I prefer Marco's Pizza to John and Mary's Arcade, which has absolutely trash customer service and…read morequality the past several years. By contrast, Marco's has excellent customer service, but I gave it 3 rather than 4 stars due to a clear and consistent obvious lack of consistency. I generally order stromboli from them, but it's really hit or miss depending on the day. Some days the stromboli is big and golden brown and amazing. I'd give it 5 stars. Other days it's tiny, completely undercooked, and even missing ingredients. I'd give it 1 star. If they could make the 5-star stromboli consistently, my rating would be 4 or even 5 stars. The pizza is decent but the chicken wings consistently disappoint. I was in there recently and a sign said the wings were so small that they'd offer more than usual to make up the difference. Again, I'd much rather have consistency. Eat here on occasion because they can't be consistent, but I do love a good stromboli. Wish they could get it right

After a day of swimming at a local town park, we needed an air conditioned place to take the kids…read morefor dinner. Marco's to the rescue. The aroma of freshly baked pizza was so enticing, and drew us up to the counter without hesitation. The kids ordered the standard KID Meals: fingers and fries and a kid's personal pan pizza. Both come with a juice box. Our smaller boy, aka the "picky one" began devouring the fingers like nobody's business. I was glad to see that they were "real" chicken cutlets, not reformed chopped chicken product. Ok, so it was the best thing he ever ate! Our bigger boy eats pizza every chance he gets, as his mom works at a pizza shop in another town. He eagerly expressed approval of Marco's sauce and cheese! Life is good! I had the chicken souvlaki salad with a garlic breadstick. Very delicious and a great bargain at only $8.99! I strongly suggest that you put Marco's on your bucket list!

Their food is next to none ! I have never had anything I didn't love. Now that I live in North…read moreTonawanda, I will make a special trip just to eat there. Yumm

The service is always great and the food as well. I've had several different dishes there and they…read morewere all good. The desserts are homemade too.

We've been eating here since they opened and we love it! Their pizza and wings are so consistently…read moregood. The service is friendly! The garlic parm wings with the homemade blue cheese is my go to!

This is St. Patrick's Day and Eric has a Rueben Calzone today as one of his Monday specials. I…read moreordered ahead and arrived about 5:15. My order was just coming out of the oven so perfect timing. They included a delicious "thousand island" homemade sauce whose flavor absolutely complemented the tasty sandwich. Normally, Eric features either a meatball sub or a beef on wick. Having now tried both you better order ahead of time as he sells out every Monday.

Excellent food. The wait staff was more than busy so being seated took more than 10 minutes even…read morethough we were the only ones waiting to be seated and there were open tables. There were only 2 wait staff for more than 25 customers. Once we were seated we got a menu and drinks quite quickly and ordered our food. The food was very good and came quickly. Getting the bill was challenging. The line to pay was very long once we finally got our bill. This is a good place with good food and warm atmosphere. Our server was pleasant, helpful and efficient. The only problems were from short staff. I would go again.

We decided to grab lunch after church today and picked Nicolo's…read more The menu is a nice mix of freshly baked Pizza, Wings, chicken fingers and fries as well as large meal salads and Italian pasta favorites The kids meals were very economical coming in at under nine dollars each. Our kids ordered the chicken tender & fries, and the pepperoni pizza, both with a small beverage. They polished off every bite without any pushback! My husband ordered the gargantuan julienne salad, brimming with meats, cheeses, olives & peppers. Mine was the antipasto. Both were very crunchy and fresh with high quality ingredients. Our waitress was extremely friendly, flashing a big beautiful smile each time she approached us. She lent us some pens, so the children could draw on the back of their placemat menus. We felt extremely welcome. We like the fact that the food offered resembles actual meals that my mother would have prepared for us. I love the array of salads, freshly baked pizzas, sizable portions of chicken, Parmesan, Alfredo, dishes, and lasagna. The sides looked extremely appealing, everything from baked potatoes to onion rings to garlic knots. We truly enjoyed everything we ate, and we will definitely return here the next time we get a craving for a meal! The vibe here is like (let's be genuine, but not mean) roadside-family restaurant-wrapped in old paneling. Not to be confused with anything close to charming. But it's clean, the food is good quality for a good price with a hardworking and friendly wait staff. Don't overlook this little gem!

05/20/26 An update: It's an odd combination of service:…read moreOrder at the counter, pour your fountain drinks, seat yourself, and then a waitress brings your food to the table. The food was cooked to order, but there was an odd taste to my dipped fried mushrooms, a flavor I couldn't identify. Examining closer, it was horseradish dipping sauce. OK. Not bad, but not expected. I loved my shrimp basket, and the huge side salad, which was included in the price. This is a very casual restaurant; the waitresses are in shorts, and most have at least one tattoo.

John & Mary's is our go-to place to pick up a quick pizza in the Arcade NY area…read more We love the crust which has the right amount of chew. The sauce is perfection and the pepperoni is abundant and flavorful. Service is always fast and friendly and the dining room is like a community center. If you grew up in this area, you're sure to see someone you know!

They have entire vegan menu, upon request…read more The pizza was phenomenal. The ricotta on top was so good. We are are good eaters and one pizza is enough for two people. We got two because we wanted to try more than one, and we took half of each one home. It was great leftover, too. Best vegan pizza I've ever had.

This place is busy and when I say busy, I'm talking about a good 45min wait type of busy. But you…read moreknow what, it's totally worth the wait. You order at the counter and they will bring your food/drinks to you. I love the open kitchen concept, and it's always a joy to watch fresh pizza being made. Would definitely come back Chopped salad- easily can serve 3 people. If I didn't want pizza, I would definitely just come here for the salad and wine itself. Mushroom pizza- nice thin crust and delicious flavor profile. Cacio e Pepe- a ricotta top pizza that tastes really amazing.

Ordered a chicken tender sub through the app. Sandwich doesn't come with mayo and rechecked my…read moreorder to make sure but for some reason they added mayo. Not very happy. Another time we ordered a simple cheese pizza. It was very slow and mostly everyone on their phones yet our pizza was cut into ridiculously sized pieces. Another time I came in grabbed my drink, the old lady was completely silent through the transaction, didn't say hello, didn't let me know my total, when to put my card in, or that I was all set. Blew her nose and stared at me not even pressing any buttons. Let me stand there for a minute staring at me at the end before I decided to walk away (I stayed bc I wanted to make sure my card went through and everything). As I walked out she threw her hands in the air and yelled rudely "have a good day". This happened multiple times to me and others I know. Absolutely ridiculous worst customer experience there. Every time!

New facility so it's clean. Cashiers seem to preform their job well. It's a much better rest stop…read morethan the 7&11 down the road.

It is Townwide Yard Sale Weekend in Strykersville, New York, so after shopping all the sales, we…read morewent to the Flip Side for some lunch. My little guy grabbed a plate of chicken fingers and fries, which made his day. We were delighted with the live band, and the big pink pig mascot was super jolly! You have to see the photos. The pit master was smoking brisket and the homemade macaroni & cheese specials looked absolutely incredible. It's the first time we sat on the outdoor upper deck, but the wind was so ferocious we had to come inside. Still blustery through the open garage doors, but much more pleasant. We could not have asked for a better day!

I've never been so disappointed with a fish fry. The fish itself was so-so. The batter was mushy…read moreexcept for the ends, which were hard as rocks. The fries were small and limp like they'd been microwaved. The way too sweet coleslaw was swimming in liquid and had little squares of maybe pineapple? I really have no idea. The best part of the 2 large orders that I paid over $45 for were the lemon wedges. I won't be back. Order #125166

I had to get my 9 year old some food afterschool as we were on our way to another appointment…read more I resisted the urge to go to McDonald's drive through which would have caused me $20, but instead we called in an order for a fresh hot crispy cheesy breadsticks with pepperoni and a marinara dip on the side for just about $8.00 This little pizza joint makes a delicious pizza. The bottom is crispy yet soft with a nice cheesy chew. We highly recommend.

I love how much this pizzeria does for their community - hosting Girl Scout cookie booths,…read moresports/club fundraisers, etc. Very friendly staff. Top-notch service. And decent menu prices.

Geez, did this pizza hit the spot or what?!?! Walked over…read moreafter a long day of skiing and was greeted by the owner himself. Sit at the bar and had a beer as I watched them hand toss my pizza, along with it cooking in a brick pizza oven right in front of my eyes. Have to say they are some of the friendliest staff I've met. And that pizza was to die for!!!! Literally had to unbutton my ski pants the next day. lol Soooo worth it though. Thanks guys, your Columbus, Ohio friend. See you next year.

Love the thin crust on the pizza. For 3 pizzas, 3 orders of wings and a salad, the wait time was an…read morehour and half. The pizza was good but it took awhile until we can pick it up. There aren't too many choices on pizza in this town.