Chef Bobby is Michelin Star! The lobster roll truly is overstuffed, seasoned perfectly, absolutely…read moredelicious a must try! Jonathan the bartender; super cool mixologist, the filthy martini is great! Hayden & Jules so hospitable & Ryan is just a delight. Go for happy hour oysters, clans casino and stay for dinner!

Came here in between breakfast and lunch time and we were told our table had to choose between…read morebreakfast or lunch, no one could pick differently. I found that odd but okay, we went with breakfast as some of our party didn't love the lunch menu. I got the avocado toast and the bread wasn't toasted? That was disappointing and honestly made the slice soggy. Nothing was seasoned except the potatoes, so the avocado and eggs were in desperate need of salt and pepper. I feel like when you order this kinda meal there's at least flavor to the mashed avocado. The potatoes were pretty good. Service was fast but almost felt like they weren't on the same page, but it's a beach town with kids working so you give a little leniency.

Stopped at Castaway for a midday snack. Oysters were fresh and a good size. Even my friend who…read moredoesn't particular enjoy seafood thought they were delicious. We also got the wings and parmesan fries. The BBQ wings were good--saucy and not too small. Fries were just meh. They're just fries and a good shareable but nothing special. The staff is so sweet and accommodating. My friends and I were here a few years back and sat at the corner table outside. Our waitress didn't hesitate to prep the table for us when we requested to sit there again. When I was here a few years back, they had nachos and they were probably the best I've ever had. Been thinking about them ever since. Petition to bring the nachos back!

I found the price for one starter and one beer to be very high. I went there after Labor Day and…read moreit had a nice atmosphere, but the food was average.

I think you have to go into Maguire's knowing what you're going to get. This is a pretty casual…read morerestaurant that is on Fire Island so they're going to charge a premium for everything, while being a beach town. The view is really nice if you get to sit out on the back deck, it's really nice to sit on the water, but if it is hot, just know it's going to be hot out there as well. The food was fine, I wouldn't say it was amazing, but if I had to eat there again, I would. We got a combination of a burger, a steak dip sandwich, the lobster roll and Poké bowl. Would eat here again, I'm sure there's other great options that would be less expensive.

We ate at Maguire's tonight and want to warn patrons this restaurant has really gone down. I…read morestarted w clams on the half shell that were pre shucked days earlier it seemed I was born and raised in East islip a prior clammer Long Island who knows little neck clams. Maguire's is an insult to our proud clam heritage serving its customers clams this way so naturally I sent them back reluctant to order anything else but against my better judgement I ordered the steamers. I was served half a bowl of empty shells w the remaining clam sandy & broken. So I was retaliated against w my food. My wife and daughter were very unhappy w the pineapple shrimps n scallops dish and the pasta pesto. All of us said to each other how bad it was. I got home and am sick to my stomach. The service was equally as bad but the food will get you sick. Beware and go else where We wish we ate at Rachel's our waiters recommend spot for coffee " our coffee is terrible "

Location, location, location! This is the perfect spot to enjoy dinner while watching the sunset…read moreover the marina. We had a little reservation debacle when we arrived. They accidentally canceled our reservation because there were two bookings under the same name, so we were initially seated indoors by the entrance. After we spoke with the manager, she quickly made it right and moved us to an outdoor table by the marina. It was absolutely worth it. Breathing view The food was spectacular, especially if you love seafood. The lobster tail was incredibly tender, the panko-fried oysters were perfectly crispy, and the wild halibut was outstanding. The service was warm and friendly from start to finish. Between the beautiful waterfront setting, excellent seafood, and attentive staff, I'd definitely recommend Matthew's for a memorable dinner on Fire Island.

We were on Fire Island for the day. We heard great reviews for Matthew's so we gave it a try. My…read morehusband started with a Brooklyn Summer beer and I went with the crazy coconut. We ordered a dozen oysters as a starter. For our entree I had the ahi tuna poke bowl and he had the grilled tuna. They do add a card processing fee. Would probably go back during golden hour.

If you like salmon, you gotta try the Blackened Artic Char at the Island Mermaid in Ocean Beach…read more Served crispy skin side up and with broccolini. Eat the stems, they're good for you.

Came here today (8/8/26) with my parents and fiancé. We got here right at opening at 12pm, so we…read morewere expecting things to move pretty smoothly. Unfortunately, it took over 45 minutes for our appetizers to come out. We ordered the calamari, clams on the half shell, and soup. The wait was frustrating considering one of those appetizers doesn't even need to be cooked. When everything finally came out, the calamari was cold. The clams however were fresh and tasty. For my entrée, I had the mussels in garlic wine sauce, which I really enjoyed. We also ordered the swordfish, McMermaid burger, and a regular burger. The swordfish was enjoyed, but unfortunately both burgers were not cooked to the preferences requested. The drinks were also on the smaller side and came with a lot of ice for the price point. Overall, there were some good dishes, but the long wait and issues with the food made the experience disappointing. Maybe we just caught them on an off day, but for us, it's one and done.

This Resturant is located right along the water with beautiful views and excellent seafood!!! We…read morewent here for my mom's birthday and they did not disappoint!!! Appetizers, drinks, food and desserts were are so delicious.

Hostess was awesome. Downhill from there 40 min for drinks. 1hr 20 min for apps. Dinner came out…read moreafter almost 2 hours. Half of it was wrong. Burgers were inedible. No sauces. Which would have been no problem but tell us before we order 3 burgers. Overall server and hostess was good everything was awful would never come back. Restaurant sucks. Menu was shitty. Would never recommend.

A gem of fire island. Located right in town it's a must stop for great food and a relaxed…read moreatmosphere. The food is unsuspecting in all the right ways. The wings are out of this world. Pro tip, get the Cajun rub with a side of buffalo sauce. Im still dreaming about them. So crispy and delicious. The buffalo sauce and ranch tastes homemade. Don't come for me that it's a side of ranch and not blue cheese. It's delicious, just eat it. We also got the tuna special. Super fresh and elevated plate design. They are stepping up the game for bar food. Also make sure you have a greyhound. I don't like grapefruit and I loved it. Make it double...and make it two! If you happen to find yourself off the ferry in fire island, this is a must stop.

Albatross was exactly what I wanted an Ocean Beach night to be. The vibe was fun without trying too…read morehard, the chicken burrito was legitimately amazing (not just "good after several cocktails" amazing), the 5-rum punch absolutely understood the assignment, and the late-night DJ's music made leaving at a reasonable hour feel like a terrible idea. Basically: Five stars. No notes. And I blame Albatross for everything that happened after 10 p.m. :)

Stopped by for happy hour ordered habanero wings and they were decent. The bar is pretty large with…read moretv's playing the Yankees. The bartender was very nice and kept us good company with her stories of life on Fire Island. I should have ordered the nachos but maybe next time. Pretty good deals too half off nachos and wings. My girlfriend loves it so it's definitely a win

Service was a little slow and backed up food was okay. Definitely a great atmosphere though and…read moregreat live music band!

We were looking for a chill spot with live music during our day trip to Fire Island, and Sandbar…read moredelivered exactly what we wanted! Laid-back, lively, and totally unique. The minute we walked in, we felt transported to a Key West-inspired oasis. The vibe at Sandbar is everything you want in a beach bar ... veteran watering hole energy, live music playing, and a crowd that's having the best time. If you're into quirky décor, you'll love the hundreds of colorful flip flops hanging from the ceiling, each one signed by past patrons. It's fun to look up and read what previous visitors have written. There are even surfboards and nautical treasures everywhere, making the spot truly one-of-a-kind. We came especially for the famous Rocket Fuel ... if you've never had one, you're missing out! Rocket Fuel is a frozen, creamy concoction featuring pina colada mix, amaretto, and rum (usually topped with a float of 151). It's the quintessential Ocean Beach drink: frosty, sweet, a little indulgent, and just strong enough to get you in island mode without derailing your afternoon! We grabbed our Rocket Fuels, settled in, and enjoyed the vibes. The live music was awesome and kept the energy up with beachy classics and crowd favorites. Even in the afternoon, Sandbar was buzzing but never felt overcrowded or hectic. From friendly bartenders and great drinks, I look forward to returning here for a fun evening with my friends.

Why did he force my friends to go into an out of service bathroom?? Extremely disrespectful and…read moreinvaded the private space of people going to the bathroom. He also open the door of someone actively going to the bathroom. Not acceptable and this is not ok. I hope this restaurant takes accountability for this...

Very patient staff when placing orders and great service. Would def recommend if staying at the…read morePalm hotel as breakfast is complimentary.

Was told I had to come here for an OG rocket fuel and it did not disappoint. It's a bummer you're…read morenot allowed to take drinks to go or even sit on the little porch with them but that's not a commentary on the place - more just the rules of OB. I think it's because they make their own mix but this rocket fuel wasn't as sweet as the others I have that probably use pre-made mix. In any case it was delish!