5 Stars for Bills Bars…read more Josh's Jaqs on the shelf. Buffalo Bills helmets on display. Walked in here waiting for a friend and it was a happy accident. Cold beer and a friendly face. Cozy Irish pub. A good pint of Guinness.

I had a delivery order of Fish & Chips, Shepards Pie and Bang Bang Shrimp from this Irish Pub…read more The Fish & Chips consists of one nice large piece of fried fish with a tasty homemade tartar sauce and a small container of very nice Cole Slaw. I opted to substitute tater tots which were very good. The Shepherds Pie was the stand out dish with a very generous portion of mashed potatoes with beef, very tasty and well made. The Bang Bang Shrimp was decent enough though soggy from the trip. Nonetheless, with the various dips (ranch, Russian and house) it was filling albeit a little breading forward. Service was a little slow, though packing was well done. I enjoyed this meal. I would order again, especially for the Shepherds Pie. Recommended.

We were staying at Hotel Shocard, and went next door to "4.2 star" Garveys for dinner - we were…read moretired and starving that first night. My wife had French onion soup, which was covered with three slices of typical Swiss melted slightly by the heat of the soup. Pulled the cheese off, leaving good-enough soup. She then ordered nachos, which she said were the worst glop she's ever had. I had a corned beef sandwich, substituting roasted "Brussel" sprouts with balsamic glaze. Sprouts were good. Corned beef was unevenly sliced up to 3/8" thick, 1/3 of which was fat that I cut out. I ate the sandwich with knife and fork. Much of the meat was tough. The staff was very friendly, and attentive enough. They asked how everything was, but we lied and said it was good. We'd eaten everything so I would have been embarrassed to complain.

I have to say I had a hamburger and it was the best Hamburger, I very had, and I had several…read more Juicy and the meat was cooked just perfect. I highly recommend this Irish Pub to everyone going to New York.

Came here for happy hour and sat at the bar. The service was a little on the slow side, but good…read moreand friendly. We also ordered their happy hour quesadilla which was really tasty but kinda small. We also ordered their fries which were also tasty, and a fair size. It was kinda busy and a little noisy, but still a fine place to catch up if you are OK with speaking loudly. It was just two of us, so we got seats, but you might have to stand if you are with a larger group.

Classic pub atmosphere with a relaxed, local crowd. Drinks were well made and the vibe is…read moreeasygoing, a good spot to catch up or unwind after work. Service was friendly and casual, exactly what you expect from a neighborhood pub. Grab a seat at the bar for the best experience and conversation.

Perfect place to watch an Arsenal match! Highly recommend the chicken sandwich... and a wonderful…read morestaff! Will go again

Fun bar! Good service and enjoyable due to the amount of space. Perfect to watch sports.read more

I went to Malone's twice this month as I was visiting NYC for work. The first time I had the…read moreshepherd's pie, which was top notch, and a most excellent old fashioned. Highly recommended. The next visit I decided to try the fish and chips. They were fine but not excellent; when I go back I'll have the shepherd's pie again. As others have said, it is super noisy at the bar but very quiet and peaceful in back. They had the World Cup games on the TVs which was good for me. The wait staff is attentive and the manager/owner (not sure) was very friendly and showed me the breakfast menu...which I didn't have a chance to try. I will be back.

We were looking for breakfast and saw a good rating, so we stopped in. The bar is in the front, and…read morea super friendly guy asked if we wanted to eat and offered to take us to the restaurant. We had sliders, tomato bisque, and beef hash with eggs. Everything was incredibly good. It all came out hot. The sliders had grilled onions, and the meat was nicely seasoned. The hash was so delicious; it might be the best I've ever had. Overall, it was a great experience with attentive, helpful service in a fun and clean Irish bar. I will come back here again!

This is my neighborhood Irish bar (kind of a sports bar). I love this place in every single way…read more a. The staff is just beyond lovely. They remember your name and come with an air of friendliness. I may be biased because I used to live in Ireland. b. The food. I mean it is not a Michelin restaurant, but it is amazing bar/gastropub food. The tenders were delightful. The spiced bag is the hidden gem. c. They have drinks of a much fancier bar... Cocktails and all. There Irish coffee is amazingly beautiful. Oh and yes, prices are like from 2019!

Great spot to chill and have a few drinks. Locate perfectly by Penn station. Good bar food and you…read morecan expect the usual; finger food, burgers, and etc. Lots of different tvs to watch sports. The bartenders are always nice and friendly.

Visited 2/23/26. Had a blast at John Sullivan's! Came here the day after a major blizzard and being…read morefrom out of state we were so relieved that it was open. Our waiter was super flexible and took our random asks (side of carrots and celery to go with our chicken tenders, side of mashed potatoes and gravy) in stride. Everything was solid and they had a decent drink selection too. Overall, good vibes-thank you John Sullivan's for a good time

Okay this place is all sorts of interesting…read more The good thing is that the food is amazing and affordable. It also at a great location, far away enough from Times Square / Penn Station that you aren't in the thick of it, but still accessible. I also really like the vibes of this place being kind of a cop bar. However, they really need to invest in some upgrades. 3 of the TVs don't seem to work all the time, and some of them are just grainy, so not the best for watching sports. I also don't know what is it about this place, but I have seen 2 bar fights break out here. I don't know why people would start fight with so many off duty cops around (and they clean up and get rid of the problem), but it just happens.

Connolly's is an absolute icon in New York City. It is exactly what you want in an Irish pub, and…read morethe staff here are incredible - many of them have been here for years, which really speaks to the heart of the place. I've been coming here for 15+ years specifically for the live music. I remember when the cover was typically $10, $15, or $20. However, when we went this evening, the cover was $40 per person. For a casual night out, that felt quite steep, especially since the pricing wasn't listed on the website. I still love the atmosphere and the history here, but I wish the cover charges were more transparent online so guests could plan accordingly. Definitely a "live and learn" moment - I'll be sure to call ahead next time to check the door price!

The restaurant was fairly busy during a lunch weekday. The place is well decorated and has a good…read morevibe to it. The food was good, nothing too special and the portion was large. Sometimes it was hard to get a hold of our server but the service itself was good.