
    (61 reviews)
    1.3 mi

    I mean...when it Atlanta right? Had to visit the legendary Magic City to see if these famous wings…read morewere as good as advertised. First thing I noted about Magic City...it's not that big. In fact, the building itself is actually pretty damn small for a strip club. Only pointing this out because Magic City Kitchen is just a to-go counter inside Magic City itself. Since I came in the afternoon when Magic City just opened, I walked in for free with no cover. Anyways, ordered some Justice Magic wings and fries. They're not the biggest wings, but they pack quite the flavor punch. I can see why they are revered by so many people! And despite only technically ordering 10 wings, I definitely got like around 15. Also, despite being way out of place here (i.e., the only Asian in the building), everyone treated me really nice. Never felt I was not welcome at all while I was eating my food at the bar. On top of those extra wings, the cook gave me a free baked wing to try as well. I guess Southern hospitality even extends to the strip club! I'm not sure I would go out of my way again to eat these wings in-house, but it was definitely a cool experience to check it out. At the very minimum, it's worth a takeout order.

    The wings were good however they were so tiny. The fries were good as well. Overall we did go at…read more6:00 on Friday so we knew it wouldn't be busy but the vibes were just not quite there. Service was fine food came out quick and the bartender was nice and brought us waters. Would love to go back but later at night in the future!

    Photos
    Magic City Kitchen
    Shrimp Wrap
    Shrimp Wrap
    Justice Magic Wings with French Fries

    See all

    Justice Magic Wings with French Fries

    Goodfellas Pizza And Wings - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...