My husband and I very much enjoyed our first visit to the Gyro House for lunch today. It was sparkling clean, had an inviting Greek atmosphere, and a top notch server, Angie, who was courteous, kind, and friendly. It was hard to choose what to have, as so many items on the menu sounded great, but I selected the spanakopita plate with the lemon sauced potatoes. Everything was just delicious; the phyllo was crispy and light, and the spinach and feta filling was the perfect density, and a side of their heavenly tzatziki sauce complemented it perfectly. The potatoes were firm yet tender, and absorbed the lemon and oregano sauce and made for a perfect side dish. My husband was astounded at the generous portion of gyro meat on his pita, and said it was incredibly flavorful and the accompanying marinated red onions and tomatoes enhanced the meat well. He, too, praised the thick, creamy tzatziki sauce, but he ended up taking at least a third of his gyro home to enjoy tomorrow. We will definitely be back soon, not just because of the food, but the excellent service. Thanks for a wonderful lunch, Gyro House! read more

This was my first visit and it will not be the last! The gyro I had was delicious. I was especially pleased by the quality of the pita and the lamb being minimally greasy. I dined in for lunch, and the service was fantastic. My server (Julie) was attentive and delightful, and they had several nice touches included in the experience, as well. I don't think I've ever had a sprinkling of paprika on a gyro before (delicious), which they did, they also used red onions, and the waitress brought me a serving of Greek honey donuts (loukoumades) as a thank you for coming in, as well. Table service patrons even get nice cloth napkins and real flatware. It was a delightful experience that I will be back for, including the upbeat, traditional Greek music. Next time I look forward to trying the chicken kebabs and spanakopita. I haven't had Greek lemon soup in years, either, and I look forward to trying that, as well. read more

Gyro House - Loukoumades (Greek honey donuts)-- a nice touch as my waitress brought them as a surprise thank you for dining in for the first time. - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

I finally made it to Gyro House!!! This has been a bucket list place for me since they opened a year ago and they're the indirect replacements for Gyros West in the area. When I stopped around 4pm they were still doing a daily special of $5 gyros between 2pm and 5pm. I grabbed two plain gyros and an order of loukoumades (honey and cinnamon donuts) to go. I've eaten at a fair number of gyro places in the Milwaukee area and I hold two in particular up on a pedestal based on their gyros. I think it's fair to say Gyro House can be added to that pedestal. There was a ton of meat on each gyro and it was moist and tender. I'm not sure if they grilled the pita a little in house or if that's how it comes out of the package, but I'm glad that attention was paid to the pita too by someone and it wasn't just dry and bland. The loukoumades came in a cylindrical plastic container, similar to what fried rice comes in from some Chinese restaurants. The honey sauce pooled at the bottom, so those donuts had more of the honey flavor soaked in by the time I got to them. It wasn't hard to tip the container on its side and let some of the honey sauce run towards the top of the container though. Overall, an excellent option for dessert or instead of a side like fries. read more

See all

This is one of our favorite restaurants! The staff is always outstanding, the restaurant is clean and well maintained, they offer outdoor dining, and the food is the best in the area! Today we had the Pastitsio and Gyro supreme with fries. The Pastitsio is excellent with exceptional flavors. The pea stew and lemon potatoes that come with it are also delicious. This is the only place we have ever had the pea stew but highly recommend it. The gyro supreme comes with a mountain of gyro meat, onions, tomatoes, and tzatziki sauce. The meat is flavorful and always hot. Their fries are very good; I like mine with ketchup read more

Gyro House - Pastitsio with pea stew and lemon potatoes. - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

See all

Absolutely delicious food, portion sizes extremely generous. You get your MONEY'S WORTH of lamb here! We had a super attentive and kind waitress named Megan and I want her to get recognition too. The music is great and I love the murals on the walls. This is one of the best Greek restaurants I've been too HANDS DOWN! The Gemista, Dolmades and obviously the gyro were all scrumptious but I especially recommend the gemista. read more

Gyro House - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

I ordered Uber eats. Portions are great size. The salad is super fresh and crisp! Appreciate they put the gyro meat on the side separately. My only issue is that the salad dressing that was included is 98% oil 2% vinegar which is not a welcome ratio. Definitely need more vinegar. The soup is like a warm hug. It's perfect. I Do you recommend!! read more

See all

Ordered the falafel pita to go and food was out quickly. I expected more of a falafel wrap but I enjoyed the thick fresh pita, I wish the falafel were a bit more crispy and moist but overall enjoyed the meal and the tzatziki dip was very good. read more

Gyro House - Falafel pita - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

We stumbled upon this place after a shopping trip. I wasn't expecting much. Boy, was I wrong. Big time. We were seated at a table of our choice, and given a menu and a pitcher of water for the table. So many items to choose from. We ended up ordering the Greek salad with a side of gyro meat. Served with amazing tzatziki sauce. The lamb was like butter. They serve it on the side, not in the salad. That was great! The salad comes with literally a slab of feta. Also a slice of amazing grilled bread. This gem is so authentic and charming that we will absolutely be back. The ambiance is adorable. Table clothes, cloth napkins and artwork that makes you feel like you're in a small Greek fishing town. Oompah! read more

See all

irst time here. From the outside, it's an unassuming storefront. However, when I entered, I was a bit confused -- and then blown away (that doesn't happen very often). Instead of what I imagined -- a counter to order from and nondescript tables and chairs -- they have managed to make a lovely little place, set up like a nice diner with tablecloths, a carafe of water, and table service. What a delightful surprise. Got there around 11:30 -- it was mostly empty, but then the place filled up fast. Our server gave us time to order our food and brought our drinks. We ordered a couple of bourekakee (spinach and feta), the Roasted Lamb Souvlaki Pita, and the Beef and Lamb Supreme Pita Combo. It didn't take very long for the food to arrive. Everything looked great -- hot and with good portions. The bourekakee were just okay. I thought they were a bit dry and not fresh. The gyro was excellent -- good flavors. It came with a generous amount of tzatziki sauce. Unfortunately, the Roasted Lamb Pita was disappointing. The meat was dry and not that flavorful. I added more tzatziki to help it out. So it was a mixed bag: wonderful atmosphere, excellent service, but some of the food items were disappointing. I would be willing to try again, but I'd order something different. read more

See all

Food is great and service was fantastic. The supreme gyro is outstanding. I definitely recommend this place.

What a fantastic stop. Service was phenomenal. Food was delicious. Honestly, the best gyro meat I think I've ever had. The flavor, the cut, everything. It's super moist/juicy with the perfect blend of seasoning and cut perfectly. The chicken souvlaki was also delicious and you won't be disappointed but the gyro meat stole my heart. The tzatziki--exactly the consistency and flavor you want and love the steak fries. I hope they never change those!! So good!! Every table has a shaker bottle of Greek salt, pepper and sweet paprika. Such a nice touch. read more

See all

Waitress Bri, is a superb at her job and extremely friendly. The food is delicious and the desserts are awesome. We tried the dessert tray and fought over who got the last piece, yum ! Portions are huge and the atmosphere is friendly, with a nice location and now outdoor seating. It's a cozy little restaurant well worth the wait if there's one. read more

Gyro House - Gyro combo - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

Great food and service. Stopped in for a takeout order and the cashier was very helpful and kind. Gyro was tasty, I'd give 5 stars but this place is still beat by another local chain in my heart. However, the service and vibes here are miles better. I'll be back soon to try some of their desserts. read more

Gyro House - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

I've been hearing a lot of really good things about this place, and I wanted a quick non junk/fast food bite while I was out running errands, so I decided to stop in. I'm from Chicago, and we have gyro stands on every block there. I was expecting this to be a gyro stand, and I was apparently wrong. If you're not ordering carryout, it's waiter service and cloth napkins only, which is not what I expected or wanted, especially when what I was ordering was $8. I just want to order at the counter, shove my food in my face, be left alone, and throw my napkin in the garbage when I'm done. Instead, I'm now forced to let someone wait on me and leave a tip. If I wanted waiter service, I would have gone to an obvious sit down restaurant. Unfortunate, this is not where the frustration ended for me. I ordered a chicken gyro. I have gone over the menu about 20 times trying to figure out how I could have ordered this differently to get what I wanted, and I've determined it's not me. What I was given was what I believe is the chicken souvlaki pita. Now, for a restaurant called Gyro House, that only has one item on the menu that has both the words gyro and chicken in it, I'm really not sure how this can be misunderstood. Once I told the server what I had actually wanted, he tried to tell me I ordered incorrectly and should have asked for the street gyro. Please see the attached photo and tell me if I'm wrong here. Then they bring me what I ordered and it has French fries on it. Now I'm confused again, because the description says potatoes, not fries. Again, if you look at the menu, fries and potatoes are listed elsewhere as two different items, so why would it say potatoes if it means fries? And not everyone eats or wants fried food, so that needs to be differentiated. I again tell this to the server, and he corrects my order with the kind of potato I expect to come on my gyro. The food had a really great flavor. The chicken was fairly fatty, but I got through it. I decided I was going to give them another chance with a carryout order at a later date, and then the staff started talking about me in Spanish, as if I can't hear, even though there's no wall between the kitchen and dining room and you can hear everything they're saying. At this point, the experience was so unpleasant that I'm not willing to come back for another chance. I'm guessing the Father and son that run this business were not present while I was there, because this is not typical Greek hospitality. Unfortunately, they don't seem to be aware of what's happening in the restaurant when they're not around, but they've lost a potential customer because of it. read more

Gyro House - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

Called in my order (note GrubHub and DoorDash seem to add $1 or so to each item for pickup despite listing "no fees") and it was ready on time. The gyro was delicious and, as is tradition, overloaded with meat! I should've got a 2nd pita and made two sandwiches out of it all. The burger was okay. The patty was a bit pink inside and softer consistency, so I just cooked it another minute at home to make sure it was done properly. I was surprised by the number of tables they had, since from the street I would've guess it was mostly take-out, but nice to see they offer sit down seating as well. read more

Gyro House - Gyro - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

This is some of the best Greek food around. Everything is fresh and home made. The Greek fries are like nothing else. The fries are crispy and fluffy with light lemon sauce and tons of feta cheese crumbled on top. So far everything we've had has been delicious. read more

Gyro House has been such an excellent addition to the area! When you first walk in, the staff here always greet you warmly and there is an immediate scent of great food. We came on a whim with another couple on a Saturday night. All that we ordered were perfection of Greek down home cooking. We had delicious appetizers of fried zucchini with skordalia and bourekeke, our entrees Loaded Gyro, Tour of Greece, chicken souvlaki, and Greek spaghetti, and then loukoumades for a tasty dessert finish. Everything came to our table well timed, hot, fresh, with very pleasing presentation. All so delicious, We came away full and very satisfied. Thank you again Gyro House, we will be back again and again! read more

My husband and I stopped in for a to go order on June 5. It was busy but food was coming out fast. Our order was correct and we started on the Greek fries in the car on the way home. They were hot and fresh, but not much Greek flair to be found. There was a scatter of feta and then some dried oregano like you would have in your spice cabinet. It didn't add any flavor because it was just dried leaves. Not much lemon taste, if any. I wouldn't get them again because they were nothing special, and the dried oregano was actually a bit unpleasantly crunchy. I've never had dolmades before. These were served cold, but I think they would have been better at room temperature. They had a very mild flavor. I liked the pork kebob, which was served with a little container of lemon juice (unlike the fresh lemon wedge that came with the dolmades). It didn't add much, but luckily the pork was nicely seasoned and delicious. I would have appreciated something more than just plain lemon juice for the pork, like maybe adding some olive oil or even some of that dried oregano. The grilled bread was very good. My husband had a gyro and said it was good, but I didn't get to taste it so I'm not including it in my review. Overall, while the food was okay, I'd probably stick to gyros and regular fries. read more

See all

Just a delightfully delicious experience. These people do Greek right! Their menu covers so many dishes, from appetizers, salads, soup, mains and a variety of desserts.....do yourself a favor and look at their menu online before you dine in the restaurant. It's a fun experience eating there. Everyone who works there is so helpful. They really hustle, too! I phoned in for carry out and they coordinate when your order will be ready according to when you will get there so your food will be fresh and hot. I really wish these people much success, they deserve it. The best Greek food this side of Greek Town in Chicago. read more

OMG !!!!! Large portions and fast service the minute that I walked and this is about a week after the grand opening on 01/15/25. The dining room is rather small. It's roughly 10 tables for 4 people. So during peak hours finding a table will be rough. The menu looks small but what they have to offer will compensate for that. You can get a soda and fry combo but it's not listed on the print takeout menu They're located in a small strip mall near a Kohl's Department store. Parking will be hard during peak dining hours read more

See all

Came here a little early on a weeknight and had no problem getting a table. (Had previously come on a Saturday night and the place was overrun so we just went someplace else.) Fairly small dining room but nice decor reminiscent of Greece. I had the gyro platter. The food came out super fast. There was a huge portion, I definitely didn't need the platter as the gyro itself would have been sufficient. Or the gyro platter could probably feed two people. There was a big pile of gyro meat with some sliced onions and tomatoes over a pita, Tzatziki sauce on the side and fries. Really too much to attempt to eat as a gyro pita sandwich. I'd actually suggest they reduce the portion (and hopefully reduce the price as well.) Unfortunately I thought the gyro was ok but not great. The meat seemed a little dry and flavorless. The tzatziki sauce was a bit too thick to easily spread on the gyro. Service was quick, efficient and friendly. read more

Gyro House - Gyro platter - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

Only had one lunch here ... will have to try it again. Very nice portions and good flavor . . . very traditional and good service.

Stopped in for the first time for the 1 year anniversary $5 gyro special. They were offering free samples of their honey puffs and ouzo. The gyro was delicious with their tzatziki sauce. Service was fast and friendly. They were busy but I didn't have to wait to order and there were still some open tables. I'll definitely go back. read more

Delicious gyros! Very generously sized. Service was excellent and easy to order on their app.

I hesitated to even order fish fry from a place I'm unfamiliar with but I ordered the cod fillet dinner. Presentation was nice enough, but unfortunately, the beautiful crispy outside did not go with the very mushy inside. I kept looking at it and pulling it apart trying to figure out what I was eating. It was so mushy. I couldn't believe it there was no taste to it. It actually grossed me out. I have such a tiny portion for coleslaw too. I'm a square thick white toasted bread that doesn't go along with fish at all. I ate some of the fries because I was hungry, but I literally couldn't eat the dinner that I just paid so much for I don't know what happened. I'm sorry to have to give it such a horrible rating. But something happened to this fish. It's probably a boxed frozen fish. They got somewhere instead of fresh fish and for the price it should be fresh. I'm writing this just to warn other people that this could vary likely happen to you. I should've known better when I saw that it was a fillet as well. Cod is better and bigger chunks. I honestly am wondering if it was even cod! It tasted nothing like it and I absolutely love cod. I'm quite sure other people that have had it and it's been very good or they wouldn't keep serving it but something was very wrong with the fish tonight and I happen to be a lucky one to have gotten such a bad piece of fish when I haven't ordered fish in over a year . read more

The service was very good and food arrived very very quickly. The food was pretty good. The appetizer spanakopita is large, but it did get a little soggy once plated. The steak and chicken kebabs were both good, but there was quite a bit of fat on both. The Greek fries were good, but the wide thick steak fries got a little bit soggy with the lemon juice on the plate. Skinnier fries might do better with that, but everyone does them differently. Sometimes I order the toppings on the side so that I can dip the fries in it. I will definitely come back to try something else. The place was very busy. The first time we came, there was no way we were going to get a table on a Saturday evening. The line was out the door. Plan accordingly!! It is very cute inside with cloth, napkins, and cut paper on top of the glass tables. The chairs are nice, and the tables are small and tightly spaced; they bring carafes of water to reduce trips to the table as space is at such a premium. Overall, good but didn't blow me away. read more

Amazing overall. For starters, we had lunch with our rambunctious toddler. The owner immediately brought over a small plate of French fries so that she didn't have to wait. This was so appreciated - she was calm and behaved the entire meal. My husband and I both had the authentic gyro sandwich meals. Very tasty! For dessert we had the baklava at home which was outstanding!!! We will definitely be back for more! read more

See all

Amazing and speedy service, attentive and kind staff, comfortable environment, generous portion sizes. read more

Gyro House - Greek Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

See all

This place is just amazing the food is delicious and fresh! I would recommend to anyone, and the service is very kind. The place is clean the decor cute overall a very nice place to eat. Again the food is amazing!!! read more

My wife and I have been looking for a really good Greek restaurant and we definitely found one with Gyro House. We went in on a Sunday after church for lunch and the food was amazing. I think that can say this having been to many Greek resultants, this one is absolutely one to try. The staff was cordial and ready to help with any of our requests. Their prices are reasonable and the establishment was very clean. There is one thing else I need to mention. I left my credit card here on accident after paying our bill. I didn't realize it for a couple days, and phoned them. Immediately they told me they had it waiting for me, so the following day I went in to pick it up and order a salad to go for my wife. Again, staff were extremely nice and generous. I will, without a doubt, be back. read more

Delicious, fast, and incredibly nice people... the Spano was dead-on as a memory from my childhood. Opa!

This place was amazing. The platter is huge so be warned if you go in thinking otherwise.

This new spot is worth the trip! Great family restaurant energy here. The fries are a shape that i love, and sadly that I don't see very often anymore at restaurants. Go ahead and get yourself a gyro over here. I will definitely be back. read more

The waitress was phenomenal and on top of everything. The manager made his rounds like he knew everyone. It felt like home and I'm not Greek. Giannis Antetokounmpo, if you miss home come check this place out. The Platter is a great dish to start with. I ate it so fast I forgot to take a photo. Instagram worthy. The atmosphere is pretty neat as well, I want to go the Greece read more

Grizzly meat on the kabobs with mediocre flavor. Don't have a few items on the menu still... and get ready for this, they charge 6.1% as sales tax in a county with 5% sales tax.. Scam bs right there. Avoid at all costs read more

Wow! Loved this place! Had the loaded supreme gyro - it awesome! We also tried the meze platter sampler, which had delicious sausage, chicken and more. We will definitely be back! read more

The street gyro was delicious. It arrived after ordering in 5-6 minutes. Super fast. The lentil soup I ordered was very good as well. The waitress very pleasant as well. I will definitely be returning. read more

Love this place! Food was great and so was the service and the environment! Definitely recommend!

Absolutely love this place. I have tried a few things from here, and I have liked every single thing. But, the lamb and beef gyro is my go to, while my wife loves the platter so she can get the fantastic rice. Personally, I think it's the best gyro in SE Wisconsin. And on top of it, everyone is so nice there and the food comes out hot and SUPER quick. An absolute must try spot. read more

MEH. Mediocre at best. Tasteless Gyro and Greek Potatoes. Sauteed onions rather than raw onions. Blah. WAY OVERPRICED. Avoid, instead go to the Greek place 1/2 to the West across from the Honda dealer...it is much better! read more