My favorite pepperoni slice ever. Always fast, fresh, and the place itself is so classic. When I was last there I lost my wallet. I went back to check and inform the staff, they helped with no hesitation. They checked the bathroom, the dinning area, and even the trash! Eventually I found it later that night, and thanked them for being so helpful. Whoever the guy that was working 8/11 around 6pm, I appreciate you! read more

The fact that this is open after a night at the bar and doesn't break the bank, what more can a college student ask for. Pizza was HOT but delicious read more

Gourmet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Service was quick and good. However,rhe pizza was horrible. I tried the plain and pepperoni. The sauce on the pie was to sweet and the cheese was not good quality mozzarella. First and last time ever going to this place read more

They charged me more for the pizza than on the menu. I won't be coming back here ever again.

Average pizza at best. Good place to grab a slice late at night. Just not best pizza around. Wings used to be good now just too greasy and undercooked in my opinion. Big plus is they are open late and delivery is usually available read more

Food was eh. But oh my god was the service impeccable ! A sweet young red haired girl(Grace, I believe) helped me and wowza. This girl was HOT. Highly recommend. read more

Gourmet Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Great for a quick slice after the bars. Open late night for those munchies. Used to be much better but still pretty good. Service is quick and friendly. Not the best pizza in town, but a good slice on the go. read more

This place has not changed inside since went to SUNY back in 1989. The same big submarine sandwiches. I don't even think the signs have changed. Plain cheese pizza is quite good. The sauce tastes fresh and homemade. The crust is good and not too much cheese on the slice. So if you want a nice cheese pizza definitely go here. I haven't ever gotten the toppings here. I can't speak for the heroes but should try one of them. Kind of nice for no changes inside at all over the years. read more

-The man who made my slices is not Italian. I know this for a fact! - For pizza to be FIVE STAR RATING AND BEYOND the slice must be made by Italian blood. -It tastes like an elementary school field trip in a beautiful/nostalgic way - The establishment itself has potential to be awesome! but is currently a little sad -I know these folks WORK HARD wearing their masks and making pizzas! - Is this a small business?! YES! - They had a $10 limit on card but homie let me slide by with $8 so that was nice - To the sir that rannggg me up, I saw u giving me googoo eyes so hml !! -I do have respect 4 the brothers. They were nice and chit chatted w me! I love it. -Thank you for this pizza! Thank you for your service, Davi read more

Gourmet Pizza - @funkymeatsticc eating plain Cheese Pizza in her room few hours after buying slices. - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

been a fan of this place for a years. the staff was polite and prompt serving me. I ordered the Huguenot sub. I had them special make it, no complains and when I asked for a little red wine vinegar splash in my sub they came though. the cuts of meat were fresh, the lettuce was chopped fine, and the condiments tasted fresh. love their monster subs, could make them into three meals for their size, well worth the money. there my go to for a great cold cut, when am in the area. read more

Gourmet Pizza - Huguenot monster sub - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

I grew up in New Paltz and the pizza is still the best. I got a slice of white broccoli and it was delicious. Thank you!

Not only are they the best pizza in town, but they're also the classiest guys. They were able to help us out in a pinch when my payment wasn't going through and let us come back to pay it the next day. They're real stand-up folks and people like them keep the world turning. They've earned my loyalty. read more

Love the bbq pizza and honey garlic wings. Nothing like a slice after enjoying some cocktails at PnGs at 3 AM on a Friday night. The chicken rolls are my favorite,and cinnamon knots. Yummmmm. read more

I just had the best slice of my life here. This place is amazing. I'm from NYC so I'm no stranger to amazing pizza. Bravo.

So people say this is the best pizza place in new paltz.....I find it hard to believe. They are not bad at all but definitely definitely not the best I have ever had. I would say more like mediocre pizza. If this is the best in New Paltz, then I guess New Paltz is full of bad pizzarias, and people are just drunk out of their mind to know they are not that good. Unfortunately I think regular franchized pizza like pizza hut is way better. I will give one star for opening so late for drunk people coming out of bars nearby. read more

Chicken Caesar Salad- Chicken was frozen and reheated in microwave. Nasty. Small serving for the price

Excellent margarita pizza. The owner is a little gruff, but I guess that's NY. The place is a little rundown, but again it's a pizza joint. The food makes up for all the issues. read more

Really good pizza and subs. Daily specials are decent and it's the only place around to get pizza at 3am on a weekend. As a bonus to the tasty pizza, you can actually get to see some frat boy use a slice as as a "weapon" when some freshman runs his mouth at the counter after realizing the three White Claws they ingested at the local bars gave them a bit of courage and drunk muscles. When you get a pie on Tuesday, and take the first bite, the taste will bring up the memories of the terrible decisions and 4am regrettable hookup you had the weekend before and you'll swear you'll change your ways. Next Saturday at 3am, as you stumble down Main St. with your sloppy friends, you'll get that amazing familiar Gourmet aroma and feel at home again, because you KNOW the employees in there speak fluent Corona and Jameson, and will know exactly what you need. When the PD arrives, and they will due to the dopes and hood boogers yelling in the street, sit back and look out the window at the chaos while holding up your phone and yelling "WORLD STAR!" as you enjoy your tasty pepperoni slice. You may regret your weekend "love" connections but you'll never regret going to Gourmet. Give the staff the respect they deserve for dealing with your almost incoherent order and asinine attempt at humor or flirting or whatever you're trying, and tip them well. read more

Oh Gourmet. The aftermath of a good night out at the bars/house parties or wherever you may wander off to. It's always JAM PACKED from like 12am on. It's pretty much your average pizza place.... I honestly don't think I've gone here before 1am ha! But for a slice after drinking it's good. My all-time favorite is not on the menu. You have to ask for a "cold cheese slice". You're probably wondering, what the heck? Who would want cold pizza? Well it's different than you think. They heat up a normal pizza slice and then sprinkle cold mozzerella cheese on top. Maybe I'm making this out to be bigger than it really is... but after going to PnG's... Gourmet is my place to go. The cheese melts and it's pretty yummy. read more

Gourmet Pizza - The best cold cheese slice. - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

They sell beer btw, Most pizza shops in the city don't. Pizza was good. Like the buffalo sauce side more. Good customer service. read more

Gourmet Pizza - Half buffalo chicken half bbq chicken, my favorite was the buffalo sauce side. - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

This place looked fine when I went in to order a pizza, and the young woman behind the counter had her mask on the entire time I was in the restaurant. When I went back to pick up the pizza, though, the man behind the counter had his bandana mask repeatedly off and on his face, there was no hand sanitizer in sight, he did not wear gloves, and when I was on my way out he openly sneezed. I left worried about coronavirus exposure and mad at myself that I hadn't just left as soon as I saw how unsafely he was handling himself. On top of that, the pizza was undercooked and overcheesed, making it difficult to eat without the entire cheese pile sliding off the top. Do not eat here until they clean up their COVID protocols!!! read more

Trey and Dave are awesome pizza guys. I really enjoyed their conversation and they were really good to me and my friend. I had the white ricotta pizza and it was amazing read more

The last time I ordered was the meatball parmigiana sub and it was amazing! Today I ordered a 10 pc boneless wings mild and asked for ranch instead of blue cheese but the ranch tasted sour. I also ordered a large pizza with half pepperoni and the other half meatball. The boneless winds and the pizza were amazing! I definitely recommend gourmet pizza in newpaltz you will not be disappointed! read more

Best prices in the area. Wings were great a few years ago but they've been very dry every time I've ordered them recently. Pizza's about as average as pizza gets but that's not a bad thing since they're very consistent about it. Haven't gotten many sandwiches but when I have they weren't the greatest. read more

Went to gourmet tonight after have been there a thousand times. I ordered slices for my kids and a beer for myself. I got a Stella that need opener. Getting it still sealed I looked for something to help. I saw something tii ok open it over counter, picked it up and opened my beer. Upon doing so the pizza cook aggressively told me how dare I reach over his counter and to never do it again. I apologized, and with no response he put his head down and walked away with an attitude. I promise you I've been going to gourmet since I was in school in 2007 and I will never go there again. Worse service ever read more

great hand made pizza. C.J. is tops. He makes a mean pizza. This place has great college town atmosphere. We had a great time. The pizza is fantastic. Forget Pizza Hut, John's, other chains. This place is great. The music is classic 80's. read more

A couple of Gourmet's staff put a pizza place in a college town to shame. Not only did they have a poor attitude and disposition but they couldn't get the concept of basic food service (couldn't tell me the ingredients of any of the salads on the menu, couldn't give prices, acted as though I was burdening them although I was the only patron on the establishment placing a large order...). These staff were useless to each other no less customers and moved at a snails pace. The pizza maker Aaron and the two young back of the house staff were the only saving grace, keeping me from walking out. Go to any of the other dozen pizza places in the area!!! read more

I was able to feed 12 people for 40.00 and had food leftover. Decent pizza, good for hungry climbers. read more

Gourmet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Gourmet Pizza is by far the worst pizza I have had in recent memory. We were drawn to the pizzeria because of its classic NY pizza joint aesthetic and extensive menu of unique toppings but that is where it's charms end. While the menu has many fun topping options, the slice options were very limited to the usual standard options plus "stuffed pizza". We ordered 5 slices all together and ended up paying around $26 which is absurd but it's New York after all and nothing is reasonably priced here so we bit the bullet and paid the outrageous price. The food itself was HORRIBLE. Truly horrendous. The pizza wasn't burned but it had a terribly bitter burnt taste to it as if the oven was dirty and desperately needed a cleaning. This was not your classic char taste either. We love that. This tasted like a dirty oven. The sauce was lack luster, the cheese tasted like generic pizza chain cheese product and the toppings were unimpressive. The stuffed pizza was so bad we had to douse it in garlic powder and parmigiana to make it go down with out a fight. The chicken bacon ranch was completely bereft of ranch and the bacon was only in the middle of the slice. The crust was off balance being too cakey. It was way too thick, didn't tear easy with each bite and had no firmness on the bottom. As Dave Portnoy would say, it had too much flop. I am an Italian American and a life long lover of NY style pizza. But if I were offered this pizza or Domino's, I'm taking Domino's every time. If you are in New Paltz and craving pizza, seek other options. read more

went here hammered and had the best slice i've ever had in my life. don't like the credit card minimum, but what can ya do. don't recommend going here without alc in your system. well done gourmet! read more

Stopped in several times while in town. The staff and owner are very friendly and accommodating. The pizzas are great and always fresh. It's a popular spot for the college students. Definitely worth visiting. read more

Why is everything seemingly closed at 7PM around here? Well come 11PM everywhere you drive looks like a ghost town. City girl in me just had to push the limit and we drove up to this pizza shop. Very dimly lit inside, but decent amount of pizzas still on display. I order a baked ziti...and my party of kiddos ordered the cheese and sausage slices. We ask if they can make a pizza slice topped with bacon. Dude at the counter thought about it for 2 seconds and gladly made it off the menu. BTW, my baked ziti came with a side of salad and they brought it to our table. For a casual pizza joint, service is pretty on point. Staff was polite, not friendly and not really welcoming...but polite. Given the scarce reviews, and quiet area ... I wasn't sure what to expect. Our pitcher of soda spilled and we cleaned it ourselves...so that's where the one star came off because it would have been easier to clean the table with a rag and clean the floor with a mop but there was no one behind the counter after we were served. Pass on the baked ziti...it was covered in mozzarella and meatballs, tasted stale...like they were just taken out of the freezer ... no taste and sauce/mozzarella were overpowering. This is where it cost them another star. Anyway...here is a picture of the salad and bacon pizza slice...we ordered another to take back to our resort. If you are out of options and it's late, come for their bacon slice pizza. read more

See all

Best in Town. Lots of flavor and variety. I don't bother going any place else. Staff is always kind! Hugs to them all! Tried other places nah don't like!Being from Brooklyn it tastes like BRooklyn Pizza! read more

Favorite post-bar pizzeria in town. They have a really great staff, I must say, tolerant of me and my stupid drunk visits, which is lovely. I thought it was just good when I was intoxicated, but, I even liked it in the daytime haha. It fixes my hunger and it fits my budget!!!! read more

Seesee the cute Asian counter girl was the absolute best. Never better service and really great great pizza. Open late too

Ok pizza I would agree its probably the best late night option available, they recently started a minimum credit purchase of $5 though, which is whatever but what burned me is that they wouldn't let me pay with a card when I didn't have any cash on me, so they'd already reheated the food and wasted my time over a 20 cent visa fee on a $3 old slice of pizza that probably ended up thrown out anyway since it was close to closing, lol. read more

Open until 4 am, perfect for a college town. Chicken bacon ranch is where it's at. Close second is the BBQ chicken. Awesome drunk pizza and good sober pizza. I haven't tried any of the non-pizza foods yet. read more

Owner/teenaged manager is very uncool. Like jeez you're sandwiched between two other pizza places and somehow they're still only have the fourth best pizza outta those three. Calm down, employees and go ANYWHERE else, NP students. read more

Ordered pizza at 4:30 pm for delivery. Was told hour Delivery and hour later did not show called the Pizza Place and they said the driver was stuck in a snowbank. Not sure how that happened because it's clear as day I called back again to find out spoke to someone named Francis who is not the nicest person could not give me any indication of when the pizza would be here and could not tell me if we would even receive it. We have ordered many times from gourmet but this is probably our last and on top of it all never got a call from the manager to apologize. Need to make their service better. I guess we'll see if we ever get a call from the manager probably not. I give it zero stars for their customer service read more

So we always order from Gourmet and the pizza are always so great BUT the last two times that we have ordered, the pizza were delivered cold. read more