New Yorkers are picky about pizza, but for us out-of-towners, any pizza here is probably better…read morethan pizza we get at "home". Forest Ave is no different. It operates a lot like most places where you can go in, select from their myriad of slice options, and they heat it up in the oven where it gets a nice, crispy bottom. I'm assuming you can order pizza pies to go as well, but for lunch and "by the slice" options, this place was pretty good. Staff was friendly and the pizza was good. The slices look bigger on the plate than they do behind the counter, so you might regret getting 2 slices!

Been going here for years, best pizza in GC. Toppings are a little pricey but other than that…read morealways fresh and loaded.

Louie's Pizzaria is a fantastic spot! The restaurant is very nice and extremely clean, and the…read moreambiance is warm, relaxed, and welcoming. It's the kind of place where you can comfortably enjoy a casual meal with family or friends. The atmosphere feels inviting without being too loud or crowded, which made our visit even more enjoyable. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful which you can tell they truly care about their customers. I also appreciate that they offer different dining options. You can choose to seat yourself and enjoy your meal, or be seated and have them take your order. We decided to sit and order our pizza , and even though we ordered at the counter, they still brought our food to our table, which was a very nice touch. Overall, a great experience with excellent service and a welcoming atmosphere. We'll definitely be back!

Feeling a bit advantageous I just happened to come across the best pizza , EVER!…read more LOUIE'S PIZZERIA is a phenomenon! It really stands out. Just going to get a bite to eat after leaving New Balance. My plus one says, there is a pizza shop around here. We find Louie's, walk in, the guy warming the pizza was very helpful explaining the variety of pizza on display. I got the broccoli and chicken slice and a sausage and pepper slice. The broccoli slice seemed like it was going to fall apart but it held together very well, it was also very light in weight but fluffy as can be. I was amazed but found it was the least of the two. Still enjoyable, I finished it. The sausage and peppers, AMAZINGLY delicious! Just enough sauce to keep it moist. Also not a very heavy slice yet really tasty. I found that it had just enough gravy, sausage, and peppers. This place is very upscale but casual dining is acceptable. I'm very glad I found this pizza place that offers dining in family style or take out. Inspire more, Yelp more!

The meatballs are stunning! My wife ordered broccoli, grilled chicken and penne. It looked…read morefabulous. I was so impressed by this restaurant and what set it apart was Mario and his lovely wife, . Mario, the owner this man is a legend. He's been making pizza for 56 years. I think he knows what he's doing! What an honor to speak with him and to be in his company and at his home/restaurant this is a fantastic business run by a fantastic family and I highly highly recommend people that love Italian food to try it out!!! PS they have a lot of celebrity clients thanks Mario for a great night

With so many places to grab pizza on Long Island, it takes a lot to impress me. My mom was in…read morerehab near this venue for a significant amount of time, and with the awful food she was forced to eat, I needed to bring her "treats" when I visited. First, let's talk about their sauce and dough for their regular pizza. The sauce is appropriately seasoned, not too heavy on oregano or basil, the tomatoes are high quality and the dough rises to perfection with the exact consistency I prefer. They have all kinds of speciality slices/pies; I highly recommend the margarita slice (their sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil). There is a casual sitting area with servers and a menu to order from. They have a thriving takeout option, and they also deliver locally. They accept credit cards, but be prepared for a fee. Their prices are competitive for the quality of their food. Vito's is Dining Deal Foodie approved--I purchased a shrimp parmigiana hero for my mom with a bottle of diet soda, both of which cost me less than $20. That is a bargain in today's economy! Give them a try--you won't be disappointed!

I stopped at this location to get a side order of grilled chicken. They put a lot of chicken in the…read morecontainer, and it tasted delicious! Customer service was quick, and the store seemed very clean. ¡Pasé por esta sucursal para comprar una porción individual de pollo a la parrilla! Sirvieron bastante pollo en el contenedor y, ¡estaba delicioso! El servicio al cliente fue rápido y la tienda se veía muy limpia.

Wow!! What a great spot!!! A place that really makes you feel like family! The owner and manager…read moreare both so welcoming and the food is literally 10 out of 10! I had a couple dishes and everything was just so delicious! Really cute spot, small - just the amount of space - to have a delicious meal! Do yourself a favor and visit this delicious Italian restaurant

Very clean, nice waitstaff, delicious fresh food. Cheese ravoli tastes homemade, lasagna has…read moreplenty of ground beef and cheese Very cold fountain soda in a tall glass, lots of fizz. Really nice fresh Italian bread (soft) to start.

Excellent food, friendly staff, good prices. What else can you ask for…read more Also convenient for The Space

I had a slice of salad pizza! First time ever!! And it was delicious. Service is good and fast. The…read moreambiance is perfect for this type of place and I love the fact that they have tables outside.

Swung by to pick up a slice and got two slices of the Mac n cheese pizza…read more I was more than pleasantly surprised by how delicious this pizza was. While I'm traditionally a pepperoni person, I wanted to switch it up and I'm glad I do. The pizza was well cooked and flavorful. Staff was super friendly as well. Absolutely enjoyed my experience and would come back in a heartbeat.

Upside down ( Inside out ) pizza is real good.. there has been a lot of places here and they have…read morebeen awful. Luca's is the first that is good.

In previous visits I was unimpressed with the pizza at this place. Though what has not changed is…read morethat, coming here in the early dinner hour, the place is empty and there's nearly nothing on the counter that looks like it recently came out of the oven. Most of the slices seem like they've been sitting, cold. This time, however, I enjoyed both slices that I took home. The proprietor recommended his inside out pizza, which sports the cheese on the inside and the sauce on the top. I have to admit, it turned out to be a good slice, but mostly because the crust was excellent. For me, I make the cheese nice and well done in my toaster oven/air fryer. Obviously, this was impossible to do with the sauce on the top; nonetheless, as I said, it was good. The other slice I brought home was a barbecue chicken slice. With that one, I did something that I've tried twice before and it's an excellent recommendation if you want to try: heat this barbecue chicken slice very well and then put cold ripe avocado on top; mash it a little. Makes a really delicious combination. You'll thank me for it. All in all, Luca's is a place that I plan on revisiting. Kind of surprised me; I came here out of necessity tonight, not expecting too much. Pleasantly surprised.

Friendly counter person. He was a gentleman. I ordered The…read morecapri salad for 10 bucks. It came with HUGE pieces of Romano salad leaves, 3 tomatoes, with 3 large pieces of mozzarella on top, drizzled with balsamic vinegar on top and all around. (See pics) It was solid. Oh did I mention the pizzaolo was talkative and friendly. He's from El Salvador. Nice all round great conversationalist & good guy. I ordered a large piece by phone. And when I arrived I decided to sit and eat with my son. He loved the pizza I enjoyed a slice as well. Good tasting pizza nice sauce to cheese ratio ( see pics) and the dough was well cooked. It's one thing I can't stand, it's an undercooked doughy pizza. Yuck. This pizza was hearty and delish. Small seating area but it was cozy and they have a public bathroom very easily accessible. I highly recommend this pizza spot when you're driving through Locust valley L.I. A little tidbit; Ray Johnson, the most famous unknown artist from the Warhol era, think "pop art" 60's nyc art vibes, had his home literally around the corner from the pizza shop. So if you're an art appreciator, check his house out. He died by suicide back in the 90's when he jumped off the Sag Harbor bridge, rest his soul. Anyways, good place for a slice or a pizza pie! Buon Appetito!

Poor attitude and poor food. Did the ownership changed. Service and food not the same, super…read moredisappointed. Sorry Locust Valley Pizza - we will take our business elsewhere.